Bechara v The State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Judicial Review)

BECHARA v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2021] SASC 126

Judgment of the Honourable Justice David  

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - ADMINISTRATION OF PRISONS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - CONDITIONS AND MANAGEMENT

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

In this judicial review, the applicant challenges three assessments and determinations made by the Chief Executive of the Department for Correctional Services (the 'CE') since 29 September 2020. They relate to the exercise of the CE's power pursuant to s 23 of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (the 'Act') and concern the applicant's security rating and ordered return to Port Augusta Prison from Yatala Labour Prison. The applicant contends that the assessments and determinations were in breach of the rules of natural justice, unlawful, unreasonable, an abuse of power, not supported by any or sufficient evidence, and that the decision-maker took into account irrelevant considerations and failed to take into account relevant considerations.

The applicant seeks various remedies including a writ of certiorari quashing the three decisions, a writ of mandamus compelling the CE to assess the applicant and his circumstances according to law, an injunction restraining the CE from carrying out any assessments or determinations in respect of the applicant until the CE complies with the requirements of s 23, and a writ of habeas corpus.

The respondent contends that the action should be summarily dismissed as there is no reasonable basis for the grounds of judicial review relied upon by the applicant in prosecuting the claim. Further, the respondent contends that even if the applicant can satisfy the Court that there is a reasonable basis for any of the grounds relied upon (which is denied), there is no reasonable basis for the relief sought by the applicant. In the alternative, the respondent seeks that the applicant's amended Originating Application and amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions be struck out in full as they fail to comply with the applicable rules and are frivolous and vexatious within the meaning of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA).

Held, per David JA, granting the respondent's application and summarily dismissing the applicant's action for judicial review:

1. There is no reasonable basis for any grounds of review relied upon by the applicant.

Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) ss 22, 23, 24, 25, 37A; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 144.2 & 256.5, referred to.
Agius v The Parole Board of South Australia [2020] SASC 225; Chief of Navy v Angre (2016) 244 FCR 457; Fyfe v State of South Australia [2000] SASC 84; Fyfe v The State of South Australia [2007] SASC 272; Hart v Parole Board [2017] SASC 184; Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550; Kleentex (Thailand) Co Ltd v Corporate IM Pty Ltd [2012] SASC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bechara v The State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASC 126
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Bechara, sought judicial review of decisions made by the Chief Executive (CE) under s 23 of the Prisons Act 2004 (SA), which pertains to the initial and periodic assessment of prisoners. The applicant's claims were dismissed by the South Australian Supreme Court on the basis that there was no reasonable basis for any of the grounds of review he had relied upon. The Court was required to decide whether there was a reasonable basis for the applicant's grounds of judicial review, specifically whether the CE had failed to consider relevant factors or had taken into account irrelevant factors in making the decision to return the applicant to Port Augusta Prison. The Court found that the applicant had not established a factual basis for his claims and that the decisions made by the CE were valid.

The Court found that the applicant had not established a reasonable basis for any of the grounds of review he had relied upon. The applicant had contended that the CE had failed to consider relevant factors or had taken into account irrelevant factors in making the decision to return him to Port Augusta Prison. However, the Court found that the applicant had not provided any factual basis for these assertions. The Court also found that the decisions made by the CE were valid and that the applicant had not identified any specific decision relating to home detention or transfer to another prison that could be reviewed. The Court held that the applicant had not established a reasonable basis for any of the grounds of review he had relied upon, and the Court summarily dismissed the applicant's action for judicial review.

The Court granted the respondent's application and summarily dismissed the applicant's action for judicial review. The Court found that there was no reasonable basis for any of the grounds of review relied upon by the applicant and that the decisions made by the CE were valid. The Court held that the applicant had not established a reasonable basis for any of the grounds of review he had relied upon, and the Court summarily dismissed the applicant's action for judicial review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, per David JA, granting the respondent's application and summarily dismissing the applicant's action for judicial review:

1. There is no reasonable basis for any grounds of review relied upon by the applicant.

Background

Background to the litigation

In determining whether there is a reasonable basis, the Court is not required to be satisfied that the action is hopeless or bound to fail.[4] The test (which applies to both rules) requires a practical enquiry or assessment of whether there is a reasonable or real prospect of prosecuting the action successfully. The inquiry may require consideration of the underlying merits of the action, the form of relief sought, or a combination of both.[5] That the relief sought is discretionary in nature is no bar on summary judgment; if the Court is satisfied there is no reasonable prospect that a trial Judge would exercise the discretion to grant the relief, it must dismiss the action.[6] However, the power to summarily determine an action should not be exercised lightly.[7][4] Spencer v The Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [17] per French CJ and Gummow J, at [52]-[53], [56] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ.[5] Kleentex (Thailand) Co Ltd v Corporate IM Pty Ltd [2012] SASC 71 at [19] per White J.[6] Spencer v The Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [51]-[52], [56]-[58] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ.[7] Spencer v The Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [24]-[26] per French CJ and Gummow J, at [52]-[60] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ.Background On 22 March 2013, following a trial by judge alone, the applicant was convicted of two counts of trafficking in a controlled drug, namely methylamphetamine, and two counts of trafficking in a commercial quantity of a controlled drug, namely cocaine. On 25 June 2013, the applicant was sentenced to a head sentence of 22 years and 6 months imprisonment, cumulative on a balance of unexpired parole of 7 months and 5 days, resulting in a head sentence of 23 years, 1 month, and 5 days imprisonment. A non-parole period of 18 years was fixed. The applicant appealed his sentence. On appeal, the head sentence was affirmed and a new non-parole period of 17 years and 3 months was imposed, which was ordered to commence on 2 February 2011, the date the applicant was first remanded in custody. The applicant’s head sentence ends on 6 March 2034.[8] His non-parole period expires on 1 May 2028.[9][8] Exhibit HMM-6 of the Affidavit of Ms Mills affirmed 16 June 2021 (FDN 22).[9] Exhibit HMM-6 of the Affidavit of Ms Mills affirmed 16 June 2021 (FDN 22).The legislative framework – s 23 of the Act Before turning to consider the grounds of review, it is first necessary to briefly describe the function of s 23 and its operation in the context of the Act as a whole. Section 23 of the Act provides for the initial and periodic assessment of prisoners. It states:23 —Initial and periodic assessment of prisoners(1) The CE must, as soon as practicable after the initial admission to a prison of a person who has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment exceeding six months, to life imprisonment or to a sentence of indeterminate duration, and thereafter at regular intervals of not more than one year, assess the prisoner and his or her circumstances and determine whether or not the prisoner should be transferred to some other prison.(2) The Minister may, for the purpose of assisting the CE in carrying out assessments under this section, establish such committees as the Minister thinks fit.(3) In carrying out an assessment under this section, the CE must have regard to—(a) the age, gender, gender identity, sexuality or sexual identity, and the social, medical, psychological and vocational background and history, of the prisoner; and(b) the needs of the prisoner in respect of education or training or medical or psychiatric treatment; and(c) the aptitude or suitability of the prisoner for any particular form of training or work; and(d) the nature of the offence, or offences, in respect of which the prisoner is imprisoned and the length of sentence; and(e) the information contained in any file held by a court in respect of the prisoner; and(f) the behaviour of the prisoner while in prison; and(g) the security of, and availability of accommodation in, any prison under consideration; and(h) the question of maintaining the prisoner's family ties; and(i) where relevant, any proposed plans in respect of the release of the prisoner and his or her social rehabilitation; and(j) such other matters as the CE thinks relevant.(4) The CE must notify the prisoner before commencing an assessment, and must, if the prisoner so requests, grant the prisoner an opportunity to make representations in person to the CE or to a committee established pursuant to subsection (2), including a request that, if practicable, the assessment be made by a person of the same sex or gender identity as the prisoner.(5) The prisoner may make written representations in respect of his or her assessment to the CE or to a committee established pursuant to subsection (2).(6) After the first assessment of a prisoner has been completed, the CE must prepare a programme in relation to the prisoner that contains particulars of any proposals for the education or training or medical or psychiatric treatment of the prisoner, and may, after any subsequent assessment, add to or vary that programme.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The matter proceeded to a hearing on 25 June 2021. At that time (and at all earlier times) Mr Mancini appeared as counsel for the applicant. During the hearing, the applicant terminated his instructions of Mr Mancini and his solicitors, who sought and were granted leave to withdraw from the matter. The applicant represented himself for the remainder of the proceedings.The Court’s power to grant summary judgment As mentioned earlier, the respondent contends that the action should be summarily dismissed as there is no reasonable basis for the grounds of judicial review relied upon by the applicant in prosecuting the claim. Under r 256.5(a) of the UCR, the Court must dismiss the applicant’s action for judicial review ‘unless the Court is satisfied that there is a reasonable basis for the action’. Rule 144.2(2)(a) empowers the Court to dismiss the action summarily on the application of the respondent ‘if there is no reasonable basis for prosecuting the claim’. The applicant bears the onus of establishing a reasonable basis for his claim.[3][3] Hart v Parole Board [2017] SASC 184 at [8] per Stanley J. In determining whether there is a reasonable basis, the Court is not required to be satisfied that the action is hopeless or bound to fail.[4] The test (which applies to both rules) requires a practical enquiry or assessment of whether there is a reasonable or real prospect of prosecuting the action successfully. The inquiry may require consideration of the underlying merits of the action, the form of relief sought, or a combination of both.[5] That the relief sought is discretionary in nature is no bar on summary judgment; if the Court is satisfied there is no reasonable prospect that a trial Judge would exercise the discretion to grant the relief, it must dismiss the action.[6] However, the power to summarily determine an action should not be exercised lightly.[7][4] Spencer v The Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [17] per French CJ and Gummow J, at [52]-[53], [56] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ.[5] Kleentex (Thailand) Co Ltd v Corporate IM Pty Ltd [2012] SASC 71 at [19] per White J.[6] Spencer v The Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [51]-[52], [56]-[58] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ.[7] Spencer v The Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [24]-[26] per French CJ and Gummow J, at [52]-[60] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ.Background On 22 March 2013, following a trial by judge alone, the applicant was convicted of two counts of trafficking in a controlled drug, namely methylamphetamine, and two counts of trafficking in a commercial quantity of a controlled drug, namely cocaine. On 25 June 2013, the applicant was sentenced to a head sentence of 22 years and 6 months imprisonment, cumulative on a balance of unexpired parole of 7 months and 5 days, resulting in a head sentence of 23 years, 1 month, and 5 days imprisonment. A non-parole period of 18 years was fixed. The applicant appealed his sentence. On appeal, the head sentence was affirmed and a new non-parole period of 17 years and 3 months was imposed, which was ordered to commence on 2 February 2011, the date the applicant was first remanded in custody. The applicant’s head sentence ends on 6 March 2034.[8] His non-parole period expires on 1 May 2028.[9][8] Exhibit HMM-6 of the Affidavit of Ms Mills affirmed 16 June 2021 (FDN 22).[9] Exhibit HMM-6 of the Affidavit of Ms Mills affirmed 16 June 2021 (FDN 22).The legislative framework – s 23 of the Act

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This ground of review is not supportable.Relevant and irrelevant considerations The applicant contends that the CE improperly exercised their power under s 23 in making the determination to return the applicant to PAP as soon as practicable. The applicant submits that the CE had regard to irrelevant considerations and failed to take into account relevant considerations. There is no factual basis identified or apparent to support this assertion. This ground of review is not supportable.Other contentions and grievances Home detention The applicant asserts that the CE omitted or refused to permit him to apply for home detention. The applicant has not established a factual basis for this assertion by reason of: first, in the Applicant’s Statement he says to the contrary, that he applied to be released on home detention in November 2019;[33] second, the CRC minutes of the applicant’s case review on 29 September 2020 note the applicant’s request to be placed on home detention and that the CMC supports his request;[34] and third, the SOC minutes taken on 23 November 2020 refer to the CRC minutes.[35] [33] Amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (FDN 21) at [75].[34] Exhibit HMM-6 of the Affidavit of Ms Mills affirmed 16 June 2021 (FDN 22).[35] Exhibit HMM-8 of the Affidavit of Ms Mills affirmed 16 June 2021 (FDN 22). Thus, it can be seen that the applicant was afforded the opportunity to apply for home detention, that he did in fact apply to be placed on home detention, and that the SOC were informed of, and considered, a request by the applicant to be placed on home detention. In any event, a decision as to home detention involves an exercise of power that is separate and distinct from a decision made under s 23 of the Act. A decision in respect of home detention is made by the CE (or their delegate) under s 37A of the Act. That section confers on the CE absolute discretion to decide whether to order a prisoner to serve a period of their sentence on home detention. A decision under s 23 may well be taken into account, and may even be influential, in the CE’s subsequent consideration of whether a prisoner is suitable for home detention. However, a determination under s 23 does not dictate the outcome of a s 37A decision. A decision as to a prisoner’s release on home detention is made under a separate and distinct power. No specific decision relating to home detention has been identified by the applicant for the purposes of this judicial review. This ground of review is not supportable.Other grievances – Part 3, Contentions 7, 11-13, 16-22, 27-30, 32-34 I accept the respondent’s submission that these contentions do not raise any grounds of judicial review, nor are they supported by any identified factual bases. As to contention 12, the applicant asserts that the CE ‘failed to carry out any or proper or adequate determination’ as to whether the applicant should be transferred to another prison. Any decision to transfer the applicant to another correctional institution involves an exercise of power under s 25 of the Act. It is a separate and distinct exercise of power from the challenged decisions made under s 23.