Baumgarten and eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Panel)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Baumgarten and eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Panel) [2025] ARTA 153 (26 February 2025)

Applicant:Celine Baumgarten

Respondent:  eSafety Commissioner

Tribunal Number:                2024/3798

GAP Reference Number:     2024-001-028

Tribunal:Justice Kyrou, President, Deputy President O'Donovan, Senior Member Manetta

Place:Melbourne

Date:26 February 2025

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and remits the matter to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with the Tribunal’s order that the Commissioner consider what action, if any, is required of the Commissioner under the Online Safety Act 2021 in relation to the complaint lodged with the Commissioner on 31 May 2024, including whether a written notice under s 88(3) must be issued to the person who made the complaint under s 36.

..................................[sgd]......................................

Justice Kyrou, President, Deputy President O'Donovan, Senior Member Manetta

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Tribunal found it had jurisdiction to review action taken by Commissioner – not in dispute that reviewable decision must be set aside by Tribunal – whether Tribunal should make a decision in substitution for reviewable decision or remit to Commissioner for reconsideration – Tribunal not satisfied appropriate to substitute a decision – matter remitted to Commissioner.

Legislation

Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2025 (Cth)

Online Safety Act 2021 (Cth)

Cases

Commonwealth v Beale [1993] FCA 294; (1993) 30 ALD 68

Statement of Reasons

  1. Following the publication of our decision and reasons in respect of the jurisdictional issue in this matter,[1] the Tribunal heard submissions with respect to the future conduct of the proceeding.[2] Having heard the parties, the Tribunal has decided that it should set aside the reviewable decision and remit the matter for reconsideration under s 105(c)(ii) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (‘ART Act’) without further hearing. Our reasons for this decision follow.

    [2]See [2025] ARTA 59, [167] (Kyrou P). The President, sitting alone, conducted a directions hearing and heard oral submissions on 19 February 2025, but a transcript of the directions hearing was available to the other Tribunal members.

  2. On the question of jurisdiction, the Tribunal decided that its predecessor, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘AAT’), had jurisdiction in this matter and that this Tribunal continues to have jurisdiction under the applicable transitional provisions.[3]

    [3]See [2025] ARTA 59, [15], [166] (Kyrou P).

  3. Ordinarily, once a preliminary jurisdictional issue is resolved in favour of jurisdiction, the substantive questions in the proceeding remain to be resolved by a hearing involving evidence and legal submissions on what is the correct or preferable decision and, depending on the resolution of those questions, what order should be made under s 105 of the ART Act. Section 105 is in the following terms:

    105 Tribunal decision on review of reviewable decision

    In relation to the reviewable decision, the Tribunal must make a decision:

    (a)affirming the reviewable decision; or

    (b)varying the reviewable decision; or

    (c)setting aside the reviewable decision and:

    (i)    making a decision in substitution for the reviewable decision; or

    (ii)   remitting the matter to the decision‑maker for reconsideration in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baumgarten and eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Pa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Baumgarten and the eSafety Commissioner (Guidance and Appeals Panel) was heard in the Australian Federal Court. The dispute centred around the jurisdiction of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) to review a decision made by the eSafety Commissioner (Commissioner) regarding a written communication given to an individual, described as a 'complaint alert'. The applicant, Baumgarten, contested the legality of the Commissioner's action, arguing that the statutory preconditions for issuing the alert were not met and thus the decision was beyond the Commissioner's authority.

The central legal issues were whether the Tribunal had the jurisdiction to review the Commissioner's decision and, if so, what course of action should be taken upon finding the decision reviewable. The Tribunal had to determine whether, following the setting aside of the reviewable decision, it should make a decision in substitution for the reviewable decision or remit the matter to the Commissioner for reconsideration.

The court found that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the Commissioner's decision, a point not contested by the parties. Both parties agreed that the statutory conditions for issuing the 'complaint alert' were unmet, and thus the decision was unlawful. The court noted that ordinarily, after resolving jurisdictional matters, the substantive issues would be resolved through a hearing involving evidence and legal submissions. However, in this case, two unique factors led to the conclusion that a further hearing was unnecessary. Both parties agreed that the reviewable decision must be set aside and that the Tribunal should not substitute its decision but rather remit the matter to the Commissioner for reconsideration.

The court agreed with the parties' assessment and concluded that the matter should be remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with any orders or recommendations of the Tribunal. This decision was based on the principle that the Tribunal should only remit a matter when it is not in a position to formulate a decision in substitution for the decision set aside, as established in Commonwealth v Beale. The court refrained from making a decision in substitution for the reviewable decision and instead directed the matter back to the Commissioner for further consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ordinarily, once a preliminary jurisdictional issue is resolved in favour of jurisdiction, the substantive questions in the proceeding remain to be resolved by a hearing involving evidence and legal submissions on what is the correct or preferable decision and, depending on the resolution of those questions, what order should be made under s 105 of the ART Act. Section 105 is in the following terms:105 Tribunal decision on review of reviewable decisionIn relation to the reviewable decision, the Tribunal must make a decision:(a)affirming the reviewable decision; or(b)varying the reviewable decision; or(c)setting aside the reviewable decision and:(i) making a decision in substitution for the reviewable decision; or(ii) remitting the matter to the decision‑maker for reconsideration in accordance with any orders or recommendations of the Tribunal. In the present case, we have held that the reviewable decision is the Commissioner’s decision to give to X a written communication (described by the Commissioner as a ‘complaint alert’), which we found answered the statutory description in s 220(2) of the Online Safety Act 2021 (‘OSA’) of being a decision to give a removal notice under s 88(1). Having made this finding, ordinarily, the substantive task of the Tribunal would be to decide whether that is the correct or preferable decision in all the circumstances. However, there are two unique features of this case which have led us to conclude that no purpose would be served by a further hearing, and that a final decision can, and should, be made now. The first unique feature is that the parties are in agreement that the statutory preconditions for the making of the reviewable decision (that is, the decision which we have found answered the statutory description of a decision to give a removal notice) were not satisfied and that there was no power to make that decision. The second unique feature is that both parties are in agreement that the logical consequence of the Tribunal’s reasons on the jurisdictional issue is that the reviewable decision must be set aside under s 105(c) of the ART Act. We agree with the parties’ position on both matters. Accordingly, the only remaining issue is whether, consequent upon the setting aside of the reviewable decision, the Tribunal should make a decision in substitution for the reviewable decision under s 105(c)(i) of the ART Act or remit the matter to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with any orders or recommendations of the Tribunal under s 105(c)(ii). The applicant submitted that the Tribunal should adopt the former course, and decide whether to give written notice of a decision to refuse to give a removal notice under s 88(3) of the OSA. The applicant relied upon Commonwealth v Beale, in which Neaves J held that the Tribunal should only remit a matter ‘where, in order to give effect to the conclusions to which the tribunal has come, it is appropriate to set aside the decision under review but the tribunal is not in a position to formulate a decision in substitution for the decision set aside.’[4][4](1993) 30 ALD 68, 70 (‘Beale’).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established