FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 148
Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 148 Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v CEMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 104 053 474, CEMENT AUSTRALIA HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 001 085 561, CEMENT AUSTRALIA (QUEENSLAND) PTY LTD FORMERLY QUEENSLAND CEMENT LTD ACN 009 658 520, POZZOLANIC ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 010 367 898, POZZOLANIC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ACN 010 608 947, CHRISTOPHER GUY LEON and CHRISTOPHER STEPHEN WHITE File number(s): QUD 295 of 2008 Judge(s): GREENWOOD J Date of judgment: 28 February 2014 Catchwords: COMPETITION LAW – consideration of the form of further orders to be made consequent upon the pronouncement of judgment in the principal proceeding on 10 September 2013 consequent upon a further hearing on 31 October 2013 Legislation: Australian Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 45, 46 and 86
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 19, 21, 23
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 39B(1A)(c)
Federal Court Rules 2011, r 1.32Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 909 – cited
Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564 – cited and quoted
Rural Press Ltd v ACCC (2003) 216 CLR 53 – cited and quoted
ACCC v Kokos International Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCA 5; (2008) ATPR 42‑212 – cited
ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1992) 38 FCR 248 – cited and quotedOther References:
Zamir & Woolf, “The Declaratory Judgment”, Lord Woolf and Jeremy Woolf, Sweet & Maxwell, 4th Edition
Perspectives on Declaratory Relief, K Dharmananda and A Papamatheos, Declarations: Homer Simpson’s Remedy – Is There Anything They Cannot Do?”, The Hon Justice French (as his Honour then was)
Date of hearing: 31 October 2013 Date of last submissions: 31 October 2013 Place: Brisbane Division: GENERAL DIVISION Category: Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 32 Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Couper QC Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor Counsel for the Respondents: Ms S Brown QC and Mr C E Bannan Solicitor for the Respondents: Gilbert and Tobin, Lawyers
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
QUD 295 of 2008
BETWEEN: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
ApplicantAND: CEMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 104 053 474
First RespondentCEMENT AUSTRALIA HOLDINGS PTY LTD
ACN 001 085 561
Second RespondentCEMENT AUSTRALIA (QUEENSLAND) PTY LTD FORMERLY QUEENSLAND CEMENT LTD ACN 009 658 520
Third RespondentPOZZOLANIC ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 010 367 898
Fourth RespondentPOZZOLANIC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ACN 010 608 947
Fifth RespondentCHRISTOPHER GUY LEON
Sixth RespondentCHRISTOPHER STEPHEN WHITE
Seventh Respondent
JUDGE:
GREENWOOD J
DATE OF ORDER:
28 FEBRUARY 2014
WHERE MADE:
BRISBANE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The interim declarations made on 10 September 2013 pending the making of formal orders consequent upon the submission of proposed formal orders by the parties for consideration…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Aust... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCA 148
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court considered the submissions of the parties and the implications of the findings in the reasons for judgment. It ultimately determined that the interim declarations made on 10 September 2013 should be discharged and dissolved, pending the formal orders to be submitted by the parties. The Court dismissed certain proceedings against the respondents and declared that specific contracts and arrangements contravened particular sections of the Act due to their substantial purpose and effect of substantially lessening competition. The Court also made orders concerning the costs of the proceeding and directed the parties to discuss the future conduct of a pecuniary penalty hearing.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The interim declarations made on 10 September 2013 pending the making of formal orders consequent upon the submission of proposed formal orders by the parties for consideration by the Court (supported by written submissions and oral submissions if sought to be made), as contemplated by Order 1 of the orders made on 10 September 2013, are discharged and dissolved.
2. The proceedings, so far as they relate to contended contraventions of Section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), now entitled the Australian Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the “Act”) on the part of any of the respondents, are dismissed as against those respondents.
3. The proceedings, so far as they relate to contentions that any one of the respondents aided, abetted, counselled or procured a person to contravene Section 46 of the Act or was directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, a contended contravention of Section 46 of the Act, are dismissed as against those respondents.
4. The proceedings, so far as they relate to contentions that Christopher Guy Leon aided, abetted, counselled or procured a person to contravene a provision of Part IV of the Act or was directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to, a contended contravention of a provision of Part IV of the Act, are dismissed as against Christopher Guy Leon.
5. The proceedings, so far as they relate to contended contraventions of Section 45 of the Act against any one of the respondents in relation to conduct in March 2005 and April 2005 (described for the purposes of the proceedings as the “Second Election to Proceed” by investing approximately $2.52 million of capital expenditure in a facility called a “classifier” at the Millmerran Power Station), are dismissed as against any of those respondents.
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
The Original Millmerran Contract
6. Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (“Pozzolanic”) by entering into a contract on 30 September 2002, described as the “Ash Purchase Agreement” or alternatively described for the purposes of these proceedings as the “Original Millmerran Contract” (the “OMC”) as buyer; Pozzolanic Industries Pty Ltd (“Pozzolanic Industries”) as guarantor; and eight companies collectively described as the Millmerran Power Partners (“MPP”) as seller, containing provisions which had:
6.1 a substantial purpose of;
6.2 the likely effect of; and
6.3 until 31 December 2003 (see declaration numbered 11), the effect of
preventing a rival of Pozzolanic from securing access to unprocessed flyash in the South East Queensland (“SEQ”) unprocessed flyash market, and preventing a rival of Cement Australia (Queensland) Pty Ltd formerly known as Queensland Cement Ltd (“QCL”) from entering the SEQ concrete grade flyash market (being a product market for fine grade concrete grade flyash), and thereby substantially lessening competition in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market and the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, contravened Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act.
7. QCL, by funding Pozzolanic’s entry into the OMC on 30 September 2002, with knowledge of the purpose, likely effect and effect of the provisions of the OMC contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 6) herein, was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act referred to in the above declaration (numbered 6).
8. Pozzolanic, by giving effect to the provisions of the OMC, having the purpose, likely effect and effect contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 6) herein, in the period 30 September 2002 until 31 December 2003 contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
9. QCL, by giving effect to the provisions of the OMC, having the purpose, likely effect and effect contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 6) herein, by funding Pozzolanic’s day‑to‑day performance of the contract in the period 30 September 2002 until 31 December 2003 contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
10. Pozzolanic Industries, by electing to act as guarantor of the obligations of Pozzolanic under the terms and conditions of the OMC and by entering into the OMC as guarantor with knowledge of the purpose, likely effect and effect of the provisions of the OMC contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 6), was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of s 45(2)(a)(ii) referred to in the above declaration (numbered 6).
11. To the extent that the identified provisions of the OMC contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 6) had the effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition in the relevant market upon inclusion of the identified provisions when making the OMC, that effect or likely effect became dissipated by 31 December 2003 with the result that any effect or likely effect upon competition in the relevant market was then attributable to the compromised quality of the Millmerran flyash rather than the continuing effect or likely effect of the identified provisions.
The Amended Millmerran Contract
12. Pozzolanic, by entering into a variation of the OMC called, for the purposes of the proceeding, the Amended Millmerran Contract (the “AMC”), on 28 July 2004, containing provisions which had the purpose of preventing a rival of Pozzolanic from securing access to Millmerran Power Station unprocessed flyash in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market, and preventing a rival of Cement Australia Pty Ltd (“Cement Australia”) from entering the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, and thereby substantially lessening competition in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market and the SEQ concrete grade flyash market with processed Millmerran flyash, contravened s 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act.
13. Cement Australia, by causing Pozzolanic to enter into the AMC with knowledge of the provisions contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 12) was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(a)(ii) referred to in the above declaration (numbered 12).
14. Pozzolanic, by giving effect to the provisions of the AMC contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 12) from 28 July 2004 until 30 April 2005 contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
15. Cement Australia, by causing Pozzolanic to give effect to the provisions of the AMC contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 12) from 28 July 2004 until 30 April 2005 contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
The Tarong Contract
16. Pozzolanic, by entering into a Flyash Agreement with Tarong Energy Corporation (“TEC”) on 26 February 2003 (the “Tarong Contract”) for the acquisition of flyash from Tarong Power Station and Tarong North Power Station (once commissioned and operating), containing provisions which had:
16.1 a substantial purpose of; and
16.2 the likely effect of; and
16.3 the effect of
preventing a rival of Pozzolanic from securing access to unprocessed flyash in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market, and preventing a rival of QCL from entering the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, and thereby substantially lessening competition in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market and the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, contravened Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act.
17. QCL, by funding Pozzolanic’s entry into the Tarong Contract with knowledge of the provisions contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 16) was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act, referred to in declaration numbered 16.
18. Pozzolanic, by giving effect to the provisions of the Tarong Contract contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 16) on and from March 2003 contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
19. QCL, by funding Pozzolanic’s performance of the Tarong Contract until 1 June 2003 contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 16), gave effect to the provisions of the Tarong Contract and thereby contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act, and with knowledge of the relevant provisions, was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(b)(ii) contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 18).
20. Cement Australia, by funding Pozzolanic’s performance of the Tarong Contract in relation to both the Tarong Power Station and the Tarong North Power Station on and from 1 June 2003 gave effect to the provisions of the Tarong Contract and thereby contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act, and with knowledge of the relevant provisions was knowingly concerned from 1 June 2003 in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(b)(ii).
The Swanbank Contract
21. Pozzolanic, by exercising an option on 11 July 2002 to extend the term of the Swanbank Contract to 31 December 2004 on the terms of the amendment letter of 9 September 1998 and the Agreement of 30 September 1998, and further extend the amended Swanbank Contract to 30 June 2005 incorporating the identified provisions conferring exclusive access to Swanbank flyash in Pozzolanic until 30 June 2005, being provisions that would have the likely effect, and had the effect of preventing a rival of Pozzolanic from securing access to Swanbank unprocessed flyash in the unprocessed flyash market from 1 January 2001 to 30 June 2005, and preventing a rival of QCL from entering the SEQ concrete grade flyash market up to 31 May 2003 and thereafter preventing a rival of Cement Australia entering the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, thereby substantially lessening competition in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market and the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, contravened Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act.
22. Pozzolanic, by entering into an agreement to extend the term of the Swanbank Contract from 31 December 2004 to 30 June 2005 on the terms of the amendment letter of 9 September 1998 and the Agreement of 30 September 1998 incorporating the identified provisions conferring exclusive access to Swanbank flyash in Pozzolanic until 30 June 2005, being an arrangement incorporating the relevant provisions, having a substantial purpose of preventing a rival of Pozzolanic from securing access to Swanbank unprocessed flyash in the unprocessed flyash market until 30 June 2005, and preventing a rival of Cement Australia entering the SEQ concrete grade flyash market until 30 June 2005, thereby substantially lessening competition in the SEQ unprocessed flyash market and the SEQ concrete grade flyash market, contravened Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act.
23. Pozzolanic, by giving effect to the identified provisions as contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 21) which conferred exclusive access to Swanbank flyash in the period 1 January 2001 to 30 June 2005, contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
24. Pozzolanic, by giving effect to the identified provisions as contemplated by the above declarations (numbered 21 and 22) which conferred exclusive access to Swanbank flyash in the period from 1 January 2005 to 30 June 2005, contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
25. QCL, by giving effect to the identified provisions as contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 21) in the period from 1 January 2001 to 31 May 2003, contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
26. Cement Australia, by giving effect to the identified provisions as contemplated by the above declarations (numbered 21 and 22), contravened Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act.
Christopher Stephen White
27. Mr White was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act in relation to the conduct contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 22).
28. Mr White was knowingly concerned in Pozzolanic’s contravention of Section 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act in relation to the conduct contemplated by the above declaration (numbered 21) from the period 31 December 2004 to 30 June 2005.
THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT:
29. The proceedings, so far as they relate to contentions that Mr White was knowingly concerned in conduct in contravention of the Act, other than the conduct contemplated by the above declarations (numbered 27 and 28), are dismissed.
30. The costs of the principal proceeding are reserved for later determination.
31. The time for filing any appeal from the declarations or orders made today, as contemplated by Order 6 of the orders made on 14 November 2013, be a period of 21 days commencing from the making of final orders in disposition of the question of whether and to what extent a pecuniary penalty is to be imposed upon any one or more of the respondents and any other final relief in the proceedings.
32. The parties are directed to conduct discussions with a view to submitting to the Court proposed directions for the future conduct of a pecuniary penalty hearing in respect of the contraventions of the Act.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On 31 October 2013, oral submissions were heard in support of written submissions of the parties directed to the forms of order to be made arising out of publication of the judgment in the principal proceeding on 10 September 2013: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 909. On that day, the Court published reasons for judgment in the principal proceeding and made a number of declarations and orders. The declarations were described as interim declarations and the orders were directed to the preparation and submission of formal orders for the consideration of the Court arising out of an analysis by the parties of the reasons for judgment identifying the various findings on the various contended contraventions. The interim declarations and orders made on 10 September 2013 were in these terms:THE COURT MAKES THE FOLLOWING INTERIM DECLARATIONS: 1.Entry into the Original Millmerran Contract by Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (“Pozzolanic”), Pozzolanic Industries Limited and Millmerran Power Partners dated 30 September 2002 does not engage a contravention of s 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (the “Act”). 2.Entry into the Amended Millmerran Contract on 28 July 2004 does not engage a contravention of s 46 of the Act. 3.The conduct in relation to the second election to proceed by electing in March and April 2005 to deploy the capital for the purpose of installing processing facilities at Millmerran does not engage a contravention of s 46 of the Act. 4.Entry into the Original Millmerran Contract engages a contravention of s 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act on the part of Pozzolanic and a contravention of s 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act on the part of Pozzolanic and Queensland Cement Limited (“QCL”). 5.To the extent that the identified provisions of the Original Millmerran Contract had the effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition in the relevant market upon inclusion of the pleaded provisions in making the contract, that effect or likely effect became dissipated by the end of 2003 with the result that any effect or likely effect upon competition was then attributable to the compromised quality of the Millmerran flyash rather than the effect or likely effect of the identified provisions. 6.Entry into the Amended Millmerran Contract engages a contravention of s 45(2)(a)(ii), as a substantial purpose, among other purposes, of entry into the amended provisions and the continuing affirmation of the Original Millmerran Contract provisions, as amended, was to prevent a rival of Pozzolanic and Cement Australia Pty Ltd from securing access to Millmerran unprocessed flyash and to prevent a rival from entering the South East Queensland concrete grade flyash with processed Millmerran flyash. 7.The conduct in relation to the second election to proceed in March and April 2005 does not engage a contravention of s 45 of the Act. 8.Entry into the Fly Ash Agreement between Tarong Energy Corporation Limited (“TEC”) and Pozzolanic of 26 February 2003 engages a contravention of s 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act on the part of Pozzolanic and a contravention of s 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act on the part of QCL. 9.Pozzolanic and Cement Australia contravened s 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act by giving effect to the pleaded provisions of the Fly Ash Agreement between TEC and Pozzolanic of 26 February 2003 in relation to both the Tarong Power Station and the Tarong North Power Station. 10.Entry into the arrangements by Pozzolanic and Cement Australia to construct a classifier at the Tarong North Power Station does not engage a contravention of s 45 of the Act. 11.Pozzolanic and QCL contravened s 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act by giving effect to the pleaded provisions of the Swanbank Contract of 1993 as amended by the letter of 9 September 1998 and the subject of the Agreement of 30 September 1998, in the period, relevantly for these proceedings, from the beginning of 2001 to 31 May 2003. 12.Pozzolanic and Cement Australia contravened s 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act by giving effect to the pleaded provisions of the Swanbank Contract of 1993 as amended by the letter of 9 September 1998 and the subject of the Agreement of 30 September 1998, in the period, relevantly for these proceedings, from 1 June 2003 to 31 December 2004 and then from 31 December 2004 until 30 June 2005. 13.Pozzolanic and Cement Australia contravened s 45(2)(a)(ii) by entering into the extension arrangements until 30 June 2005 in relation to the Swanbank Contract. 14.The contentions that Mr Leon was knowingly concerned in particular contraventions of the Act are not made out. 15.The contention that Mr White was knowingly concerned in a contravention of s 45(2)(a)(ii) and s 45(2)(b)(ii) of the Act in relation to aspects of the Swanbank contractual arrangements is made out. 16.The contention that Mr White was otherwise knowingly concerned in contraventions of the Act is not made out. THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1.The parties are directed to prepare and submit formal orders for the consideration of the Court. 2.The costs of the proceeding are reserved.3.The parties consider the extent to which any information contained in the reasons for judgment is confidential to a party or otherwise falls within orders for the preservation of confidentiality. 4.The parties are directed to confer concerning the matters at Order 3 with a view to enabling the matter to be re‑listed to hear submissions concerning the question of the extent to which the reasons for judgment ought to be redacted or orders for confidentiality otherwise be addressed.