Alhalek v Quintiliani trading as Kells Lawyers

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Alhalek v Quintiliani trading as Kells Lawyers [2020] FCA 1272

File number: NSD 336 of 2020
Judgment of: mARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 7 September 2020
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY – application to set aside bankruptcy notice – whether the applicant has a counter-claim, set off or cross demand – whether the judgment underlying the bankruptcy notice will be set aside – whether the bankruptcy notice constitutes an abuse of process – where there was no evidence that the judgment underlying the bankruptcy notice was served – where applicant claims he was solvent – whether time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice should be extended – application dismissed
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 30, 40(1)(g), 41
Cases cited:

Coshott v Prentice, in the matter of Coshott (No 2) [2016] FCA 1531

Glew v Harrowell, in the matter of Glew [2003] FCA 373; (2003) 198 ALR 331

Guss v Johnstone [2000] HCA 26; (2000) 171 ALR 598

Royal v Nazloomian, in the matter of Royal [2019] FCA 555

Sandell v Porter (1966) 115 CLR 666

Seller v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2011] FCA 865; (2011) 282 ALR 80

Sharpe v W H Bailey & Sons Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 921; (2014) 317 ALR 738

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 99
Date of hearing: 10 August 2020
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr M Sibley of MDW Law
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr M Micevski of Kells Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 336 of 2020
BETWEEN:

MR KYLED ALHALEK

Applicant

AND:

MARIO QUINTILIANI, PETER CHODAT, DAVID POTTS, AMY HARPER, MICHAEL HATFIELD AND PAUL MAGANINO T/AS KELLS LAWYERS

Respondents

order made by:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 SEPTEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The amended application filed on 22 July 2020 be dismissed.

2.Pursuant to s 41(6A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), extend the time for compliance with bankruptcy notice BN 248915 issued on 19 March 2020 to the applicant to 14 September 2020.

3.The applicant pay the respondents’ costs.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J

  1. On 19 March 2020 bankruptcy notice BN 248915 was issued by the Official Receiver to the applicant, Kyled Alhalek (Bankruptcy Notice).  Pursuant to the Bankruptcy Notice, Mario Quintiliani, Peter Chodat, David Potts, Amy Harper, Michael Hatfield and Paul Maganino trading as Kells Lawyers (Kells) seek payment of the amount of $21,738.24 from Mr Alhalek.

  2. By amended application filed on 22 July 2020 Mr Alhalek seeks an order setting aside the Bankruptcy Notice or, in the alternative, extending the time for compliance with it.

    Background

    Costs assessment application

  3. As is evident, Kells is a law firm.  Mario Quintiliani, a partner of Kells, formerly acted for Mr Alhalek, having been retained on or about 6 February 2018 to represent him in two proceedings in the Local Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alhalek v Quintiliani trading as Kells Lawyers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1272
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Alhalek, acting pro se, seeks an order setting aside the bankruptcy notice issued to him by Quintiliani trading as Kells Lawyers (Kells). Alternatively, Mr Alhalek seeks an extension of time to comply with the bankruptcy notice. The bankruptcy notice was issued in respect of an outstanding debt in the amount of $27,587.55, being the net amount owing for legal costs and disbursements. The debt arose out of work carried out by Kells on behalf of Mr Alhalek between 2 and 28 August 2018. The dispute between the parties concerns whether the bankruptcy notice should be set aside and, if not, whether the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice should be extended.

The court had to determine whether the bankruptcy notice constituted an abuse of process, whether there was evidence that the judgment underlying the bankruptcy notice would be set aside, and whether the applicant had a counter-claim, set off or cross demand. The court considered whether the Bankruptcy Notice was issued in bad faith or as a means of pressuring the applicant to pay the debt. The court also assessed the applicant’s financial position and whether there was any evidence that the judgment underlying the bankruptcy notice would be set aside. Finally, the court considered whether the applicant had any counter-claim, set off or cross demand that could be set against the debt.

The court found that there was no evidence that the judgment underlying the bankruptcy notice would be set aside. The court also found that the Bankruptcy Notice was not an abuse of process, as Kells had attempted to garnishee the applicant’s bank accounts and had not employed any other meaningful form of execution. The court further found that the applicant did not have any counter-claim, set off or cross demand that could be set against the debt. The court held that the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was not made out. However, the court extended the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice to 14 September 2020 and ordered the applicant to pay the respondents’ costs.

In summary, the court dismissed the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice but extended the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice and ordered the applicant to pay the respondents’ costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The amended application filed on 22 July 2020 be dismissed.

2. Pursuant to s 41(6A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), extend the time for compliance with bankruptcy notice BN 248915 issued on 19 March 2020 to the applicant to 14 September 2020.

3. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

By amended application filed on 22 July 2020 Mr Alhalek seeks an order setting aside the Bankruptcy Notice or, in the alternative, extending the time for compliance with it.BackgroundCosts assessment application As is evident, Kells is a law firm. Mario Quintiliani, a partner of Kells, formerly acted for Mr Alhalek, having been retained on or about 6 February 2018 to represent him in two proceedings in the Local Court of New South Wales (Local Court). On 27 August 2018 Mr Alhalek withdrew his instructions. As at 29 August 2018 Mr Alhalek had incurred costs and disbursement of $35,699.40 with a balance owing of $25,699.40. That balance was included in a tax invoice dated 29 August 2018 addressed to Mr Alhalek (August Account) which covered work carried out over the period of 2 to 28 August 2018 as follows: Prior to 29 August 2018 Kells had received two payments in satisfaction of its costs and disbursements in a total amount of $10,000 which was reflected in the balance owing in the August Account. Those payments were made as follows: the first payment of $2,500 was made in cash; and the second payment of $7,500 was made by cheque by Mortgage Loan & General Pty Ltd (Mortgage Loan & General). Mr Quintiliani was aware that Mr Alhalek was in control of Mortgage Loan & General as a result of previous instructions he had received from him. Mr Alhalek refused to pay any further amounts in satisfaction of Kells’ fees and took no steps to have Kells’ fees assessed, despite an alleged dispute as to the amount owing. On 12 June 2019 Kells issued and served a bill of costs in itemised form on Mr Alhalek for a net amount of $27,587.55, made up of fees and disbursements of $37,587.55 less the amount of $10,000 which had been paid on account of those costs (Bill of Costs). Mr Alhalek refused to pay the amount claimed in the Bill of Costs and took no steps to have the claimed costs assessed. On 5 August 2019:(1)Kells filed an application for assessment of the Bill of Costs (Costs Assessment Application) with the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Supreme Court). The Costs Assessment Application was addressed to Mr Alhalek at 168 Oxford Street, Woollahra NSW 2025 (Woollahra Address); and(2)the Supreme Court notified Mr Alhalek by email at admin@mortgageloangeneral.com that “[a]n application for assessment of costs was filed” and “[a]ny objections to the application must be lodged in writing and in triplicate with The Manager Costs Assessment by 26 August 2019”. Mr Alhalek resided at the Woollahra Address until about 20 June 2019 at which time he moved to an address in Paddington NSW 2021 (Paddington Address) where he continues to reside. On 26 August 2019 Mr Alhalek filed written submissions in the Costs Assessment Application in support of his objection to the Bill of Costs. Under cover of a letter dated 13 September 2018 (but which I assume was in fact intended to be dated 13 September 2019 and was despatched on or about that date) addressed to Mr Alhalek at both the Woollahra Address and the Paddington Address and at the email address admin@mortgageloangeneral.com, Kells provided to Mr Alhalek a copy of its submissions and letter to the costs assessor.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Alhalek says that he did not contact Kells after 22 September 2019 because he was not aware that the Costs Certificate or the Costs Judgment had issued or that Kells was attempting to garnishee his “previous bank accounts” (see [18]-[23] below).Steps taken by Kells to enforce the Costs Judgment On 22 November 2019 Mr Quintiliani caused garnishee notices to be served on the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) and the Australia and New Zealand Bank (ANZ). By letter dated 26 November 2019 the ANZ informed Mr Quintiliani that there were “insufficient funds in the account(s) in the name of the Judgment Debtor to answer the Garnishee Order” and that, “[a]s a result, ANZ is not in a position to make any payment to you pursuant to the Garnishee Order”. Mr Quintiliani has not received any reply from the CBA in response to the garnishee notice served on it. Mr Alhalek’s evidence is that he has bank accounts at other financial institutions. By way of example he put into evidence a statement for the period ended 19 March 2020 for an account held with the National Australia Bank (NAB) which showed a closing balance of $251.82. Mr Alhalek says, had Kells issued a garnishee notice to the NAB or other financial institutions, it would have been properly informed as to his financial position. In or about mid-October 2019 Mr Quintiliani became aware that Mortgage Loan & General had been placed into liquidation by order of the Supreme Court of Victoria. Mr Quintiliani was not aware that Mr Alhalek had any other means to satisfy the debt owed to Kells or any capacity to earn an income other than his involvement with Mortgage Loan & General. Following the receipt of the letter from ANZ (see [19] above), Mr Quintiliani formed the view that Mr Alhalek was probably insolvent and on 19 March 2020 concluded that the only course of action he could take in light of Mr Alhalek’s apparent impecuniosity was to issue the Bankruptcy Notice. Mr Alhalek’s financial position Mr Alhalek says that in about January 2020 he sold a “Ferrari California” to F1 Prestige Car Sales Pty Ltd (F1 Prestige) for approximately $300,000 and that it was agreed, as between him and F1 Prestige, that F1 Prestige would keep the proceeds of sale to reinvest in the business but that Mr Alhalek could call upon his investment on 24 hours’ notice. According to Mr Alhalek, by 19 March 2020 he had a running account with F1 Prestige in the amount of $385,000. A statement of account dated 31 March 2020 from F1 Prestige for account KALHAK004 marked to the attention of “Kyled” shows the following:Steps taken by Mr Alhalek subsequent to service of the Bankruptcy Notice Mr Alhalek seeks review of the Costs Certificate On 23 March 2020 Mr Alhalek sent an email to the costs assessment division of the Supreme Court seeking a copy of the Costs Certificate. According to Mr Alhalek, on 28 March 2020 he lodged an application for review of the determination of the costs assessor in relation to the Costs Certificate (Review Application).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Alhalek submits that he will be successful in the Judicial Review Proceeding and will have the Determination set aside. On the assumption that he is successful in the Judicial Review Proceeding, he also submits that, if his subsequent review is successful, the debt underpinning the Bankruptcy Notice will change, the Bankruptcy Notice will be invalid and therefore it should be set aside.Consideration Mr Alhalek acts for himself in the Judicial Review Proceeding. Little weight can be given to his assertion that he will be successful in that proceeding. But even if I was to accept that to be so, success in that proceeding will result in the quashing of the Determination and the remittal of the application for an extension of time to bring the Review Application to a different decision-maker. That is, the matter will be remitted to re-determine the extension of time application. It is only if Mr Alhalek is successful in obtaining an extension of time that the Review Application will proceed and the costs assessment reconsidered. Thereafter, it is only if the costs assessor accepts some or all of Mr Alhalek’s grounds in his Review Application that the Costs Certificate which underpins the Costs Judgment will change and thus the amount due to Kells will change. There is no evidence before me, other than Mr Alhalek’s own opinion that he will be successful in achieving a reduction in the assessed costs, of Mr Alhalek’s prospects of obtaining an extension of time within which to bring his Review Application, or the likelihood of Mr Alhalek’s grounds of review achieving some measure of success in reducing the assessed amount of Kells’ costs and, if so, the likely quantum of that reduction. The contention that there will be a variation of the Costs Certificate and thus a variation or setting aside of the Costs Judgment is mere speculation. In those circumstances it is not possible to conclude that the Judicial Review Proceeding and, if successful, the applications that will or may follow will lead to a setting aside or variation of the Costs Judgment such that the Bankruptcy Notice should be set aside. This ground is not made out.Does the Bankruptcy Notice constitute an abuse of process? The third ground relied on by Mr Alhalek to set aside the Bankruptcy Notice is that it is an abuse of process. Mr Alhalek submits that, while Kells attempted to garnishee two bank accounts, they were accounts which he no longer used or in which he had minimal funds. He contends that at no stage after obtaining the Costs Judgment did Kells write to him to ascertain whether he had alternative bank accounts with funds sufficient to satisfy the debt, such as his account held at the NAB. Mr Alhalek submits that it was unreasonable for Kells to draw the inference that he was insolvent as a corollary of the insufficiency of funds in bank accounts known by Kells to be in his name and that the Court should refuse to draw that inference on that basis. Mr Alhalek submits that despite issuing two garnishee notices, both of which were unsuccessful, Kells did not attempt any other meaningful form of execution including, for example, issuing an application for examination or a letter of demand. Mr Alhalek says, had Kells issued an application for examination or a letter of demand, he would have responded and Kells may then have properly determined his true financial position and may have agreed suitable payment terms with him. Mr Alhalek submits that in circumstances where Kells did not employ meaningful execution methods or exhaust those methods, beyond a meagre unsuccessful attempt to garnishee obsolete bank accounts, the Court should draw an inference, akin to that drawn in Royal v Nazloomian, in the matter of Royal [2019] FCA 555 (Nazloomian) at [74], that Kells issued the Bankruptcy Notice with the intention of pressuring him.