AgCare Biotech Pty Ltd v Crop Smart Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by AgCare Biotech Pty Ltd to application under section 92 of the Act by Crop Smart Pty Ltd to remove trade mark number 824645 - SMART (stylised) – in Classes 1 and 5 in the name of AgCare Biotech Pty Ltd

Delegate: Michael Kirov
Representation: Opponent: Michelle Howe of Davies Collison Cave, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant: Tim O’Callaghan of Piper Alderman, Lawyers
Decision: 2009 ATMO 41
s.92(4)(b) opposition: No relevant use shown and opposition not established. No reason for exercise of discretion in Opponent’s favour. Trade Mark to be removed. Costs awarded against Opponent.

Background

  1. AgCare Biotech Pty Ltd (“the Opponent”) is the registered owner of trade mark registration 824645, relevant details of which are as follows:

    Trade mark number:  824645
    Registered from:                   22 February 2000

    Goods:Class: 1 Chemicals used in agriculture, horticulture and forestry
    Class: 5 Preparations for destroying vermin; pesticides, insecticides, parasiticides; fungicides, weedicides and herbicides    

    (“the Goods”)

    Trade Mark:   (“the Trade Mark”)

  2. On 16 April 2007 Crop Smart Pty Ltd (“the Removal Applicant”) filed an application under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) for removal of the Trade Mark from the register, alleging the Trade Mark was not used in good faith in relation to the Goods during the three year period ending on 16 March 2007 (“the Non-use Period”).

  3. Section 92 of the Act as it stood at 16 April 2007 is reproduced below:

    92 Application for removal of trade mark from Register etc.

    (1) Subject to subsection (3), a person may apply to the Registrar to have a trade mark that is or may be registered removed from the Register.

    (2) The application:

    (a) must be in accordance with the regulations; and
    (b) may be made in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services in respect of which the trade mark may be, or is, registered.

    (3) An application may not be made to the Registrar under subsection (1) if an action concerning the trade mark is pending in a prescribed court, but the person may apply to the court for an order directing the Registrar to remove the trade mark from the Register.

    Note:  For prescribed court see section 190.

    (4) An application under subsection (1) or (3) (non-use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and on no other grounds:

    (a) that, on the day on which the application for the registration of the trade mark was filed, the applicant for registration had no intention in good faith:

    (i) to use the trade mark in Australia; or
    (ii) to authorise the use of the trade mark in Australia; or
    (iii) to assign the trade mark to a body corporate for use by the body corporate in Australia;

    in relation to the goods and/or services to which the non-use application relates and that the registered owner:

    (iv) has not used…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AgCare Biotech Pty Ltd v Crop Smart Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition to the removal of a trade mark from the Register, heard before Michael Kirov, delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The Removal Applicant sought to remove the trade mark SMART 450 from the Register on the grounds of non-use, while the Opponent, AgCare Biotech Pty Ltd, argued that it had used the trade mark in Australia from August 1998 in relation to a herbicide. The Opponent contended that its use of the trade mark SMART 450, as evidenced by purchase orders, invoices, and product labels, qualified as use of the registered trade mark under section 100(3)(a) of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), which permits use of a trade mark with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity.

The central legal issue before the delegate was whether the Opponent's use of the trade mark SMART 450 constituted use of the registered trade mark, or if the variations amounted to alterations that substantially affected its identity. The Removal Applicant did not dispute that the Opponent had used the trade mark SMART 450 in the course of trade, but contested that this use was of the registered mark. The delegate was required to determine if the differences between the registered mark and the mark as used were substantial enough to negate the claim of use under the Act.

The delegate considered the Opponent's submission that its use of SMART 450 was equivalent to the registered mark, referencing *QH Tours Ltd v Mark Travel Corporation* for the proposition that minor alterations might not affect a trade mark's identity. However, the delegate found this case unhelpful, distinguishing it by noting that the element "SERVICE" in *QH Tours* was descriptive and redundant. In contrast, the delegate found the stylisation of the word "SMART" in the present case to be significant, not only in signalling its trade mark status but also in distinguishing it from numerous other registered marks containing "SMART" in Class 5. The delegate concluded that the stylisation was part of the identity of the trade mark, and that the Opponent had not demonstrated use of the registered trade mark in good faith during the non-use period.

Consequently, the delegate found that the opposition had not been established and that there were no circumstances warranting the exercise of discretion to prevent removal. The delegate directed that the registration be removed from the Register one month from the date of the decision, subject to any appeal. The Removal Applicant was awarded costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The matter was heard before me as delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks in Sydney on 7 May 2009. Tim O’Callaghan of Piper Alderman, Lawyers appeared for the Removal Applicant. Michelle Howe of Davies Collison Cave, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys, appeared for the Opponent.The Evidence and SubmissionsActual use The Opponent’s evidence is that, whereas it has not used the trade mark as registered, it has continuously used the trade mark SMART 450 in Australia from August 1998 in relation to a particular herbicide. Mr Idda exhibits copies of many purchase orders and invoices issued during the Non-use Period which demonstrate this use of the trade mark SMART 450 and both Mr Idda and Mr Bhaur exhibit a label and an instruction sheet sold with the herbicide which each prominently feature the trade mark SMART 450. In the case of the exhibited purchase orders and invoices the SMART 450 trade mark is either typed or hand-written in plain script, with the element SMART sometimes rendered in upper case only and sometimes as “Smart”. The SMART 450 mark appears on the exhibited label and instruction sheet as shown below: The Removal Applicant does not dispute this use. The Removal Applicant does however dispute the Opponent’s claim that the trade mark SMART 450 qualifies as the trade mark “with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity” as comprehended by s.100(3)(a) of the Act[1].[1] Which essentially reflects the words used in the definition of “use of a trade mark” provided in s.7(1) of the Act. Both parties’ representatives noted that the words “with additions or alterations not substantially affecting its identity” used in sections 7(1) and 100(3)(a) are echoed in other provisions of the Act, such as those dealing with amendments to pending or registered marks, and those relating to series applications. Both parties consequently referred in their submissions to case law in some of these other areas. On behalf of the Opponent, Ms Howe referred firstly to QH Tours Ltd v Mark Travel Corporation (1999) 45 IPR 533, wherein the hearing officer concerned held that use of the trade mark FUNJET for travel agency services was effectively use of the trade mark FUNJET SERVICE as registered, since omission of the element SERVICE was an alteration that did not substantially affect the identity of the registered mark. It is however difficult to see how this decision, where the element SERVICE was clearly both descriptive and redundant in the context of the services for which the mark was registered, assists the Opponent in the case at hand. In the present case the differences between the SMART 450 trade mark for which use has been shown and the trade mark as registered are on the face of it much more significant. It is apparent from consulting the Trade Marks Register that there are currently more than a hundred registered marks in Class 5 alone which feature the element SMART, presumably owned by many different parties. While one must be careful not to place too much emphasis on the state of the Register without knowing details of the registrations or how the relevant trade marks may be used, this large number of Class 5 registrations does prima facie tend to confirm that the element SMART is a relatively popular one. Its popularity is not surprising since, unlike the apparently made up word FUNJET, (which could on the face of it function in its own right as a trade mark for the services concerned), SMART is both a relatively common surname (appearing some 3,750 times on the Australian Electoral Roll as at the time of writing) and may also be a descriptive, indeed laudatory, word. In my view the manner of stylization of the trade mark is thus very significant in both signalling it is a trade mark in the first place and in distinguishing it from the trade marks of others which also feature the word or name SMART. In other words, whereas the element SERVICE in the FUNJET SERVICE trade mark was descriptive and redundant in relation to a travel agency service, the stylization of the element SMART in the Trade Mark is in my opinion part of the identity of the Trade Mark.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In summary, while I accept that the Opponent is not required to point to “exceptional circumstances”, the Opponent has not satisfied me that any facts or circumstances exist, or that there is any relevant public interest, which would make it reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion in its favour.Decision I find that there was no use of the Trade Mark in good faith in the course of trade in Australia for the Goods during the Non-Use Period and thus that the opposition has not been established. I further find no circumstances have been shown which warrant exercise of the Registrar’s discretion to not remove the Trade Mark in respect of all of the Goods. I accordingly direct that registration 824645 be removed from the Register one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before then I direct that removal shall not occur until the appeal has been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, that the registration be dealt with as the Court sees fit.Costs As the successful party, the Removal Applicant is entitled to its costs and I award costs against the Opponent as per Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.Michael KirovHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings9 June 2009

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.