Birbilis Bros Pty Ltd v Chubb Fire and Security Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Birbilis Bros Pty Ltd v Chubb Fire and Security Pty Ltd & Ors [2018] QSC 3

PARTIES:

BIRBILIS BROS PTY LTD (ACN 115 942 311)

(plaintiff)

v
CHUBB FIRE AND SECURITY PTY LTD
(ACN 000 067 541)

(first defendant)
and
ASSETINSURE PTY LTD (ACN 066 463 803)
(second defendant)
and
AAI LIMITED (ACN 005 297 807)
(third defendant)

FILE NO:

SC 9882 of 2013

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

15 January 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 July 2017

JUDGE:

Brown J

ORDER:

The order of the Court is that:

1.     The application for leave to file a fifth further statement of claim be adjourned until 23 February 2018.

2.     That the plaintiff is ordered to deliver particulars of the allegation in paragraph 74.1(b) that “the appropriate discount in respect of the orders from all customers other than Super Amart is no discount” by 21 February 2018.

3.     That the plaintiff deliver a further draft statement of claim to the defendants, with liberty to re-plead paragraphs 107 and 109, by 21 February 2018.

4.     That the stay of proceedings pursuant to paragraph 4 of the Orders made on 31 March 2016 be lifted.

5.     That the application for security for costs be dismissed subject to undertakings being given in the form of paragraph 6 of the letter from Piper Alderman of 11 July 2017.

6.     That there be liberty to apply.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY – INHERENT AND GENERAL STATUTORY POWERS – TO STAY OR DISMISS ORDERS OR PROCEEDINGS GENERALLY –– where the third defendant submits that on the basis that the plaintiff should be refused leave to file the fifth further amended statement of claim, the proceeding against the third defendant should be dismissed or permanently stayed – where the defendants contend that the pleading fails to plead material facts – where the proceedings have suffered delay including by the vacation of trial dates – whether the proceedings or part of the proceedings should be permanently stayed or dismissed – whether a previous order staying the proceedings pending payment of certain costs by the plaintiff to the third defendant should be vacated

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – PARTICULAR PLEADINGS – where the plaintiff seeks leave to file a fifth further amended statement of claim – where the defendants contend that leave should be refused if the amended pleading should be struck out if filed – where the defendants oppose the granting of leave on several grounds, including that: the pleading is incomplete, the pleading lacks particularity, the pleading is confusing, the pleading fails to disclose a reasonable cause of action against the third defendant and the pleading is an abuse of process or likely to delay the proceedings – whether leave should be granted and on what conditions

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – SECURITY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Birbilis Bros Pty Ltd v Chubb Fire and Security Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Birbilis Bros Pty Ltd v Chubb Fire and Security Pty Ltd involves a dispute between a furniture manufacturer and a fire and security company, along with an insurer, regarding alleged damages to essential machinery due to water leakage from a fire sprinkler system. The plaintiff, Birbilis, sought leave to file a fifth further amended statement of claim (FFASOC) against the defendants, Chubb and Vero, who opposed the application on multiple grounds. The court had to determine whether leave should be granted for Birbilis to file the FFASOC, whether the proceedings should be permanently stayed or dismissed, whether a previous order staying the proceedings should be vacated, and whether Birbilis should provide security for costs. The central issue was the adequacy of the pleadings, with the defendants arguing that the proposed FFASOC was incomplete, lacked particularity, and was confusing, among other things.

The court found that while some of the pleadings were indeed defective, they were not of such significance as to render the pleading substantively deficient. The court was satisfied that minor amendments could address the defects and that the proceedings should not be dismissed or permanently stayed. The court noted that while the litigation had been marked by delays, Birbilis had been taking active steps to progress the matter. The limitation period had not expired, and Birbilis could still launch fresh proceedings if the current ones were dismissed or stayed. The court also dismissed the application for security for costs, subject to certain undertakings.

In conclusion, the court granted Birbilis leave to file the FFASOC, with certain conditions and deadlines attached. The court ordered Birbilis to provide particulars regarding a specific allegation and to deliver a further draft statement of claim with liberty to re-plead certain paragraphs. The stay of proceedings was lifted, and the application for security for costs was dismissed subject to undertakings. The court allowed liberty to apply for further orders as necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

The order of the Court is that:

1. The application for leave to file a fifth further statement of claim be adjourned until 23 February 2018.

2. That the plaintiff is ordered to deliver particulars of the allegation in paragraph 74.1(b) that “the appropriate discount in respect of the orders from all customers other than Super Amart is no discount” by 21 February 2018.

3. That the plaintiff deliver a further draft statement of claim to the defendants, with liberty to re-plead paragraphs 107 and 109, by 21 February 2018.

4. That the stay of proceedings pursuant to paragraph 4 of the Orders made on 31 March 2016 be lifted.

5. That the application for security for costs be dismissed subject to undertakings being given in the form of paragraph 6 of the letter from Piper Alderman of 11 July 2017.

6. That there be liberty to apply.

Background

Background to the litigation

As a result of the above applications the matters that have to be determined by this Court are:(a)whether leave should be provided for Birbilis to file and serve the FFASOC in light of the alleged deficiencies identified by Chubb and Vero;(b)if leave for the FFASOC is not given, whether the proceedings should be:(i) permanently stayed or dismissed against Vero; and (ii) permanently stayed insofar as the proceedings seek lost profits against Chubb;(c)whether the order of Justice Applegarth staying the proceedings pending the payment of certain costs of 31 March 2016 should be vacated;(d)whether an order should be made for Birbilis to pay security in favour of Chubb in the form of a bank guarantee.Background Birbilis is a furniture manufacturer producing flat pack furniture. Chubb services and maintains fire sprinkler systems. Vero is an insurer of Birbilis under an industrial special risks policy. In July 2012, two pieces of machinery, said to be essential to Birbilis’ business, namely a Giben saw and a computerised boring and routing machine manufactured in Italy, called a Morbidelli, both of which were insured by Vero under a policy of industrial special risks insurance, are alleged to have been damaged by water. According to the FFASOC:(a)Chubb undertook repair works on a fire sprinkler system in the building occupied by Birbilis. On or about 25 June 2012, the sprinkler system was shut down and drained after a pipe ruptured.(b)Chubb repaired the sprinkler system on 4 July 2012 and reinstated the system. After repairing the pipe, Chubb reinstated water to the system in the middle of the night, at which time it had no access to the Birbilis factory.(c)The Chubb crew recognised that the system could not maintain pressure and eventually realised, after searching in the dark for a window through which to get a glimpse into the Birbilis factory, that a sprinkler head was spraying water onto the Birbilis machinery. The water system was subsequently turned off, however, it is alleged that as a result of water damage the Giben saw had been rendered incapable of properly functioning and it was subsequently scrapped. It is also alleged that as a result of water damage the Morbidelli was rendered inoperable and ceased to have the functionality it previously had and was incapable of repair to the standard it was before or alternatively incapable of economic repair. Repairs of the Morbidelli were undertaken by Vero but it is alleged by Birbilis that it could not be operated in automatic mode and was functionally impaired in manual mode when returned to Biribilis. Vero is alleged to have breached and repudiated the policy by its conduct and given the effluxion of time. A matter of significant controversy in this application is the claim by Birbilis for the loss of the commercial opportunity to utilise the Giben saw and the Morbidelli in its business as a result of the breaches by both Chubb and Vero. Birbilis alleges it has as a result suffered a significant loss of profits. The proceedings

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the basis of the above analysis, I accept Vero’s contention that material facts should have been pleaded setting out the basis upon which Birbilis would have become aware that a new Morbidelli had been ordered or steps taken to acquire one. I otherwise do not accept the contention of Vero. Conclusion I consider that Birbilis should be given leave to file the proposed FFASOC against Chubb. An order should however be made for Birbilis to provide particulars of the allegation in [74.1] that no discount is appropriate in relation to four customers other than Super Amart. In relation to Vero I propose that leave to file the FFASOC be given save for paragraphs [107] and [109] as identified in the reasons above. I am satisfied that liberty should be given to Birbilis to re-plead those allegations. Application for permanent stay Vero submits that on the basis that leave should be refused because the pleading is fundamentally defective, the proceeding should be dismissed or permanently stayed against Vero. The matters identified by Vero which I have found require amendment are not matters which are of such significance that the pleading could be regarded as substantively deficient. I am also satisfied that they can be addressed by minor amendments being made by Birbilis. I am not satisfied that the proceedings against Vero should be dismissed or permanently stayed. While Vero has, understandably, focused on the fact that the events in relation to this matter occurred in 2012 and 2013 and the proceedings were commenced in 2013 and a final pleading was still not provided by this application, the respects in which I have found that it is defective are relatively minor. It is true that the litigation has been characterised by long periods of delay, particularly due to Birbilis’ failure to plead a case. There has also been a lengthy delay since Applegarth J’s order in March 2016 and the seeking of leave for the FFASOC. The applicant has been taking active steps to progress the matter by the delivery of six further expert reports and obtaining non-disclosure, notwithstanding that the matter has been stayed. Further, in March 2016 Birbilis changed solicitors and its counsel have also subsequently changed. While that is not a matter which can weigh heavily in Birbilis’ favour, the fact remains that the claim has changed significantly in the way it was pleaded and particularly in terms of consequential loss can be attributed to the fact that there is a new legal team. Draft FFASOC’s have also been provided to Chubb and Vero since December 2016 and been the subject of some negotiation. The limitation period in relation to this matter has not expired and even if the proceedings were dismissed or stayed it would be open to Birbilis to launch fresh proceedings. While the pleading of the loss of opportunity has changed considerably, lost profits have been the subject of the claim prior to the trial being vacated, albeit a different legal team has pleaded it differently.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.