Natale v Minister for Environment and Conservation

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

NATALE v MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Besanko

10 May 2005

ENERGY AND RESOURCES - WATER RESOURCES - STREAMS, RIVERS AND WATER COURSES

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SUPREME COURT

Appeal against orders of a Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) and application for an extension of time and application to amend the Notice of Appeal - where respondent granted a water licence to appellant under the Water Resources Act 1997 - where appellant appealed against respondent's decision, sought leave to amend his Notice of Appeal and sought an extension of time within which to institute an appeal - where a Judge of the ERD court made an order striking out the appeal - where appellant appealed to the Supreme Court - where Judge allowed the appeal, set aside the order and remitted the matter to the ERD Court - where a different Judge of the ERD Court made an order striking out the appeal - whether Judge erred in concluding that the matter raised by the proposed amendment to the Notice of Appeal was not reasonably arguable - whether Judge erred in refusing the application to extend time - appeal dismissed.

Water Resources Act 1997 ss 29, 36, 142; Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 s 30, referred to.
Natale v Minister for Environment and Conservation [2004] SASC 176, considered.

NATALE v MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION
[2005] SASC 170

Land and Valuation Division

  1. BESANKO J:        This is an appeal from orders made by a Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (“ERD Court”).  The appellant is Mr Roberto Natale and the respondent is the Minister for Environment and Conservation.  The Minister made a decision under the Water Resources Act 1997 (“WRA”) on or about 13th September 2000 granting a water licence to the appellant.  The water allocation given under the licence was 1.2 hectares for the purpose of vines.  The appellant appealed against the Minister’s decision by notice of appeal dated 15th October 2003. He complains of the water allocation given under the licence and he says that it should have been greater. The appeal was not instituted within six weeks of the decision appealed against and the appellant sought an extension of time pursuant to s 142(4) of the WRA.  Under that subsection the Court may grant further time for instituting an appeal “as the Court considers to be reasonable in the circumstances”.  The appellant also sought leave to amend the notice of appeal by adding a further ground of appeal.

  2. The applications to extend the time for instituting the appeal and for leave to amend the notice of appeal came on for hearing before a Judge of the ERD Court (Judge Cole) on 12th March 2004. The Judge made an order striking out the appeal. The appellant appealed to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Natale v Minister for Environment and Conservation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Natale v Minister for Environment and Conservation involves an appeal by the appellant against the orders of a Judge of the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) and an application for an extension of time and to amend the Notice of Appeal. The appellant had been granted a water licence under the Water Resources Act 1997, but appealed against the Minister’s decisions regarding the water allocation. The ERD Court Judge had previously struck out the appeal, which the appellant now sought to overturn in the Supreme Court. The central legal issues were whether the ERD Court Judge was correct in deciding that the proposed amendment to the Notice of Appeal was not reasonably arguable and whether the refusal to extend the time to institute the appeal was justified.

The Supreme Court found that the ERD Court Judge had properly exercised her discretion in rejecting the proposed amendment to the Notice of Appeal as it did not present a reasonably arguable case. The proposed amendment concerned the allocation of water under s 36(2) of the Water Resources Act 1997, but the appellant had already received the water allocation they requested. Given this, the amendment did not significantly alter the substantive grounds of appeal, making it unlikely to succeed. Regarding the extension of time, the Court considered that the appellant had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances that would warrant an extension. The appellant had been aware of the relevant legal framework and had sufficient time to prepare and file the appeal within the original time limits.

In conclusion, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the ERD Court Judge's decision to strike out the appeal and deny the extension of time. The Court held that the proposed amendment to the Notice of Appeal was not reasonably arguable, and there were no exceptional circumstances justifying an extension of time. Therefore, the appeal was properly dismissed, and the ERD Court's orders were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals against the orders made by Judge Trenorden. The appeal is against orders of an interlocutory nature and lies to a single Judge of this Court (s 30(1)(a) of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993).The Facts The appellant is the owner of land in the Hundred of Kuitpo, Section 868, in the State of South Australia being the land comprised and described in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5440 Folio 987. The land is within the McLaren Vale Prescribed Wells area under the WRA. The water licence issued on 13th September 2000 grants a water allocation for vines and the allocation is for 1.2 hectares. By a subsequent notice dated 17th November 2000 the Minister stated that the allocation was 1536 kilolitres per annum. On 31st August 2001 the appellant applied to vary the licence to increase the areas of vines which might be irrigated. That application was refused by the Minister on 13th December 2001. On 28th August 2003 the Minister varied the appellant’s water allocation by reducing it to 1320 kilolitres per annum. On 15th October 2003 the appellant appealed to the ERD Court against the variation made on 28th August 2003 and against the allocation of water under the licence granted on 13th September 2000. In the hearing before Judge Cole the Minister accepted that he had no power to vary the licence on 28th August 2003 and from that point that particular decision was no longer in issue. The Minister also conceded during the hearing before Debelle J that he had no authority to issue the notice dated 17th November 2000 stating that the appellant’s allocation was 1536 kilolitres per annum. By consent, Debelle J made orders declaring that the notices dated 17th November 2000 and 28th August 2003 respectively are invalid. The only issue then is the appellant’s appeal against the allocation of water under the licence granted on 13th September 2000. The notice of appeal which was filed in the ERD Court contains the following grounds of appeal:1. That the grant of the licence:(a) was not consistent with the relevant water allocation plan;(b) was not in the public interest;(c) was based upon incorrect information as to the area of vines requiring irrigation.2. That the allocation of water on the licence:(a) was contrary to Section 33 of the Water Resources Act 1997;(b) by way of further particulars the appellant repeats paragraphs 1(a) – (c) hereof. The Crown Solicitor on behalf of the Minister wrote to the appellant’s solicitors on 28th November 2003 and advised them that the water licence had been issued pursuant to s 36 of the WRA and the appellant then sought leave to amend the notice of appeal by amending ground 2 to read as follows:2. That the allocation of water on the licence:(a) was not determined in accordance with the provisions of section 36(2)(a), (b) and (c) of the Water Resources Act 1997.(b) was contrary to section 33 of the Act and by way of particulars the appellant repeats paragraphs 1(a) – (c) hereof.The decision of Judge Trenorden

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Crown Solicitor on behalf of the Minister wrote to the appellant’s solicitors on 28th November 2003 and advised them that the water licence had been issued pursuant to s 36 of the WRA and the appellant then sought leave to amend the notice of appeal by amending ground 2 to read as follows:2. That the allocation of water on the licence:(a) was not determined in accordance with the provisions of section 36(2)(a), (b) and (c) of the Water Resources Act 1997.(b) was contrary to section 33 of the Act and by way of particulars the appellant repeats paragraphs 1(a) – (c) hereof.The decision of Judge Trenorden The Judge had before her an application to amend the notice of appeal and an application for an extension of time within which to institute the appeal. The Judge dealt with the application to amend the notice of appeal first. She said that the application to amend should not be allowed if the appellant’s case, with the amendment, is not reasonably arguable or does not have a reasonable prospect of success. She referred to other considerations relevant to the application to amend but she decided the application by reference to the matter which I have identified. The Judge noted that by his application the appellant had asked for a water allocation for 1.2 hectares of vines and that he had received the allocation which he had requested. The applications before Judge Trenorden and before me proceeded on the basis that the relevant section for the purpose of the appellant’s appeal is s 36 of the WRA. That is because that is the section which is relevant to the decision which led to the grant of the licence on 13th September 2000. In effect, the proposed amendment to the grounds of appeal raises the issue the appellant wishes to agitate on the appeal. That was common ground on the hearing before me. Section 36 of the WRA provides:1)On declaration of a watercourse, lake or well as a prescribed watercourse, lake or well or declaration of a part of the State as a surface water prescribed area, an existing user of water from the water resource concerned—(a) may, subject to a restriction or prohibition under section 16, continue to use water without a licence until the end of the prescribed period or, if he or she applies for a licence within six months after the publication in the Gazette of the regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource, until the application is granted or refused;(b) is, subject to subsection (3), entitled to have endorsed on the licence without the payment of a purchase price a water (taking) allocation determined by the Minister under subsection (2) after consultation with the existing user.(2)The water allocation will be the quantity of water that will, in the opinion of the Minister, meet the future requirements of the existing user—(a) based on his or her reasonable requirements in the establishment period; or(b) for water for a development, project or other undertaking to which he or she was legally committed or in respect of which he or she had committed significant financial or other resources before the commencement of the prescribed period; or(c) under both paragraphs (a) and (b).(3)If at the expiration of the prescribed period, the aggregate of the allocations of water to which existing users are entitled under subsection (1) exceeds, in the opinion of the Minister, the capacity of the resource, the Minister may—(a) reduce the allocation to which each existing user is entitled proportionately; or(b) reduce the allocations pursuant to a scheme set out in regulations.(4)Before determining the capacity of the resource the Minister must prepare a report assessing the need for water of ecosystems that depend on the resource for water.(5) The Minister must make the report publicly available.(6)An existing user may appeal to the Court against a determination or decision of the Minister under subsection (2).(7)Subject to a restriction or prohibition under section 16, a person who is not an existing user may take water from the water resource without a licence until the end of the prescribed period.(8)If the quantity of water available for allocation exceeds the entitlements of existing users, the Minister may allocate the excess in accordance with this Act and the relevant water allocation plan.(9)An entitlement referred to in subsection (1)(b) may be transferred to another person with the approval of the Minister.(10) In this section—the establishment period in relation to the declaration of a water resource means the period prescribed for the purposes of this definition by the regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource being a period that ends at the commencement of the prescribed period;existing user means, subject to subsection (11), a person—(a) who took water from the resource at any time during the establishment period; or(b) who did not take any water during that period but who needs water for a development, project or undertaking to which he or she was legally committed or in respect of which he or she had, in the opinion of the Minister, committed significant financial or other resources before the commencement of the prescribed period;the prescribed period in relation to a water resource commences on the date of publication in the Gazette, a newspaper circulating generally throughout the State or a local newspaper (whichever occurs first) of the notice inviting submissions in relation to the proposed regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource and ends on the date specified for that purpose in the regulation.(11)A person ceases to be an existing user if he or she does not apply for a water licence within six months after publication in the Gazette of the regulation declaring the resource to be a prescribed resource.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established