Auburn Municipal Council v Szabo

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      ALCOA AUSTRALIA ROLLED PRODUCTS PTY LTD v WESTON ALUMINIUM PTY LTD [2006]  NSWCA 273

FILE NUMBER(S):
40293/06
41009/05

HEARING DATE(S):               6 September 2006

DECISION DATE:     04/10/2006

PARTIES:
Matter No. 40293/06:  Alcoa Australia Rolled Products Pty Ltd - Appellant
Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd - Respondent
Matter No. 41009/05:  Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd - Appellant
Environment Protection Authority - First Respondent
Alcoa Australia Rolled Products Pty Ltd - Second Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Spigelman CJ McColl JA Basten JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          LEC 41622/03 LEC 40149/05

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Lloyd J - CA 40293/06, Pain J - CA 41009/05, 

COUNSEL:
Mr R. Ellicott QC/Ms S. Duggan - Aloca Australia Rolled Products
Mr P. Tomasetti/Mr J. Johnson - Weston Aluminium
N/A - Environment Protection Authority

SOLICITORS:
Holding Redlich - Alcoa Australia Rolled Products
Kanjian & Company - Weston Aluminium
Environment Protection Authority, Legal Services Branch

CATCHWORDS:
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW – Building and town planning – scope of development consent – construction by reference to existing activities – incorporation by reference of material extrinsic – when reference to extrinsic material permissible.
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW – Noxious and offensive trades and premises – licensing under environmental protection legislation – aluminium processing plant – licence permitting reprocessing of by-product conditional upon development consent – variation of licence – whether power to vary subject to s 50(2) - Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997 (NSW), ss 50(2), 58, Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), s 91

LEGISLATION CITED:
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), ss 91, 91A, 93
Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), s58
Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997 (NSW), ss 48, 50, 51, 55, 58

DECISION:
(1)  In matter no. 40293 of 2006
(a)  grant the Applicant an extension of time within which to seek leave to appeal up to and including the day on which the summons for leave to appeal was filed in this Court
(b)  grant the Applicant leave to appeal
(c)  allow the appeal and order that the application by Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd filed in matter no. 41622 of 2003 in the Land and Environment Court be dismissed with costs
(d)  order the Respondent, Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd to pay the costs of the Appellant of the appeal
(2)  In matter no. 41009 of 2005
(a)  allow the appeal and set aside order 2 made in the Land and Environment Court on 9 December 2005
(b)  in lieu thereof, order that the applicant in that Court, Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd, pay the costs of the Second Respondent of the application before Pain J
(c)  order the Appellant to pay the Second Respondent’s costs of the appeal.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40293/06
LEC 40149/06
CA 41009/05
LEC 41622/04

SPIGELMAN CJ
McCOLL JA
BASTEN JA

4 October 2006

ALCOA AUSTRALIA ROLLED PRODUCTS PTY LIMITED v WESTON ALUMINIUM PTY LIMITED
WESTON ALUMINIUM PTY LIMITED v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Auburn Municipal Council v Szabo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 273
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the scope of development consent and the variation of an environmental protection licence. The parties were Auburn Municipal Council (the Appellant) and Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd (the Respondent), with the Environment Protection Authority also involved. The dispute arose from a variation to Weston Aluminium's licence to process by-products, which the Council argued constituted development requiring separate development consent under the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW). The matter was heard in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were: (a) the precise scope of the variation made to licence no. 642 on 29 November 2001; and (b) whether the change in use requiring the licence variation constituted development requiring development consent under the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW). The Court also considered whether a variation to an environmental protection licence under section 58 of the *Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997* (NSW) was permissible if it involved development requiring consent under the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW).

The Court of Appeal found that the approach adopted by the court below had miscarried, leading to the identification of false issues based on unexpressed assumptions. The Court reasoned that if the licence variation, properly understood, involved "development" requiring consent under the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW), then it could not be lawfully made under section 58 of the *Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997* (NSW), and any such variation would be invalid. The Court noted that the questions of the precise scope of the variation and whether it constituted development requiring consent were not adequately addressed.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the orders made by the Land and Environment Court, and ordered that Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd pay the costs of the Appellant and the Second Respondent in the proceedings. The Court also granted an extension of time for the Appellant to seek leave to appeal and granted leave to appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) In matter no. 40293 of 2006; (a) grant the Applicant an extension of time within which to seek leave to appeal up to and including the day on which the summons for leave to appeal was filed in this Court; (b) grant the Applicant leave to appeal; (c) allow the appeal and order that the application by Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd filed in matter no. 41622 of 2003 in the Land and Environment Court be dismissed with costs; (d) order the Respondent, Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd to pay the costs of the Appellant of the appeal; (2) In matter no. 41009 of 2005; (a) allow the appeal and set aside order 2 made in the Land and Environment Court on 9 December 2005; (b) in lieu thereof, order that the applicant in that Court, Weston Aluminium Pty Ltd, pay the costs of the Second Respondent of the application before Pain J; (c) order the Appellant to pay the Second Respondent's costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SPIGELMAN CJ
On the analysis set out above, the formulation of the question is inapt. If the variation, properly understood, involved “development” requiring consent under the EPA Act, it could not be made under s 58. An absence of power must spell invalidity.Licence variation: conclusions Because of the approach adopted below, two questions were not adequately addressed, namely:(a)what was the precise scope of the variation made to licence no. 642 on 29 November 2001?(b)did the change in use which required variation of the licence constitute a development requiring development consent under the EPA Act? There remains a possible outstanding issue as to the scope of the existing development consents in relation to the acceptance and storage of dross from Point Henry. However, these questions were not addressed on appeal, nor were they raised in the Court below. The procedure before Pain J appears to have involved something analogous to the formulation of separate questions for the determination of the Court. That process, especially when carried out informally, can readily give rise to the identification of false issues, based on unexpressed assumptions. That may have happened in the present case. The uncertainty so identified may be found in the relief sought in the application. The declaration referred to “any licence or notice of variation of licence”, and thus did not limit itself to the variation which took place in November 2001. Similarly, the second order sought was a mandatory order requiring the Environment Protection Authority to remove from the licence “those conditions inserted which in any way relate to or concern” the storage or processing of dross from Point Henry. The vagueness of the order sought might have alerted the applicant to matters which needed to be addressed. The exercise undertaken in the Court below having miscarried, there is a question as to whether order 1 made by the primary judge, dismissing the application before her, should be overturned and the matter remitted for further consideration according to law. Such an order would be an invitation to the applicant to present its case on a different basis. That should not be permitted. Accordingly the order dismissing the proceedings should stand, but for the reasons set out above.Costs Pain J ordered that “costs be reserved” in the proceedings before her. As the application was dismissed, that was not an appropriate order. The erroneous approach adopted below appears to have been the direct result of the manner in which counsel for the applicant formulated the issues which arose for determination. In its notice of appeal, Weston Aluminium sought “costs”, which was presumably intended to be a request for an order for costs in this Court and in the Court below. By its written submissions, Alcoa claimed that the appropriate order in relation to the appeal was that it should be “dismissed with costs of the appeal and Court below”. It would therefore seem appropriate to set aside order 2 made by her Honour, that costs be reserved and in lieu thereof order that Weston Aluminium pay the costs of the proceedings before Pain J in the Land and Environment Court. The appeal should otherwise be dismissed and Weston Aluminium should pay Alcoa’s costs of the appeal. The costs of the application for leave to appeal and the appeal from Lloyd J, should also be paid by Weston Aluminium.Orders

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SPIGELMAN CJ

Full text does not contain this section.