Bebek and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Bebek and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2022] AATA 3181 (30 September 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2022/6029      

Re:Mirjana Bebek  

APPLICANT

Australian Capital TerritoryAnd  

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY Decision

Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member

Date:30 September 2022

Place:Canberra

Application made within the prescribed time.

............[SGD]...............

Mr S. Webb, Member

Catchwords

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – application for review of reconsideration decision denying liability in respect of a workers’ compensation claim – prescribed time for making application – notice of decision sent by email – when decision is given to the applicant – decision given when it was capable of being retrieved by the applicant – application within prescribed time

Legislation

Acts Interpretation Act 1901, ss 28A, 29
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 25, 29, 68
Electronic Transactions Act 1999, ss 5, 9, 14, 14A
Evidence Act 1995, ss 4, 5, 160, 161, 163
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4, 4A, 60, 62, 64, 74, 108E

Administrative Appeals Tribunals Regulations 2015, r 17, 18

Cases

Swanton v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2017] FCA 1142

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 220

Adhikari & Anor v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCCA 1884

Palmer v Commissioner of State Taxation (WA) [1976] HCA 61; 136 CLR 406

Russell v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 110

Flahive and Comcare [2020] AATA 3044

Danagher v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCA 1408

Wagner v National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 1775

Sullivan v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2014] FCAFC 93

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

30 September 2022

  1. Mirjana Bebek claims she was injured in her employment by the Australian Capital Territory (ACT). Initially, her claim was accepted but this was subsequently revoked following an own-motion reconsideration by Employers Mutual Limited (EML), compensation claims manager for the Australian Capital Territory (ACT). Ms Bebek applied for review of this decision.

  2. In response, the ACT asserts Ms Bebek’s application is outside the time prescribed for the making of an application for review and, without the grant of an extension of time, it is not valid. In the ACT’s submission, grant of an extension of time is not reasonable in all the circumstances.

  3. These interlocutory issues came on for hearing. Documents were taken into evidence and the parties have made written and oral submissions addressing relevant issues.

  4. It is appropriate in the circumstances, with the parties agreement, to proceed to determine threshold issues relating to the prescribed time for making an application first.

  5. These reasons address that issue, alone.

    Relevant facts

  6. The following relevant facts are established by evidence, without controversy:

    (a)Ms Bebek signed a compensation claim form on 21 February 2021.

    (b)On 6 May 2021, under s 14 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act), EML determined to accept liability for an injury in the form of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood and symptomatic exacerbation of alopecia areata.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bebek and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 3181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a reconsideration decision made by EML, which revoked Ms Bebek's accepted workers' compensation claim. The Australian Capital Territory (ACT) contended that Ms Bebek's application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was lodged outside the prescribed 60-day time limit. The central dispute revolved around when Ms Bebek was deemed to have been given notice of the reconsideration decision.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were: firstly, whether the AAT Act was relevant to determining the time for lodging an application for review; and secondly, when the reconsideration decision was legally given to Ms Bebek for the purposes of calculating the prescribed time limit under section 29 of the AAT Act, as modified by section 65(4) of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The ACT argued that notice was given on 20 April 2022, relying on a presumption of email receipt, while Ms Bebek maintained she only became aware of the decision on 15 June 2022.

The Tribunal determined that the AAT Act was indeed relevant, as section 29 governs the time for lodging applications for review. It found that the prescribed period commenced on the day the decision was made (20 April 2022) and ended 60 days after the decision was given to the applicant. Crucially, the Tribunal found that the evidence did not establish that Ms Bebek was given the reconsideration decision on 20 April 2022. Instead, the evidence confirmed she was given the decision on 15 June 2022.

Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Ms Bebek's application for review, lodged on 21 July 2022, was within the prescribed 60-day period. No extension of time was necessary, and the application was deemed valid, enlivening the Tribunal's jurisdiction to proceed with the matter in the usual manner.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons address that issue, alone.Relevant facts The following relevant facts are established by evidence, without controversy:(a)Ms Bebek signed a compensation claim form on 21 February 2021.(b)On 6 May 2021, under s 14 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act), EML determined to accept liability for an injury in the form of adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood and symptomatic exacerbation of alopecia areata. (c)On 18 June 2021, EML issued a further decision in which, under s 7(4) of the SRC Act, it determined the date of the injury to be 28 July 2016.(d)On 20 April 2022, on its own motion under s 62 of the SRC Act, EML reconsidered and decided to revoke the 6 May 2021 determination (reconsideration decision).[1](e)On 22 April 2022, ACT Payroll, Shared Services HR, Payroll Compo (Shared Services), sent an email to Ms Bebek informing her she had passed the 45 week threshold and, in consequence, changes to her leave accruals would occur.[2](f)On 15 June 2022, Shared Services sent Ms Bebek an email attaching EML’s reconsideration decision in which it stated:Payroll received late notification that EML did a re-consideration of own motion and revoked the acceptance of your compensation claim … effective 20/4/22. Due to this decision you currently do not have an accepted compensation claim… [3](g)Also on 15 June 2022, Ms Bebek’s Rehabilitation Case Manager forwarded the Shared Services email to Ms Bebek’s nominated private email address: Mirjana Mirjana <m…1@mail.com>.[4](h)On 21 July 2022, Ms Bebek instructed her solicitor, Mr Bill McCarthy of Bradley Allen Love Lawyers to lodge an application for review of the reconsideration decision,[5] which he did.[6] In the application, Ms Bebek stated she received the reconsideration decision on 15 June 2022.[7](i)On 23 August 2022, Mr Ron Moss, a solicitor employed by HWLE Ebsworth Lawyers, acting for the ACT, informed the Tribunal Ms Bebek’s application was outside the 60 day timeframe prescribed under s 29(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act) as modified by s 65(4) of the SRC Act.[1] Exhibit B.[2] Exhibit F.[3] Exhibit D, Attachment A.[4] Ibid, Attachment B.[5] Exhibit D.[6] Exhibit C.[7] Ibid, page 2. Affidavits sworn by Mr McCarthy and Mr Moss are in evidence.[8] Relevant claim notes from Ms Bebek’s compensation claim file have been placed before the Tribunal.[9][8] Exhibits E and G respectively.[9] Exhibit H. There is a controversy about an email the ACT asserts was sent to Ms Bebek on 20 April 2022. The ACT contends notice of the reconsideration decision was attached to the email, which was sent to two addressees: Mirjana Mirjana and ACTG.[10] Ms Bebek maintains she did not receive this email and she was not aware of it or the reconsideration decision until 15 June 2022.[10] Exhibit A.Submissions In the ACT’s submission, notice of the reconsideration decision was given to Ms Bebek on 20 April 2022. The ACT asserts the notice was sent to Ms Bebek’s nominated email address on that day. Relying on Swanton v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (Swanton),[11] the ACT argues there is a legal presumption under s 161 of the Evidence Act 1901 (Evidence Act) the email was sent and it was received the next day by Ms Bebek. The presumption holds, so the argument goes, unless Ms Bebek produces contrary evidence sufficient to raise doubt about the presumption. The ACT relies on Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Singh)[12] and Adhikari & Anor v Minister for Immigration & Anor (Adhikari)[13] as authority for the proposition a computer printout is evidence the email and any attachments were sent to Ms Bebek on 20 April 2022.[11] [2017] FCA 1142, per Tracy J at [14]-[17].[12] [2015] FCA 220.[13] [2017] FCCA 1884.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the purposes of s 29(2)(a) of the AAT Act, the evidence does not establish and I am unable to find Ms Bebek was given the reconsideration decision on 20 April 2022. The evidence establishes she was given the reconsideration decision on 15 June 2022.Conclusion The prescribed period in which Ms Bebek was entitled to lodge an application for review of the reconsideration decision commenced on the day the reconsideration decision was made it ended 60 days after the decision was given to her on 15 June 2022. This means the application for review Ms Bebek lodged on 21 July 2022 was within the prescribed period. No extension of time is required. The application is valid and sufficient to enliven the Tribunal’s jurisdiction. Henceforth, the application will proceed in the usual manner.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On this basis, Ms Bebek contends her application on 21 July 2022 is within the 60 day prescribed period, which commenced on 15 June 2022, and there is no cause for her to apply for the grant of an extension of time.Consideration There are difficulties with the submissions of each party.Relevance of the AAT Act Ms Bebek’s submission the AAT Act is not relevant must be rejected. The dispute whether Ms Bebek’s application to the Tribunal for review of the reconsideration decision is outside the prescribed period turns on when the reconsideration decision was given to Ms Bebek. This is to be determined under and for the purposes of s 29 of the AAT Act. Section 29 is the starting point in the calculation of time when applying the period prescribed for the purposes of making an application to the Tribunal for review. The following sections are of present relevance: (1) An application to the Tribunal for a review of a decision:…(d) if the terms of the decision were recorded in writing and set out in a document that was given to the applicant or the decision is deemed to be made by reason of the operation of subsection 25(5) or (5A)—shall be lodged with the Tribunal within the prescribed time.Note: Paragraph 33(1)(c) provides that the Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence but may inform itself on any matter in such manner as it thinks appropriate.…Prescribed time for making applications—general(2) Subject to subsection (3), the prescribed time for the purposes of paragraph (1)(d) is the period commencing on the day on which the decision is made and ending on the twenty‑eighth day after:(a) if the decision sets out the findings on material questions of fact and the reasons for the decision—the day on which a document setting out the terms of the decision is given to the applicant; or…(7) The Tribunal may, upon application in writing by a person, extend the time for the making by that person of an application to the Tribunal for a review of a decision (including a decision made before the commencement of this section) if the Tribunal is satisfied that it is reasonable in all the circumstances to do so. Importantly, s 29(2) is modified by s 65(4) of the SRC Act:Subsection 29(2) of the Act has effect as if the reference to “the twenty‑eighth day” (first occurring) were a reference to “the sixtieth day”. Thus it can be seen, the prescribed period commences on the day on which the reconsideration decision was made, 20 April 2022, and it ends on the sixtieth day after the day on which a document setting out the terms of the decision is given to Ms Bebek. Requirements for the giving of documents to a person are set out in s 68 of the AAT Act, in particular: (2) A document that is required or permitted by this Act or another enactment to be given to a person for the purposes of a proceeding before the Tribunal must be given to the person in accordance with:(a) any direction under section 18B; or (b) regulations made under this Act or the other enactment.