Bobbe and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)
Link copied
CaseCopied
65 min read
Full text
Bobbe and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] AATA 47 (22 January 2024)
File Number: 2023/1621
Re:Mahmudul Hasan Bobbe
APPLICANT
And Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Member D. Cosgrave
Date:22 January 2024
Place:Brisbane
Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision made by the delegate of the Respondent dated 21 February 2023 to not revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa.
.............[SGD]..............
Member D. Cosgrave
Catchwords
MIGRATION – Mandatory visa cancellation – Bangladeshi citizen – Class VB Subclass 885 – Skilled Independent visa – failure to pass good character test – criminal record – whether another reason why the mandatory visa cancellation should be revoked – Ministerial Direction No. 99 applied – where Applicant has left Australia voluntarily – decision under review affirmed.
Direction No. 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (3 March 2023)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Member D. Cosgrave
22 January 2024
INTRODUCTION
Mr Bobbe seeks review of the Respondent’s delegate’s 21 February 2023 decision not…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bobbe and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicul... and more:
This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Bobbe, a Bangladeshi citizen, against the mandatory cancellation of his visa. Mr Bobbe had arrived in Australia in 2007 and last departed in July 2022. His visa was mandatorily cancelled in September 2020 due to his failure to pass the character test, stemming from a substantial criminal record. This included convictions for using a carriage service to menace/harass/offend, drink driving, driving while suspended, driving while disqualified, assault with an act of indecency, taking a person with intent to commit a serious indictable offence, and engaging in a police pursuit. He was serving a total aggregate sentence of six years imprisonment with a non-parole period of three years and six months. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered whether there was another reason why the mandatory visa cancellation should be revoked.
The Tribunal was required to determine whether, despite Mr Bobbe not passing the character test, there was another reason why the mandatory cancellation of his visa should be revoked. This involved a holistic and integrated consideration of all relevant matters, including the primary considerations and other considerations outlined in Ministerial Direction No. 99, and any additional considerations favouring revocation. The Tribunal was tasked with standing in the shoes of the original decision-maker and assessing the situation as at the time of its consideration, giving genuine and real consideration to any substantial or significant claims made for revocation.
In its reasoning, the Tribunal adopted a comprehensive, holistic, and integrated approach to the evidence. It considered Mr Bobbe's background, including his personal history, health issues, previous offending, and rehabilitation prospects. The Tribunal noted that Mr Bobbe had a substantial criminal record, which meant he did not pass the character test, and therefore, the only avenue for revocation was if there was "another reason" to do so. After synthesising all the evidence, including the primary considerations, other considerations under Ministerial Direction No. 99, and additional favourable considerations, the Tribunal found that these factors, when weighed together, favoured affirming the decision not to revoke the visa cancellation.
Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision made by the delegate of the Respondent dated 21 February 2023, which was to not revoke the cancellation of Mr Bobbe's visa.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Unless the context indicates otherwise, passages quoted in bold font have been emphasised by the Tribunal.FACTS Mr Bobbe is a 36-year-old Bangladeshi citizen (born September 1987). He arrived in Australian on 8 April 2007 and last departed Australia on 28 July 2022.[2][2] G10, pages 220-221. Mr Bobbe’s offending in Australia is summarised below:(a)He was convicted in January 2014 of using a carriage service to menace/harass/offend and released on a $500.00 good behaviour bond.(b)He was convicted in November 2016 of driving with low range prescribed concentration of alcohol. He was disqualified from driving for three months and fined $500.00.(c)He was convicted in October 2017 of driving a motor vehicle while suspended. He was fined $700.00 and disqualified from driving for a further 12 months.(d)He was convicted in July 2018 of five counts of driving a motor vehicle while disqualified and was fined $100 in respect of each count and disqualified from driving for a further 6 months. Mr Bobbe appealed against these convictions, but the appeal was dismissed.(e)He was convicted in April 2020 of four counts of assault with an act of indecency, taking a person with intent to commit a serious indictable offence, driving with a middle range prescribed concentration of alcohol, and of engaging in a police pursuit, after not stopping and driving off at speed from police. (f)Following his conviction, he was sentenced to a total aggregate sentence of 6 years(commencing 19 August 2018 and concluding 18 August 2024) and was given a non-parole period of 3 years and 6 months (concluding on 18 February 2022).[3][3] Exhibit R1: G2, pages 26-30. Mr Bobbe’s Visa was mandatorily cancelled in September 2020.[4] [4] Exhibit R1: G2, pages 64–69. He sought revocation of the mandatory cancellation decision on the grounds that he was not guilty of the April 2020 offences[5] and that he was appealing those convictions.[6][5] Exhibit R1: G2, page 72, point 7.[6] Exhibit R1: G2, pages 72-74. In March 2021 he sought bail as part of his application for leave to appeal his April 2020 convictions. The NSW Court of Criminal Appeal unanimously rejected his bail application.[7] [7] Bobbe v The Queen [2021] NSWCCA 44. In July 2021, the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal unanimously dismissed his application for leave to appeal both his convictions and his sentences.[8][8] Bobbe v R (No 2) [2021] NSWCCA 150.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 25(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (‘the AAT Act’) and Section 500 of the Act are the sources of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in this matter. Section 501(3A) of the Act, read with sections 501(6) and 501(7), oblige the Minister to cancel a person’s visa if the Minister is satisfied the person does not pass the character test and is serving a full-time sentence of imprisonment. The ‘character test’ is defined in Section 501(6) of the Act. A person fails the test if they have a ‘substantial criminal record’ as defined by section 501(7) of the Act.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The following is a summary of the evidence before the Tribunal, including Mr Bobbe’s oral testimony. The evidence referred to below includes documentary evidence collated for the purposes of section 501G of the Act, documents tendered by the Respondent and the Applicant and evidence given by Mr Bobbe at the hearing in response to questions in examination-in-chief, re-examination, under cross-examination and from the Tribunal.Documentary evidence The hearing received written evidence, which is attached to this Decision and marked ‘Annexure A’. Her Honour Judge Huggett of the NSW District Court’s April 2020 sentencing decision formed part of the written evidence.[22] [22] G2, pages 31-56. Relevant parts of her decision are quoted below:Mr Bobbe’s background‘The offender was born in Bangladesh in 1987 and is now aged 32. He reported a very good childhood, although described a somewhat strained relationship with his father. He is a practising Muslim. His parents remain married and his siblings reside overseas. He completed primary and high school to the equivalent of Year 12 in Bangladesh. He was a good student with no behavioural issues.He came to Australia in 2007 on a Student Visa and completed an Advanced Diploma in Business Administration and a Certificate III in Hospitality. He has had numerous semi-skilled jobs while in Australia and has also been unemployed at times, receiving government assistance.He reports that he is a permanent resident in Australia. However, according to the Sentence Assessment Report, the Department of Homes Affairs has indicated his visa may be liable to cancellation depending on the outcome of these proceedings. While that potential consequence is one I must disregard, the offender does not want to be deported and any suggestion that that might occur causes him distress and anxiety.His grandmother passed away in 2018 whilst he was in gaol. He reports being close to her and is apparently grieving her passing.The offender has reportedly maintained regular contact with his parents while living in Australia and they have visited him here a few times prior to him committing these offences. In terms of visitors to gaol, the offender has some friends who have visited him when he has been imprisoned in Sydney. One of those friends has provided a written testimonial and has offered him temporary accommodation on his release.The offender has had four relationships since being in Australia. He married in 2011 but that marriage dissolved after a few years. He has no children but reports hoping to have a family one day. Prior to being incarcerated, he resided with his most recent partner in Wolli Creek, but that relationship has since ended.’[23][23] G2, pages 46-48.Health‘In November 2009 he was involved in a motorbike accident. He suffered a number of injuries including a broken leg, fractured shoulder and fractured skull. He describes waking up two or three days later and not recalling much, but states “something happened to my brain and memory”. Medical reports indicate he had surgical open reduction and internal fixation and had bleeding in his brain. He was hospitalised for around a month and was in a wheelchair for close to a year and was prescribed painkillers for a lengthy period of time.He reports difficulty arose with his memory and hearing following this incident, which has deteriorated over time. He also reports that ongoing pain from this accident led to extended use of pain relief drugs such as Endone as well as regular consumption of excess amounts of alcohol apparently to deal with ongoing pain. He reports that following this accident he was unemployed for around two years.In March of 2017 the offender was assaulted in a road rage incident. The hospital discharge papers indicate he was punched to the face and suffered swelling to the bridge of his nose without displacement and suffered a minor laceration requiring no intervention. The medical evidence before me suggests that this incident did not cause any significant brain injury, however the offender reports this incident exacerbated his short term memory problems - at which time he was still abusing alcohol and pain relief medication. The offender reports that following this incident his work performance deteriorated resulting in the loss of his then job which caused financial pressure. He reports that he eventually returned to work in 2018 for around four to five months until suffering a workplace injury prior to the commission of the present offences.I note that the offender said in his evidence before me that although he used alcohol and pain relief medication for many years to assist with pain relief, he reports that since being in custody he has done exercises recommended by a physiotherapist and reports an alleviation of his pain, stating he no longer requires any pain relief medication.A suggestion is raised in the reports of Ms Cortes, Psychologist, that either or both of these incidents 2009 and 2017 may have led to a brain injury. The high point in this regard is that in Ms Cortes’ opinion the offender reports significant impairments which seem to have impacted his overall cognitive behavioural and social functioning. However, no neurological testing has ever been conducted in this regard and other evidence from Dr Elliott, Psychiatrist, is to the effect that his presentation and abilities do not conclusively suggest a brain injury.A suggestion is also raised by Ms Cortes, but not in any conclusive way, that the offender might be suffering symptoms of post- traumatic stress disorder as a result of either or both of these incidents. The symptoms he describes includes intrusive nightmares, fear/anxiety of further attacks and avoidance of certain places and activities.The offender gave evidence that he has been “bashed” once whilst being in custody. No further information is before me regarding this alleged event. He describes that he finds custody very hard and struggles with low mood, anxiety and feelings of depression. I accept this evidence and further accept that he is struggling in custody and that he has had psychological issues which require treatment.As mentioned, the offender has significant problems in relation to alcohol and was intoxicated at the time he committed the present offences. He does not appear to have a history of drug abuse, reporting only having tried cannabis two or three times.He has been diagnosed with Alcohol Use Disorder. He has acknowledged his problematic use of alcohol and reports a willingness to participate in alcohol treatment. Whilst being on remand he has been able to participate in one alcohol related program - the Save-a-Mate Alcohol and Other Drugs Emergency Course with CPR demonstration over a two week period in early 2019.It is accepted the offender was intoxicated at the time of his offending. It is also accepted that he well understood that what he was doing was wrong.’ [24][24] G2, pages 47-50.Previous Offending ‘Stated simply, he has an appalling driving record given his age and the relatively short time he has been licensed. Having been first licensed in New South Wales in 2008, he has been convicted of a large number of traffic offences including speeding offences, disobeying traffic signal offences and a low range PCA offence. In addition, in 2013 he committed one offence of using a carriage service to menace/harass/offend.’[25][25] G2, page 50.Rehabilitation‘Evidence also suggests he has done some charity work, although the nature and scope of that work is not apparent and that he has been a blood donor.’ [26]and‘He states a willingness to participate in any program or treatment plan that will assist his rehabilitation. Whilst he has only engaged in two courses to date that is because he has been on remand that was all he was able to do.’[27]Risk of reoffending‘In terms of his risk of reoffending, the assessments before this Court are mixed. In the Sentence Assessment Report he is assessed as being Medium- High. In contrast, according to Ms Cortes, his risk of sexual recidivism is low to moderate and his risk and needs assessment also Low-Moderate.Curiously Ms Cortez opines that he does not have any criminogenic needs. However, the Sentence Assessment Report notes, and I agree, that he does have risk factors, including intimacy deficits, self-regulation, social rejection and loneliness.Mr Buckman contends, in effect, that I would find that he does have good prospects of rehabilitation and that he presents as a low risk of reoffending. Putting to one side his driving offences - for which I consider there is a real risk of reoffending - this is the first time he has committed sexually related offending. These offences arose in a context where to an extent there was some planning and where he determined to assault each victim, who he knew was not interested in sexual contact with him. These offences are very concerning, particularly given their close proximity and they represent a serious escalation in his criminal conduct, which was also contrary to his religious beliefs. He has abused alcohol and pain relief medication for many years. He has been involved in several failed relationships and has moved from job to job, many being relatively unskilled and he has had some lengthy periods of unemployment. He has no family here but has some friends and support. While I appreciate he has stated he is motivated to make changes to address the issues in his life that led to his offending, in my view it would be naive to find he has good prospects of rehabilitation. The best that can be said is that his prospects are guarded. One thing that I can say with confidence however, is that he will require significant assistance to assist in his reintegrating into the community.’ [28][26] G2, page 50.[27] G2, page 51.[28] G2, pages 51-52.Oral Testimony
Decision
Reasons for decision
Synthesising a comprehensive, holistic and integrated view of this matter and considering the evidence in its entirety, the Tribunal finds that the Primary Considerations, the other considerations in the Direction, together with the additional consideration favour on balance affirming the delegate’s decision to not revoke the cancellation of Mr Bobbe’s Visa.DECISION Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision made by the delegate of the Respondent dated 21 February 2023 to not revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Under s 501CA(4) of the Act, the Respondent Minister may revoke the original decision if:(a)representations have been made by the person in accordance with the invitation[9]; and(b)the Minister is satisfied that:(i)the person passes the character test:[10] ; and if not(ii)whether there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked.[11] MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION[9] Section 501CA(4)(a) of the Act.[10] Section 501CA(4)(b)(i) of the Act.[11] Section 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Act.Character test Mr Bobbe’s Visa was mandatorily cancelled in September 2020 on the basis that he had a substantial criminal record as he had been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of more than 12 months and was serving a sentence of imprisonment on a full-time basis in a custodial institution, for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a State or Territory.[12][12] Sections 501(6)(a) and 501(7)(c) of the Act. Consequently, he does not pass the character test due to the operation of ss 501(6)(a) and 501(7)(c) of the Act. This means that s 501CA(4)(b)(i) of the Act does not provide a basis to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision. The remaining issue for the Tribunal to consider, under s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Act, is whether the Tribunal is satisfied of there being another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision.[13] The Tribunal “stands in the shoes of the original decision-maker” but with regard for the situation as at the time of its consideration.[14] [13] Tohi v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 125, [3]-[5] (Katzmann J); [24] (Derrington J) [103] (O’Bryan J).[14] Nathanson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 26 (“Nathanson”); Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 266 CLR 250 at 271 [51]; Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286 at 299 [40], 315 [100], 324-325 [134]; Bushell v Repatriation Commission (1992) 175 CLR 408, 425 (Brennan J); Dzik v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 78, [10]-[11] (Logan, Perry, and Beach JJ).Is there another reason why Mr Bobbe’s visa cancellation should be revoked? The Full Court of the Federal Court in Bettencourt v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 172, approving the reasoning in Viane,[15] identified the following principles as relevant to the statutory task conferred by Section 501CA(4) at [27]:‘If representations are made to the Minister, a statutory obligation arises on the part of the Minister to form a state of satisfaction as to whether the person passes the character test or there is 'another reason' why the original decision should be revoked.The state of satisfaction must be formed by reference to the representations such that a failure to consider the representations as a whole would be a failure to consider a mandatory relevant consideration.The individual matters raised in the representations are not each mandatory relevant considerations and therefore do not need to be brought to account in the making of the decision such that they must form part of the considerations that give rise to the required state of satisfaction.However, a state of satisfaction that is formed without considering a substantial or significant and clearly expressed claim made in the representations that there is a particular reason why the visa cancellation decision should be revoked is not a state of satisfaction of the kind required by the statute.Further, there must be a real and genuine consideration of each such substantial or significant and clearly expressed claim.If the state of satisfaction is formed that there is 'another reason' why the original decision cancelling the visa should be revoked then the Minister must revoke the cancellation.…’[15] Viane v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 263 FCR 531, [64] (Colvin J).