Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O'Halloran

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O’Halloran [2020] FCA 1291  

File number(s): QUD 222 of 2019
Judgment of: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 7 September 2020
Catchwords:  PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – civil penalty proceedings – claim of privilege against self-exposure to penalty – whether at conclusion of applicant’s case individual respondents entitled to waive privilege and advance positive defence – whether principles articulated in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Mining Projects Group Ltd (2007) 164 FCR 32 good law – whether Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) or Part VB of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) abrogated privilege against self-exposure to penalty.
Legislation:

Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth) ss 46, 52, 86

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 348, 355, 417, 500, 551

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) Pt 16

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt VB

Explanatory Memorandum, Access to Justice (Civil Litigation Reforms) Amendment Bill 2009

Explanatory Statement, Federal Court Rules 2011

Cases cited:

A & L Silvestri Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2005] FCA 1658; (2005) ALR 247

Adams v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2017] FCAFC 228; (2017) 258 FCR 257

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v FFE Building Services Ltd [2003] FCAFC 132, (2003) 130 FCR 37

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v J McPhee & Son (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2) [1997] FCA 1013, (1997) 77 FCR 217

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Mining Projects Group Ltd [2007] FCA 1620; (2007) 164 FCR 32

Banque Commerciale SA v Akhil Holdings Ltd [1990] HCA 11; (1990) 169 CLR 279

Bridal Fashions Pty Ltd v Comptroller-General of Customs (1996) 17 WAR 499

Chief Executive Officer of Customs v Camile Trading Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1256

Commonwealth v Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482

Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing & Allied Services Union of Australia v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2007] FCAFC 132; (2007) 162 FCR 466

Dare v Pulham [1982] HCA 70; (1982) 148 CLR 658

Environment Protection Authority v Caltex Refining Co Pty Ltd [1993] HCA 74; (1993) 178 CLR 477

Fair Work Ombudsman v Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (No 2) [2020] FCA 348

Fair Work Ombudsman v Hu [2017] FCA 1081

Frugtniet v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2017] FCA 537

MacDonald v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2007] NSWCA 304; (2007) 73 NSWLR 612

Police Service Board v Morris [1985] HCA 9; (1985) 156 CLR 397,

Pyneboard Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission [1983] HCA 9; (1983) 152 CLR 328

R v Associated Northern Collieries [1910] HCA 61; (1910) 11 CLR 738 at 742

Refrigerated Express Lines (Australasia) Pty Ltd v Australian Meat and Livestock Corporation (1979) 42 FLR 204

Rich v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2004] HCA 42; 220 CLR 129

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v O'Hallor... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1291
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (ABCC) brought civil penalty proceedings against various respondents, including natural persons (Individual Respondents) and a Union, for alleged unlawful industrial action. The Individual Respondents claimed the privilege against self-exposure to civil penalties and denied each allegation. The primary legal issue was whether the Individual Respondents were entitled to waive their privilege and advance a positive defence at the conclusion of the ABCC's case, without having to plead such a defence beforehand. The court had to determine if the principles in ASIC v Mining Projects Group Ltd were still valid and whether the Federal Court Rules or Part VB of the Federal Court of Australia Act had abrogated the privilege against self-exposure to penalty.

The court found that the privilege against self-exposure to penalty did not require a blanket exemption from the rules of pleading. Instead, the dispensation should only go as far as necessary to serve the privilege and the interests it protected. The court followed the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia in Bridal Fashions and the observation of Mason P in MacDonald, which held that the privilege was available to natural defendants in civil penalty proceedings but had no practical application in pleading a defence to a statement of claim in such a prosecution. The court also referred to the decision of Gyles J in Silvestri, which stated that a personal respondent to a penalty proceeding is entitled to put the applicant to proof of its case and cannot be forced to make an admission.

The court concluded that the law as presented by the Individual Respondents was correct. The court held that if, at the conclusion of the applicant’s case, the Individual Respondents elected to waive the privilege against self-exposure to a penalty and advance a positive defence, those respondents were at liberty to file and serve any amended defences, affidavits, and any outline of submissions immediately following the close of the applicant’s case or otherwise in accordance with orders of the Court.

The orders of the court allowed the Individual Respondents to waive their privilege and advance a positive defence at the conclusion of the ABCC's case, without having to plead such a defence beforehand. This decision provided flexibility in civil penalty proceedings while maintaining the privilege against self-exposure to penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. If at the conclusion of the applicant’s case the individual respondents (or any of them) elect to waive the privilege against self-exposure to a penalty and advance a positive defence, those respondents are at liberty to file and serve any amended defences, affidavits and any outline of submissions immediately following the close of the applicant’s case or otherwise in accordance with orders of the Court.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I informed the parties that I would publish reasons for this order. These are those reasons.BACKGROUND In his originating application filed on 28 March 2019 the applicant Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (ABCC) sought declarations and penalties against the respondents referable to alleged unlawful industrial action, contravening (inter alia) ss 46 and 52 of the Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth) (BCIIP Act) and ss 417, 355, 348 and 500 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act). In their defence filed on 29 May 2019 to these proceedings, the 1st, 2nd, and 4th to 28th respondents, who are natural persons (Individual Respondents), claimed and reserved their right to claim the privilege against self-exposure to civil penalties, and deny each allegation of the ABCC. I note in passing that the third respondent (the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia) has made various admissions in that defence. The Union filed an outline of submissions dated 28 February 2020. However in his outline of submissions filed on 28 February 2020 the second respondent, Mr Andrew Blakeley, stated that he claimed the privilege against self-exposure to penalty and therefore did not propose to file any submissions prior to the applicant closing his case. For the same reason, no form of submissions have been filed by the other Individual Respondents. All parties were represented at the first day of the trial. Mr Murdoch QC and Mr Smith represented the ABCC. Mr Massy acted for the Union and all Individual Respondents except Mr Blakeley. Mr Reitano acted for Mr Blakeley. At the commencement of the hearing it became apparent that the ABCC anticipated objecting to any questions in cross-examination posed by either Counsel for the Individual Respondents which introduced material going beyond a response to the case pleaded by the ABCC. Mr Murdoch QC and Mr Smith for the ABCC submitted that any such questions were irrelevant to matters currently in issue in the proceeding, and should not be permitted by the Court. Further, it was clear that the ABCC anticipated opposing the raising of any positive defence which, in his submission, ought to have been pleaded by the Individual Respondents prior to the ABCC opening his case. No interlocutory application came before the Court. Rather, after questions of Counsel it became clear that the parties sought competing case management orders referable to the filing by the Individual Respondents of an amended defence following the close of the ABCC’s case. Written submissions in support of the position adopted by the ABCC were then emailed to the Court and the respondents. Mr Smith for the ABCC addressed the Court in relation to this issue, relying on these written submissions, and made oral submissions. Mr Massy and Mr Reitano made oral submissions. During his oral submissions Mr Smith also referred to an affidavit of Patrick Turner dated 1 September 2020, filed shortly before the commencement of the hearing, which described and annexed correspondence between the parties concerning the conduct of the matter. Mr Turner is employed by Maurice Blackburn lawyers, the legal representatives of the 1st and 4th-28th respondents and the Union. Annexed to that affidavit was a letter dated 27 August 2020 from Maurice Blackburn to the lawyers for the ABCC. Paragraph 14 of the letter stated:14.To avoid an arid dispute about whether the views of Mason P in MacDonald are apposite to matters of this kind, the first and fourth to twenty-eight to [sic] respondents place the applicant on notice that if they waive the privilege against self-exposure to a penalty, they intend to rely on the facts alleged in [2], [3], [4], [11], [22] and [31] of the statement of claim, s 19 (2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and s 7 (2)(a) of the Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2016 (Cth). The first and fourth to twenty-eighth respondents reserve the right to advance in their case additional material in support of their defence, the details whereof will be disclosed by amending the defence after the close of the applicant’s case.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

His Honour did not accept that the claimant’s privilege went so far as to require such a blanket dispensation from the rules of pleading. Given the terms of s1317L of the Corporations Act, his Honour considered (at [54]) that dispensation should only go so far as is necessary to serve the privilege and the interests it protected. Section 1317L provides:Civil evidence and procedure rules for declarations of contravention and civil penalty ordersThe Court must apply the rules of evidence and procedure for civil matters when hearing proceedings for:(a) a declaration of contravention; or(b) a pecuniary penalty order. Mason P observed that the primary Judge had followed the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia in Bridal Fashions, where the Full Court found that in the context of civil penalty proceedings under the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) that the privilege against self-exposure to a penalty was available to natural defendants, it had not been abrogated by the Customs Act, but nonetheless the privilege had no practical application in the pleading of a defence to a statement of claim in a Customs prosecution. Mason P referred to Silvestri at 251 [17] where Gyles J had said:A personal respondent to a penalty proceeding is entitled to put the applicant to proof of its case. Such a respondent cannot be forced to make an admission and no solicitor acting for that person can be held responsible for not ensuring that a party plead in a way which goes further than this. In other words, such a respondent can decline to admit matters alleged against it. To the extent that the rules of pleading require to be modified to enable this to take place, that will be done. There is no occasion, however, for relieving respondents of a duty to plead. Even in a criminal trial, a defendant pleads guilty or not guilty. The issue would arise in a case where a personal respondent proposes to rely upon a positive defence. Penalty proceeding or not, means must be found to advise the applicant and the court of any positive defence so that the trial can be properly prepared and conducted. It is at that point that there may be a debate as to the appropriate course, which may involve a closer examination of the decisions in Bridal Fashions and Hadgkiss. That has not yet arisen here. Directions can be sought if and when it does. At [59] Mason P noted that ASIC had submitted there should be no relaxation of the pleading rules. Further:59…To require a full pleading does not require the defendant to assist ASIC in its claim for penalties, it merely ensures that the defendant gives timely notice of any positive case he proposes to advance whether by reliance upon evidence tendered by the plaintiff, cross-examination of the plaintiff’s witnesses, or (in due course) tendering evidence of his own. Without full pleadings the trial may be prolonged because the defendant could scarcely complain that ASIC was splitting its case if it tendered in reply evidence responsive to material first foreshadowed and revealed in the defence case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Massy and Mr Reitano made separate submissions on behalf of the Individual Respondents. However in summary they submitted as follows:·The position advanced by the ABCC involved a fundamental misapprehension of what the Full Court was dealing with in Adams, and what the Court of Appeal of New South Wales said in MacDonald.·No distinction has historically been drawn between the notions of exculpatory or inculpatory information in such cases.·Provisions in the Federal Court Rules and the Federal Court Act are not inconsistent with claims of privilege against self-exposure to penalties. ·The dichotomy drawn by the ABCC between inculpatory pleas and exculpatory pleas is a false frame of reference.·The leading Federal Court authority on point is the decision of Finkelstein J in ASIC v Mining Projects, in particular at [13] of the decision.·Nothing said by the High Court in the Agreed Penalties case bears on the question of privilege which can be asserted by the Individual Respondents and what flows from the exercise of the privilege.·The issue decided by the Full Court in Adams was not the same as that decided by Finkelstein J in ASIC v Mining Projects. In particular at the conclusion of the case in Adams the then-respondent ran a positive case without delivery of an amended defence setting out that positive case.·When evidence is given by the witnesses for the ABCC, the respondents are entitled to ask questions which are relevant to the case even though an amended defence has not yet been pleaded. There cannot be a legitimate objection to questions on the basis that an amended defence is not yet pleaded.·The Full Court in Adams expressly embraced the notion that the respondent there would be entitled to amend its defence after closure of the applicant’s case.·The decision of Finkelstein J in ASIC v Mining Projects has been followed in numerous Federal Court decisions, none of which have qualified the right of a respondent to subsequently plead an amended defence in terms claimed by the ABCC.·If a respondent who wishes to run a positive case is required to plead its case, that can be accommodated whilst maintaining the privilege. What should occur is that the respondent should be entitled to rely on the privilege until the applicant’s case is concluded. If, at that point, the respondent decides to run a positive case, it can deliver an amended defence ·To the extent that there is any conflict between MacDonald and ASIC v Mining Projects, the Court should prefer the reasoning in ASIC v Mining Projects.CONSIDERATION Notwithstanding the persuasive submissions of Mr Smith for the ABCC, in my view the law as presented by Mr Massy and Mr Reitano for the Individual Respondents is correct. I have formed this view for the following reasons. It is uncontroversial that civil penalty proceedings brought in respect of contraventions of provisions of such statutes as the FW Act and the BCIIP Act are civil proceedings, notwithstanding that the proceedings have a quasi-criminal quality: see comments of Isaacs J in R v Associated Northern Collieries [1910] HCA 61; (1910) 11 CLR 738 at 742, Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing & Allied Services Union of Australia v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2007] FCAFC 132; (2007) 162 FCR 466 at 477-479 [19]-[29], the Agreed Penalties Case at [53]. This is reinforced in respect of these Acts by s 551 of the FW Act and s 86 of the BCCIP Act, which require the court to apply the rules of evidence and procedure for civil matters when hearing proceedings relating to a contravention, or proposed contravention, of a civil remedy provision.