Baumgarten and eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Panel)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Baumgarten and eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Panel) [2025] ARTA 59 (5 February 2025)

Applicant/s:  Celine Baumgarten

Respondent:  eSafety Commissioner

Tribunal Number:                2024/3798

GAP Reference Number:    2024-001-028

Tribunal:Justice Kyrou, President, Deputy President O'Donovan, Senior Member Manetta

Place:Melbourne

Date:5 February 2025

Decision:The respondent made a reviewable decision in respect of which the Tribunal has jurisdiction.

................................[sgd]........................................

Justice Kyrou, President

................................[sgd]........................................

Deputy President O'Donovan

................................[sgd]........................................

Senior Member Manetta

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Tribunal’s jurisdiction – respondent has power to give a removal notice to a social media service provider requiring removal of online material – Tribunal has jurisdiction to review a decision to give a removal notice – statutory preconditions for giving a removal notice relating to applicant’s online material not satisfied – respondent gave a social media service provider a written communication described as a complaint alert regarding the applicant’s online material – service provider withheld the material from its social media platform within Australia less than two hours after receiving the alert – whether action taken by respondent was an exercise of powers conferred by the relevant enactment for the purposes of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction – whether a decision to give a removal notice was in fact made even though it was not legally effective – whether decision reviewable by the Tribunal – found Tribunal has jurisdiction to review action taken by respondent in accordance with the principles in Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd (1979) 41 FLR 338

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – referral of a proceeding to the Guidance and Appeals Panel – issue of significance to administrative decision-making – the identified issue of significance to administrative decision-making is a gateway and does not define the matters to be determined by the Panel

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for review lodged with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal but not determined at the time that Tribunal was replaced by the Administrative Review Tribunal – jurisdiction to be determined by reference to the provisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 as in force at the time the application for review was lodged

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024
Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024

Online Safety Act 2021

Cases

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd (1979) 41 FLR 338

Plaintiff M174/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 264 CLR 217

Table of Contents

Statement of Reasons

KYROU P

INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY

RELEVANT STATUTORY PROVISIONS

Online Safety Act

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act

PRINCIPLES RELATING TO THE TRIBUNAL’S JURISDICTION

EVIDENCE

UNCONTESTED FACTS

X’s terms of service

Action taken by the Commissioner in relation to the applicant’s post on X

Procedural background

CONTESTED FACTS

Evidence on contested facts

Mr Hannath’s evidence

Ms Caruana’s evidence

Parties’ submissions on contested facts

Conclusion on contested facts

PARTIES’ SUBMISSIONS ON THE TRIBUNAL’S JURISDICTION

DECISION ON THE TRIBUNAL’S JURISDICTION

Was the Commissioner’s communication to X a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baumgarten and eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Pa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Ms Caruana, brought a case against the eSafety Commissioner, a respondent, regarding a decision made by the Commissioner to issue a removal notice to a social media service provider. The matter was heard and decided by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART). The crux of the dispute was whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the Commissioner's decision and whether the statutory preconditions for issuing a removal notice were met.

The legal issues that the court needed to resolve included whether the Tribunal had the jurisdiction to review the Commissioner's action of issuing a removal notice to a social media service provider, whether the statutory preconditions for issuing such a notice were satisfied, and whether the decision to issue the notice, even if not legally effective, could be reviewed by the Tribunal. The court also needed to determine if the matter should be referred to the Guidance and Appeals Panel for review, and whether the jurisdiction of the Tribunal should be determined based on the provisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 as it was in force at the time the application for review was lodged.

The court found that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the action taken by the Commissioner in accordance with the principles established in the case of Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd. The court determined that the issue of significance to administrative decision-making was a gateway and did not define the matters to be determined by the Panel. Furthermore, the court concluded that the jurisdiction should be determined by reference to the provisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 as in force at the time the application for review was lodged. The court found that the statutory preconditions for issuing a removal notice were not satisfied, and the decision to issue the notice was not legally effective. However, the court determined that the decision was still reviewable by the Tribunal.

No final orders were made in this case as the matter was referred to the Guidance and Appeals Panel for further review.

Background

Background to the litigation

The online portal that Ms Caruana used to communicate with X in relation to the Post does not provide a copy of the information entered into the portal. Accordingly, the Tribunal did not have before it the fields of the portal that Ms Caruana populated in the present case. Prior to the conclusion of the hearing, the Tribunal enquired of counsel for the Commissioner whether it would be possible for the Commissioner to now utilise X’s portal for the purpose of taking screenshots of the pages and fields that the Commissioner would need to populate in lodging a complaint alert. The Tribunal was informed that the Commissioner was willing to attempt this exercise. The Tribunal requested the Commissioner to do so and to lodge with the Tribunal the screenshots obtained by her, provided that the applicant agreed to that course. On 14 January 2025, the Commissioner lodged with the Tribunal five screenshots, and advised that the applicant did not object to their lodgement. I will refer to these screenshots below.UNCONTESTED FACTS The facts summarised at [‎46] to [‎71] below are based upon the documents referred to at [‎39] to [‎44] above and matters that were common ground between the parties.X’s terms of service The parties did not file with the Tribunal all of the provisions of X’s terms of service and policies to which reference is made in other documents. It can be inferred from those references that X had policies which prohibited the posting of material which:(a)incited others to harass members of a protected category;(b)incited behaviour that targeted individuals or groups of people belonging to protected categories;(c)targeted others with repeated slurs, tropes or other content that intended to degrade or reinforce negative or harmful stereotypes about a protected category, including severe repetitive usage of slurs or racist/sexist tropes where the context is to harass or intimidate others. It can also be inferred that, where X formed the view that a post violated its policies, its terms of service authorised it to remove the post from its platform or withhold access to it in a particular country. The parties provided to the Tribunal X’s ‘Platform Use Guidelines’. In those guidelines, X explained ‘country withheld content’ relevantly as follows:Why might content be withheld? Many countries, including the United States, have laws that may apply to posts and/or X account content. In our continuing effort to make our services available to people everywhere, if we receive a valid and properly scoped request from an authorized entity, it may be necessary to withhold access to certain content in a particular country from time to time. Such withholdings will be limited to the specific jurisdiction that has issued the valid legal demand or where the content has been found to violate local law(s)……Withheld postsIf you see the above message, it means X was compelled to withhold the original post in response to a valid legal demand, such as a court order.If you see the above message, it means X withheld content based on local law(s)in response to a report filed through specific support intake channels.…How can I submit a legal request to have content withheld?If you are a law enforcement agent, government official, or other third-party intending to submit a valid legal request and would like to have potentially illegal content or accounts removed from X, we ask that you first review the X Rules and, if applicable, submit a request to have the content reviewed for possible violations of X's Terms of Service, here: you have already submitted a request and have received a response from X indicating that the content in question does not currently violate X's Terms of Service, you can submit a request for content to be withheld through our legal request submission site: You will then receive an automated response confirming that your request has been received by our support system. We will send another email once we've had a chance to evaluate your request. [31][31]Underlining added for emphasis.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The above analysis is consistent with Plaintiff M174/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection.[29] One of the issues in that case was whether the jurisdiction of the Immigration Assessment Authority (‘IAA’) to review a ‘fast track reviewable decision’ of the Minister or their delegate made under Part 7AA of the Migration Act 1958 was confined to a validly made, legally effective decision. The High Court applied Lawlor in finding that the IAA’s jurisdiction was not so confined. The plurality (Gageler, Keane and Nettle JJ) referred to the Lawlor ‘construction’ of s 25 of the AAT Act. Their Honours stated that the Full Court of the Federal Court in Lawlor ‘construed the reference in s 25 of the [AAT Act] to a “decision” in respect of which an enactment might provide for review by [the AAT] as a reference to nothing more than “a decision in fact made, regardless of whether or not it is a legally effective decision.”’[30] Gordon and Edelman JJ delivered short concurring judgments which broadly agreed with the plurality.[29](2018) 264 CLR 217, 232-3 [39], 236-7 [52].[30]Plaintiff M174/2016 (2018) 264 CLR 217, 232-3 [39].EVIDENCE The applicant relied upon an affidavit sworn by Reuben Kirkham on 4 October 2024. Dr Kirkham is a director of Free Speech Union of Australia Pty Ltd, which represented the applicant in this proceeding together with Scott Young of Counsel. Dr Kirkham is not a lawyer. He was not cross-examined on his affidavit. I will refer to the affidavit further below. The applicant also relied upon the following categories of documents:(a)some documents in a bundle of 57 pages lodged by the Commissioner on the basis that they may be relevant to the jurisdictional issue to be determined by the Tribunal (‘Bundle Documents’); and(b)some documents in a bundle of 48 pages lodged by the applicant, being documents obtained on her behalf from the Commissioner under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (‘FOI Documents’). The Commissioner relied upon three affidavits. The first affidavit was affirmed by a solicitor acting for the Commissioner, which is not presently relevant. The second affidavit was affirmed by Luke Hannath on 17 October 2024. He is a lawyer and, in June 2024, he was the acting manager of the adult cyber abuse team (‘ACA team’) in the Commissioner’s office. The third affidavit was affirmed by Samantha Caruana on 11 December 2024. In June 2024, she was an investigator in the ACA team, and reported to Mr Hannath. Both Mr Hannath and Ms Caruana were cross-examined. The Commissioner also relied upon some documents in the Bundle Documents and the FOI Documents. In the course of the cross-examination of Mr Hannath, reference was made to two policy documents of the Commissioner, namely, ‘Compliance and Enforcement Policy eSC CEP December 2021’, and ‘Adult Cyber Abuse Scheme Regulatory Guidance eSC RG 3 December 2023’. Also, two emails forming part of the FOI Documents which had redactions in relation to the names of the sender and recipients were supplemented by versions of the emails without those redactions. These policy documents and unredacted emails form part of the material before the Tribunal on the jurisdictional issue, in addition to the documents referred to at [‎39] to [‎42] above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 220 of the OSA sets out the merits review jurisdiction of the ART from 14 October 2024 (until 13 October 2024, it set out in identical terms the jurisdiction of the AAT) in respect of decisions made by the Commissioner. It relevantly provides as follows:220 Review of decisions by the … Tribunal… Removal notice—cyber‑bullying, intimate images and cyber-abuse(2)An application may be made to the … Tribunal for a review of a decision of the Commissioner under section 65, 77 or 88 to give a removal notice to the provider of:(a)a social media service; or(b)a relevant electronic service; or(c)a designated internet service.(3)An application under subsection (2) may only be made by:(a)the provider of the social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service; or(b)if the material that is the subject of the notice was posted on the service by an end‑user of the service—the end‑user.(4)An application may be made to the … Tribunal for a review of a decision of the Commissioner to refuse to give the provider of:(a)a social media service; or(b)a relevant electronic service; or(c)a designated internet service;a section 65, 77 or 88 removal notice that relates to material provided on the service.(5)An application under subsection (4) may only be made:(a)by a person who made a section 30, 32 or 36 complaint about the material provided on the service; or(b)in the case of a refusal to give a section 65 or 88 removal notice—by, or with the consent of, the person who was the target of the material provided on the service; …… The Bill for the OSA in the form in which it was initially introduced into the Parliament did not refer to ‘informal notices’ or ‘informal requests’. Section 183 deals with the annual reports of the Commissioner. Section 183(2) was inserted during the parliamentary process to add a large list of items to be included in the annual reports,[6] including new paragraph (zi) of s 183(2) which is in the following terms: ‘the number of informal notices given, and informal requests made, by the Commissioner to a person in relation to cyber-abuse material targeted at an Australian adult during that year’. The OSA does not define ‘informal notices’ or ‘informal requests’, and these terms only appear in s 183(2) of the Act.[6]See: Online Safety Bill 2021 (4 February 2021), s 183, p. 148; Online Safety Bill 2021 Schedule of the amendments made by the Senate (22 June 2021), item 8, pp. 3-5.Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act Upon the commencement of the ART Act on 14 October 2024, the ART replaced the AAT. In broad terms, item 24 in schedule 16 of the Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No 1) Act 2024 (‘Transitional Act’) provides that any proceeding commenced in the AAT which is not determined by 14 October 2024 continues in the ART and is to be determined by the application of the provisions of the ART Act. This proceeding was commenced on 7 June 2024. It was not determined by 14 October 2024. If the AAT had jurisdiction in respect of the proceeding, it now falls to be determined by the ART in accordance with the provisions of the ART Act. The question whether the AAT had jurisdiction in respect of the proceeding – and whether it is now properly before the ART – must be determined in accordance with the AAT Act as in force on 7 June 2024.[7][7]Because the definition of ‘decision’ in s 4 of the ART Act is similar to the definition of that term in s 3(3) of the AAT Act and the provisions of the ART Act and the AAT Act which set out what is a reviewable decision (s 12 of the ART Act and s 25 of the AAT Act) are also similar, my analysis and conclusion regarding jurisdiction would have been the same if the provisions of the ART Act had applied.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the principles established in Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd to determine if the ART had jurisdiction over the Commissioner's actions. The court found that the essence of the Commissioner's action, issuing a complaint alert resulting in the removal of online content, was an exercise of statutory powers, satisfying the criteria for tribunal review as per Lawlor. This interpretation aligns with the broader view that a decision in fact made, regardless of its legal effectiveness, can be reviewed by the tribunal. The court also clarified that the issue of significance to administrative decision-making serves as a gateway for determining the Panel's jurisdiction but does not prescribe the specific matters to be addressed. Regarding the jurisdiction's temporal application, the court held that since the application was filed before the ART Act took effect, the jurisdiction should be assessed under the AAT Act as it was in force at the time of filing. This decision ensures that the tribunal's jurisdiction is not retroactively affected by legislative changes, maintaining the legal certainty and predictability in administrative law.