Anderson v Commissioner of Highways

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

ANDERSON v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS

[2018] SASC 13

Ruling of The Honourable Justice Parker

16 February 2018

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - GENERALLY

PROCEDURE - MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MATTERS - DECLARATIONS - REQUIREMENT THAT ALL MATTERS IN CONTROVERSY BE DETERMINED

The applicant referred a “question arising in the course of negotiations” to the Court pursuant to s 23C of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) (‘Act’). The referred question was whether personal injury of the nature alleged to have been suffered by the applicant is compensable under the Act.

A question arose as to whether it was appropriate to determine the referred question as a preliminary matter or defer its resolution until trial.

Held, per Parker J:

1. The object of s 23C is to facilitate the expeditious and just resolution of disputes concerning the acquisition of land and the payment of compensation. Section 23C should be applied consistently with that object.

2. The requirement in s 23C that the question referred must have arisen in the course of negotiations operates in lieu of various restraints that apply to the grant of declaratory relief in equity.

3. The interests of justice are best served by answering the referred question as a preliminary matter. While an affirmative answer will not resolve the dispute, it will serve to narrow the issues. That outcome is consistent with the object of s 23C.

Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) s 22B, 23C, s 25; Land and Valuation Division Rules 2014 (SA) r 3; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 210, referred to.
Commissioner of Highways v George Eblen Pty Ltd (1975) 10 SASR 384; Re Lemon Tree Passage & Districts RSL & Citizens Club Cooperative Ltd (1987) 11 ACLC 796; Dean-Willcocks v Soluble Solution Hydroponics (1997) 24 ACSR 79; Re Dallhold Investments Pty Ltd (in liq) (1994) 53 FCR 339; Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC [2008] SASC 369; The Tap Inn Pty Ltd v Matthews [2015] SASCFC 188, discussed.

ANDERSON v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS
[2018] SASC 13

  1. PARKER J:          The applicant has referred “a question arising in the course of negotiations” to the Court under s 23C of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) (‘the Act’). In substance, the two questions initially referred to the Court were:

    1Whether the applicant is a person with an interest in the relevant land within the meaning of s 6 of the Act; and

    2Whether a personal injury of the nature suffered by the applicant is compensable as loss arising under s 22B of the Act as qualified by the principles of compensation set out in s 25 of the Act.

  2. The Commissioner of Highways has accepted that the applicant is a person with an interest in the relevant land within the meaning of s 6. That disposes of question one. Thus, the only question before the Court is whether compensation may be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anderson v Commissioner of Highways and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Anderson v Commissioner of Highways involved the applicant, who had resided with his parents on a property compulsorily acquired by the Commissioner for major roadworks. The applicant sought compensation for an adjustment disorder with post-traumatic stress disorder type symptoms, which he attributed to factors other than the acquisition process. The key legal issues were whether the Court could determine the applicant’s proposed question under Section 23C of the Act and whether it should consider assumed facts that were contested. The Court had to decide if the question should be resolved through negotiation or if it had the authority to make a determination.

The Court examined the broad powers conferred by Section 23C, noting that it was intended to empower the Court to make various orders to resolve disputes arising from negotiations. The Court found that Section 23C(3)(c) allows for making orders that are just in the circumstances, providing a wide discretion to the Court. The Court concluded that it was appropriate to determine the applicant’s question, considering it necessary to resolve the dispute about the quantum of compensation. However, the Court also emphasised the importance of basing any determination on factual findings, not assumptions, to ensure the resolution was grounded in reality.

In light of the Court's analysis, it held that while it had the power to determine the applicant's question, it should not do so based on contested assumed facts. Any determination would be hypothetical and unlikely to aid in the ultimate resolution of the compensation claim. Therefore, the Court declined to decide the question under Section 23C, advising further negotiation as the appropriate course.

The Court made no final orders regarding compensation but emphasised the necessity of factual findings to support any future claim. It encouraged the parties to negotiate further to address the applicant's claims based on actual facts rather than assumptions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before considering the question raised, it is necessary to state briefly the relevant background.Background For many years the parents of the applicant owned a home on Main South Road at Bedford Park (‘the Property’). The Property has been compulsorily acquired by the Commissioner for the purpose of undertaking major road works. Compensation has been paid to the applicant’s parents and they have moved to another home in a nearby suburb. The applicant is now aged 43 years. From 1980 to 2002 he resided with his parents at the Property and operated home businesses from that address. From 2002 to 2009 the applicant resided elsewhere in Adelaide but still attended at the Property on a daily basis for the purpose of conducting his home businesses. The applicant married in 2007 but separated in November/December 2015. In 2009 the applicant resumed living at the Property with his wife and two children and continued to conduct his business activities at and from the Property. The two businesses conducted by the applicant have been described as a vending machine business and a blind cleaning business. The applicant contends that during the period from July 2014, being about the time that the Commissioner notified the applicant and his parents of the proposed acquisition, until May 2016 the applicant suffered from an adjustment disorder with post-traumatic stress disorder type symptoms including anxiety, mental stress, forgetfulness, insomnia, depression, feelings of hopelessness and helplessness and suicidal ideations. The applicant further contends that this injury was caused by factors other than the acquisition process being made without his consent or against his will. The latter contention is of particular importance given that s 25(1)(g) of the Act provides that, in determining compensation, no allowance shall be made on account of the fact that the acquisition is effected without the consent, or against the will, of any person. The applicant lodged an application seeking interlocutory relief under s 23C of the Act by way of determination of the two questions referred to in paragraph [1]. However, as earlier mentioned, only the second question remains in contention. The applicant also seeks final relief by way of an order for compensation in accordance with s 22B and s 25 of the Act.Section 23C Section 23C of the Act relevantly provides:(1)The Authority or a claimant may refer a question arising in the course of negotiations into Court. (2)On the reference of a matter into the Court, the Court may— (a) if of the opinion that the question should be the subject of further negotiation—adjourn the matter to allow further negotiation to take place; or (b) make any order necessary to resolve the question. (3)In particular— (a) if there is a dispute about whether the claimant is interested in the subject land, or the nature of the claimant's interest—the Court may, subject to subsection (4), declare whether the claimant has an interest in the subject land and, if so, the nature of the interest; and (b) the Court may make orders for compensation that the Court finds to be justified on the claim; and (c) the Court may make other orders that may be just in the circumstances of the case.…The applicant’s contentions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For these reasons the Commissioner submits that, in accordance with well‑established principles, the applicant’s proposed question should not be determined by reference to assumed facts that are contested. In those circumstances any answer given by the Court would be hypothetical and would be unlikely to assist the ultimate resolution of the applicant’s claim for compensation.Consideration In my view, the powers conferred upon the Court by s 23C are very broad. I base that view upon both the text of the provision and its purpose. There are several indications that s 23C was intended to confer a broad power upon the Court. Those indications are as follows. Section 23C(1) empowers either the Authority or a claimant to “refer a question arising in the course of negotiations into Court.” There is no requirement that the question be one of law. Thus, the question may be one of law, of fact or of mixed law and fact. The only requirement is that the question has genuinely arisen in the course of negotiations. A further indication of the intended breadth of s 23C is provided by subsection (2). Paragraph (a) of that subsection empowers the Court, if it considers that the question should be the subject of further negotiation, to adjourn the matter to allow further negotiation. That provision confers a broad discretionary power on the Court. Furthermore, that power is clearly directed at facilitating the resolution of disputes by consent. Paragraph (b) of subsection (2) empowers the Court to make any order necessary to resolve the question that has arisen in the course of negotiations. The nature of the order made is within the discretion of the Court. The only condition precedent to the making of an order is that the Court considers it necessary to resolve the question. Paragraph (b) reinforces the breadth of the discretionary power conferred upon the Court by s 23C. Subsection (3) of s 23C operates to confirm the scope of the orders that may be made in response to a question referred in the course of negotiations. Paragraph (a) of that subsection specifically provides that if there is a dispute as to whether the claimant has an interest in the subject land, then the Court may (leaving aside cases where native title is asserted) declare whether the claimant has an interest, and if so, the nature of that interest in the land. If the first of the two questions originally referred to the Court by the applicant had not been resolved it would have been necessary for the Court to exercise its power under s 23C(3)(a) by making a declaration as to whether the applicant had an interest in the Property. Section 23C(3)(b) empowers the Court to make orders for the payment of compensation that it finds to be justified on the claim. That is the power called upon the Court to resolve disputes about the quantum of compensation where it cannot be agreed between the parties. More importantly in the present context, s 23C(3)(c) empowers the Court to make other orders that may be just in the circumstances of the case. The reference to “other orders”, particularly when read in the overall context of s 23C, confers a wide power upon the Court to do what it determines to be just in the circumstances.