Agius v State of South Australia (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Agius v State of South Australia (No 4) [2017] FCA 361

File number: SAD 6001 of 2000
Judge: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 7 April 2017
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – native title proceeding – application for extension of trial timetable – history of extensive delay in proceedings – request for extension due to lack of funding for applicant – in the absence of significant changes in circumstances not previously brought to the Court's attention, parties are expected to comply with Orders made
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth), ss 37M, 37N, 37P

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), ss 61, 62A, 94C, 203C, 203FB, 203FBB, 203FE

Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA)

Cases cited:

Agriculture and Rural Finance Pty Ltd v Kirk [2011] NSWCA 67

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; 239 CLR 175

Arthur Andersen Corporate Finance Pty Ltd v Buzzle Operations Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2009] NSWCA 104

Atkinson v Minister for Lands (NSW) [2010] FCA 1073

Bennell v Western Australia [2004] FCAFC 338

Hart v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2016] FCA 250

Hill v Queensland [2015] FCA 300

Horne v Retirement Guide Management [2017] VSCA 47

Kokatha Native Title Claim v South Australia [2006] FCA 838

Levinge & Ors v Queensland [2012] FCA 1321; 208 FCR 98

Levinge on behalf of the Gold Coast Native Title Claim Group v State of Queensland [2013] FCA 634

Narrier v State of Western Australia [2016] FCA 1519

Osgood v Wham [2007] WASCA 178

Re Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (in liquidation) [2015] VSC 745

Savcor Pty Ltd v Cathodic Protection International APS [2005] VSCA 213; 12 VR 639

Waddon v Whitecroft-Scovill Ltd [1988] 1 WLR 309

Date of hearing: 28 March 2017
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Native Title
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 197
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Billington
Solicitor for the Applicant: Campbell Law
Counsel for the State of South Australia: Mr P Tonkin
Solicitor for the State of South Australia: Crown Solicitor’s Office
Solicitor for the Commonwealth: Ms S Davis of Australian Government Solicitor
Solicitor for the South Australian Native Title Services Ltd: Mr A Beckworth of South Australian Native Title Services
Solicitor for the various local government entities: Mr N Llewllyn-Jones of Norman Waterhouse
Counsel for the City of Burnside: Ms N Johns
Solicitor for the City of Burnside: Kelledy Jones
Solicitor for the South Australian Apiarists Association Inc, Water licence holders, Fishing licence holders: Ms A Lea of Mellor Olsson

ORDERS

SAD 6001 of 2000
BETWEEN:

GARTH AGIUS & OTHERS

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA & OTHERS

Respondent

JUDGE:

MORTIMER J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 April 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Compliance with paragraph 14 of the Orders made by Justice White on 11 November 2016 be extended to 7 August 2017.

2.The interlocutory applications filed by the applicant on 23 January 2017 and 25 January 2017 be dismissed.

3.The proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Agius v State of South Australia (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Agius v State of South Australia (No 4) involved an application for an extension of the trial timetable in a native title proceeding. The applicant, a group of Aboriginal people, sought an extension due to a lack of funding for their case. The proceedings had a history of extensive delays, and the applicant argued that their inability to secure funding had contributed to these delays. The South Australian Native Title Services (SANTS) was also involved in the proceedings, as it was responsible for providing funding and support to the applicant.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant was entitled to an extension of the trial timetable due to their lack of funding. The court needed to consider the responsibilities of the parties under sections 37M and 37N of the Federal Court Act, and whether the applicant had taken reasonable steps to secure funding for their case. The court also had to balance the need for fairness and justice to all parties against the potential consequences of dismissing the whole proceeding for non-compliance with the Court’s orders.

The court found that the applicant had not taken sufficient steps to secure funding for their case, and that there had been no significant changes in circumstances not previously brought to the Court's attention. The court emphasised the importance of proactivity, cooperation, and a focus on what is critical and not what is peripheral in bringing a complicated proceeding to trial. The court also highlighted the responsibility of the parties and their legal representatives to make compromises and negotiate where necessary to avoid unnecessary expenses. The court ultimately decided not to grant the applicant an extension of the trial timetable, and dismissed the interlocutory applications filed by the applicant.

In conclusion, the court denied the applicant's request for an extension of the trial timetable, and emphasised the importance of all parties taking responsibility for their roles and responsibilities in the proceedings. The court dismissed the interlocutory applications filed by the applicant, and the proceeding was adjourned to a case management hearing on 10 May 2017 in the Adelaide registry. The court's decision highlighted the need for all parties to be proactive, cooperative, and focused on what is critical and essential in bringing a complicated proceeding to trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Compliance with paragraph 14 of the Orders made by Justice White on 11 November 2016 be extended to 7 August 2017.

2. The interlocutory applications filed by the applicant on 23 January 2017 and 25 January 2017 be dismissed.

3. The proceeding be adjourned to a case management hearing on 10.15 am on 10 May 2017 in the Adelaide registry.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In early March 2017, this proceeding was transferred into my docket. I listed the matter for a case management hearing on 28 March 2017 in order to ensure the parties were progressing in their compliance with White J’s orders. Ahead of the case management hearing, and upon reading the transcript of the hearing before White J on 11 November 2016, I made the following directions:1.On or before 11 am on 28 March 2017, Ms Davis, solicitor for the Commonwealth, is to file and serve an affidavit deposing to the steps which have been taken to draw the Commonwealth’s attention to the funding issues raised by the applicant in this proceeding, as foreshadowed by Ms Davis to Justice White on 11 November 2016, including any responses by or on behalf of the Commonwealth.2.On or before 11 am on 28 March 2017, Mr Campbell, solicitor for the applicant, is to file and serve an affidavit deposing to the steps which he has taken since 11 November 2016 to secure further funding for the applicant in relation to preparation for the trial fixed to commence on 3 April 2018, including:(a) Steps to secure funding for legal representations;(b)Steps to secure funding for expert witnesses in relation to connection; (c)Steps to secure funding for preparation of lay connection evidence; and(d)The provision of the transcript of the 11 November 2016 directions hearing to the Commonwealth.3.On or before 11 am on 28 March 2017, South Australia Native Title Services (SANTS) is to file and serve an affidavit deposing to the work it has undertaken since 11 November 2016 with the applicant in relation to their application for funding, and any steps taken by SANTS since 11 November 2016 to secure extra funding from the Commonwealth for the trial preparation of the applicant’s case for trial as set out in the Court’s directions made on 11 November 2016.4.The proceeding is to be placed forthwith on the priority list of native title applications in the South Australia District Registry, on the basis that it is listed for the trial of a separate question on connection, commencing on 3 April 2018 for a period of 6 weeks.EVIDENCE ON THE APPLICATION The following affidavits were filed:·Affidavit of Mr Tim Campbell, affirmed on 27 March 2017 deposing to the type and amount of funding required for the applicant, including the need for expert anthropologist and historian reports, the hours of work said by Mr Campbell to be required, and the responses received in relation to the various funding requests. In particular, Mr Campbell deposed, at [34]:The Application for Special Funding is for the sum of $3,818,272.00. The Application for Special Funding identifies that the following is required in order to prepare the claim for hearing:(a) Interviewing 80 witnesses by an anthropologist and a lawyer and preparing witness statements will require four days per witness amounting to 320 days;(b) An expert report by an historian will require 30 hours a week for 50 weeks;(c) An expert report by an anthropologist will require 30 hours a week for 50 weeks;(d) A Genealogy report will take 70 days by an anthropologist. There is a genealogy available which was prepared by Neale Draper in 2001 and updated in 2010. I am told by law clerk, Wendy Jollands, that she has installed and looked at the genealogy records on the Campbell Law computer system. She has told me and I verily believe that the genealogy records refer to some 4500 individual records (living and dead). There are 1162 families' records, with 452 unique surnames.(e) A review of documentary sources will require at least one year of full time work by a lawyer and 6 months of full time work by a law clerk;(f) Preparation for trial will require 24 weeks;(g) A trial of 12 weeks (rather than the 6 weeks presently estimated)·Affidavit of Mr Jeffrey Newchurch, a Kaurna elder and the Chair of the Kaurna Nation Cultural Heritage Association Incorporated (KNCHA), sworn on 27 March 2017, deposing to the funding (or lack thereof) available to the applicant;·Affidavit of Ms Sally Davis, an Australian Government Solicitor lawyer representing the Commonwealth, affirmed on 28 March 2017, deposing to the status of any funding application submitted to the Commonwealth. In particular, Ms Davis’ affidavit exhibited correspondence from the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (PM&C) that no funding application had been received by that Department from SANTS in respect of this proceeding;·Affidavit of Mr Andrew Beckworth, the principal legal officer employed by SANTS, affirmed on 28 March 2017, deposing to SANTS’ funding arrangements, and deposing that SANTS received a funding application from Campbell Law on 14 March 2017; and·Affidavit of Mr Nicholas Llewellyn-Jones, the solicitor representing a number of councils in this proceeding, sworn on 28 March 2017, deposing to the proposed procedure for resolving the discovery application. I return to the discovery application later in these reasons.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Otherwise, the timetable set by White J will remain as it is. The parties, and in particular those individuals representing the applicant, should familiarise themselves with paras 31 and 32 of White J’s orders, and the possible consequence of dismissal of the whole proceeding for which they provide. The Court does not make orders of that kind as an empty gesture. Similar powers are available under s 37P of the Federal Court Act, and are available to be exercised where appropriate.CONCLUSION I have emphasised the role and responsibilities of the Court, the parties and their legal representatives under ss 37M and 37N of the Federal Court Act. Of course, the roles and responsibilities set out in ss 37M and 37N do not all tend one way. The resolution of any proceeding does involve fairness and justice to all parties. However that fairness and justice is to be objectively viewed, and objectively ascertained. It does not necessarily correlate with one party’s wishes or desires about how to run her or his case. As this matter proceeds towards trial, further adjustments to the timetable may be necessary. The active respondents no doubt will have to be proactive and cooperative in narrowing the issues in dispute to those which are critical and significant to the resolution of the connection issue. As fully-funded active parties, it may be the Court can expect them to assume some additional responsibilities in the preparation of the case if it turns out that the applicant struggles to fund certain aspects, such as the preparation of a court book. The Court’s decision today does not preclude further adjustments being made to reflect new difficulties that may arise in the preparation of the case. Any party seeking such further adjustments will have to justify them by the provision of persuasive evidence. The point presently to be made is that proactivity (instead of reactivity), cooperation, and a focus on what is critical and not what is peripheral are all essential and expected components of bringing a complicated proceeding to trial, and the Court is and will continue to be willing to accommodate parties’ further requests where those essential components require it. I accept that some members of the claim group may be frustrated and disappointed with an outcome which is different to the way they appear to have been advised will best advance their native title claim. As both White J and I have observed, ultimately how those individuals who have been chosen by the claim group to act as representatives decide to instruct their legal representatives, and which legal representatives they choose to instruct, are matters for them. Those choices are part of the weighty responsibilities involved in being a representative of a claim group in a proceeding as large and serious as this one. Like very many other litigants in this Court, and in other courts, the individuals who represent the claim group, and have under s 62A of the Native Title Act the responsibility and authority to make decisions about the conduct of the proceeding, may have to consider compromises to the way they are able to present their case: they will have to focus on what is critical and essential, and may have to leave some of the more peripheral matters aside; they may have to negotiate with other parties to see what can be agreed so that the expenses of proof of some matters can be avoided. They will have to place cooperation above obstruction. That is what, in the modern era of case management, the Court expects of all parties in all proceedings, including litigants without substantial means, and those who are self-represented.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established