Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macleod

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macleod [2024] FCAFC 174  

Appeal from: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Noumi Ltd [2024] FCA 349
File number(s): NSD 676 of 2024
NSD 678 of 2024
Judgment of: BURLEY, ANDERSON AND MEAGHER JJ
Date of judgment: 20 December 2024
Catchwords:

PRIVILEGE – legal professional privilege – third party report – investigation into accounting issues – whether report was created for the dominant purpose of providing legal advice

PRIVILEGE – waiver – implied waiver – whether voluntary disclosure of report to the regulator was inconsistent with the maintenance of confidentiality in the report – whether “derivative use” and/or “derivative disclosure” of the report amounted to a waiver of privilege – no waiver found – appeal allowed  

Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 19

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24(1A)

Cases cited:

Attorney-General (NT) v Maurice [1986] HCA 80; (1986) 161 CLR 475

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Noumi Limited (No 3) [2024] FCA 862

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Noumi Limited (No 4) [2024] FCA 1192

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Noumi Ltd [2024] FCA 349

British Coal Corporation v Dennis Rye Ltd (No 2) [1988] 1 WLR 1113; [1988] 3 All ER 816

Cantor v Aldi AustraliaPty Ltd [2016] FCA 1391

Citic Pacific Ltd v Secretary for Justice [2012] HKCA 153

Commissioner of Australian Federal Police v Propend Finance Pty Ltd [1997] HCA 3; (1997) 188 CLR 501

Commissioner of Taxation v PricewaterhouseCooper [2022] FCA 278

Daniels Corporation International Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2002] HCA 49; (2002) 213 CLR 543

Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries [1991] FCA 844; (1991) 33 FCR 397

Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Kinghorn; Kinghorn v Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) [2020] NSWCCA 48; (2020) 379 ALR 345

DSE (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Intertan Inc [2003] FCA 384; (2003) 127 FCR 499

Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Limited [2013] HCA 46; (2013) 250 CLR 303

Fyffes v DCC [2005] 1 IR 59

Goldberg v Ng [1995] HCA 39; (1995) 185 CLR 83

Goldman v Hesper [1988] 1238; [1988] 3 All ER 97

Gotha City v Sotheby’s [No 1] [1998] 1 WLR 114

Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 9; (1959) 101 CLR 298

Macquarie Bank Ltd v Arup Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 117

Mann v Carnell [1999] HCA 66; (1999) 201 CLR 1

New South Wales v Betfair Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 160; (2009) 180 FCR 543

Osland v Secretary to the Department of Justice [2008] HCA 37; (2008) 234 CLR 275

Pratt Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2004] FCAFC 122; (2004) 136 FCR 357

Property Alliance Group Ltd v Royal Bank of Scotland plc [2016] 1 WLR 361

Robertson v Singtel [2023]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macleod and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 174
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macleod, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia addressed the issues of legal professional privilege and waiver in the context of a PwC report concerning accounting irregularities at Noumi, a company. The primary judge had found that the PwC report was protected by legal professional privilege but had also concluded that the privilege had been waived by the disclosure of the report to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). The appeal by Noumi and Mr Macleod centred on whether the primary judge erred in applying the dominant purpose test and in finding that privilege had been waived.

The court found that the primary judge did not err in applying the dominant purpose test, which requires that the privilege be claimed for documents created for the dominant purpose of providing or receiving legal advice. However, the court held that the primary judge erred in concluding that the privilege had been waived. The court examined whether the voluntary disclosure of the PwC report to ASIC was inconsistent with the maintenance of confidentiality and whether any "derivative use" or "derivative disclosure" of the report amounted to a waiver of privilege. The court found no such waiver occurred.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, finding that the primary judge's conclusion on waiver was incorrect but did not affect the application of the dominant purpose test. The court emphasised that the circumstances of each case must be considered carefully, and the principles established in Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Robertson were relevant. The orders included that the parties confer on the terms of minutes of order and on any confidential information to be redacted, with specific timelines and confidentiality protocols to be observed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 1 February 2025, the parties confer and supply to the chambers of Justices Burley, Anderson and Meagher short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons for judgment.

2. Until further order, the Full Court’s reasons for judgment not be disclosed to or published by any person, save to the parties, their legal representatives, and Court staff.

3. By 1 February 2025, the parties confer and supply to the chambers of Justices Burley, Anderson and Meagher a list identifying any paragraphs or parts therefore of these reasons for judgment which are said to contain confidential information and that ought not be published in an unredacted form, including the reasons why a confidentiality claim is made; noting that for the convenience of the parties only and without indicating any view as to confidentiality, the Full Court has highlighted yellow parts of the reasons for judgment which were redacted by the primary judge for reasons of asserted confidentiality.

4. Insofar as the parties are unable to agree to the terms of the short minutes of order referred to in order 1 or the list of confidential information referred to in order 3, the areas of disagreement should be set out in mark-up.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out in more detail below, we find that the primary judge did not err in the application of the dominant purpose test but did err in his conclusion that legal professional privilege in the PwC Report had been waived. Accordingly, we allow the appeal.2. BACKGROUND FACTS The following statement of the background facts is derived from the reasons of the primary judge. As the grounds of appeal make clear, some of the primary judge’s factual findings are challenged. Nonetheless, the following is a convenient summary of the relevant background to the proceedings. The events in issue concern an allegation that Noumi had accumulated large amounts of unsaleable inventory without having any or adequate policy for writing down the carrying value of the inventory within its accounts in the period from 1 January 2019 to 30 June 2020 (Inventory Issue). It is alleged that Noumi’s annual report for the year ending 30 June 2019 and the half-yearly report for the six months ending 31 December 2019 demonstrate the lack of sufficient provisions or write-downs for the unsaleable inventory. These events are alleged to have been brought to Mr Macleod’s attention in early October 2019 by an employee of Noumi. In March 2020, Noumi engaged the law firm, Ashurst, to provide legal advice relating to a separate matter about its employee share option plan (ESOP Issue). [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED]. On or about 15 April 2020, Mr Nicholas, sought the assistance of Ms Paddy Carney, Partner of PwC, in relation to the ESOP Issue. Mr Nicholas was thereafter provided with a proposed scope of work regarding the ESOP Issue. On 28 May 2020, the Inventory Issue was escalated to Noumi’s Board. On the following day, Noumi issued an ASX announcement which included that there would be a “one-off non-cash write down of the carrying value of inventory in FY 20”. On 30 May 2020, Mr Trevor Allen, then a non-executive director of Noumi, sent an email to Mr Nicholas, copied to Mr Macleod, regarding matters to be included in a brief to PwC to conduct a “review [into] the process for determining the quantification of the stock provision requirement”. Mr Nicholas ceased working as the CFO and Company Secretary of Noumi on 23 June 2020. Noumi’s Board met twice on 24 June 2020. At a meeting at 8:30am, the Board accepted Mr Nicholas’s resignation and resolved to issue an announcement to the ASX that Mr Macleod had been placed on leave pending a further announcement. At the second meeting, later that day, the Board also resolved to request an immediate trading halt in the shares of the company. The primary judge records that the Board discussed the trading halt in the context of information it had “just received” that “there may be further irregularities in the accounts of the company…[which] could not be immediately particularised or quantified and required further investigation”. The trading halt continued until 22 March 2021.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, the issues for determination, in the order in which they are addressed below are, first, whether the primary judge erred in finding that the dominant purpose test was met. Secondly, whether the primary judge erred in finding that by disclosing the PwC Report to ASIC, Noumi waived privilege in its contents. 1.4 Summary of conclusions For the reasons set out in more detail below, we find that the primary judge did not err in the application of the dominant purpose test but did err in his conclusion that legal professional privilege in the PwC Report had been waived. Accordingly, we allow the appeal.2. BACKGROUND FACTS The following statement of the background facts is derived from the reasons of the primary judge. As the grounds of appeal make clear, some of the primary judge’s factual findings are challenged. Nonetheless, the following is a convenient summary of the relevant background to the proceedings. The events in issue concern an allegation that Noumi had accumulated large amounts of unsaleable inventory without having any or adequate policy for writing down the carrying value of the inventory within its accounts in the period from 1 January 2019 to 30 June 2020 (Inventory Issue). It is alleged that Noumi’s annual report for the year ending 30 June 2019 and the half-yearly report for the six months ending 31 December 2019 demonstrate the lack of sufficient provisions or write-downs for the unsaleable inventory. These events are alleged to have been brought to Mr Macleod’s attention in early October 2019 by an employee of Noumi. In March 2020, Noumi engaged the law firm, Ashurst, to provide legal advice relating to a separate matter about its employee share option plan (ESOP Issue). [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED]. On or about 15 April 2020, Mr Nicholas, sought the assistance of Ms Paddy Carney, Partner of PwC, in relation to the ESOP Issue. Mr Nicholas was thereafter provided with a proposed scope of work regarding the ESOP Issue. On 28 May 2020, the Inventory Issue was escalated to Noumi’s Board. On the following day, Noumi issued an ASX announcement which included that there would be a “one-off non-cash write down of the carrying value of inventory in FY 20”. On 30 May 2020, Mr Trevor Allen, then a non-executive director of Noumi, sent an email to Mr Nicholas, copied to Mr Macleod, regarding matters to be included in a brief to PwC to conduct a “review [into] the process for determining the quantification of the stock provision requirement”. Mr Nicholas ceased working as the CFO and Company Secretary of Noumi on 23 June 2020. Noumi’s Board met twice on 24 June 2020. At a meeting at 8:30am, the Board accepted Mr Nicholas’s resignation and resolved to issue an announcement to the ASX that Mr Macleod had been placed on leave pending a further announcement. At the second meeting, later that day, the Board also resolved to request an immediate trading halt in the shares of the company. The primary judge records that the Board discussed the trading halt in the context of information it had “just received” that “there may be further irregularities in the accounts of the company…[which] could not be immediately particularised or quantified and required further investigation”. The trading halt continued until 22 March 2021.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

See also the Full Court’s recent statement of relevant principles in Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Robertson [2024] FCAFC 58 at [24]–[32] (Murphy, Anderson and Neskovcin JJ).3.5 Consideration During the relevant period in 2020, PwC had been engaged by Noumi to provide advice and services relating to a number of different matters, including the ESOP Issue as set out at [18] above. On 28 May 2020, the separate Inventory Issue was escalated to the Noumi Board. The Board was informed on that day that $37 million for inventory was considered “at risk” with a provision to be made in the range of $20-25 million as net exposure. Mr Allen expressed that “this issue (known by senior management, not Board [sic]) was not stated anywhere in the Audit Report for the last 4 years” and that Mr Macleod believed that “the issues started to occur in 2018 & 2019 during rapid expansion but could offer no explanation as to why is [sic] was not stated in the report for those years.” Ms Gregor stated the need for an external review: “possibly PwC given their current engagement for the Option Series they could add this engagement [sic]”: PJ[20]. While Mr Allen’s subsequent email on 30 May 2020 was consistent with the above, it raised a number of issues that would need to be considered, including whether management knew about the issue and the efficacy of control procedures. Notwithstanding the contents of Mr Allen’s email and subsequent developments, we nonetheless agree with the primary judge’s approach outlined at PJ[82] that:[I]t does not follow that the purposes for the engagements of the professional advisers that followed were immutably anchored in time to these initial reactions. Nor does it follow that the purposes were incapable of refinement after further consideration. As the primary judge correctly pointed out, there were subsequent developments following 28 May 2020 when the Inventory Issue was first escalated to the Noumi Board. In particular, the matters that came to light before the Board by late June 2020 (which are identified at [19]–[20] and [41]–[42] above) resulted in the Board determining that it would seek legal advice. In our view, the primary judge was also correct to consider the various PwC engagements with a degree of specificity. As the primary judge found at PJ[85], “[e]ach engagement related to a different stream of work and was distinct to the other, but obviously enough all related to the general topic of the Inventory Issue”. Mr Macleod did not seek to challenge this finding on appeal. As the primary judge outlined at PJ[85]:(a)By 5 July 2020, Mr Longley was tasked with, in a simplified sense, looking backwards in time in relation to the accounting and reporting issues in so far as any revisions were required;(b)By 20 July 2020, Ms Carney was tasked with, in a simplified sense, looking forward in time to impending reports and announcements; and(c)By early July 2020, Mr John was specifically retained to provide advice in relation to the Inventory Issue, and it was this engagement which brought about the engagement with Ms Michie.