Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Ltd [2010] QMC 001

PARTIES:

GRAHAM BELL

(complainant/ respondent)

WILLIAM GORDON

(complainant/ respondent)

v

UNIMIN AUSTRALIA LTD

(defendant/ applicant)

FILE NO/S:

MAG245636/09(1); MAG245626/09(6); MAG113031/10(7)

DIVISION:

Magistrates Courts

PROCEEDING:

Application to strike out charge

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

23 December 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7 September 2010; 12 November 2010

MAGISTRATE:

Lee G

ORDER:

The application to strike out or permanently stay one complaint charging the applicant with an offence under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and one complaint charging the applicant with an offence under the Environmental Protection Act 1994 is refused

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW - Summary offences – two complaints issued under the Justices Act 1886 – whether plead elements of offence – whether adequately plead essential factual ingredients of offence – whether complaints are so defective that they should be either struck out or permanently stayed.

COUNSEL:

SOLICITORS:

  1. This is an application by Unimin Australia Limited (Unimin) to quash or strike out complaints issued pursuant to the Justices Act 1886 (the JA) charging it with certain offences.  In the alternative, the application seeks the complaints be permanently stayed[1].  There are two grounds for the application.  The first is that the charges are insufficient in law to found the jurisdiction of this court because they fail to plead essential factual ingredients to each of the offences[2].  The second ground is that if Unimin is unsuccessful on the first ground, the complaints are an abuse of process[3].  The hearing of the application on the second ground has been adjourned pending the outcome of the first ground.

    [1] Paragraph 1.1 submissions for the defendant dated 2 August 2010 (“Unimin’s first submissions”) ;

    [2] Paragraph 4 Unimin’s first submissions; 

    [3] Paragraph 5 Unimin’s first submissions;

  2. Pursuant to orders made 14 July 2010, the parties filed and served written submissions[4] and the application was set down, and heard, on 7 September 2010.  Upon my invitation, further written submissions on Cohen v. Macefield Pty Ltd [2010] QCA 95 (Cohen) and Broome v. Chenoweth (1946) 73 CLR 583 were received from Unimin dated 14 September 2010 and the complainants dated 21 September 2010. On 14 October 2010 Boddice J. delivered judgement in NK Collins Industries Pty Ltd v. President of the Industrial Court of Queensland et al [2010] QSC 373. Among other things, that case considered the application of Kirk v. Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales et al (2010) 239 CLR 531; (2010) HCA 1. The parties requested the opportunity of making further submissions in the light of that case. Further written submissions were received from Unimin dated 27 October 2010 and from the complainants dated 11 November 2010. The matter was further mentioned in court on 12 November 2010.

    [4] Unimin’s first submissions; submissions for Complaint (undated); Unimin’s submissions in reply dated 24 August 2010 (“Unimin’s reply”);

  3. There are three complaints each charging Unimin with an offence under section 4.3.1 Integrated Planning Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QMC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bell & Anor v Unimin Australia Limited was heard in a court, where Unimin Australia Limited applied to strike out or permanently stay two complaints issued against the applicants under the Justices Act 1886. The applicants, Bell and another, were charged with offences under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and the Environmental Protection Act 1994. Unimin's primary contention was that the complaints were defective and should be dismissed on the grounds that they failed to adequately plead the essential factual ingredients of the offences. The court had to determine whether the complaints sufficiently outlined the elements of the offence and whether they were so defective as to warrant being struck out or permanently stayed.

The legal issues central to this case revolved around the interpretation of the term "get" within the context of the offence definitions and whether the complaints had adequately alleged the necessary factual components to substantiate the charges. The court had to analyse the complaints to ascertain if they complied with the statutory requirements and if they sufficiently detailed the factual basis for the charges. The court also needed to consider whether the complaints were so fundamentally flawed that they should be dismissed, either by being struck out or permanently stayed.

In its decision, the court concluded that the complaints, although presenting difficulties, did not reach the threshold of being so defective that they should be dismissed. The court found that the term "convert" in the definition of "get" stood out as having a distinct meaning that materially differed from the other terms, which shared overlapping meanings. The court decided to hear further submissions from the parties on this specific point and indicated that if they could not resolve it, the matter would be heard again. Consequently, the application to strike out or permanently stay the complaints was refused. The court left the door open for further orders if they were sought by the parties and indicated that if Unimin wished to pursue the "abuse of process" ground, the matter would need to be listed for a hearing in the usual way.

The final orders of the court were that the application to strike out or permanently stay the complaints charging the applicants with offences under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and the Environmental Protection Act 1994 was refused. The court indicated that further applications or hearings could be scheduled if necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application to strike out or permanently stay one complaint charging the applicant with an offence under the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and one complaint charging the applicant with an offence under the Environmental Protection Act 1994 is refused

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is a difficult question given the broad and overlapping meanings of the words used in the definition of “get”. I have not heard detailed submissions on this point. I note however, that one word in the definition of “get” stands alone i.e. “convert”. Its meaning materially differs from all the other words which, to some degree or other, overlap in their meanings. I will hear the parties further on this question upon a fresh application in the event that they cannot resolve that issue. Conclusion The application to strike out or permanently stay complaints 1 & 2 on the basis that they are a nullity is refused. I will hear the parties if other orders are sought. In the event that Unimin wishes to pursue the second ground of its application i.e. “abuse of process”, the matter will need to be listed for hearing in the usual way.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.