Minister for Environment and Conservation v Wylie Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION v WYLIE GROUP PTY LTD

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Vanstone and The Honourable Justice White)

6 April 2005

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION

ENERGY AND RESOURCES - WATER RESOURCES

An appeal from the decision of a single Judge in the Environment, Resources and Development Court - the respondent was growing lucerne and undertook a project to grow olives in an area that was declared a 'surface water prescribed area' under the Water Resources Act 1997 (SA) - the Minister granted the respondent a licence with water allocation for the lucerne but not for the olives - in the Environment, Resources and Development Court the respondent successfully challenged the Minister's exclusion of the olive project from the water allocation - on appeal to this Court - interpretation and application of Water Resources Act 1997 (SA) s36(1) and s36(2)(b) in reference to 'project', 'legally committed' and 'committed significant financial or other resources' - appeal allowed.

Water Resources Act 1997 (SA) s 8(2), s 9, s 36; Development Act 1993 (SA) s 44(1), s 55, s 56; Environment Resources and Development Act 1993 (SA) s 30(2); Development Regulations 1993 (SA) Reg 48, referred to.

MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION v WYLIE GROUP PTY LTD
[2005] SASC 127

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Vanstone and White JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:  This is an appeal against a decision of the Environment Resources and Development Court (“the ERD Court”), allowing an appeal to that Court against a decision by the Minister for Environment and Conservation (“the Minister”) under the Water Resources Act 1997 (SA) (“the Act”).

  2. The issue is whether the ERD Court was correct in holding that Wylie Group Pty Ltd (“Wylie”) was entitled to have endorsed on a water licence a water taking allocation, under a provision of the Act that protects an “existing user” (as defined by the Act) when a part of the State is declared to be a “surface water prescribed area”, with the result that restrictions on the taking of water come into force.

    Introduction

  3. Under s 8(2) of the Act, the Governor may by regulation “declare that part of the State is a surface water prescribed area”.

  4. When that declaration is made, s 9 of the Act immediately imposes restrictions on the taking of water from the prescribed area. The holder of a water licence is authorised to take water, but there is an obvious need to deal with the position of water users in the period of time that is likely to elapse between the making of a declaration and the Minister making a decision on licence applications by existing water users.

  5. S 36 of the Act is intended to protect the position of an “existing user” as defined. Relevantly, s 36 provides as follows:

    “36Allocation on declaration of prescribed water resource

    (1)    On declaration of a watercourse, lake or well as a prescribed watercourse, lake…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Environment and Conservation v Wylie Group Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Minister for Environment and Conservation v Wylie Group Pty Ltd, the respondent, Wylie Group Pty Ltd, sought to challenge a decision by the Minister for Environment and Conservation, who had issued a water licence to Wylie Group for lucerne cultivation but not for an olive project. Wylie Group was engaged in growing lucerne and had a project to grow olives on a property that was declared a 'surface water prescribed area' under the Water Resources Act 1997 (SA). The legal issue at the heart of this case concerned the interpretation and application of sections 36(1) and 36(2)(b) of the Act, specifically in relation to the terms 'project', 'legally committed', and 'committed significant financial or other resources'. Wylie Group contended that it was entitled to water allocations for its olive project under the Act because it was an 'existing user' who had committed significant resources to the project prior to the relevant date.

The Court had to determine whether Wylie Group's proposal to grow olive trees constituted a project to which it was 'legally committed' or in respect of which it had 'committed significant resources' before 11 May 2000. The Court held that the term'significant' should be interpreted objectively, assessing whether the resources committed were substantial or sizeable, rather than focusing on the subjective importance of the commitment or comparing it to other projects. The Court found that Wylie Group had not sufficiently demonstrated a legally binding commitment to the olive project or that it had invested significant resources into it before the specified date, and thus did not qualify as an 'existing user' under the Act. The appeal was therefore allowed, and the decision of the Environment, Resources and Development Court was set aside, with the Court ruling that Wylie Group was not entitled to the water allocation for its olive project.

In summary, the Court's decision underscored the importance of a clear and objective interpretation of the statutory terms in question and reaffirmed the need for a demonstrable legal commitment or significant resource investment to qualify as an 'existing user' under the Water Resources Act 1997 (SA).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue at both stages was whether a proposal to grow olive trees over much of the relevant land was a project to which Wylie was “legally committed” or in respect of which Wylie had “committed significant resources” before 11 May 2000.Relevant facts It is possible to simplify the statement of relevant facts to some extent. There was no real dispute about the facts. In November 1998 Wylie acquired an option to purchase 807 hectares of land at Makin in the south-east of South Australia. About 80 hectares were being irrigated for lucerne seed. The land was considered suitable for growing olive trees. Wylie acquired the option over the property at Makin with a view to growing olives on most of it. The success of the plan depended on Wylie being able to take water to irrigate the olives. Wylie’s initial plan, in late 1998, was to divide the land into about 19 lots, and sell them to investors. Wylie would manage the project for the investors. Over a period of some months Wylie investigated the feasibility of its proposal, and obtained advice and reports on various aspects of the proposal. It paid for this advice and these reports. In December 1998 Wylie wrote to the Minister’s Department outlining its proposal, and asked for confirmation that Wylie would be granted an appropriate water allocation. In late 1998 or early 1999 Wylie learned of certain restrictions on the use of water in the area (the details do not matter), and that the area might be prescribed under s 8. On 2 March 1999 the Minister granted to Wylie an interim authorisation to irrigate 128 hectares of olives on the land, in addition to the 80 hectares being irrigated for lucerne seed. The authorisation operated until January 2000. The letter from the Minister’s Department indicated that the grant of further authorisations for the taking of water would depend on the circumstances at the time. On 10 March 1999 the local council approved Wylie’s application under the Development Act 1993 (SA) for the division of the land into 19 allotments and for a change of use of the land to an olive plantation. On 25 March 1999 Wylie exercised its option to purchase the land. Shortly thereafter certain third parties appealed against the development approval granted to Wylie. During March of 1999 Wylie became concerned about the fact that it had no assurance that it would be allocated the water required to develop the olive tree plantings. It was concerned that if it did not use the interim allocation it might lose its status as an existing user. It considered that it was not practical to plant out 128 hectares of olive trees, relying on the interim allocation, if it did not have an assurance that it would be granted a water allocation for the balance of the project. In March 1999, Wylie applied for authorisation to irrigate the 128 hectares for lucerne seed rather than olives, as an interim measure, and in June 1999 the Minister’s Department granted that application. In about July and August 1999, Wylie obtained permits for wells to be used in connection with irrigating the 128 hectares, had bores drilled and did other work in connection with the bores.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is unnecessary to grapple with the question of what is a significant commitment. However, because the matter was argued, and because of its importance for future cases, it is appropriate to express some views on the topic. A commitment is not significant simply because it is significant from the point of view of the person making the commitment. That approach would give rise to an entirely subjective enquiry. Nor is a commitment significant only if it is significant compared with the commitment made by other water users undertaking comparable projects. That approach would give rise to an almost impossible enquiry. Nor is there any reason why Parliament should have had that meaning of “significant” in mind. Nor can I see any reason to think that Parliament intended that a commitment be significant only if the commitment so far made is a significant part of the overall commitment that will be required. That approach would give an undue emphasis to the progress made with a particular project, as distinct from the objective significance of the commitment. In my opinion if resources have been committed, the significance of the commitment is to be determined by asking whether the resources are significant in the sense of being substantial or sizeable. That is a relatively common, if colloquial, use of the word “significant”. This requires an objective assessment of the resources involved. I accept that it will involve having regard, to some extent, to the activity involved. By that I mean that the significance of the resources is to be assessed from the stand point of persons who use water, subject to the Act, and bearing in mind, in a very general way, the sort of cost that is involved in the development, project or undertaking that involves the use of water under the Act. Unfortunately, I am unable to be any more precise than that. Deciding whether a commitment is significant will often be a difficult factual question.Conclusion For the reasons that I have given, the Judge was wrong in deciding that Wylie was an “existing user” for the purposes of s 36 of the Act, and was wrong in concluding that Wylie was entitled to a water taking allocation endorsed upon its licence. The appeal should be allowed. The decision of the ERD Court of 2 September 2004 should be set aside. For that decision should be substituted an order dismissing the appeal against the Minister’s decision. VANSTONE J: I agree with the orders proposed by the Chief Justice and with the reasons he has given. WHITE J: I agree with the orders proposed by the Chief Justice. I also agree with his reasons. There is nothing which I wish to add.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

S 36 of the Act is intended to protect the position of an “existing user” as defined. Relevantly, s 36 provides as follows:“36Allocation on declaration of prescribed water resource(1) On declaration of a watercourse, lake or well as a prescribed watercourse, lake or well or declaration of a part of the State as a surface water prescribed area, an existing user of water from the water resource concerned -(a)may, subject to a restriction or prohibition under section 16, continue to use water without a licence until the end of the prescribed period or, if he or she applies for a licence within six months after the publication in the Gazette of the regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource, until the application is granted or refused;(b)is, subject to subsection (3), entitled to have endorsed on the licence without the payment of a purchase price a water (taking) allocation determined by the Minister under subsection (2) after consultation with the existing user.(2) The water allocation will be the quantity of water that will, in the opinion of the Minister, meet the future requirements of the existing user -(a)based on his or her reasonable requirements in the establishment period; or(b)for water for a development, project or other undertaking to which he or she was legally committed or in respect of which he or she had committed significant financial or other resources before the commencement of the prescribed period; or(c)under both paragraphs (a) and (b).…(7) Subject to a restriction or prohibition under section 16, a person who is not an existing user may take water from the water resource without a licence until the end of the prescribed period.…(10) In this section -‘the establishment period’ in relation to the declaration of a water resource means the period prescribed for the purposes of this definition by the regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource being a period that ends at the commencement of the prescribed period;‘existing user’ means, subject to subsection (11), a person -(a)who took water from the resource at any time during the establishment period; or(b)who did not take any water during that period but who needs water for a development, project or undertaking to which he or she was legally committed or in respect of which he or she had, in the opinion of the Minister, committed significant financial or other resources before the commencement of the prescribed period;‘the prescribed period’ in relation to a water resource commences on the date of publication in the Gazette, a newspaper circulating generally throughout the State or a local newspaper (whichever occurs first) of the notice inviting submissions in relation to the proposed regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource and ends on the date specified for that purpose in the regulation.(11) A person ceases to be an existing user if he or she does not apply for a water licence within six months after publication in the Gazette of the regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource.”