Battery World Australia Pty Ltd v Axon Enterprise Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Axon Enterprise, Inc to applications under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by Battery World Australia Pty Ltd for removal of trade marks numbered 1438324 (9, 13) and 1698200 (9) – Lightning breaks circle (Figurative) – in the name of Axon Enterprise, Inc

Delegate: Nicholas Smith
Representation: Opponent: Wrays Pty Ltd
Applicant: Griffith Hack
Decision: 2022 ATMO 153
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - section 96 opposition: s 92(4)(b) applications for partial removal - Removal Opponent’s evidence shows use of the Trade Marks during the relevant period for a subset of goods – exercise of Registrar’s discretion not appropriate – Trade Marks to be removed from the Register for some of the goods for which they are registered

Background

  1. This decision is pursuant to applications made on 4 September 2020 under s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) by Battery World Australia Pty Ltd (‘Applicant’) to remove the trade marks detailed below[1] from the Register of Trade Marks.  The applications are made in respect of all the class 9 goods for which the trade marks are registered (‘Relevant Goods’), that is, the applications are for complete removal of trade mark 1698200 but only a partial removal of trade mark 1438324.

    [1] I note that the trade marks as registered are identical, so this decision will refer to them in the singular (i.e. Trade Mark) when appropriate.

Registration No. 1438324
Lodgement date 19 July 2011
Goods Class 9: Electronic modules for installation as a component part of, on or in a weapon, including modules including battery or data storage for operation of the weapon or recording operation of the weapon; and parts, fittings and accessories in this class, for any of the aforementioned goods
Class 13: Weapons, including weapons that deliver an electrical current through muscle to cause pain and/or to interfere with operation of the muscle, hand-held weapons having terminals for coupling an electrical current through muscle proximate to the terminals to cause pain and/or to interfere with operation of the muscle, and weapons that launch probes to muscle to conduct an electrical current from the weapon through the probes to cause pain and/or to interfere with operation of the muscle; projectiles for use with any of the aforementioned weapons; cartridges for use with any of the aforementioned weapons; holsters for carrying any of the aforementioned weapons; holsters for carrying any cartridges for any of the aforementioned weapons; and parts, fittings and accessories in this class, for any of the aforementioned goods
Owner Axon Enterprise, Inc
Trade Mark  
(‘Trade Mark’)
Registration No. 1698200
Lodgement date 8 June 2015
Goods

Class 9: Scientific, nautical, surveying, photographic, cinematographic, optical, weighing, measuring, signalling, checking (supervision), life-saving and teaching apparatus and instruments; apparatus and instruments for conducting, switching, transforming, accumulating, regulating or controlling electricity; apparatus for recording, transmission or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Battery World Australia Pty Ltd v Axon Enterprise Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ATMO 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Battery World Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought the removal of two trade marks, numbered 1438324 and 1698200, from the Register of Trade Marks under section 92 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth) due to non-use. Axon Enterprise, Inc (the Opponent) opposed these applications. The matter was heard by Nicholas Smith, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the Opponent had used the trade marks in Australia in good faith in relation to the specified goods and services during the three-year period ending one month before the filing of the removal applications. The onus was on the Opponent to rebut the allegation of non-use, as stipulated by section 100 of the Act.

The delegate considered the evidence presented by both parties, including declarations and exhibits. The Opponent's evidence was assessed against the requirements of section 92(4)(b) of the Act, which requires proof of use in Australia during the relevant period. The delegate found that the Opponent had adopted a new logo in 2016 and had transitioned to using this new logo on its products and marketing materials. Consequently, the delegate was not satisfied that the Opponent intended to continue using the trade marks in any significant way.

The delegate directed that registration 1438324 be amended to remove all class 9 goods, but it would remain registered for class 13 goods. Registration 1698200 was to be removed from the Register in respect of all remaining goods, but would remain registered for specific class 9 goods: body-worn video cameras, head-mounted video cameras, and body-worn recorders. The delegate awarded costs to the Applicant in relation to trade mark 1438324, but made no order as to costs for trade mark 1698200, as both parties had achieved a degree of success.

Background

Background to the litigation

Battery World Australia Pty Ltd, the Applicant, filed applications under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) seeking the removal of two trade marks from the Register, numbered 1438324 and 1698200, owned by Axon Enterprise, Inc, the Opponent. The applications targeted the non-use of the trade marks during the three-year period ending one month before the applications were filed. The trade marks in question were "Lightning breaks circle" (Figurative) and were registered in the names of Axon Enterprise, Inc. The relevant period for establishing use of the trade marks was the three years ending on 4 August 2020. Axon Enterprise, Inc opposed the applications, asserting that the trade marks had been used or used in good faith in relation to the goods and services specified in the applications during the relevant period.

Axon Enterprise, Inc adopted a new logo in 2016 and transitioned to using the new logo on its products and marketing materials. The Applicant contended that Axon Enterprise, Inc had not used the trade marks in the relevant period, while Axon Enterprise, Inc maintained that it had used the trade marks in good faith during that time. The Applicant submitted evidence to support its applications, while Axon Enterprise, Inc provided evidence in opposition. The decision-maker considered the evidence and submissions from both parties in reaching the decision on the applications. The onus of proving use of the trade marks during the relevant period was on the Opponent, as per section 100 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).

This matter came before the court as a result of an application by Battery World Australia Pty Ltd under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) for the removal of trade marks numbered 1438324 (9, 13) and 1698200 (9) from the Register on the grounds of non-use. Axon Enterprise Inc opposed these applications. The case was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, who was tasked with deciding whether the trade marks should be removed from the Register. The decision was based on evidence submitted by both parties, including declarations and annexures. The delegate found that Axon Enterprise Inc had not sufficiently demonstrated that it planned to continue using the trade marks, and as such, granted the application for partial removal of the trade marks. The decision also included orders regarding costs, with Battery World Australia Pty Ltd being awarded costs in relation to the successful application for partial removal of Trade Mark 1438324, and no costs being ordered in relation to the removal of Trade Mark 1698200. The decision was made on 6 September 2022.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I am a delegate of the Registrar and the matter has been allocated to me to decide, which I have done, on the basis of the following relevant material and the evidence listed below:·The Applications for Removal;·The Notices of Intention to Oppose and SGPs; ·The Opponent’s Submissions; and ·The Applicant’s Submissions.Evidence in SupportEvidence in AnswerEvidence in Reply Declaration by Isaiah Fields, Vice President and Associate General Counsel of the Opponent, dated 7 May 2021 (‘Fields 1’) together with Annexures IF-1 to IF-19. Declaration by Jack Leo Collings, Senior Associate at Griffith Hack, legal representative for the Applicant, dated 10 August 2021 (‘Collings declaration’) together with Exhibits JLC-01 to JLC-04. Declaration by Isaiah Fields dated 8 October 2021 (‘Fields 2’) together with Annexures IF-20 to IF- 23.The Relevant Provisions Part 9 of the Act deals with removal of trade marks from the Register on account of non-use. In respect of this matter s 92 of the Act relevantly provides:92 Application for removal of trade mark from Register etc.(4)An application under subsection (1) or (3) (non‑use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and on no other grounds: (a) … (b)that the trade mark has remained registered for a continuous period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the non‑use application is filed, and, at no time during that period, the person who was then the registered owner:(i)used the trade mark in Australia; or(ii)used the trade mark in good faith in Australia;in relation to the goods and/or services to which the application relates.Note 1:For file and month see section 6.Note 2:If non‑use of a trade mark has been established in a particular place or export market, then instead of the trade mark being removed from the Register, conditions or limitations may be imposed under section 102 on the registration of the trade mark so that its registration does not extend to that place or export market. Under s 92(4)(b) the relevant period during which the Opponent must establish use of the Trade Mark is the three year period ending on 4 August 2020 (‘relevant period’). I note that an application under s 92(4)(b) may not be made before a period of five years has passed from the filing date of the applications,[2] and I confirm that five years since filing the applications have in fact passed.[2] Per s 93(2) of the Act prior to the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Productivity Commission Response Part 1 and Other Measures) Act 2018 (sch 1, pt 3) as applies in the present matter. The updated s 93(2) of the Act applies to trade marks filed from 24 February 2019 onwards. The onus of rebutting an allegation of non-use lies with the Opponent. This onus is articulated in s 100 of the Act which provides, relevantly to this matter:100 Burden on opponent to establish use of trade mark etc.(1) In any proceedings relating to an opposed application, it is for the opponent to rebut:(a) …(b) …(c) any allegation made under paragraph 92(4)(b) that the trade mark has not, at any time during the period of 3 years ending one month before the day on which the opposed application was filed, been used, or been used in good faith, by its registered owner in relation to the relevant goods and/or services.[…](3) For the purposes of paragraph 1(c), the opponent is taken to have rebutted the allegation that the trade mark has not, at any time during the period referred to in that paragraph, been used, or been used in good faith, by its registered owner in relation to the relevant goods and/or services if:(a) the opponent has established that the trade mark, or the trade mark with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity, was used in good faith by its registered owner in relation to those goods or services during that period; or (b) in a case where the trade mark has been assigned but a record of the assignment has not been entered in the Register:(i) the opponent has established that the trade mark, or the trade mark with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity, was used in good faith by the assignee of the trade mark in relation to those goods or services during that period and that that use was in accordance with the terms of the assignment; and(ii) the Registrar or the court is of the opinion that it is reasonable, having regard to all the circumstances of the case, to treat the use of the trade mark by the assignee during that period as having been a use of the trade mark in relation to those goods or services by the registered owner; or(c) the opponent has established that the trade mark was not used by its registered owner in relation to those goods and/or services during that period because of circumstances (whether affecting traders generally or only the registered owner of the trade mark) that were an obstacle to the use of the trade mark during that period.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present case, I am not satisfied from the evidence before me that the Opponent plans to continue to use the Trade Mark in any significant way. The Opponent adopted a new logo in 2016 and has transitioned to use of the new logo on its products and marketing materials. Given that, I am unpersuaded that the removal of the Trade Mark for the Remaining Goods would result in consumer confusion or practically impact on the interests of the Opponent in any way. Given the importance of the integrity of the Register I do not consider it appropriate to exercise my discretion not to remove the Trade Mark in respect of any of the Remaining Goods. Decision The Opponent has partly established its opposition to the removal applications. Accordingly, I direct that registration 1438324 be amended to remove all the class 9 goods one month from the date of the Decision. This mark shall remain registered for the class 13 goods. I also direct that registration 1698200 be removed from the Register in respect of all Remaining Goods one month from the date of the Decision. It will remain registered for the goods listed below. Class 9: body-worn video cameras, head-mounted video camera, and body worn recorders If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal I direct that removal shall not occur until the appeal has either been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, that the registrations be dealt with as the Court sees fit.Costs The Applicant has been successful in relation to the application for partial removal of Trade Mark 1438324 and has requested its costs. I accordingly award costs against the Opponent in respect of Trade Mark 1438324 under s 221 in the relevant amounts under Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth). With respect to the application for removal of Trade Mark 1698200, both parties have had a degree of success and as such I make no order as to costs. Nicholas SmithHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks6 September 2022

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the Opponent had demonstrated that the trade marks were used in good faith by the registered owner during the relevant three-year period, the court found that the evidence presented by the Opponent was insufficient to rebut the Applicant's allegations of non-use. The court noted that the Opponent had adopted a new logo in 2016 and had transitioned to using this new logo on its products and marketing materials. This transition indicated that the Opponent had moved away from using the trade marks in question, and the evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate that the trade marks were used in good faith during the relevant period.

The court further examined whether the Opponent had established that the trade marks were not used due to circumstances that were an obstacle to their use. The evidence did not provide convincing support for the existence of such obstacles. The Opponent's failure to present compelling evidence regarding any significant obstacles meant that the court could not accept this defence. The court's focus on the lack of evidence regarding obstacles highlights the necessity for the Opponent to provide concrete and convincing proof to successfully oppose the removal of the trade marks.

In considering whether the removal of the trade marks from the Register would result in consumer confusion or practically impact the Opponent, the court found that the transition to a new logo by the Opponent mitigated any potential for confusion. The court noted that since the Opponent had already transitioned to a new logo and had ceased to use the trade marks in question, the removal of these trade marks would not likely cause consumer confusion. Moreover, the practical impact on the Opponent's interests was deemed minimal given the Opponent's adoption of a new identity through its new logo.

The court also evaluated the effect of the Opponent's adoption of a new logo in 2016 and its transition to using the new logo on its products and marketing materials. This transition was seen as a significant factor in the Opponent's failure to use the trade marks in question meaningfully. The court reasoned that since the Opponent had moved away from the trade marks, it was reasonable to conclude that the removal of the trade marks would not significantly impact the Opponent's business operations or brand identity.

In assessing whether the integrity of the Register would be compromised if the trade marks were not removed in respect of the Remaining Goods, the court concluded that maintaining the trade marks on the Register without evidence of their use would undermine the Register's integrity. The court emphasized the importance of ensuring that only genuinely used trade marks remain on the Register to avoid misleading consumers and competitors. Given the lack of evidence demonstrating the use of the trade marks in question, the court determined that their removal was necessary to uphold the integrity of the Register.

Finally, the court considered whether the Registrar should exercise discretion not to remove the trade marks in respect of the Remaining Goods despite the Applicant's success in the removal applications. The court found that exercising such discretion would not be appropriate given the lack of evidence supporting the continued use of the trade marks and the importance of maintaining the Register's integrity. The court's decision to remove the trade marks from the Register underscores the principle that trade marks must be used or used in good faith to remain validly registered.