Batterham v Nauer, in the matter of Peter James Batterham

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Batterham v Nauer, in the matter of Peter James Batterham [2019] FCA 485

File numbers: NSD 982 of 2018
NSD 990 of 2018
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 11 April 2019
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – application to set aside bankruptcy notice under s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – where applicant asserts cross‑claim exceeding the amount in the bankruptcy notice – where claims of relief are either misconceived or doomed to fail – application summarily dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summary dismissal under r 26.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011– applicant seeks damages for breaches of director’s duties under ss 180, 181, and 182, as well as oppressive conduct under s 232 and s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – where no entitlement to claim damages or statutory compensation – claim summarily dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summary dismissal under r 26.01 of the Rules – applicant seeks damages pursuant to s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law, being Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – material facts not pleaded – no identifiable basis for claim – application summarily dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summary dismissal under r 26.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011  – applicant seeks damages for breach of fiduciary duties in a joint venture – no facts pleaded of partnership or other fiduciary relationship – claim summarily dismissed

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 180, 181, 182, 232, 233

Australian Consumer Law, being Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 236

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 5, 40(1)(g), 58

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A

Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 16.21, 26.01

Limitation Act 1969 (NSW)

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) v Cassimatis (No 8) [2016] FCA 1023; (2016) 336 ALR 209

Birtchnell v Equity Trustees, Executors and Agency Co Ltd [1929] HCA 24; (1929) 42 CLR 384

Blair v Owners - Strata Plan No. 71656 [2016] FCA 1522

Blakeley v National Australia Bank [2017] FCA 835

Breen v Williams [1996] HCA 57; (1996) 186 CLR 71

Cavoli v Etl [2007] FCA 1191

Daemar v Industrial Commission of New South Wales(No 2) (1990) 22 NSWLR 178

Dowling v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2008] FCA 59

Ebert v The Union Trustee Co of Australia Limited [1060] HCA 50; (1960) 104 CLR 346

Fraser Edmiston Pty Ltd v AGT (Qld) Pty Ltd [1988] 2 Qd R 1

Gibson Motorsport Merchandise Pty Ltd v Forbes [2003] FCA 583

Glew v Harrowell [2003] FCA 373; (2003) 198 ALR 331

Grant v John Grant & Sons Proprietary Limited [1954] HCA 23; (1954) 91 CLR 112

Guss v Johnstone [2000] HCA 26; (2000) 171 ALR 598

Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation [1984] HCA 64; (1984) 156 CLR 41

Imobilari Pty Ltd v Opes Prime Stockbroking Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Batterham v Nauer, in the matter of Peter James Batterham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 485
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Batterham v Nauer, in the matter of Peter James Batterham, the Federal Court of Australia was called upon to consider an application to set aside a bankruptcy notice and to dismiss various claims made by Mr Batterham against Mr Nauer. The application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was based on Mr Batterham's assertion of a cross-claim that exceeded the amount specified in the bankruptcy notice. The court was required to determine whether the bankruptcy notice was an abuse of process and whether Mr Batterham had a viable claim against Mr Nauer.

The court held that Mr Batterham's claims were either misconceived or doomed to fail. The court found that Mr Batterham did not have a claim against Mr Nauer based on his status as the sole beneficiary of the Batterham Retirement Fund or otherwise on behalf of the fund. Additionally, any cause of action Mr Batterham may have had against Mr Nauer was personal to him, accrued prior to his bankruptcy, and did not re-vest in him upon the discharge of his bankruptcy. The court also found that the amended statement of claim did not disclose any reasonable cause of action, and there was no reason to believe that Mr Batterham had a viable cause of action against Mr Nauer. Consequently, the court concluded that Mr Batterham did not have the requisite counter-claim, set-off, or cross-demand for the purposes of s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act. As a result, the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was dismissed, and the proceeding was dismissed with costs.

The court also dismissed claims made by Mr Batterham for damages for breaches of director's duties under ss 180, 181, and 182 of the Corporations Act 2001, as well as claims for oppressive conduct under ss 232 and 233 of the same Act. The court found these claims to be misconceived because Mr Batterham did not have standing to apply for an order under s 233. Furthermore, the court dismissed Mr Batterham's claim for damages for contravention of the Australian Consumer Law, finding that the material facts were not pleaded and there was no identifiable basis for the claim. Lastly, the court dismissed Mr Batterham's claim for damages for breach of fiduciary duties in a joint venture, finding that there were no facts pleaded of a partnership or other fiduciary relationship.

In summary, the court dismissed Mr Batterham's application to set aside the bankruptcy notice and summarily dismissed his various claims against Mr Nauer. The court ordered that the proceeding be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In proceeding NSD982/2018, the application to set aside bankruptcy notice BN224341 be refused.

2. In proceeding NSD982/2018, the proceeding be dismissed with costs.

3. In proceeding NSD990/2018, the proceeding be summarily dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As I am not satisfied that the bankruptcy notice is an abuse of process, Mr Batterham’s application to set aside the bankruptcy notice must fail.BACKGROUND The history of this matter goes back to 2007. In essence, Mr Batterham alleges that he and Mr Nauer were parties to a joint venture in the business of strata management. Mr Batterham alleges that Mr Nauer and others took control of the joint venture and marginalised Mr Batterham to his financial detriment. The ASOC is lengthy and includes a recitation of complex factual allegations, many of which are not obviously relevant to any particular claim. A notable feature of the ASOC is the absence of facts that might be relied upon to support findings as to the creation of the alleged joint venture. Many of the facts set out below are the facts as alleged in the ASOC. Those facts are assumed in Mr Batterham’s favour for the purpose of considering Mr Nauer’s application.Relevant parties Mr Batterham is the sole member and beneficiary of the Batterham Retirement Fund. Maylord Equity Management Pty Ltd (“Maylord”) is the trustee of the Batterham Retirement Fund, and Maylord holds any assets of the fund on trust for Mr Batterham as its sole member and beneficiary. Prior to and since his bankruptcy, between 13 November 2014 and 3 December 2017, Mr Batterham was and has been a director of Maylord. At relevant times, Mr Nauer:(1)controlled or directed Vesture Limited, now known as Smarter Communities Limited (“Vesture”), as its principal shareholder and executive chairman;(2)was a director and officer or a de facto director or a shadow director of Vesture; and(3)was required to act as a director of Vesture. Victorian Body Corporate Services Pty Ltd (“VBCS”) is a company identified by Mr Batterham in 2007 as a “foundation business entity” for the alleged joint venture. At around the time that it was identified by Mr Batterham, VBCS provided strata management services in Melbourne for 30,000 strata units and had EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization) of about $3.5 million. Ztrata Capital Limited (“ZCL”) is a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands on 9 November 2009. Mr Nauer was a shareholder and director of ZCL from that date. On or about 15 March 2010, Ztrata Limited (“ZL”) was incorporated in Hong Kong with ZCL as its controlling shareholder, and Mr Batterham and an entity called “Urunga” as minority shareholders.4 July 2011 settlement deed An important background fact is a deed dated 4 July 2011 between Maylord, Mr Batterham, Vesture and VBCS. On its face, the deed provides for the sale and purchase of 1,250 shares in ZL and 600 shares in ZCL by Maylord to Vesture for $450,000. The deed formed part of Mr Batterham’s evidence. Paragraph 134 of the ASOC alleges that $450,000 was paid to Mr Batterham (not Maylord) for 1,250 shares in ZL. Paragraph 134 further alleges that Mr Batterham received “no compensation” for “the value of the ZCL shares”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Nauer’s application was argued by reference to the amended statement of claim (“ASOC”) filed by Mr Batterham on 9 July 2018.Summary of conclusions Proceeding NSD990/2018 should be summarily dismissed because Mr Batterham’s claims for relief are either misconceived or doomed to fail. In particular, Mr Batterham does not have a claim against Mr Nauer based on his status as the sole beneficiary of the Batterham Retirement Fund or otherwise on behalf of the Batterham Retirement Fund. Further, any cause of action that Mr Batterham may have had against Mr Nauer is personal to him, accrued prior to his bankruptcy in November 2014, and did not re-vest in Mr Batterham upon the discharge of his bankruptcy. Further, the ASOC does not disclose any reasonable cause of action and, on the available evidence, there is no reason to believe that Mr Batterham has a viable cause of action against Mr Nauer. It follows that I am not satisfied that Mr Batterham has the requisite counter-claim, set-off or cross-demand for the purposes of s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act. As I am not satisfied that the bankruptcy notice is an abuse of process, Mr Batterham’s application to set aside the bankruptcy notice must fail.BACKGROUND The history of this matter goes back to 2007. In essence, Mr Batterham alleges that he and Mr Nauer were parties to a joint venture in the business of strata management. Mr Batterham alleges that Mr Nauer and others took control of the joint venture and marginalised Mr Batterham to his financial detriment. The ASOC is lengthy and includes a recitation of complex factual allegations, many of which are not obviously relevant to any particular claim. A notable feature of the ASOC is the absence of facts that might be relied upon to support findings as to the creation of the alleged joint venture. Many of the facts set out below are the facts as alleged in the ASOC. Those facts are assumed in Mr Batterham’s favour for the purpose of considering Mr Nauer’s application.Relevant parties Mr Batterham is the sole member and beneficiary of the Batterham Retirement Fund. Maylord Equity Management Pty Ltd (“Maylord”) is the trustee of the Batterham Retirement Fund, and Maylord holds any assets of the fund on trust for Mr Batterham as its sole member and beneficiary. Prior to and since his bankruptcy, between 13 November 2014 and 3 December 2017, Mr Batterham was and has been a director of Maylord. At relevant times, Mr Nauer:(1)controlled or directed Vesture Limited, now known as Smarter Communities Limited (“Vesture”), as its principal shareholder and executive chairman;(2)was a director and officer or a de facto director or a shadow director of Vesture; and(3)was required to act as a director of Vesture. Victorian Body Corporate Services Pty Ltd (“VBCS”) is a company identified by Mr Batterham in 2007 as a “foundation business entity” for the alleged joint venture. At around the time that it was identified by Mr Batterham, VBCS provided strata management services in Melbourne for 30,000 strata units and had EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization) of about $3.5 million.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, the claims for damages for breach of ss 180, 181 and 181 are misconceived and should be summarily dismissed.Sections 232 and 233 Corporations Act Sections 232 and 233 may be invoked to obtain relief for oppressive conduct of a company’s affairs. Section 232 sets out the grounds on which the Court may make an order under s 233. As appears from s 232, the relief provided for in s 233 is directed towards conduct that is either contrary to the interests of the members of a company as a whole, or oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against, a member or members whether in that capacity or in any other capacity. It is not concerned with oppressive conduct towards a non-member. Section 234 identifies who may apply for an order under s 233 including, relevantly, a member of the company. Paragraph 126 of the ASOC alleges that Mr Nauer “as a director and or as a majority shareholder has used his control and direction to oppress” Mr Batterham in contravention of s 232 and s 233. The ASOC does not specify the company in respect of which the oppressive conduct occurred. However, para 117(f) pleads that Mr Nauer:As a 53% shareholder in Vesture and as such a shadow director of Vesture, negotiated with Zuellig, his co director of ZCL, for Vesture to acquire control of the joint venture by purchasing shares in ZL from ZCL and Urunga without the knowledge or agreement of the Applicant and to oppress the Applicant in contravention of Chapter 2F of the Corporations Act 2001. If the claim is based upon the conduct of the affairs of Vesture, it is misconceived because Mr Batterham does not claim to be a member of Vesture and therefore, by s 234, has no standing to apply for an order under s 233. An alternative is that the claim concerns the conduct of the affairs of ZCL. However, as explained above, Mr Batterham has no prospect of demonstrating that he was a member of ZCL. Accordingly, Mr Batterham has no basis to claim relief under Part 2F.1. His claims for damages for breach of s 232 and s 233 are, accordingly, misconceived and should also be summarily dismissed.Damages for contravention of Australian Consumer Law The claim for damages pursuant to s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law (“ACL”), being Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), is expressed to be based upon:(1)“the matters pleaded … in relation to the 5 February 2015 Deed … as well as the representations made by the Koffels letter dated 16 February 2011 … [Mr Nauer] has engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct (ASOC para 127); and(2)“the matters pleaded … in relation to the 2015 Deed [Mr Nauer] has engaged in unconscionable conduct (ASOC para 129). There is a single allegation made in relation to the “5 February 2015 Deed”, as follows:On 5 February 2015 the Respondent as a matter of material fact entered into a Deed to add himself to the settlement deed dated 4 July 2011 without the prior knowledge of the Applicant. This allegation does not identify any conduct that could be characterised as misleading or deceptive on the part of Mr Nauer. Nor does it identify any facts by reason of which it could be found that Mr Nauer engaged in unconscionable conduct in relation to the “2015 Deed”.