Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Skins Compression Garments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Skins Compression Garments Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 710

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – penalty – where first respondent admitted engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct or conduct likely to mislead or deceive – where parties submitted draft consent orders and statement of agreed facts

Held: declarations made, undertakings given by first and second respondents accepted and orders for corrective advertising made.

TRADE PRACTICES – resale price maintenance – penalty – where first respondent admitted engaging in resale price maintenance – where third respondent admitted being directly or indirectly knowing concerned in or party to first respondent’s resale price maintenance – factors to be considered by Court in determining appropriate pecuniary penalties – where parties submitted draft consent orders, joint submissions and statement of agreed facts – whether figures for pecuniary penalties proposed by parties appropriate

Held: declarations made, undertaking given by first respondent accepted and orders for pecuniary penalties of $120,000 for first respondent and $14,000 for third respondent made.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21, s 50
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 4, 48, 52, 76, 80, 84, 86C, 87B, 96

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Auspine Ltd (2006) 235 ALR 95 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.Net.Au Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (2007) 161 FCR 513 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hobie Cat Australasia Pty Ltd [2008] ATPR 42-225 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v McMahon Services Pty Ltd [2004] ATPR 42-031 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v NW Frozen Foods [1996] ATPR 41-515 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 161 ALR 79 cited
ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1992) 38 FCR 248 referred to
NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285 discussed
Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 216 CLR 53 referred to
Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR 41-076 discussed

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION v SKINS COMPRESSION GARMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 110 666 923), JAIMIE ROYSTON FULLER and CHRISTOPHER THOMAS WARHURST

SAD 136 of 2007

BESANKO J
2 JULY 2009
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 136 of 2007

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

SKINS COMPRESSION GARMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 110 666 923)
First Respondent

JAIMIE ROYSTON FULLER
Second Respondent

CHRISTOPHER THOMAS WARHURST
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

BESANKO J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 DECEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE VIA VIDEO LINK WITH SYDNEY

THE COURT DECLARES BY CONSENT THAT:

1.The First Respondent (“Skins”) engaged in the practice of resale price maintenance in contravention of section 48 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (the Act) in its dealings with The Sports Locker Pty Ltd (“Sports Locker”) in that Skins, by reason of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Skins Compr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 710
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Skins Compression Garments Pty Ltd and Mr. Christopher Thomas Warhurst, alleging breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974. Specifically, the ACCC claimed that Skins engaged in resale price maintenance and misleading conduct related to the provision of its products to sports teams and athletes. The case involved allegations that Skins had made misrepresentations about not paying sports stars to wear or endorse their products, despite having agreements in place that involved financial payments and provision of products. The court was required to decide whether Skins and Mr. Warhurst contravened sections 48 and 52 of the Trade Practices Act by their actions.

The court concluded that Skins had indeed engaged in resale price maintenance by inducing and attempting to induce a retailer not to advertise Skins products at prices lower than those specified by Skins. This was in violation of section 48 of the Act. Additionally, Mr. Warhurst was found to be knowingly concerned in these activities. Regarding the misleading conduct, the court found that Skins had made various misrepresentations in their advertising and on their websites, claiming they did not pay sports stars to wear or endorse their products, which was contrary to the agreements in place. These actions contravened section 52 of the Act. The court accepted the proposed penalties of $120,000 for Skins and $14,000 for Mr. Warhurst, to be paid in instalments. The court also ordered Skins to provide corrective notices and advertisements and to publish a report detailing the broadcasting of these corrective actions.

In summary, the court's decision confirmed the breaches of the Trade Practices Act by Skins and Mr. Warhurst and ordered appropriate pecuniary penalties and corrective actions to address the misleading conduct.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The First Respondent (“Skins”) engaged in the practice of resale price maintenance in contravention of section 48 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (the Act) in its dealings with The Sports Locker Pty Ltd (“Sports Locker”) in that Skins, by reason of the operation of section 84(2)(a) of the Act:

1.1 induced Sports Locker not to advertise Skins products at prices less than prices specified by Skins, by reason of, in about July 2005, Christopher Thomas Warhurst (“Warhurst”) of Artipena Springs Pty Limited trading as Warhurst Agencies, being the South Australian agent of Skins requesting that Sports Locker remove an advertising board which advertised Skins products at 20% off (“the Skins advertising board”) on display outside the premises of Sports Locker, in response to which request Sports Locker removed the Skins advertising board for a period of approximately 4 weeks;

1.2 attempted to induce Sports Locker not to advertise Skins products at prices less than prices specified by Skins, by reason of, in about September 2005, Warhurst requesting that Sports Locker remove the Skins advertising board on display outside the premises of Sports Locker; and

1.3 attempted to induce Sports Locker not to advertise Skins products at prices less than prices specified by Skins, by reason of, in about May 2006, Warhurst requesting that Sports Locker remove the Skins advertising board on display outside the premises of Sports Locker.

2. On each occasion that Skins engaged in conduct that contravened section 48 of the Act, Warhurst was directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contravention in that:

2.1 he engaged in the conduct referred to in paragraph 1; and

2.2 he was aware of all the facts and circumstances by reason of which the conduct was resale price maintenance.

UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT:

3. The Court accepts the following undertaking from Skins:

3.1 Skins undertakes to the Court that Skins shall not, by itself, its servants, agents or otherwise howsoever, for a period of 3 years from the date of this undertaking, induce or attempt to induce, any person or corporation not to sell or advertise Skins products supplied to it by Skins for sale at a price less than a price specified by Skins.

THE COURT ORDERS BY CONSENT THAT:

4. Pursuant to section 76(1) of the Act that Skins pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $120,000 in respect of the conduct set out at paragraph 1.

5. Pursuant to section 76(1) of the Act that Warhurst pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $14,000 payable by 12 monthly instalments of $1,166.67 each commencing on 5 December 2008 and on or before the 5th day of each month thereafter.

6. In the event of default by Warhurst in the making of a periodical payment so ordered in order 5 hereof, which default has continued for 14 days, then the whole of the outstanding pecuniary penalty payable by Warhurst shall thereupon become due and payable.

7. Skins provide a letter in the terms and size of Annexure A to this Order, which letter shall be on Skins letterhead, within 7 days of the making of this Order, to each of Skins’ current retailers, agents and/or distributors.

THE COURT DECLARES BY CONSENT THAT:

1. By making representations:

1.1 during July 2006, in television advertisements broadcast during coverage of the Tour de France on the SBS national television network; and

1.2 from at least 26 September 2005 to 28 August 2007, on its website www.skins.com.au/ns (“the first website”) through the display of print advertisements, radio advertisements, a television advertisement and statements,

that:

1.3 Skins does not pay money to sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies for sports stars to wear Skins products (this representation is referred to below as the “no payment to wear” representation);

1.4 Skins does not provide Skins products to sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies unless the Skins products are paid for with money (this representation is referred to below as the “always paid for” representation);

1.5 Skins does not pay money to sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies for sports stars to endorse Skins products (this representation is referred to below as the “no payment to endorse” representation);

in circumstances where, pursuant to agreements with sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies (“the Skins agreements”):

1.6 during the period from 26 September 2005 to 28 August 2007 Skins paid money to:

1.6.1 each of Brett Lee, Michael Milton and Jono Brauer, or their representatives, for each of Brett Lee, Michael Milton and Jono Brauer respectively to wear and endorse Skins products; and

1.6.2 each of the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs, the Wests Tigers rugby league team and NSW Rugby Union for players from respectively the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne football teams, the Wests Tigers rugby league team and the Waratahs rugby union team to wear and endorse Skins products;

1.7 during the period from 1 July 2005 to 28 August 2007 Skins provided Skins products to:

1.7.1 players associated with Cricket Australia;

1.7.2 Michael Milton;

1.7.3 Jono Brauer;

1.7.4 players from the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs;

1.7.5 players from the Sydney Roosters, North Queensland Cowboys and Wests Tigers rugby league teams;

1.7.6 players from the Sydney Kings basketball team and the Opals and Boomers national Australian basketball teams;

1.7.7 players from the Newcastle Jets soccer team;

1.7.8 players from the Waratahs rugby union team;

1.7.9 players from the Kookaburras national Australian hockey team; and

1.7.10 athletes representing Rowing Australia,

or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies without the Skins products being paid for with money;

Skins engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was misleading or deceptive, or was likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52 of the Act.

2. By making:

2.1 between July 2005 and October 2005, the “always paid for” representation in print advertisements;

2.2 during July 2005, the “always paid for” representation in radio advertisements;

2.3 during July 2005, the “always paid for” representation in television advertisements; and

2.4 during October 2005, the “no payment to wear” representation in print advertisements,

in the circumstances set out at paragraphs 1.6 and 1.7, Skins engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of section 52 of the Act.

3. By making from at least 5 April 2006 to 28 August 2007, the “always paid for” representation and the “no payment to wear” representation on its website www.skins.com.au, which changed to www.skins.net (“the second website”) through the display of a statement and a television advertisement, and in the circumstances set out at paragraphs 1.6 and 1.7, Skins engaged in conduct, in trade or commerce, that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of section 52 of the Act.

4. From at least 1 June 2006 to 28 August 2007, by making representations in respect of the following sports stars depicted in photographs on the first website:

4.1 cricketer Brett Lee;

4.2 athlete Michael Milton;

4.3 skier Jono Brauer;

4.4 Australian Football League players from the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs;

4.5 rugby league players from the Sydney Roosters, North Queensland Cowboys and Wests Tigers rugby league teams;

4.6 basketball players from the Sydney Kings basketball team and the Opals and Boomers national Australian basketball teams;

4.7 soccer players from the Newcastle Jets soccer team;

4.8 rugby union players from the Waratahs rugby union team;

4.9 hockey players from the Kookaburras national Australian hockey team; and

4.10 athletes representing Rowing Australia

(for the remainder of paragraph 4, the persons referred to in paragraphs 4.1 to 4.10 are referred to as “the sports stars”),

that:

4.11 Skins does not pay money to the sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies for the sports stars to wear or endorse Skins products;

4.12 Skins does not provide Skins products to the sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies unless the Skins products are paid for with money;

in circumstances where, pursuant to the Skins agreements:

4.13 during the period from 26 September 2005 to 28 August 2007 Skins paid money to:

4.13.1 each of Brett Lee, Michael Milton and Jono Brauer, or their representatives, for each of Brett Lee, Michael Milton and Jono Brauer respectively to wear and endorse Skins products; and

4.13.2 each of the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs, the Wests Tigers rugby league team and NSW Rugby Union for players from respectively the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs, the Wests Tigers rugby league team and the Waratahs rugby union team to wear and endorse Skins products;

4.14 during the period from 1 July 2005 to 28 August 2007 Skins provided Skins products to:

4.14.1 Michael Milton;

4.14.2 Jono Brauer;

4.14.3 players from the Western Bulldogs, St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs;

4.14.4 players from the Sydney Roosters, North Queensland Cowboys and Wests Tigers rugby league teams;

4.14.5 players from the Sydney Kings basketball team and the Opals and Boomers national Australian basketball teams;

4.14.6 players from the Newcastle Jets soccer team;

4.14.7 players from the Waratahs rugby union team;

4.14.8 players from the Kookaburras national Australian hockey team; and

4.14.9 athletes representing Rowing Australia,

or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies, without the Skins products being paid for with money,

Skins engaged in conduct in trade or commerce that was misleading or deceptive, or was likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52 of the Act.

5. From at least 5 April 2006 to 28 August 2007, by making representations in respect of the following sports stars depicted in photographs on the second website:

5.1 skier Jono Brauer;

5.2 touring car driver Garth Tander;

5.3 Australian Football League players from the St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs;

5.4 rugby league players from the Sydney Roosters and Wests Tigers rugby league teams;

5.5 basketball players from the Sydney Kings basketball team and the Opals national Australian basketball team;

5.6 soccer players from the Newcastle Jets soccer team;

5.7 rugby union players from the Waratahs rugby union team; and

5.8 hockey players from the Kookaburras national Australian hockey team,

(for the remainder of paragraph 5, the persons referred to in paragraphs 5.1 to 5.8 are referred to as “the sports stars”)

that

5.9 Skins does not pay money to the sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies for the sports stars to wear Skins products;

5.10 Skins does not provide Skins products to the sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies unless the Skins products are paid for with money;

in circumstances where, pursuant to the Skins agreements:

5.11 during the period from 26 September 2005 to 28 August 2007 Skins paid money to:

5.11.1 Jono Brauer, or his representative, for Jono Brauer to wear Skins products; and

5.11.2 each of the St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs, the Wests Tigers rugby league team and NSW Rugby Union, for players from, respectively the St Kilda and Melbourne football teams, the Wests Tigers rugby league team and the Waratahs rugby union team to wear Skins products;

5.12 during the period from 1 July 2005 to 28 August 2007 Skins provided Skins products to:

5.12.1 Jono Brauer;

5.12.2 Garth Tander;

5.12.3 players from the St Kilda and Melbourne Football Clubs;

5.12.4 players from the Sydney Roosters and Wests Tigers rugby league teams;

5.12.5 players from the Sydney Kings basketball team;

5.12.6 players from the Newcastle Jets soccer team; and

5.12.7 players from the Waratahs rugby union team,

or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies, without the Skins products being paid for with money,

Skins engaged in conduct in trade or commerce that was misleading or deceptive, or was likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52 of the Act.

THE COURT ORDERS BY CONSENT THAT:

6. Skins within 30 days of the making of this Order, at its own expense, cause to be published on the Internet at the home page of all websites which are owned, operated or maintained by or on behalf of Skins, including the following website accessible via uniform resource locator address (“URL”) www.skins.net (or if any such URL is replaced or changed, the Internet home page of the corresponding website) for a period of 4 months, a notice in terms of Annexure A to this Order and use its best endeavours to ensure that:

6.1 such notice shall be viewable by clicking a “click-through” icon located on the homepage of the website www.skins.net;

6.2 the 'click-through' icon referred to in the previous sub-paragraph is located on the left hand side of the homepage directly below the “click-through” icon labelled “contact” and is the same size as the “click-through” icon in relation to the NSW Swifts which was included at that location on the homepage on 6 August 2008;

6.3 the “click-through” icon shall contain the words “Misleading Advertising by Skins – Corrective Notice Ordered by Federal Court of Australia” prominently in yellow and the words “click here”; and

6.4 the notice accessed via the above mentioned 'click-through' icon shall:

6.4.1 have a bold type heading in at least 16 point type and the body of the notice shall be in a type not less than 11 point, Times New Roman font and right and left justified;

6.4.2 include the business logo of Skins at the top as appearing on Skins letterhead; and

6.4.3 occupy the entire webpage which is accessed via the “click-through” icon referred to above.

7. Skins within 90 days of the making of this Order, at its own expense cause to be broadcast a corrective advertisement, in the form of and containing the content set out in Annexure B to this Order, with such corrective advertisement to be broadcast:

7.1 on the SBS national television network;

7.2 with a frequency of twice per day for seven consecutive days;

7.3 once between 6.00 pm and 6.30 pm and once between 6.30 pm and 9.00 pm; and

7.4 for a duration of at least 30 seconds;

8. Skins, within 1 month of the conclusion of the broadcasting of the corrective advertisement and not later than 6 months from the date of this Order, provide a written report to the Applicant detailing the dates upon and times at which the corrective advertisement was broadcast.

9. Skins within 3 months of the making of this Order, at its own expense, cause to be published in B & T Weekly, a notice in terms of Annexure C to this Order, with such notice to:

9.1 be within the first 10 pages;

9.2 be of a size that is not less than half a page;

9.3 be in Times New Roman font, with a bold type heading in at least 18 point type and the body of the notice in at least 11 point type, and right and left justified; and

9.4 include the business logo of Skins at the top as appearing on Skins letterhead.

The First Respondent to pay the Applicant’s party/party costs fixed at $80,000.00

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Skins Compression Garments Pty Ltd (Skins) and Christopher Thomas Warhurst (Warhurst) were involved in several instances of alleged anti-competitive conduct and misleading or deceptive conduct. Between July 2005 and August 2007, Skins made various representations in advertisements and on its websites that it did not pay money to sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies for sports stars to wear or endorse Skins products, and that Skins did not provide Skins products to sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies unless the Skins products were paid for with money. However, it was found that Skins had entered into agreements with sports stars and sports organisations where Skins paid money for the athletes to wear and endorse Skins products and provided Skins products without payment. Additionally, Skins was found to have engaged in resale price maintenance by inducing or attempting to induce Sports Locker Pty Ltd (Sports Locker) not to advertise Skins products at prices less than those specified by Skins.

The case was brought before the Federal Court of Australia by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) against Skins and Warhurst. The matter proceeded on the basis of consent orders and undertakings. Various interlocutory applications and negotiations led to the parties reaching an agreement on the terms of the orders and declarations to be made by the Court. The Court accepted the consent orders and undertakings, and made the orders and declarations as agreed by the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
It was not necessary for me to determine whether, unaided by the agreement of the parties, I would have arrived at the very figures the parties proposed. It was sufficient for me to conclude that, having regard to the matters I have identified, the proposed pecuniary penalties of $120,000 in the case of Skins and $14,000 in the case of Mr Warhurst were appropriate.Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, I made orders on 2 December 2008 in the terms that appear preceding these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J

The court examined the conduct of Skins in relation to its agreements with The Sports Locker Pty Ltd, finding that Skins had engaged in the practice of resale price maintenance by inducing The Sports Locker not to advertise Skins products at prices less than those specified by Skins. Warhurst, acting as the South Australian agent of Skins, made several requests to The Sports Locker to remove an advertising board that displayed Skins products at a discounted price, which The Sports Locker complied with. The court held that Skins engaged in conduct that contravened section 48 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 and that Warhurst was directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contravention.

The court also found that Skins engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974. Skins made representations through various media, including television, radio, print advertisements, and its website, that it did not pay money to sports stars, or their representatives, clubs, teams or governing bodies for sports stars to wear or endorse Skins products. However, pursuant to agreements with sports stars, Skins had paid money to various sports stars and their representatives for them to wear and endorse Skins products and had provided Skins products to various sports teams and athletes without the products being paid for with money. The court concluded that Skins' conduct was misleading or deceptive, or was likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974.

The ratio decidendi of the decision lies in the application of sections 48 and 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 to the specific conduct of Skins and Warhurst. The court applied the legal principles of resale price maintenance and misleading or deceptive conduct, considering the factual circumstances of the agreements and representations made by Skins. The decision reinforces the obligations of businesses to comply with competition laws and the consequences of engaging in conduct that contravenes those laws.