Fyfe v The State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

FYFE v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2007] SASC 272

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kelly

23 July 2007

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT

Application for judicial review of a decision not to revoke an order to keep applicant separate and apart from other prisoners – decision made pursuant to s36 Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) – whether there was jurisdictional error – whether procedural fairness was afforded to the applicant – complaint of inhumane treatment of applicant.

Held: Decision maker exercised discretion according to the law – procedural fairness was afforded to the applicant – conditions of incarceration not relevant to the exercise of decision maker’s discretion - in any event applicant has not been subjected to inhumane treatment -no jurisdictional error.  Application dismissed.

Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) s36(2)(c), s36(6)(b), referred to.
Fyfe v Bordoni & Ors (1998) 199 LSJS 401; Fyfe v The State of South Australia [2000] SASC 84; Page v The State of South Australia (1997) 95 A Crim R 25; Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550, applied.

FYFE v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2007] SASC 272

Criminal:                  

KELLY J:

Introduction

  1. The applicant seeks judicial review of a decision not to revoke an order made on 16 January 1995 to keep him separate and apart from other prisoners. This decision was made by the General Manager of Yatala Labour Prison (“Yatala”), exercising his discretion under s36(6)(b) of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (“the Act”).

  2. On 16 January 1995 the applicant murdered a fellow prisoner.  On the same day, the General Manager of Yatala directed that in the interests of protecting other prisoners the applicant be kept separate and apart.  That direction has never been revoked.  Prior to the hearing of this application the last determination under the section by the General Manager not to revoke the direction was made on 12 April 2007 (the relevant decision).

    Grounds

  3. The applicant has brought two previous applications of a similar nature.  The matters relevant to those applications can be found in the judgments of Olsson J in Fyfe v Bordoni & Ors[1] (the 1998 review) and Martin J in Fyfe v The State of South Australia[2] (the 2000 review).

    [1] (1998) 199 LSJS 401.

  4. At the hearing of this application the applicant was unrepresented.  The grounds he identified for seeking judicial review of the General Manager’s decision were put in the following way:

    1.The conditions that apply to the applicant in G Division are unacceptable and more restrictive than in the past.

    2.There are errors in some of the documentation relied on by the General Manager in reaching the decision not to revoke the order made.  Therefore his continued separation from the mainstream prison population is not authorised.

    3.Procedural fairness has been denied to the applicant in a number of ways including:

    (i)       Prisoner complaint procedures to visiting inspectors;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fyfe v The State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 272
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fyfe sought judicial review of a decision by the General Manager of Yatala, Gary John Oxford, not to revoke an order to keep him separate and apart from other prisoners. The decision was made under section 36 of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA). The applicant contended that the decision was a jurisdictional error and that he was not afforded procedural fairness. He further alleged that he was being subjected to inhumane treatment. The court was required to determine whether the decision-maker exercised his discretion according to the law and whether the applicant was afforded procedural fairness. Additionally, the court had to examine whether the conditions of the applicant’s incarceration were relevant to the exercise of the decision-maker’s discretion, and whether the applicant had been subjected to inhumane treatment.

The court found that the decision-maker had exercised his discretion according to the law and that procedural fairness was afforded to the applicant. The court held that the conditions of incarceration were not relevant to the exercise of the decision-maker’s discretion. The court also found that the applicant had not been subjected to inhumane treatment. The court held that there was no jurisdictional error in the decision. The application was dismissed.

The court dismissed the application and held that the decision-maker exercised his discretion according to the law. The court found that the applicant was afforded procedural fairness and that the conditions of incarceration were not relevant to the exercise of the decision-maker’s discretion. The court also found that the applicant had not been subjected to inhumane treatment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I respectfully agree that I should apply these principles to the determination of this application.The relevant decision Mr Gary John Oxford, in his position as the current General Manager of Yatala, is the delegate of the Chief Executive Officer. Mr Oxford explained the basis of his decision to keep the applicant separate and apart from other prisoners in affidavits sworn on 18 August 2006 and 30 March 2007. These affidavits were supplemented by oral evidence at the hearing. According to Mr Oxford, the applicant continues to present an unreasonably high level of risk of harm to other prisoners. He told the Court that he had taken a number of factors into account in reaching this conclusion. His considerations included a psychological assessment of the applicant’s likelihood of re-offending if reintegrated into the prison population, the applicant’s behaviour since the last judicial review (the 2000 review) and subsequent behavioural responses of the applicant to Department attempts to implement the recommendations in the Bambonye report. In assessing the applicant’s behavioural responses, Mr Oxford reviewed documentation concerning interactions between the applicant and various officers of the Department for Correctional Services over a considerable period. Those documents are held electronically on the Justice Information System (JIS). Each Correctional Services Officer makes entries on the JIS more or less contemporaneously with any significant interaction with the applicant. In light of his quite recent appointment as General Manager of Yatala in November 2004, Mr Oxford explained that it was necessary for him to review documentation held by the Department to inform himself adequately of the history of the applicant’s incarceration in G Division. Mr Oxford gave evidence that he relied on specific material related to occasional threats made by the applicant towards Correctional Services Officers and others between 1999 and 2004. The applicant submitted that he had made no threats to anyone since 1999. However, there are a number of reports of allegations made by various Correctional Services staff. There are also a number of threats contained within letters written by the applicant himself to various authorities. It is true that the threats over the period of time appear to have diminished and sometimes are quite non-specific. Nevertheless, the material upon which Mr Oxford relied, as set out in his affidavit of 18 August 2006[6] was all relevant material to be considered by him in making the relevant decision.[6] Affidavit of Gary John Oxford dated 18 August 2006, para 83. In addition to this material, Mr Oxford also relied on a psychologist’s report of 1 September 2004. A matter of ongoing concern has been the failure in the past of the applicant to proffer any reasons for his earlier violent offending. At the hearing of this application, the applicant did proffer some reasons for the commission of the offences of both murder and attempted murder, for which he has been convicted. However, his explanation for murdering the police officer appears to be at odds with the explanation he proffered to the psychologist in 2004. Whether that explanation approximates to the truth is a matter of conjecture. However, the applicant’s evidence on this topic in my view demonstrates the accuracy of the psychologist’s conclusion in the September 2004 report that the applicant continues to demonstrate little insight into his offending behaviour.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established