FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Safe Breast Imaging Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 998
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Safe Breast... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCA 998
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the respondents had engaged in misleading conduct by falsely representing that their breast imaging services had an adequate scientific basis, could assure customers that they did not have breast cancer, could assess the risk of breast cancer, and could substitute for mammography. These representations were made without reasonable grounds and were misleading to consumers. The court deemed it appropriate to grant declarations to clearly outline the nature and extent of the contraventions and their seriousness. Injunctions were also granted to prevent the respondents from continuing the misleading conduct and to emphasize the seriousness of their actions. The court determined that pecuniary penalties were necessary to provide a just and appropriate penalty outcome. Safe Breast Imaging was ordered to pay a penalty of $200,000, and Joanne Firth was ordered to pay $50,000. Additionally, the court ordered publication of notices on the respondents' Facebook profiles and retention of sealed reasons for judgment for future proceedings. Lastly, the court ordered the respondents to pay the ACCC's costs of the proceedings.
The court concluded that the comprehensive set of orders, including declarations, injunctions, pecuniary penalties, publication orders, and costs, adequately addressed the seriousness of the contraventions and provided appropriate relief. The court's decision aimed to ensure that the respondents understood the gravity of their actions and to deter similar conduct in the future.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Injunctions
(a) Safe Breast Imaging be restrained, whether by itself, its servants, agents or howsoever otherwise, in trade or commerce in Australia, from representing, whether by publishing or distributing promotional material or otherwise, that:
(i) there is an adequate scientific medical basis for any breast imaging service being:
(A) able to assure a customer that they do not have breast cancer;
(B) an effective means of assessing whether a customer may be at risk from breast cancer or the level of such risk;
(C) an effective substitute for mammography; or
(ii) any part of such breast imaging service is performed by a medical doctor who is registered to practise as a medical practitioner in Australia,
unless, at the time of making the representation, reasonable grounds exist for the making of such a representation.
(b) Joanne Firth be restrained, whether as an officer, servant or agent of Safe Breast Imaging or otherwise, in trade or commerce, from:
(i) representing, whether by distributing promotional material or otherwise, that:
(A) there is an adequate scientific medical basis for any breast imaging service being:
a. able to assure a customer that they do not have breast cancer;
b. an effective means of assessing whether a customer may be at risk from breast cancer or the level of such risk;
c. an effective substitute for mammography services; or
(B) any part of such breast imaging service is performed by a medical doctor who is registered to practise as a medical practitioner in Australia; or
(ii) aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to any person or corporation from representing, whether by publishing or distributing promotional material or otherwise, that:
(A) there is an adequate scientific medical basis for any breast imaging service being:
a. able to assure a customer that they do not have breast cancer;
b. an effective means of assessing whether a person may be at risk from breast cancer or the level of such risk;
c. an effective substitute for mammography services; or
(B) any part of such breast imaging service is performed by a medical doctor who is registered to practise as a medical practitioner in Australia,
unless, at the time of making the representation, reasonable grounds exist for the making of such a representation.
2. Penalties
(a) Pursuant to s 76E of the TPA and s 224 of the ACL, Safe Breast Imaging pay to the Commonwealth within 30 days of the making of this Order by the Court a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $200,000 in respect of the conduct described in paras 1 to 4 of this Order.
(b) Pursuant to s 76E of the TPA and s 224 of the ACL, Joanne Firth pay to the Commonwealth within 30 days of the making of this Order by the Court a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $50,000 in respect of the conduct described in para 5 of this Order.
3. Other orders
(a) The applicant (ACCC) be at liberty to cause an email in terms of Annexure A to this Order to be sent to all customers of Safe Breast Imaging listed in Annexure AH31 (AH31) of the affidavit of Anthony Gerard Hilton affirmed on 1 February 2013. If there is no email address listed in AH31 or the email has been rejected by the customer’s server, the ACCC be at liberty to cause a letter in terms of Annexure A to be sent by post to the postal address listed in AH31.
(b) Joanne Firth shall within 14 days of the date of these orders cause a post to be entered on the Facebook profiles of each of Safe Breast Imaging and Joanne Firth in terms of Annexure A to this Order.
(c) An order pursuant to s 248 of the ACL that Joanne Firth be disqualified from managing corporations for a period of four (4) years from the date of the Court’s order.
(d) The reasons for judgment, with the Court’s seal affixed, be retained on the Court file for the purposes of s 83 of the TPA and s 137H of the CCA.
4. Costs
(a) Safe Breast Imaging and Joanne Firth pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The question now before the Court, in light of the contraventions, is what orders the Court should make.Should declarations be made? There is no real dispute between the parties that declarations, as sought by ACCC, are appropriate. I have given careful consideration to the declarations proposed to ensure that they are framed appropriately and reflect the contraventions and other findings made by the Court. I am satisfied that, in each case, the declarations proposed by ACCC should be made in respect of both Safe Breast Imaging and Ms Firth. They convey to the public at large the nature and extent of the contraventions found in this case and their seriousness. Accordingly, there will be declarations made in accordance with the minute of proposed orders submitted by ACCC.Should injunctions be granted? I consider this is a case where injunctions, as sought by ACCC, should be granted. While it is perhaps not unusual, in proceedings such as these, for respondents who have been found to have contravened the consumer legislation, both to cease a contravening course of conduct and/or to say that they are unlikely to contravene again, there is reason in this case for injunctions to be granted in order to communicate both to the respondents particularly and to the public more generally that the conduct engaged in was serious and should not be repeated. The granting of injunctions is calculated to emphasise those messages, along with the declarations. Additionally in this case, as her submissions on penalty tend to indicate, Ms Firth appears to remain defensive so far as the company’s and her contravening conduct is concerned. While Ms Firth and the company hold strong views about the validity of breast health research and technologies extending beyond mammography, the findings of the Court are such that they should not be left to think that they, or others, remain free to engage in conduct of the type found in this case to have contravened the consumer laws. The injunctions as sought by ACCC are appropriate and should be granted.Should the pecuniary penalties sought be ordered? ACCC seeks orders that Safe Breast Imaging pay a pecuniary penalty of $550,000 and Ms Firth pay a pecuniary penalty of $110,000. Under s 224 of ACL (or s 76E of the TP Act), the maximum penalty for a corporation is $1.1 million for each act or omission. The maximum penalty for an individual is $220,000 for each act or omission. ACCC submits that for penalty purposes it is appropriate for the Court to consider the science representations and the medical practitioner representations as, respectively, separate and distinct courses of conduct engaged in by Safe Breast Imaging, each deserving of sanction. ACCC accepts that the conduct engaged in by Safe Breast Imaging formed part of one continuous marketing campaign in respect of its use of the MEM device for breast imaging. It submits, however, that because of the different character of the science representations, on the one hand, and the medical practitioner representations, on the other, each class of representation amounts to a separate course of conduct for the purpose of assessing the appropriate penalty to be imposed.