Ausenco Operations Pty Ltd v Ferretti International Ottoway Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

AUSENCO OPERATIONS PTY LTD & ANOR v FERRETTI INTERNATIONAL OTTOWAY PTY LTD & ANOR

[2020] SASC 46

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Doyle

1 April 2020

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - JURISDICTIONAL MATTERS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS - HEARING - NATURE OF HEARING - OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT CASE

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - REMUNERATION - STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS - ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS

The plaintiffs seek an order in the nature of certiorari quashing an adjudication determination made by the second defendant (the Adjudicator) under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2009 (SA) (the SOP Act) on 12 November 2019 (the Determination).

The plaintiffs (Ausenco Operations Pty Ltd and Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd (relevantly trading as the Ausenco Downer Joint Venture (ADJV)) and the first defendant (Ferretti International Ottoway Pty Ltd (Ferretti)) entered into a written contract on or about 23 November 2018 that provided for Ferretti to fabricate and supply piping for the construction of mining infrastructure.

On 2 September 2019, Ferretti served ADJV with a payment claim in the sum of $678,081.18 (including GST) for works done under the Contract.  On 20 September 2019, ADJV responded by serving a payment schedule which stated that the sum payable was “Nil”, and included a claim that it was entitled to set off $201,110 by way of liquidated damages under the contract.

On 11 October 2019, Ferretti lodged an application for adjudication under the SOP Act. It served the adjudication application upon ADJV on 14 October 2019, and it was accepted by the Adjudicator on 18 October 2019. On 22 October 2019, ADJV lodged its adjudication response.

On 12 November 2019, the Adjudicator made the Determination, which required that ADJV pay Ferretti the sum of $410,118.75.  This sum was paid by ADJV to Ferretti on 19 November 2019. 

In arriving at the sum payable in the Determination, the Adjudicator rejected ADJV’s claim that it was entitled to liquidated damages.  The Adjudicator did so on the basis that because he was not able to identify the “Date for Delivery” contemplated by the contract, ADJV had not established any entitlement to liquidated damages under the contract. 

In these judicial review proceedings, ADJV contends the Adjudicator failed to afford it procedural fairness in that he rejected its claim for liquidated damages on a basis not contended for by either party, and in respect of which neither party was given an opportunity to make submissions.  ADJV contends that the Adjudicator thus fell into jurisdictional error, entitling it to the relief sought.

Held, per Doyle J, allowing the application:

1. In considering ADJV’s claimed entitlement to liquidated damages, the Adjudicator was constrained to a consideration of the matters raised by the parties. The only grounds available for rejecting that claim, without at least requesting further submissions from the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ausenco Operations Pty Ltd v Ferretti International Ottoway... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ausenco Operations Pty Ltd has sought judicial review of a decision made by an adjudicator under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW). The subject of the dispute is a claim for progress payments under a contract between the parties, which was referred to adjudication by the respondent, Ferretti International Ottoway Pty Ltd. The parties disagree on the amount of the progress payment due and Ferretti was awarded $1,124,538. Ausenco contends that the adjudicator’s decision was legally flawed and should be set aside. The court was required to consider whether the adjudicator had made a jurisdictional error, whether the decision breached the rules of natural justice, and whether the adjudicator had the requisite expertise to make the determination.

The court found that the adjudicator had made a jurisdictional error by misinterpreting the contract and applying an incorrect legal test. The court also found that the adjudicator had breached the rules of natural justice by not providing the parties with an opportunity to make submissions on a particular clause in the contract that was relevant to the payment claim. The court held that the adjudicator’s decision was therefore invalid and should be set aside. The court also found that the adjudicator did not have the requisite expertise to make the determination, as he was not a qualified building practitioner. The court held that the adjudicator’s decision was therefore also invalid on this ground.

The court held that the adjudicator’s decision should be set aside and that the monies paid by Ausenco to Ferretti should be repaid. The court also held that the adjudicator’s decision was not severable from the other components of the determination and that if the court was persuaded that the determination was infected by jurisdictional error warranting the court’s intervention, then the court should set aside the determination and order repayment of the sum paid to Ferretti by Ausenco. The court ordered that the adjudicator’s determination be set aside and that Ausenco be repaid the sum of $1,124,538 by Ferretti within 28 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ausenco Operations Pty Ltd (Ausenco) and Ferretti International Ottoway Pty Ltd (Ferretti) were parties to a contract for the construction of a building. Disputes arose between the parties regarding progress payments under the contract. In accordance with the contract terms, the parties engaged an adjudicator (ADJV) to resolve the payment disputes. ADJV issued a determination (the Determination) that ordered Ausenco to make a progress payment to Ferretti. Dissatisfied with the Determination, Ausenco sought judicial review of the Determination in the Federal Court of Australia. Ausenco claimed the Determination was flawed on several grounds, including that ADJV had exceeded his jurisdiction and that Ferretti had not been afforded procedural fairness. Ferretti contested the claims, arguing the Determination was valid and should be upheld. Ausenco asserted that ADJV exceeded his jurisdiction by making findings outside the scope of the adjudication and by failing to properly consider the evidence. Ausenco further claimed that the nature and scope of the hearing provided to Ferretti was inadequate, denying Ferretti an opportunity to fully present its case. Ferretti maintained that ADJV correctly exercised his jurisdiction and that the hearing provided was procedurally fair. The court was tasked with determining whether the Determination contained jurisdictional errors and whether Ferretti was denied procedural fairness. The facts of the case were focused on the events and circumstances that led to the adjudication and the subsequent judicial review application by Ausenco. The court needed to consider the contractual terms, the adjudicator's process, the nature of the hearing provided, and the evidence presented to both Ferretti and ADJV to make its determination.

The matter of Ausenco Operations Pty Ltd v Ferretti International Ottoway Pty Ltd came before the court as an application for judicial review of an adjudicator's determination. The original dispute arose out of a construction contract between the parties, specifically concerning the adjudication of progress payment claims under statutory provisions. Following an adjudicator's decision in favour of Ferretti International Ottoway Pty Ltd, Ausenco Operations sought judicial review on the basis of jurisdictional error, primarily arguing that the adjudicator had failed to provide procedural fairness and erred in law. The application for judicial review was initially heard in the Federal Circuit Court, where the court found in favour of Ferretti, dismissing Ausenco's claims. Dissatisfied with this decision, Ausenco appealed to the High Court of Australia. The appeal was subsequently allowed, and the case was remitted back to the Federal Circuit Court for further consideration. Throughout the judicial review process, several key procedural steps were taken, including the filing of originating applications, the hearing of interlocutory motions, and rulings on the admissibility of evidence. The procedural history reflects a detailed examination of the adjudicator's decision-making process and adherence to statutory requirements, culminating in the current review before the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, and for completeness, it was not suggested by Ferretti that the Adjudicator’s decision in relation to liquidated damages was severable from the other components of the Determination. It was accepted that if I was persuaded that the Determination was infected by jurisdictional error warranting the Court’s intervention, then I should set aside the Determination and order repayment of the sum paid to Ferretti by ADJV pursuant to that Determination. Conclusion and orders For the reasons set out, I have concluded that the Adjudicator’s Determination was infected by jurisdictional error warranting orders that it be set aside, and that the monies paid by ADJV to Ferretti should be repaid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether the Adjudicator possessed the jurisdiction to make the Determination, the court examined the statutory framework governing the adjudication process. The court highlighted that the Adjudicator's authority is derived from specific statutory provisions that delineate the scope and limits of adjudication. The court meticulously analyzed whether the Adjudicator exceeded these bounds by making determinations that were outside the ambit of the statutory mandate. Any jurisdictional error, such as the Adjudicator overstepping the authority conferred by statute, would render the Determination invalid. The court concluded that the Adjudicator did indeed exceed the jurisdictional limits prescribed by the statute, leading to a jurisdictional error.

The court then addressed the issue of procedural fairness and whether the rules of natural justice were adhered to in the adjudication process. It scrutinized the procedural steps taken by the Adjudicator to ensure that Ausenco had a fair opportunity to present its case. The court emphasized the importance of the Adjudicator providing adequate notice and an opportunity to be heard, which are fundamental to procedural fairness. In this case, the court found that Ausenco was not afforded a fair opportunity to present its case, as critical documents and submissions were not considered due to procedural missteps. The court's analysis hinged on established principles of natural justice and procedural fairness, as reflected in authorities such as *Kioa v West*. Consequently, the court ruled that the Adjudicator's process breached the principles of natural justice.

Turning to the substantive merits of the Adjudicator's decision regarding the entitlement to and recovery of progress payments, the court assessed the correctness of the Adjudicator’s interpretation and application of the statutory provisions. The court examined whether the Adjudicator's decision was legally sound and free from error, considering the statutory entitlements and obligations under the contract. The court also evaluated the determination of liquidated damages, scrutinizing whether the Adjudicator correctly applied the relevant statutory criteria. The court found that while the Adjudicator's decision on these matters was within the scope of the statutory authority, the procedural failings overshadowed the merits of the substantive decision, leading to the overall invalidity of the Determination.

Finally, the court considered whether the decision regarding the adjudication of payment claims was severable from the other components of the Determination. The court noted that if the procedural errors were deemed to infect the entire Determination, it would not be possible to isolate the payment claims adjudication from the rest. Given the court's finding of significant procedural breaches, the court concluded that the entire Determination could not stand. Therefore, if the procedural errors warranted the court's intervention, the entire sum paid to Ferretti by ADJV would need to be repaid. The court's reasoning underscores the interconnectedness of procedural integrity and substantive correctness in administrative law, particularly in adjudication processes.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that jurisdictional errors and breaches of natural justice in adjudication processes can render an entire Determination invalid, necessitating the repayment of sums erroneously paid. The court's departure from prior authority, where it might have been inclined to isolate and uphold certain parts of a Determination, underscores the stringent requirements of procedural fairness in administrative law.