Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Paper Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Paper Pty Ltd (No 2) [2004] FCA 1471

TRADE PRACTICES – pecuniary penalties – attempts to enter and attempts to induce entry into a contract containing an ‘exclusionary provision’ – criteria to be taken into account – significance of legal uncertainty – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 76(1)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 45(2)(a)(i), (6), 76

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR 41-076 followed
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ithaca Ice Works Pty Ltd [2002] ATPR 41-851 cited
Minister for the Environment and Heritage v Greentree (No 3) [2004] FCA 1317 cited
Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 131 FCR 529 followed
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) (2002) 201 ALR 618 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v George Weston Foods Ltd [2000] ATPR 41-763 followed
Schneider Electric (Australia) Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 127 FCR 170 cited
J McPhee & Son (Aust) Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2000] ATPR 41-758 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v The Tasmanian Salmonid Growers Association Ltd [2003] ATPR 41-954 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Z-Tek Computer Pty Ltd (1997) 78 FCR 197 cited
BMW Australia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2004) 207 ALR 452 cited

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v VISY PAPER PTY LTD and Ors
NSD 1244 of 1998

SACKVILLE J
SYDNEY

18 NOVEMBER 2004


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1244 of 1998

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

VISY PAPER PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

WILLIAM GUTHRIDGE
SECOND RESPONDENT

STEPHEN RICHARDS
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SACKVILLE J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 NOVEMBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The First Respondent, Visy Paper Pty Ltd (‘Visy’):

(a)by sending the six draft contracts set out in the Schedule hereto to Northern Pacific Paper Pty Ltd (‘NPP’), each containing a provision that had the purpose of preventing, restricting or limiting NPP, a competitor of Visy in relation to the acquisition of recyclable waste paper, from acquiring recyclable waste paper from customers of Visy or from persons with whom Visy has entered into discussions or negotiations to become a customer (‘NPP non-competition clause’), with the intention of making a contract with NPP on the terms in each draft contract, and

(b)by endeavouring to persuade NPP to enter into a contract in terms of the six draft contracts set out in the Schedule hereto, including the NPP non-competition clause, with the intention of making a contract with NPP on the terms in each draft contract,

attempted to contravene s 45(2)(a)(i) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (‘TP Act’) and attempted to induce NPP to contravene s 45(2)(a)(i) of the TP Act.

2.The second respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Visy Paper... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1471
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Visy Paper Pty Ltd, along with two of its executives, Mr Guthridge and Mr Richards, for engaging in conduct that contravened the Trade Practices Act. The dispute centred around Visy's attempts to induce its competitor, National Paper Products (NPP), to enter into agreements containing non-competition clauses. This conduct was alleged to have restricted competition in the market for the acquisition of waste paper and for the supply of waste removal services in the Sydney metropolitan area.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether Visy had indeed engaged in conduct that contravened the Trade Practices Act, and if so, what remedies and penalties should be imposed. The court had to determine if Visy's attempts to include non-competition clauses in agreements with NPP were anti-competitive and if the executives were aware of and intended these actions. Additionally, the court needed to decide on appropriate penalties and remedial orders, including compliance programs and pecuniary penalties.

In its reasoning, the court found that Visy had deliberately contravened the Trade Practices Act by attempting to include non-competition clauses in agreements with NPP. The court acknowledged that Visy's executives understood the anti-competitive effects of such clauses. Despite the executives' lack of covert conduct or dishonesty, the deliberate nature of the contravention warranted penalties. The court also considered the impact on competition, noting that the non-competition clauses would have restricted NPP's ability to compete with Visy, thus harming market competition. Consequently, the court imposed penalties on Visy and its executives, ordered Visy to implement a trade practices compliance program without an external audit requirement, and restrained Visy and its executives from engaging in similar conduct in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

4. Visy, by itself, its directors, servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained for a period of four years from:

(a) attempting to make a contract or arrangement or arrive at an understanding to acquire recyclable waste paper from any person;

(b) inducing or attempting to induce any person, being a corporation, to make a contract or arrangement or arrive at an understanding for Visy to acquire recyclable waste paper from the person; or

(c) making a contract or arrangement or arriving at an understanding to acquire recyclable waste paper from any person;

if:

(d) the person is competitive with Visy in relation to the acquisition of recyclable waste paper; and

(e) the contract, arrangement or understanding contains a provision that has the purpose of preventing, restricting or limiting the person from acquiring recyclable waste paper from particular persons or classes of persons, including customers of any of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.

5. Mr Guthridge be restrained for a period of four years from inducing or attempting to induce any corporation to make a contract or arrangement or arrive at an understanding with him or any person or corporation on whose behalf he is acting (in each case referred to as the ‘acquirer’) by which the acquirer will acquire recyclable waste paper from the corporation if:

(a) the corporation is competitive with the acquirer in relation to the acquisition of recyclable waste paper; and

(b) the contract, arrangement or understanding contains a provision that has the purpose of preventing, restricting or limiting the corporation from acquiring recyclable waste paper from particular persons or classes of persons, including customers of any of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.

6. Mr Richards be restrained for a period of four years from inducing or attempting to induce any corporation to make a contract or arrangement or arrive at an understanding with him or any person or corporation on whose behalf he is acting (in each case referred to as the ‘acquirer’) by which the acquirer will acquire recyclable waste paper from the corporation if:

(a) the corporation is competitive with the acquirer in relation to the acquisition of recyclable waste paper; and

(b) the contract, arrangement or understanding contains a provision that has the purpose of preventing, restricting or limiting the corporation from acquiring recyclable waste paper from particular persons or classes of persons, including customers of any of the parties to the contract, arrangement or understanding.

7. Visy pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty of $500,000 in respect of its acts set out in paragraph 1.

8. Mr Guthridge pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty of $10,000 in respect of his acts set out in paragraph 2.

9. Mr Richards pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty of $15,000 in respect of his acts set out in paragraph 3.

10. Visy:

(a) at its own expense, implement within two months of this order and subsequently maintain for three years, a trade practices compliance program in relation to Part IV of the Act (‘the Program’);

(b) use its best endeavours to ensure the Program is compliant with the Australian Standard on Compliance Programs (AS 3806-1998) to reduce the risk of a repeat of contraventions of Part IV of the TP Act;

(c) include in the Program the following elements:

(i) a procedure enabling a review of all written and oral contracts, arrangements or understandings with respect to the acquisition or proposed acquisition of recyclable waste paper to ensure that they comply with Part IV of the TP Act, prior to them being made or arrived at;

(ii) the maintenance of written records documenting the details of the reviews undertaken;

(d) permit the applicant (‘ACCC’) to inspect, upon reasonable notice in writing, the written records referred to in subpar (c)(ii).

11. Visy pay the costs of the ACCC in an amount to be agreed, or, if unable to be agreed, to be taxed.

SCHEDULE

(a) Exclusive Collection Agreement (First ECA) sent on or about 16 October 1996.

(b) Exclusive Collection Agreement (Second ECA) sent on 6 December 1996.

(c) Exclusive Collection Agreement (Third ECA) sent on 6 January 1997.

(d) Exclusive Collection Agreement (Fourth ECA) sent on 22 January 1997.

(e) First Supply Agreement sent on 27 March 1997.

(f) Second Supply Agreement sent on 30 April 1997.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

SACKVILLE J (dissent)
Accordingly, I propose to order Visy to implement a trade practices compliance program, but I do not propose to include an external audit requirement.CONCLUSION Declarations and injunctions should be made in the form agreed between the parties. Visy should be ordered to implement a trade practices compliance program, but the program should not include an external audit requirement. Visy should pay a pecuniary penalty of $500,000. Mr Guthridge should pay a penalty of $10,000 and Mr Richards should pay a penalty of $15,000. Visy must pay the ACCC’s costs of the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

I note that Mr Geminder, in his evidence at the hearing on penalty, said that he did not consider NPP a competitor of Visy. Mr Guthridge also said in evidence at the trial that he saw NPP as an agent rather than a competitor. In ACCC v Visy (No 1), I rejected a contention that Visy and NPP were not in competition in the relevant market, namely the market in the Sydney metropolitan area for the acquisition of waste paper and for the supply of waste removal services. On the contrary, I found (at 758 [138]) that the evidence overwhelmingly suggested that NPP was competitive with Visy in that market between February and April 1997, although it had suspended its attempts to obtain waste products from Visy’s customers from March 1996 to February 1997 in the expectation that an agreement could be reached with Visy. I also found (at 762 [153]) that Mr Guthridge and Mr Richards were well aware, at the time the supply agreements were presented to NPP, that NPP was attempting to secure waste paper from Visy’s customers. In these circumstances, it is perhaps not surprising that Mr Young did not submit that any penalty should be reduced by reason of any failure on the part of Mr Geminder or Mr Guthridge to appreciate that Visy and NPP were competitors in the relevant market.OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Visy’s conduct involved attempts to induce NPP, during the period from October 1996 to April 1997, to enter an agreement containing a non-competition clause. Visy attempted to do so on six separate occasions during that period. NPP requested removal of the non-competition clause at an early stage of the negotiations, but Mr Richards insisted on its retention. NPP was both a supplier to and competitor of Visy. The effect of the non-competition clause, if implemented, was to prevent NPP from competing with Visy to obtain supplies of waste paper products from, or to provide waste paper removal services to, Visy’s customers or potential customers (that is, those with whom Visy had entered into discussions or negotiations to become customers). The non-competition clause plainly would have had an anti-competitive effect on the market for the acquisition of waste paper and for the supply of waste paper removal services in the Sydney Metropolitan area. Participants designated by Visy as its ‘customers’ would have been denied the opportunity to negotiate for better terms or services from NPP than Visy was prepared or able to provide. Indeed, in a sense, the non-competition clause, even though never part of a concluded agreement, did have an adverse effect on competition in the market. For a time, NPP voluntarily suspended its attempts to obtain waste products from Visy’s customers, in the expectation that a satisfactory agreement with Visy could be finalised and that such an agreement would include a non-competition clause. Once the question of legal uncertainty is put to one side (as I think it must), this is a case of deliberate contravening conduct on Visy’s part. I accept that Mr Guthridge and Mr Richards did not engage in covert conduct or dishonesty. Nonetheless, as I found in ACCC v Visy (No 1) at 759 [143]:‘It is clear that Mr Guthridge and Mr Richards intended that a non‑competition clause whether in the form of cl 3.2(b) of the ECAs or of the equivalent clauses in the supply agreements, should be included in a contract with NPP. They also understood and intended that each non-competition clause, if incorporated in a contract, would prevent NPP from acquiring goods from or supplying services to Visy’s customers. Both Mr Guthridge and Mr Richards wanted to stop NPP from acquiring waste paper from or supplying waste paper collection services to Visy’s customers.’