Bell v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No4)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No4) [2013] QMC 3

PARTIES:

GRAHAM BELL

(complainant)

WILLIAM GORDON

(complainant)

v

UNIMIN AUSTRALIA LIMITED

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

MAG245636/09(1), MAG245626/09(6), MAG113031/10(7)

DIVISION:

Magistrates Courts

PROCEEDING:

Complaint – Application to strike out or permanently stay proceeding – Application for costs

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

1 March 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

28 September 2012 (in Warwick)

MAGISTRATE:

Lee G

ORDER:

The defendant’s application to strike out or permanently stay the complaint under the Forestry Act 1959 made one day outside the limitation period for an abuse of process is granted. The application by the defendant for costs in this respect is refused.

The defendant’s application to strike out or permanently stay complaints under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and Environmental Protection Act 1994 for failing to plead essential factual ingredients and for an abuse of process is refused. The application by complainant Bell for costs in defending those complaints is granted. I order the defendant pay the complainant’s costs assessed at $199,557

The application by complainant Bell for costs in successfully defending the defendant’s costs application on the Forestry Act complaint and its application for costs on the other two complaints is granted. I order the defendant pay the complainant’s costs assessed at $55,130.

CATCHWORDS:

MAGISTRATES COURTS – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – complaint made under the Justices Act 1886 – application by applicant before trial to strike out or permanently stay three complaints for abuse of process -where defendant successful on one issue - where defendant unsuccessful on the other issues - liability and quantum of costs for each party

Justices Act 1886 (Qld), ss 4, 88 (1) & (3), 145, 146, 157, 158, 158A, 159, former 209, 222

Justices Regulation 2004, reg 18, Schedule 2

The following cases were either cited or considered:

Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Limited [2010] QMC 1

Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Limited (No 2) [2011] QMC 24

Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Limited (No 3) [2012] QMC 16

Bell v Carter; ex parte Carter [1992] QCA 245

Boettcher v Boettcher (1948) St R Qd 73

Byrne v Baker (1964) V.L.R. 443

Commissioner of the Police Service v Hall (2005) 158 A Crim R 10; [2005] QSC 388

Coulter v Ryan [2006] QCA 567 

Crowe v Bennett; ex parte Crowe [1993] 1 Qd R 57

Darcey v Pre-Term Foundation Clinic and Another [1983] 2 NSWLR 497

Director-General, Department of Environment and Climate Change v Gleeson and others (No 2) [2009] NSWLEC 200

Director of Public Prosecutions v Boykin, unreported, 102204 of 1994, 21 June 1994 (Lexis reference: BC9405141)

Doonan v McKay [2002] QCA 514 & [2002] QCA 531

Durrant v Gardner [2000] QDC 198

Grassby v The Queen (1989) 168 CLR 1; [1989] HCA 45

Hickey v Crime and Misconduct Commission, File 2868 of 2006 (19 May 2008

Higgins v Comans (2005) A Crim R 565; [2005] QCA 234  

Markisic v Vizza…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QMC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bell v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No4) was a case in the Magistrates Court of Queensland involving a complaint by Bell against Unimin Australia Pty Ltd for alleged breaches of environmental legislation. The defendant had applied to strike out or permanently stay three complaints, made under different statutes, on the grounds of abuse of process and failure to plead essential factual ingredients. The court was tasked with deciding whether the defendant's applications to strike out or stay the complaints were justified and, if so, whether the defendant should be ordered to pay costs. The case hinged on the interpretation of the court's inherent jurisdiction to control its own process and the associated power to order costs.

The court examined the nature of the defendant's applications, particularly whether the Magistrate had the implied power to order costs in a successful stay application. The court referred to precedents from both Queensland and other jurisdictions, concluding that while the court does have inherent jurisdiction to control its process and to stay proceedings where there has been an abuse of process, there is no general or inherent power to order costs against the Director of Public Prosecutions. The court found that the power to order costs is not an essential or necessary incident of the exercise of the court's jurisdiction, as the stay itself largely addresses the hardship suffered by the defendant. The court distinguished between the powers of superior courts and those of the Magistrates Court or Local Court, highlighting that the absence of a general implied power to make costs orders in the latter.

The court granted the defendant's application to strike out or permanently stay the complaint made one day outside the limitation period under the Forestry Act 1959 but refused the application for costs in this respect. The court rejected the defendant's applications to strike out or stay the complaints under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and the Environmental Protection Act 1994, ordering the defendant to pay the complainant's costs in defending those complaints. The court also granted the complainant's application for costs in successfully defending the defendant's costs application on the Forestry Act complaint and its application for costs on the other two complaints.

ORDERS:
The defendant's application to strike out or permanently stay the complaint under the Forestry Act 1959 made one day outside the limitation period for an abuse of process is granted. The application by the defendant for costs in this respect is refused.
The defendant's application to strike out or permanently stay complaints under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and Environmental Protection Act 1994 for failing to plead essential factual ingredients and for an abuse of process is refused. The application by complainant Bell for costs in defending those complaints is granted. I order the defendant pay the complainant’s costs assessed at $199,557.
The application by complainant Bell for costs in successfully defending the defendant’s costs application on the Forestry Act complaint and its application for costs on the other two complaints is granted. I order the defendant pay the complainant’s costs assessed at $55,130.

Orders

Orders of the court

The defendant’s application to strike out or permanently stay the complaint under the Forestry Act 1959 made one day outside the limitation period for an abuse of process is granted. The application by the defendant for costs in this respect is refused.

The defendant’s application to strike out or permanently stay complaints under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and Environmental Protection Act 1994 for failing to plead essential factual ingredients and for an abuse of process is refused. The application by complainant Bell for costs in defending those complaints is granted. I order the defendant pay the complainant’s costs assessed at $199,557

The application by complainant Bell for costs in successfully defending the defendant’s costs application on the Forestry Act complaint and its application for costs on the other two complaints is granted. I order the defendant pay the complainant’s costs assessed at $55,130.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Macrossan CJ in Crowe expressly observed that interstate decisions such as Darcey and O’Connell v Short (1985) 20 A Crim R 111 to similar effect should not be followed in Queensland[17]. The other members of the court did not refer to Darcey but did not express disagreement with this statement. I have not been referred to any authorities to contrary effect relating to the laws of Queensland. In fact, in the light of Grassby v The Queen (1989) 168 CLR 1, Wood J of the New South Wales Supreme Court in Director of Public Prosecutions v Boykin[18] disagreed with Darcey where he said:The existence of the inherent jurisdiction is no longer unquestionably correct in the light of Grassby, and the decision in Darcey is therefore distinguishable. If I am to assume, in view of the concession, that the learned Magistrate had an implied power to stay the proceedings, for the reasons expressed in Smiles, namely that such a power is an essential attribute of the exercise of the jurisdiction with which the Local Court is vested, it does not inevitably follow that a power to order costs is associated with it. As I have earlier observed, there is no general or inherent power in the Local Court to make costs orders. The question which then follows is whether by virtue of the doctrine of necessity, such a power should be regarded as an essential adjunct to the stay power. The latter power can be seen, at least as highly desirable, so as to protect citizens from abuse of process and from being prosecuted in a way that involves unfairness or oppression. While a power to order costs might provide further protection, and help to relieve hardship in a case where a stay is granted, I do not perceive it to be an “essential” or “really necessary” incident of the exercise of the Court’s jurisdiction.In substance, the case for its existence is only marginally stronger than the argument for its existence in any case where a prosecution fails. The absence of a general implied power to make costs orders, and the fact that a stay will itself largely redress the hardship suffered by a defendant faced with an abuse of process, leads me to the view that the relevant power to order costs against the DPP does not exist, as an implied power. (emphasis in complainant’s submissions)[17] [1993] Qd R 57 at 61 line 20; see paras [7] – [11] complainant’s submissions; [18] Unreported decision, 10204 of 1994, 21 June 1994 (Lexis reference: BC9405141 at p 4; para [17] complainant’s submissions; The Magistrate in Boykin stayed proceedings and ordered the DPP pay costs purportedly made under section 81(1) Justices Act 1902 (NSW). This was rejected by Wood J. as well as concluding there was no implied or inherent power in the Local Court to award costs in favour of a defendant in a successful stay application. Boykin was referred to by Lloyd J in Gleeson. However, among other reasons for his decision, Lloyd J considered himself bound[19] by the Court of Appeal in Markisic v Vizza. I note that Boykin was not referred to in Markisic. However, both Gleeson and Markisic were concerned with powers of superior courts, not a Magistrates Court or Local Court. [19] At para [48];

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.