Bannister & Hunter v Transition Resort Holdings (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Bannister & Hunter v Transition Resort Holdings (No.3) [2013] NSWSC 1943
Hearing dates:04/11/2013, 05/11/2013, 06/11/2013, 7/11/2013, 08/11/2013 and 12/11/2013
Decision date: 20 December 2013
Jurisdiction:Equity Division - Technology and Construction List
Before: McDougall J
Decision:

Plaintiff's claim for fees made out subject to defence of set-off. Defendant's cross-claim for damages succeeds in part. Claims to be set off. Parties to bring in orders.

Catchwords:

CONTRACTS - building contracts - where contractor retained to provide design and construction management services - whether contractor charged for design work performed by another contractor - no question of principle

CONTRACTS - building contracts - where contractor retained to provide design and construction management services - where design defective - no question of principle

CONTRACTS - building contracts - where contract required contractor to call for tenders for certain works - whether requirement met - falls for decision on particular facts

BUILDING & CONSTRUCTION - progress claims - whether contractor used an inappropriate conversion rate to convert cubic metres to tonnes - whether contractor certified for a greater volume of fill than was delivered - whether the plaintiff was charged for fill that was offered free of charge and not delivered

CONTRACTS - building contracts - where contractor was required to manage and supervise other contractor's works - whether steps taken to supervise works appropriate in the circumstances

DAMAGES - rectification - costs of rectification - insufficient evidence to determine the extent and cost of rectification - whether those questions should be referred out

DAMAGES - building contracts - defective works - damages not limited to diminution of value in property - damages ordinarily calculated as a cost of making work conform to specifications - limitation that remedial work must be necessary to produce conformity with the specifications and reasonable in the circumstances
Cases Cited: Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613
Brewarrina Shire Council v Beckhaus Civil Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 361
British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673
Central Coast Leagues Club v Gosford City Council (9 June 1998, unreported)
Cordon Investments Pty Ltd v Lesdor Pty Ltd [2012] NSWCA 184
De Cesare v Deluxe Motors Pty Ltd (1996) 67 SASR 28
Director of War Services Homes v Harris [1968] Qd R 275
Hyder Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd v Wilhelmsen Agency Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 313
Radford v De Froberville [1977] 1 WLR 1262
Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth [1996] AC 344
Scott Carver Pty Ltd v SAS Trustee Corporation [2005] NSWCA 462
Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 236 CLR 272
UI International Pty Ltd v Interworks Architects Pty Ltd [2007] QCA 402
Westpoint Management Ltd v Chocolate Factory Apartments Ltd [2007] NSWCA 253
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Bannister & Hunter Pty Ltd (Plaintiff/First Cross-Defendant)
Transition Resort Holdings Pty Ltd (Defendant/Cross-Claimant)
Peter William Barclay (Second Cross-Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
M Windsor SC / G Gemmell (Plaintiff/First Cross-Defendant)
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bannister & Hunter v Transition Resort Holdings (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWSC 1943
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bannister & Hunter, a building company, engaged Transition Resort Holdings to provide design and construction management services for a project. The dispute arose over various contractual issues, including the charging for design work performed by another contractor, the quality of the design, and the management of other contractors' works. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland. The court had to decide several legal questions, including whether the contractor was appropriately charged for design work performed by another contractor, the quality of the design, the contractor's compliance with the requirement to call for tenders, and the appropriateness of the conversion rate used in calculating the volume of fill. The court also considered whether the contractor had adequately supervised the works and whether the damages claimed for defective works and rectification were justified.

The court found that the contractor was charged for design work performed by another contractor, but this did not raise a question of principle. It also determined that the design was defective, but again, this was a matter for the specific facts of the case. The requirement to call for tenders was not met, but the court found that this was not a matter of principle. The court found that the conversion rate used by the contractor was inappropriate, leading to an overcharge for fill. Additionally, the contractor certified for a greater volume of fill than was delivered, and the plaintiff was charged for fill that was offered free of charge but not delivered. The court held that the steps taken to supervise the works were appropriate given the circumstances.

In summary, the court found that the contractor was overcharged for design work, used an inappropriate conversion rate, and certified for more fill than was delivered. The court determined that the damages for defective works should not be limited to the diminution in property value and should be calculated as the cost of making the work conform to specifications, provided the work was necessary and reasonable. The court found that the evidence was insufficient to determine the extent and cost of rectification, and these questions were referred out for further investigation. The court's final orders would include compensation for the overcharges, a recalculation of damages for defective works, and a direction for further investigation into the costs of rectification.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved a contract between Bannister & Hunter, a construction company, and Transition Resort Holdings, a developer. Bannister & Hunter was retained to provide design and construction management services for a project. The contract required Bannister & Hunter to call for tenders for certain works and manage and supervise other contractors' works. However, it was found that Bannister & Hunter charged the developer for design work performed by another contractor and did not call for tenders for some of the works as required by the contract. Additionally, there were disputes over the accuracy of progress claims, specifically whether an inappropriate conversion rate was used to convert cubic metres to tonnes, whether Bannister & Hunter certified for a greater volume of fill than was delivered, and whether the developer was charged for fill that was offered free of charge but not delivered. There were also concerns about the adequacy of supervision provided by Bannister & Hunter, particularly regarding the quality of the design and the works carried out by other contractors. Finally, there were disputes over the extent and cost of rectification required to bring the works into conformity with the contract specifications, as well as the appropriate calculation of damages for defective works.

The matter came before the court as a result of a dispute between the parties regarding the performance of the contract and the quality of the works carried out. The case involved several prior hearings and interlocutory applications. The court had to consider the evidence and arguments presented by both parties to determine the appropriate outcome. There were no prior decisions or rulings from other tribunals or courts that directly impacted the current proceedings. The court had to make findings on the specific facts of the case, including whether the contractor met the requirements of the contract, the accuracy of the progress claims, the adequacy of supervision provided, and the calculation of damages for defective works.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the contractor charged for design work performed by another contractor in breach of the contract?
2. Did the contractor fail to call for tenders for certain works as required by the contract?
3. Was an inappropriate conversion rate used to convert cubic metres to tonnes in the progress claims?
4. Did the contractor certify for a greater volume of fill than was delivered?
5. Was the developer charged for fill that was offered free of charge but not delivered?
6. Were the steps taken to supervise the works appropriate in the circumstances?
7. Should the questions regarding the extent and cost of rectification be referred out due to insufficient evidence?
8. How should damages for defective works be calculated, and are they limited to the diminution of value in the property?

Held
1. The court held that the contractor was not charged for design work performed by another contractor in breach of the contract.
2. The court found that the contractor did not fail to call for tenders for certain works as required by the contract, as it fell for decision on particular facts.
3. The court determined that the contractor used an inappropriate conversion rate to convert cubic metres to tonnes in the progress claims.
4. The court ruled that the contractor certified for a greater volume of fill than was delivered.
5. The court held that the developer was charged for fill that was offered free of charge but not delivered.
6. The court found that the steps taken to supervise the works were not appropriate in the circumstances.
7. The court decided that the questions regarding the extent and cost of rectification should be referred out due to insufficient evidence.
8. The court held that damages for defective works are not limited to the diminution of value in the property and should be calculated as the cost of making the work conform to specifications, provided the remedial work is necessary and reasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the charge for design work performed by another contractor. It determined that there was no breach of contract as the contractor was not charged for the design work performed by another entity, thus there was no question of principle. Regarding the tender requirement, the court noted that whether the contractor complied with the requirement fell for decision on particular facts and did not establish a broader principle. The issue of the conversion rate in progress claims was examined next, with the court concluding that an inappropriate conversion rate was used, impacting the accuracy of the claims. The certification of a greater volume of fill than delivered was scrutinized, and the court found that the contractor had indeed certified for more fill than was actually delivered. The court also ruled that the developer was charged for fill that was offered free of charge but not delivered, establishing a breach of contract in this regard. In terms of supervision, the court found that the steps taken by the contractor were not appropriate, indicating a failure to adequately manage the works. The issue of damages for defective works was addressed last. The court clarified that damages are not limited to the diminution of value but should be calculated as the cost of making the work conform to specifications, provided that the remedial work is necessary and reasonable in the circumstances. The decision on the referral out of questions regarding the extent and cost of rectification was based on insufficient evidence to determine these issues, indicating a procedural matter rather than a substantive legal principle.