Narroway v Department for Correctional Services

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Judicial Review)

NARROWAY v DEPARTMENT FOR CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

[2024] SASC 19

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre  

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT – DECISIONS TO WHICH JUDICIAL REVIEW LEGISLATION APPLIES - MEANING OF DECISION – REPORTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT – DECISIONS TO WHICH JUDICIAL REVIEW LEGISLATION APPLIES – DECISIONS OF AN ADMINISTRATIVE CHARACTER

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY – SUMMARY DISPOSAL – SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

The applicant, Samuel Narroway, made an application to this Court seeking judicial review of a decision of the respondent, the Department for Correctional Services.  The decision is one that amongst other things assessed the applicant as suitable to complete the Domestic & Family Violence Intervention Program (‘DFVIP’).

The applicant seeks orders that the decision be set aside, a declaration be made that DFVIP is not applicable to him and that a tag of ‘DV Offender’ be removed from the applicant’s records within the respondent’s Justice Information System (‘JIS’) on the basis that he has never been convicted of a domestic violence offence.

Held granting the respondent’s application for summary judgment:

1.      There is no reasonable basis for any ground of review relied upon by the applicant nor                the relief sought by the applicant.

Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 12.1, 12.2, 34.1, 143.1, 143.2, 144.2, 256.3; Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) s 23, referred to.
Narroway v Parole Board of South Australia [2023] SASC 100; Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd. v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd (2020) 137 SASR 117; Spencer v Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; (2010) 241 CLR 118; Hot Holdings Pty Ltd v Creasey (1996) 185 CLR 149 ; Vansetten v The State of South Australia [2020] SASC 158; Bechara v The State of South Australia [2021] SASC 126, considered.

NARROWAY v DEPARTMENT FOR CORRECTIONAL SERVICES
[2024] SASC 19

Civil: Judicial Review

  1. McINTYRE J:   The applicant, Mr Narroway, issued these proceedings for judicial review of a decision of the respondent, the Department for Correctional Services (‘DCS’), which resulted in him being offered a place on the Domestic & Family Violence Intervention Program (‘DFVIP’).  The applicant seeks orders that the decision be set aside, a declaration be made that DFVIP is not applicable to him and that a tag of “DV Offender”[1] be removed from the applicant’s records within the respondent’s Justice Information System (‘JIS’). 

    [1]    Domestic Violence Offender.

  2. The respondent filed an interlocutory application seeking summary judgment on the basis that there is no reasonable basis for any ground of review relied upon by the applicant nor for any relief sought by the applicant. 

  3. For the reasons that follow I find that there is no reasonable or real prospect of success for the application and accordingly I grant the respondent’s application for summary judgment. 

    Background

  4. The applicant has an extensive history of offending…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Narroway v Department for Correctional Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Narroway v Department for Correctional Services, the applicant, who has an extensive history of offending, sought judicial review of a decision made by an employee of the respondent, the Department for Correctional Services (DCS). The applicant challenged the decision to deem him eligible to attend a domestic and family violence intervention program (DFVIP) and sought to have a 'DV Offender' tag removed from his records. The respondent sought summary dismissal of the application on the grounds that the challenge was made out of time and that the applicant's claims were not amenable to judicial review. The court was required to determine whether the applicant's challenge to the decision was time-barred and whether the decision was a reviewable one under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (SA).

The court held that the applicant's challenge to the decision made on 9 February 2021 was indeed time-barred as it was not made within the prescribed period. Additionally, the court found that the decision was not amenable to judicial review because it was not a decision of an administrative character. The court reasoned that the decision to deem the applicant eligible for the DFVIP was based on an actuarial risk assessment tool and considered information beyond prior convictions, including police reports and allegations of domestic violence. The court concluded that such a decision did not constitute a reviewable administrative decision under the Act.

Given these findings, the court granted the respondent's application for summary judgment and dismissed the applicant's challenge. The court found that there was no reasonable or real prospect of success for the application and that it was therefore appropriate to summarily dismiss the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow I find that there is no reasonable or real prospect of success for the application and accordingly I grant the respondent’s application for summary judgment. Background The applicant has an extensive history of offending in both South Australia and interstate. He is currently serving a total sentence of imprisonment of five years and two months with a non-parole period of two years, eight months, and 14 days related to three sets of offending. Details of the offending and the sentences imposed are set out in Narroway v Parole Board of South Australia.[2] For present purposes it is relevant to note that the applicant has been in custody since 7 September 2019 and that the expiry date for his head sentence is 5 November 2024. His non-parole period expired on 19 May 2022. [2] Narroway v Parole Board of South Australia [2023] SASC 100 at [4] to [9] (‘Narroway’). The applicant initiated these proceedings by filing an application for review on 2 March 2023. He applied for, and was granted, leave to file an amended application. The applicant filed this amended application on 25 August 2023. In this application he identifies the decision the subject of his application as:Date of decision: 09/02/2021 & 06/11/2022. The applicant says that he received the decision, presumably the 6 November 2022 decision, on 17 January 2023. In summary, the applicant challenges an assessment of an employee of the respondent which resulted in him being considered suitable to attend the DFVIP and he further seeks removal of the ‘tag’ denoting ‘DV Offender’ from JIS. The respondent issued an interlocutory application seeking summary dismissal of the application pursuant to either rr 143.1 or 144.2 of the Uniform Civil Rules (‘UCR’). In the alternative, the respondent says that the pleading and claims in the amended originating application ought to be either struck out under r 34.1of the UCR or dismissed under r 143.2 of the UCR on the basis that the action is frivolous, vexatious or an abuse of the process of the Court. The respondent’s application is brought on two grounds. First that any challenge to a decision made on 9 February 2021 is made out of time[3] and requires leave. No extension of time has been sought. Second, the respondent contends that the matters raised in the originating application are not decisions, acts, or omissions amenable to judicial review. [3] Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 256.3 (‘UCR’).Hearing For convenience, both the respondent’s interlocutory application and the originating application were heard together. The following affidavits were tendered by consent:·Angela Ruth Fletcher dated 16 May 2023;[4] ·Samuel Mark Narroway dated 2 February 2023; [5] and ·Samuel Mark Narroway dated 21 June 2023.[6][4] Exhibit R1.[5] Exhibit A2.[6] Exhibit A3. There was no oral evidence called and the matter proceeded by way of written and oral submissions.The Decisions Ms Fletcher’s affidavit establishes that on 8 February 2021, after the applicant was sentenced, she conducted an initial assessment of the applicant under s 23 of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (‘the Act’). Ms Fletcher then created an individual development plan (‘IDP’) for the applicant the following day, 9 February 2021.[7] This appears to be the first decision identified by the applicant in his originating application. [7] Exhibit R1 at [4].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There was no oral evidence called and the matter proceeded by way of written and oral submissions.The Decisions Ms Fletcher’s affidavit establishes that on 8 February 2021, after the applicant was sentenced, she conducted an initial assessment of the applicant under s 23 of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (‘the Act’). Ms Fletcher then created an individual development plan (‘IDP’) for the applicant the following day, 9 February 2021.[7] This appears to be the first decision identified by the applicant in his originating application. [7] Exhibit R1 at [4]. This initial assessment concluded that, based on a review of the DFVIP criteria and the applicant’s Ontario Domestic Abuse Risk Assessment (‘ODARA’) score, the applicant was eligible for the DFVIP. Ms Fletcher’s affidavit says that the ODARA is an actuarial risk management tool comprised of empirically tested and validated predictions. Ms Fletcher explained the manner in which that tool is applied. The DFVIP is a group based rehabilitation program for men with an identified history of violence and abuse against their intimate partners. Ms Fletcher said that all available and relevant information held by DCS relating to an offender, including information provided by the offender in an interview, is considered when an IDP is prepared. Whilst the applicant has never been convicted of a domestic violence offence, DCS was aware of a police report made by the applicant’s former spouse in August 2020. This report detailed allegations concerning three separate occasions in which the applicant allegedly acted in an abusive and threatening manner toward her. The report also noted that the applicant had allegedly threatened her from gaol, and that she was fearful that he would hurt or assault her in the future when released from prison. The applicant declined to comment when interviewed by the police. He was subsequently issued with an intervention order and charged with three counts of aggravated assault and property damage. Those charges were on foot at the time Ms Fletcher prepared the IDP; however, the criminal charges were withdrawn on 17 February 2022 and the intervention order was revoked on 1 December 2022.[8] Ms Fletcher explained the rationale for taking such material into account as follows:[9]There is considerable international and Australian research showing that, in addition to being less likely than many offence types to be brought to the attention of police, domestic violence incidents are particularly unlikely to result in a criminal conviction. As such, it is DCS practice to examine not only prior convictions but also prior police reports, even where these did not result in charges or convictions in administering the ODARA. This is consistent with the ODARA scoring method.[8] Exhibit A3 at [8] – [9].[9] Exhibit R1 at [8]. Given that there was information indicative of partner violence, albeit consisting of unproven allegations, Ms Fletcher said that the applicant met the criteria for the administration of the ODARA and she proceeded with that assessment. The ODARA rated the applicant against thirteen variables and gave him a score of either zero or one for each variable. Those scores were collated in order to determine a risk assessment score. The applicant’s final raw ODARA score was seven and made up as follows: ·prior custodial sentence of 30 days or more;·failure on a prior conditional release;·victim concern about future assaults;·more than one child;·victim’s biological child from a previous partner;·history of substance abuse; and·barriers to victim support.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.