Bade v Rural City of Murray Bridge

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Application for Judicial Review)

BADE v RURAL CITY OF MURRAY BRIDGE & DAVIES

[2008] SASC 189

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Bleby and The Honourable Justice Anderson)

9 July 2008

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - BUILDING CONTROL - COUNCIL CONSENT AND APPROVAL - CONSENTS, APPROVALS AND PERMITS

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - BUILDING CONTROL - OTHER MATTERS - OFFENCES AND PENALTIES - NON-CONFORMITY OF WORK WITH APPROVAL

Adjoining leasehold allotments - Development authorisation for construction of house extension and boat shed - Whether constructed in accordance with development authorisation - Whether in accordance with approved plan - Whether subsequent alteration approved - Whether development substantially or fully completed within 3 years - Whether approved development - Second development application by addition to first development - First development not approved development - Whether second development non-complying development - Whether second development approval invalid - Whether plaintiff should be granted an extension of time within which to bring application for judicial review - Prejudice to defendant - Construction completed - Extension of time granted - Appeal allowed - Development authorisation for second development quashed.

Development Act 1993 (SA) 4, 32, 33, 35, 38, 40, 44, 45, 55, 56, 84, 85, 86, 105; Encroachments Act 1944 (SA) 2; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 38, 117, 200; Supreme Court Rules 1987 98.06; Development Regulations 1993 16, 32, 48, referred to.
Minister for Environment and Conservation v Wylie Group Pty Ltd (2005) 91 SASR 242; Compaction Application Tips Pty Ltd v Australian Waste Pty Ltd (2001) 80 SASR 435; Transfield (Adelaide) Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Port Augusta (1982) 29 SASR 467; Corporation of the Town of Walkerville v Adelaide Clinic Holdings Pty Ltd (1985) 38 SASR 161; Esther Investments Pty Ltd v Markalinga Pty Ltd (1989) 2 WAR 196; Jackamarra v Krakouer (1998) 195 CLR 516, applied.
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541, distinguished.
Bade v Rural City of Murray Bridge and Anor [2008] SASC 9, not followed.
Hall & Ors v City of Burnside & Ors (2006) 245 LSJS 440, discussed.

BADE v RURAL CITY OF MURRAY BRIDGE & DAVIES
[2008] SASC 189

Full Court:      Doyle CJ, Bleby and Anderson JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:          I agree with the orders proposed by Bleby J and with his reasons.  There is nothing that I wish to add.

    BLEBY J.

    Introduction

  2. River-front residential allotments proximate to Adelaide are a limited and increasingly valuable commodity.  It is not surprising that those entitled to them will jealously guard their right to views of the river and the amenity of their allotments, particularly where the allotment is no more than 12 metres wide with a total area of a little over 400 square metres.  Indeed, the surprisingly small size of the allotments in this case may well have contributed to the problems giving rise to this litigation.

  3. The allotments in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bade v Rural City of Murray Bridge and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bade v Rural City of Murray Bridge involved a dispute between Mrs Bade and the Rural City of Murray Bridge concerning the construction of a house extension and a boat shed on adjoining leasehold allotments. Mrs Bade sought to challenge the development approval granted by the Council for the construction, while Mrs Davies, the owner of the adjoining property, cross-appealed the extension of time granted to Mrs Bade for her application for judicial review. The central issue before the court was whether the construction complied with the approved development plan and whether the subsequent alterations were approved. The court also had to determine if the second development was a non-complying development and if the approval for this second development was invalid.

The court examined the evidence and found that the construction did not conform to the approved development plan. Specifically, the boat shed on lot 15 was a separate structure from the extended house on lot 14, which was not in line with the approved plans. The court determined that the second development, which included the boat shed and the living area extending onto lot 15, was a non-complying development as it was not part of the approved first development. Additionally, the court held that the approval for the second development was invalid as it was not in accordance with the approved plan. The court allowed the appeal and quashed the development authorisation for the second development, while dismissing the cross-appeal regarding the extension of time.

The final orders of the court included allowing the appeal and quashing the development authorisation for the second development. The court also declared the encroachment of the boat shed onto lot 16 as a trespass and set aside certain orders related to costs and the Council's participation in the proceedings. The costs of the application and the appeal were reserved for further argument.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mrs Bade now appeals, on various grounds to be discussed, against the Judge’s order dismissing her application. Mrs Davies cross-appeals against the grant of the extension of time within which to commence the proceedings and, by way of notice of contention, seeks to justify the Judge’s decision on other grounds.The facts The essential facts were not in dispute. However, the trial Judge did hear disputed oral evidence relevant both to his discretion to grant the relief sought and to the extension of time. The trial Judge’s findings in respect of those disputed facts were not challenged on the appeal. Accordingly, the summary of the facts which follows is of facts which were either undisputed or which were found by the Judge. In December 1997 a company controlled by Mr and Mrs Davies acquired the leases to lots 14 and 15. At that time a dwelling had been constructed on lot 14. Lot 15 was vacant and unimproved. Lot 14 was later sold, and Mrs Davies is now the registered proprietor of the lease of lot 15. In February 1999 Mr and Mrs Davies caused a survey to be made of lots 14 and 15. They retained a copy of the survey plan. On 3 June 1999 Mr Davies lodged a development application form with the Council in respect of lots 14 and 15 describing the proposed development as “Additional Bedrooms, New Boat Shed”. Mr Davies was described in the application as “Owner/builder”. The plans showed the development as an extension to the existing house on lot 14 by the construction of two bedrooms and a bathroom at the southern end of the house, all on lot 14, with a living area extending eastwards onto lot 15, part of which would be above a newly constructed boat shed extending to the eastern boundary of lot 15. The new living area was to open onto the roof of the boat shed as an open deck which was to be linked to the front balcony and decking of the house on lot 14. Along the eastern boundary of lot 15 to the south of the boat shed there was to be constructed a ramp with retaining walls on either side providing rear or southern access to the eastern side of the boat shed. On 3 August 1999 the Council granted final development approval for the proposed development subject to a number of conditions, one of which was that the development proceed in accordance with the plans and details submitted with the application. Condition 4 was not a condition but a disclaimer by the Council for any loss which may occur as a result of flooding. The condition stated in part:The applicant is advised that the proposed development will be located within the River Murray Flood Zone, which is subject to periodic flooding which may cause extensive or total loss. Construction commenced in November 1999. However, it was limited to the addition of the two bedrooms and bathroom to the rear of the house on lot 14 together with the concrete slab floor, concrete walls and ultimately the steel frame, roof and panel doors on the front of the boat shed on lot 15. A small encroachment of the house on lot 14 onto lot 15 was removed. In other words, the boat shed on lot 15 was a completely separate structure from the extended house on lot 14.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLEBY J
In my opinion the Judge was correct in extending the time within which Mrs Bade could bring her action but not for all the reasons he gave. I would therefore dismiss the cross-appeal.Conclusion It follows that the appeal must be allowed and the cross-appeal must be dismissed. The actual orders made by the trial Judge on 18 January 2008 were as follows:THE COURT ORDERS that:1Extend the time within which the plaintiff may make this application to 13 October 2006 (sic).2The application of the plaintiff to quash the decision of the first defendant dated 24 November 2005 granting development approval No 415/599/05 be dismissed.3That the encroachment by the second defendant on to the land occupied by the plaintiff, as shown within the plan in the reasons for judgment herein, and is (sic) hereby declared to be a trespass.4That the second defendant have leave to make a counter-claim seeking the following orders:-a.That the plaintiff execute in favour of the second defendant an underlease of the plaintiff’s interest in that portion allotment 16 upon which the second defendant’s building on allotment 15 encroaches.b.That the second defendant pay to the plaintiff such compensation as this Honourable Court determines in account of the encroachment.5Adjourn the hearing of the counter-claim for a directions hearing at 9.00am on Monday 11 February 2008.6Leave to the first defendant to take no further part in these proceedings.7Question of costs reserved.8Liberty to apply. Of those orders it will be necessary to set aside order number 2. Although their substance remains the same, orders numbered 1 and 3 should both be expressed in a more satisfactory form. I think it is inappropriate to grant leave to the Council to take no further part in the proceedings, at least until the question of costs has been resolved. It is therefore appropriate to set aside orders numbered 6 and 7. It would appear that orders numbered 4 and 5 relate to the encroachment and that these have been followed up by a further order made by the Judge on 11 March 2008. It was not argued before us and I make no comment on the efficacy of those orders or of any proceedings which may be dependent upon them. I would hear the parties as to the costs of this appeal and of the application before the trial Judge. Accordingly, the orders I would propose are as follows:1That the appeal be allowed;2That the cross-appeal be dismissed;3That orders numbered 1, 2, 3, 6 and 7 of the orders made by this Court on 18 January 2008 be set aside;4That the following orders be substituted for those orders:(1) That the time within which the plaintiff may make this application be extended to 13 October 2006;(2) That the development authorisation issued by the defendant the Rural City of Murray Bridge on 24 November 2005 in development No. 415/599/05 be quashed;(3) That the Court declares that the encroachment of the building described in the affidavit of the plaintiff sworn on the 13th day of October 2006 and referred to therein as “the Boat Shed” together with the second storey addition thereto constitute a trespass on the land known as Lot 16, Greenbanks, of which the plaintiff is the registered lessee;5That the costs of the plaintiff’s application and of this appeal be reserved for argument at (time and date to be fixed).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLEBY J