Decision
Reasons for decision
Relevantly, para 8.4 of Direction 99 was in the following terms.8.4 Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision (1)Decision-makers must make a determination about whether cancellation or refusal under section 501, or non-revocation under section 501CA is, or is not, in the best interests of a child affected by the decision.(2)This consideration applies only if the child is, or would be, under 18 years old at the time when the decision to refuse or cancel the visa, or to not revoke the mandatory cancellation of the visa, is expected to be made. (3)If there are two or more relevant children, the best interests of each child should be given individual consideration to the extent that their interests may differ.(4)In considering the best interests of the child, the following factors must be considered where relevant: a)the nature and duration of the relationship between the child and the non-citizen. Less weight should generally be given where the relationship is non-parental, and/or there is no existing relationship and/or there have been long periods of absence, or limited meaningful contact (including whether an existing Court order restricts contact);b)the extent to which the non-citizen is likely to play a positive parental role in the future, taking into account the length of time until the child turns 18, and including any Court orders relating to parental access and care arrangements;c)the impact of the non-citizen’s prior conduct, and any likely future conduct, and whether that conduct has, or will have a negative impact on the child;d)the likely effect that any separation from the non-citizen would have on the child, taking into account the child’s or non-citizen’s ability to maintain contact in other ways;e)whether there are other persons who already fulfil a parental role in relation to the child;f)any known views of the child (with those views being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child);g)evidence that the child has been, or is at risk of being, subject to, or exposed to, family violence perpetrated by the non-citizen, or has otherwise been abused or neglected by the non-citizen in any way, whether physically, sexually or mentally;h)evidence that the child has suffered or experienced any physical or emotional trauma arising from the non-citizen’s conduct. The applicant’s case in the Tribunal concerning the best interests of his eldest sonApplicant’s statement of facts, issues and contentions The applicant’s statement of facts, issues and contentions provided to the Tribunal included the following submission (footnotes omitted):BEST INTERESTS OF MINOR CHILDREN IN AUSTRALIA AFFECTED BY THE DECISION114.The Direction instructs decision-makers to make a determination about whether visa cancellation is in the best interests of any minor children in Australia who will be affected by the decision. Each child's interests must be considered individually. 115.The Applicant has two sons in Australia under the age of 18 who will be affected by the Tribunal's decision. [Applicant’s eldest son]116.The Applicant states:I've always been a major part in [his] life. Me and … his mother have a private custody agreement in place which works as follows; as it is with [my youngest son], [he] is dropped off at my mum and dad's at the end of my swing where he stays until I arrive back in Busselton after my flight home from site. I then have full custody of the boys until the end of my week off to which I drop them to their mothers house the day before I fly out.[My eldest son] is an extremely sensitive young boy and he suffers from ADHD and is medicated for it. I am also diagnosed with ADHD so [he] has been able to relate to me and I have been a pillar of strength for him. Throughout my incarceration I have had constant contact with him through phone calls, multiple letters and cards. …The impact from my incarceration alone has affected [him] immensely ... He is emotionally distraught knowing there is a chance I could be sent back to the UK and that he may lose his dad forever. Since my incarceration he has been misbehaving and playing [up] in school and I strongly believe it is from the emotional strain caused by me being in prison. [My eldest son] will not only lose me if my visa is cancelled but his relationship with his little brother … will be greatly affected as he only gets to see him when I have him and I have them both in my care.117.[The applicant’s eldest son] is an 11-year-old child currently living with his mother and on occasion with his paternal grandparents. Before the Applicant was imprisoned and detained, [he] would live with his father and [younger] brother during "off swings". This was as per a verbal agreement the Applicant had with [his mother]. 118.Apart from resulting in an ongoing separation from their father, the Applicant's behaviour has not had a negative impact on his sons or any physical or emotional trauma. He has played a positive role in his sons' lives and will continue to do so until the boys turn 18 (for [the applicant’s eldest son] this is seven years away). Given the Applicant's low risk of reoffending and commitment to sobriety, as well as his increased family support and ongoing rehabilitation, there is no evidence that his sons will be negatively impacted by his presence in Australia. 119.The impact of a decision to not revoke the Original Decision however will have devastating consequences for [the applicant’s eldest son]. There is no possibility that [he] will accompany his father to the United Kingdom and it is very unlikely he will be able to travel to visit him while a minor. In an undated statement received by the Applicant in March 2024, [the applicant’s eldest son] states: Please let my dad home, even though he has done silly things ... It will make me very very sad if he can't come home we want to do lots of things together and me and my brother will miss him so much. 120.[The applicant’s eldest son] has been diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), for which he is medicated. The Applicant is awaiting receipt of documents relating to his son's medication and will provide these to the Tribunal once they are available. 121.The Applicant's mother and father have both expressed their concerns about the impact that a non-revocation decision would have on [the applicant’s eldest son]. [The applicant’s mother] states:[The applicant's eldest] son is at that turning point in his age, not a little boy but still not quite a teenager. His emotions and [behaviour] can at times be all over the place. I am very close with [the applicant’s eldest son], and he confides to me of his worries that he can't see his dad and how much he misses him. [The applicant] needs to be part of his life, be there for him through [his] struggles and his problems, to help guide him and teach him not to make bad choices and what consequences mean in life. I truly believe [the applicant’s eldest son] will suffer immensely if his dad is deported, no child should suffer his parents' bad choices, especially if there is a chance of redemption. If [the applicant] goes back to the UK there is a high possibility they will not see each other physically for many years and this is devastating.122.If the Original Decision is not revoked, then [the applicant’s eldest son] will not only lose the opportunity to have a meaningful relationship with his father, but his ability to maintain a meaningful relationship with his [younger] brother … will also be drastically affected. Prior to their father's incarceration the boys would spend the same week with them so they could foster their sibling relationship at the same time as their paternal one. If the Applicant were unable to return to Australia then [his sons] would not spend as much time together and this would exacerbate the emotional impact of the decision on them both. [The applicant’s youngest son] 123.Many of the submissions made in relation to [the applicant’s eldest son] apply equally to his five-year-old brother .... There is no indication that [the applicant’s youngest son] has suffered physical or emotional trauma from the Applicant's offending behaviour or drug use, however he stands to be detrimentally affected if his father is unable to remain in Australia. 13 years have yet to pass before [the applicant’s youngest son] turns 18, and the Applicant hopes to continue to be a positive influence and role model in his son's life during that time. [The applicant’s mother] states:[My youngest son] is a beautiful little soul, he is so loving, kind and funny. [The applicant] calls him daily and they have a wonderful relationship. [He] is now five and constantly asking his daddy "When are you coming home, you have been at work for too long now?" He asks this as we tell him daddy is working away, as it is too hard on such a little boy to understand the reality of where his dad is. [He] has just started school and is so desperate to have his dad come to see his school and teacher, to pick him up and give him cuddles 124.The Applicant's friend … has also witnessed the relationship between the Applicant and his sons and believes - as do his parents and other family members - that the Applicant would not risk the opportunity to maintain a meaningful relationship with his sons again by relapsing into drug use or reoffending Best interests of minor children 125.The potential long-term impact of these types of decisions on young children in Australia was discussed in Bettencourt v Minister for Immigration. Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 172. In that case, the court held that the Minister's decision "failed to form the required state of satisfaction" in relation to the impact on the applicant's Australian citizen children if separated from their father. It noted at [44] that the assessment by the Minister is required to include the "nature, extent or duration" of the harm caused to the children by being permanently separated from their father. 126.There is a plethora of research that demonstrates the detrimental physical, emotional and psychological impact that ongoing separation from one or both parents has on a young child.127.In the Tribunal decision Snowden and Minister for Immigration. Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] AATA 4504 (2 December 2021) (Snowden) the best interests of the applicant's four children weighed strongly in the applicant's favour. In determining that there was another reason why the visa cancellation should be revoked, Senior Member Puplick AM stated at [98] and [99] (emphasis added): The Respondent sought to establish that the Applicant would be able to maintain some sort of relationship with his children from New Zealand were he returned there. This is undoubtedly true in a technological sense and to some degree it would be no better or worse that his current method of daily communication from immigration detention. It is fanciful however to believe that a meaningful parental relationship can be established, matured and maintained via some sort of electronic or social media platform - even when the technology works. The evidence of Mr Snowden (Jeffrey) to the effect that the family would not relocate to New Zealand until the last of the boys reached the age of 18 rules out any suggestion that this is a viable option to keep the family together. 128.While technology would allow the Applicant to communicate with his sons if they are living in separate countries, it would be no substitution for [the applicant’s sons] having no father physically present in their lives. Technology therefore is by no means an adequate substitute for the meaningful physical presence the Applicant has stated he wishes to have in his sons' lives in Australia (see paragraph 8.4(4)(d) of the Direction). 129.The Australian community would expect that the principles of the CRC are upheld, and that the Applicant's sons continue to be provided with a safe and loving environment which will enable [them] to grow and develop throughout their childhood and into adulthood. A permanent separation from their father would see Australia acting contrary to its obligations under the CRC and in direct opposition to what is in the children's best interests. 130.Therefore, the best interests of the Applicant's sons can only be served by a decision to revoke the Original Decision. A decision to the contrary will force two Australian citizens to face life-long damaging consequences. Given the Applicant's low risk of reoffending, his commitment to rehabilitation and his ongoing family support in Australia, the best interests of his Australian citizen children should outweigh all considerations weighing against revocation. Materials before the Tribunal
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It follows that in the context and circumstances, I do not infer from the brief manner in which the Tribunal addressed the applicant’s submissions and information, the incomplete summary of the applicant’s submissions and the absence of any description or specific or detailed evaluation of the evidence that, there was a failure to evaluate the applicant’s claim (or representations) as a whole. Therefore, I am not satisfied that the Tribunal failed to read, identify, understand and evaluate the applicant’s representations about the best interests of his eldest son.Was there a failure to give individual consideration to the best interests of the applicant’s sons to the extent their interests may differ? The Tribunal was bound by s 499(2A) to apply Direction 99. Consequently, where the evidence or materials before the Tribunal raised a matter that was made relevant and was required to be taken into account in accordance with Direction 99, the Tribunal was bound to take that matter into account irrespective of whether or not the applicant had specifically made a representation (or submission) about that matter: e.g., Uelese at [61]-[68]. Otherwise, it was common ground that non-compliance with Direction 99 may constitute jurisdictional error: FHHM v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 19 at [6] (O’Callaghan and Colvin JJ). A failure to comply with s 499(2A) may be characterised as a breach of a condition governing the exercise of the making of a decision: LPDT at [30]-[31] (Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson and Jagot JJ). Paragraph 8.4(3) of Direction 99 required the Tribunal to give individual consideration to the best interests of each child to the extent that their interests may differ. I accept that that described an objective test by which the Tribunal was obliged to give individual consideration to the interests of the children where, on the information before the Tribunal, their interests may differ. However, once that threshold was crossed, the extent to which the interests of each child actually differ was a matter for the Tribunal to determine in its evaluation of the individual consideration of each child’s interests. Thus, where the interests of each child may differ, provided the Tribunal gives each child’s best interests individual consideration, it will sufficiently comply with the requirements of Direction 99. How it evaluates that consideration and what conclusions it reaches after that evaluation is a matter for the Tribunal. Put another way, while upon consideration of the evidence and other materials it can be determined objectively that each child’s interests may differ and, consequently the individual interests of each child must be considered, the Tribunal is entitled to conclude on the information before it that the interests of each child do not actually differ or do not differ in any material respect. In this case, that each child had a different mother, was of a different age, had different circumstances, individual needs and reasons that separation from the applicant would be detrimental meant that each child’s interests may differ and, therefore, the Tribunal was required to consider their individual interests.