FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Bennell v State of Western Australia [2004] FCAFC 338
NATIVE TITLE – case management – Regional Case Management Conference – whether trial date should be vacated – funding issues – availability of expert reports – ongoing mediation – directions given
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
ANTHONY BENNELL, ALAN BLURTON, ALAN BOLTON AND OTHERS (SNC) v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD6006 of 2003
KEN COLBUNG, GLEN COLBUNG AND OTHERS (SOUTH WEST BOOJARAH), M VAN LEEUWEN ON BEHALF OF THE HARRIS FAMILY , L BELLOTTI AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE NYUNGAR PEOPLE (GNAALA KARLA BOOJA) v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD 6279, 6085, Part of 6274 of 1998
ANTHONY BENNELL AND OTHERS (Single Noongar Claim Area 2) v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
WAD 6012 OF 2003
MARTHA BORINELLI, ARNOLD FRANKS AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE YUED FAMILIES v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD6192 of 1998
LORRAINE BELLOTTI AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE NYUNGAR PEOPLE (GNAALA KARLA BOOJA) v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD 6274 of 1998
PATRICIA MORICH AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE WOM-BER PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD 6130 of 1998
CEDRIC ANDERSON, DONALD COLLARD, SYLVIA COLLARD AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE BALLARDONG PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD 6181 of 1998
ALAN BOLTON AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE SOUTHERN NOONGAR FAMILIES, ALAN BOLTON AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE WAGYL KAIP, PATRICIA MORICH AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE WOM-BER PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
WAD 6134, 6286 and Part of 6130 of 1998
DONALD COLLARD and SYLVIA RACHAEL COLLARD ON BEHALF OF THE NOONGAR PEOPLE
WAD6091, 6102, 6142, 6171 and 6223 of 1998WILCOX, FRENCH and FINN JJ
23 DECEMBER 2004
PERTH
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
WAD6006 of 2003
BETWEEN:
ANTHONY BENNELL, ALAN BLURTON, ALAN BOLTON AND OTHERS (SNC)
APPLICANTSAND:
THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS
RESPONDENTSJUDGE:
WILCOX J
DATE OF ORDER:
23 DECEMBER 2004
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The trial of so much of the application as relates to the area covered by the Perth Metropolitan Application, formerly WAG142/98, be adjourned to a date to be fixed early in the second half of 2005.
2.The time limited for the filing of an historical report by Dr John Host be extended to 21 January 2005.
3(a)The applicants and the State of Western Australia do endeavour to agree a revised timetable for pre-trial programming to be filed in Court prior to 31 January 2005 on notice to the other parties to the application.
(b)If no timetable can be agreed the applicants are to apply to Wilcox J on or before 7 February 2005 for further directions and, in any event, are to apply for directions as to the fixing of trial dates in the second half of 2005.
4.There is liberty…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bennell v State of Western Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] FCAFC 338
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues that the court had to decide were whether to grant an extension for the filing of the expert historical report prepared by Dr John Host, and to determine the appropriate schedule for the trial of the native title applications. Dr Host's report, which was crucial for the applicants, was initially due by 30 November 2004, but due to the extensive nature of the research, he requested an extension until 21 January 2005. The court also needed to address the trial scheduling for the Perth Metropolitan area and other regions, as well as the mediation process for the combined applications.
The court granted the extension for the filing of Dr Host's report, acknowledging the necessity for a thorough and accurate historical analysis. The court emphasised that rushing the research would compromise the integrity of the report. Regarding the trial scheduling, the court decided to adjourn the trial for the Perth Metropolitan area to a date in the second half of 2005 to allow more time for the necessary pre-trial preparations. The mediation process was to continue, with a detailed program for negotiation and mediation of the combined applications to be prepared by the applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal.
The final orders included an extension for the filing of the historical report, an adjournment of the trial for the Perth Metropolitan area, and directives for the preparation of a negotiation and mediation program. The mediation facilitated by the National Native Title Tribunal was to continue, with a report requested by 23 May 2005. The directions hearing was also adjourned to 1 June 2005, at which time the court would address the question of formal referral to mediation.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The trial of so much of the application as relates to the area covered by the Perth Metropolitan Application, formerly WAG142/98, be adjourned to a date to be fixed early in the second half of 2005.
2. The time limited for the filing of an historical report by Dr John Host be extended to 21 January 2005.
3(a) The applicants and the State of Western Australia do endeavour to agree a revised timetable for pre-trial programming to be filed in Court prior to 31 January 2005 on notice to the other parties to the application.
(b) If no timetable can be agreed the applicants are to apply to Wilcox J on or before 7 February 2005 for further directions and, in any event, are to apply for directions as to the fixing of trial dates in the second half of 2005.
4. There is liberty to apply.
5. The balance of the application is to continue in mediation in accordance with the protocol presently agreed.
6. Liberty to apply to French J for directions as to formal referral to mediation following completion of notification and for any variation of mediation protocols for the balance of the application.
7. The SWALSC is directed to take all reasonable steps to pursue its application to the Commonwealth for funding to represent the applicants in connection with the trial of the Perth Metropolitan area claim and pre-trial steps in relation to it.
8. The SWALSC is directed to prepare and file prior to 1 June 2005 a statement of its priorities in respect of the trial of applications and/or the hearing of evidence in respect of particular parts of any application including this application.
9. The directions hearing in respect of so much of this application as does not relate to the area covered by the Perth Metropolitan application, formerly WAG142/98, be adjourned to 1 June 2005 at 9am.
1. The applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 February 2005. The program is to set out:
(i) specific issues to be negotiated;
(ii) a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;
(iii) an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;
(iv) provision for the taking of connexion evidence;
(v) identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.
2. A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 28 February 2005.
3. A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.
4. The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.
5. A directions hearing be listed on 1 June 2005 at 9am to provide direction under Order 1 rule 9 of the Federal Court Rules.
6. The applicants file any documents and/or submissions relating to the directions hearing at least 28 days prior to the date set in Order 5.
7. The respondents file any documents and/or submissions in relation to the directions hearing at least 14 days prior to the date set in Order 5.
8. The applicant file any documents and/or submissions in reply at least 11 days prior to the date set in Order 5.
1. The applicants and the State in conjunction with the National Native Title Tribunal are to prepare a program for the negotiation and mediation of the combined applications commencing 1 February 2005. The program is to set out:
(i) specific issues to be negotiated;
(ii) a detailed timetable including proposed meeting dates and venues set in a regional context;
(iii) an outline of a negotiated protocol to be adopted by the State and the applicants;
(iv) provision for the taking of connexion evidence;
(v) identification of questions of law or fact which, if determined by the Court, could advance the resolution of a particular claim or conflict between claims.
2. A copy of the program is to be lodged with the Court by 28 February 2005.
3. A copy of the program is to be made available to any party on request to the applicants.
4. The parties are to comply with the timetable set out in the program provided that, if it appears likely to any party that it will be unable to take a programmed step within two months of the time limited for doing so by the program, it must apply to the Court to vary the program accordingly.
5. The directions hearing is adjourned to 1 June 2005 at 9am at which time the question of formal referral to mediation will be dealt with.
Note:
1. The mediation facilitated by the National Native Title Tribunal continue.
2. The directions hearing be adjourned to 1 June 2005 at 9am.
3. The National Native Title Tribunal be requested to provide a mediation report on or before 23 May 2005.
4. There be liberty to apply.
Note:
1. The mediation facilitated by the National Native Title Tribunal continue.
2. The directions hearing be adjourned to 1 June 2005 at 9am.
3. The National Native Title Tribunal be requested to provide a mediation report on or before 23 May 2005.
4. There be liberty to apply.
The directions hearing be adjourned to 1 June 2005 at 9am.
Note:
The directions hearing be adjourned to 1 June 2005 at 9am.
.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi