Body Corporate for Eumundi Village Centre v Vyseon Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Body Corporate for Eumundi Village Centre v Vyseon Pty Ltd [2024] QDC 202

PARTIES:

BODY CORPORATE FOR EUMUNDI VILLAGE CENTRE CTS 26926

(Appellant)

v.

VYSEON PTY LTD (ACN 009 285 027) as trustee for the J and B Palmateer Superannuation Fund.

(Respondent)

FILE NO:

D177 of 2023

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Maroochydore Magistrates Court.

DELIVERED ON:

3 December 2024.

DELIVERED AT:

Maroochydore.

HEARING DATE:

24 October 2024.

JUDGE:

Byrne KC DCJ

ORDERS:

1.       The appellant’s application filed 5 July 2024 is allowed in part.

2.       The appellant has leave to file an amended notice of appeal in terms of the draft amended notice of appeal attached to the affidavit of Christopher Robert Sutton filed 4 September 2024 at attachment CRS-4, limited to grounds 1 to 10 inclusive.

3.       The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs thrown away in responding to the notice of appeal filed 14 November 2023.

4.       Grounds 2(b) and 4 of the appellant’s application filed 5 July 2024 are dismissed.

5.       The appellant’s application filed 5 July 2024 is otherwise refused.

6.       The respondent’s application filed 1 October 2024 is allowed.

7.       The subpoena issued to the Proper Officer, Vyseon Pty Ltd, ACN 009 285 027, Suite 4, 2 Centro Avenue, Subiaco, WA, 6008 on 4 September 2024 is set aside in its entirety.

8.       I will hear the parties as to costs.

Additionally, I give the following directions:

1.       The amended notice of appeal the subject of the grant of the leave is to be filed on or before 4.00 pm on 10 December 2024.

2.       The appellant is to file an Outline of Submissions concerning the amended notice of appeal and a separate Outline of Submissions in respect of its appeal against the costs order below on or before 4.00 pm on 10 January 2025.

3.       The respondent is to file an Outline of Submissions concerning the aforementioned amended notice of appeal and a separate outline of submissions in respect of its response to the appeal against the costs order below on or before 4.00 pm on 7 February 2025.

4.       The parties are to each sign and file, or cause to be filed, a jointly executed Request for Trial Date on or before 4.00 pm 21 February 2025, or within 14 days after the respondent’s outlines are filed, whichever is the earlier.

CATCHWORDS:

MAGISTRATES – APPEAL AND REVIEW – QUEENSLAND – APPEAL – PROCEDURE – where the respondent commenced proceedings against the appellant and the appellant filed a counterclaim – where judgment was entered in favour of the respondent and the counterclaim was dismissed – where the appellant appeals that decision - where the appellant filed an application seeking that the judgment be stayed pending the determination of the appeal – whether the execution of the judgment should be stayed.

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW – PROCEDURE – where the appellant seeks leave to file an Amended Notice of Appeal – where the Notice of Appeal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate for Eumundi Village Centre v Vyseon Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QDC 202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Body Corporate for Eumundi Village Centre v Vyseon Pty Ltd, the Court was called upon to address several issues arising from the proceedings between the parties. The dispute originated when the respondent initiated legal action against the appellant, who subsequently filed a counterclaim. The judgment was rendered in favour of the respondent, and the counterclaim was dismissed. The appellant has since appealed this decision and applied for a stay on the enforcement of the judgment while the appeal is pending.

The legal issues before the Court included whether there were grounds to amend the Notice of Appeal, whether special leave was required to adduce further evidence in the appeal, and whether a subpoena should be set aside. The Court was tasked with determining if the appellant had a good arguable case on appeal, if there was a significant disadvantage to the appellant if the stay was not granted, and if the risk of prejudice to the appellant was greater than any potential harm to the respondent.

The Court found that while the appellant had a good arguable case on appeal, the potential for delay in enforcing the judgment did not sufficiently outweigh the usual enforcement process. The Court also determined that special leave was not warranted to adduce further evidence, as the appellant could not demonstrate that the evidence could not have been obtained at the original hearing, that it would have an important influence on the outcome, or that it was credible. Additionally, the subpoena issued by the appellant was set aside as it was considered a "fishing expedition".

The Court granted the appellant leave to file an amended Notice of Appeal, limited to ten grounds, and ordered that the amended notice be filed by a specified date. The Court also directed the parties to file outlines of their submissions and to jointly request a trial date. The Court further ordered that the subpoena be set aside in its entirety and left the issue of costs to be determined later.

This case illustrates the Court's careful consideration of procedural issues in appeals, including the criteria for granting a stay of execution, the requirements for adduced evidence, and the proper use of subpoenas. The Court's decision balances the rights of both parties and adheres to procedural fairness and legal precedent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellant’s application filed 5 July 2024 is allowed in part.

2. The appellant has leave to file an amended notice of appeal in terms of the draft amended notice of appeal attached to the affidavit of Christopher Robert Sutton filed 4 September 2024 at attachment CRS-4, limited to grounds 1 to 10 inclusive.

3. The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs thrown away in responding to the notice of appeal filed 14 November 2023.

4. Grounds 2(b) and 4 of the appellant’s application filed 5 July 2024 are dismissed.

5. The appellant’s application filed 5 July 2024 is otherwise refused.

6. The respondent’s application filed 1 October 2024 is allowed.

7. The subpoena issued to the Proper Officer, Vyseon Pty Ltd, ACN 009 285 027, Suite 4, 2 Centro Avenue, Subiaco, WA, 6008 on 4 September 2024 is set aside in its entirety.

8. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Additionally, I give the following directions:

1. The amended notice of appeal the subject of the grant of the leave is to be filed on or before 4.00 pm on 10 December 2024.

2. The appellant is to file an Outline of Submissions concerning the amended notice of appeal and a separate Outline of Submissions in respect of its appeal against the costs order below on or before 4.00 pm on 10 January 2025.

3. The respondent is to file an Outline of Submissions concerning the aforementioned amended notice of appeal and a separate outline of submissions in respect of its response to the appeal against the costs order below on or before 4.00 pm on 7 February 2025.

4. The parties are to each sign and file, or cause to be filed, a jointly executed Request for Trial Date on or before 4.00 pm 21 February 2025, or within 14 days after the respondent’s outlines are filed, whichever is the earlier.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Had the application been considered without those issues, I would have set aside the subpoena on the basis it was a “fishing expedition”, as the respondent submits. The appellant has an understanding of what documents exist, or are likely to exist, but cannot be sufficiently certain of what will be revealed if they are produced. I accept that the subpoena was issued in the hope of providing useful material, rather than in securing evidence known to exist.The application for leave to adduce further evidence. The evidence the subject of this application is particularised as the 12 items listed in the appellant’s solicitor’s letter to the respondent’s solicitors dated both 24 June 2024 and again on 4 July 2024.[5][5]Affidavit of Christopher Robert Sutton filed 4 September 2024, CRS-3 pp 31-34. Rule 766 of the UCPR, apart from r. 766(3), applies to appeals to this Court by dint of r. 785. In the circumstances here pertaining, special leave is required to adduce the intended further evidence. The appellant submits that each of the subject documents are found on the court file but, it is unclear if any were exhibits in the trial and whether any or all were taken into account by the Magistrate. The respondent’s Counsel, who appeared below, explained that each party provided a tender bundle and documents from these bundles were marked as exhibits when they were relied on in evidence. The appellant has not contested that proposition, but maintains that, because of what is said to be the “impossibility of determining what was in and what was out”,[6] the appropriate order is to allow the further evidence to be adduced on the appeal. Counsel did however accept that the application was based on an assumption that the Magistrate took into account the material not marked as an exhibit, and did not express that he did so.[7] [6]Ts 1-33, ll 8-10.[7]Ts 1-33, l 41 to 1-34, l 19. I am unable to accept the assumption is properly made. As the appellant accepts, a list of exhibits was kept and there are numerous references to exhibits in the judgment, suggesting that the Magistrate was aware of what could be considered and what could not. His Honour is an experienced Magistrate, and is unlikely to have overlooked the distinction between documents tendered and those not tendered when tender bundles are utilised at trial. Further, the appellant has not pointed to any passage in a lengthy judgment which suggests that the assumed conduct has occurred. For all of those reasons, this is not a basis for giving leave, let alone special leave, to appeal. In Clarke v Japan Machines (Australia) Pty Ltd[8] the Court adopted the test espoused in Langdale v Danby[9] as to what amounts to special reasons; namely satisfaction that the evidence could not have been obtained at the original hearing, that it would probably have an important influence on the result of the case, although it need not be decisive and it must be apparently credible, although not necessarily incontrovertible.[8][1984] 1 Qd R 404, 408.[9][1982] 3 All ER 129 at 137-138.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The application for leave to adduce further evidence must be refused.The application to stay the enforcement of the judgment below. The power to grant a stay is confirmed by r. 761 of the UCPR. The test can be distilled to whether the appellant can demonstrate that there is a good arguable case, whether there is a disadvantage to the appellant if the stay is not ordered and whether the disadvantage to the appellant is greater than that suffered by the respondent, if any.[15] The tests have also been expressed, in addition to the requirement to show a good arguable case, as whether the appeal would be rendered nugatory if the stay was not granted and whether the appellant would be irremediably prejudiced if the stay were not granted and the appeal succeeded.[16][15]Asia Pacific International Pty Limited v Peel Valley Mushrooms Limited [1999] 2 Qd R 458.[16]Cook’s Construction Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Aust Pty Ltd [2008] 2 Qd R 453, [15]. Usually, Courts should not be disposed to delay the enforcement of court orders. More than mere inconvenience to the unsuccessful litigant needs to be demonstrated.[17][17]Cook’s Construction at [12]. In this case it is difficult to make an accurate assessment of the strength of the appellant’s case without resort to the trial transcript, although some grounds appear to have better prospects than others. None can be said to have no prospects at all, although I do not pre-judge the outcome of the appeal. Given the view I have otherwise reached, this consideration is not determinative of the application. I consider there is no proper need to deprive the respondent of the ability to enforce the damages judgment below. It is for a money order which, if collected prior to the conclusion of the appeal, can be refunded if the appellant succeeds. Enforcement does not entail undoing something of a more lasting nature. Accepting that the appellant has incurred substantial costs in conducting the proceeding below, there is no suggestion of an inability to pay the judgment amount. It is in effect said to be onerous and also risky, given the possibility the respondent may enter liquidation. It can be conceded that is a possibility – it always is – but it is nothing more than a mere theoretical possibility in this case. Nothing has been adduced to show that it is likely. The risk does not favour interfering with the usual ability to enforce the judgment. Finally, I do not accept the appellant’s submission that the delay in enforcement tells in favour of the application. I accept that preliminary steps had been taken by the respondent since 21 June 2024, but without response. It was not appropriate to pursue that further on the filing of the present application on 5 July 2024. Any earlier preliminary attempts to commence enforcement action were undoubtedly influenced by the outstanding costs judgment. That was a reasonable approach, but the longer there was a delay in the provision of that judgment, the more reasonable it became to commence enforcement of the judgment debt.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established