Sambo v State of Western Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sambo v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2010] FCA 927

Citation: Sambo v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2010] FCA 927
Parties: DENNIS SAMBO, LINDA CHAMPION, VICTOR COOPER, ELIZABETH SAMBO, CARLENE SCEGHI, NANCY WILSON and SUE WYATT v STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA, COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA, SHIRE OF COOLGARDIE, SHIRE OF MUKINBUDIN, DONALD BALLINGER, CYRIL BARNES, BARRON BONNEY, MARK CHAMPION, DOROTHY DIMER, GLEN DIMER, KEVIN DIMER, MAXINE DIMER, OLLAN DIMER, RICKY DIMER, GOLDFIELDS LAND & SEA COUNCIL ABORIGINAL CORPORATION, DALE GRAHAM, JOHN GRAHAM, GRAEME PELLEW, KATIE RAY, EDNA REID, BONNIE SMITH, DANIEL TUCKER, UNITED NORTH EAST CLAIMANTS, PETER RONALD GEORGE MILNE, PERILYA LIMITED, TENNANT CREEK GOLD LIMITED, BHP BILLITON NICKEL WEST PTY LTD, AUSTRALIAN GOLD RESOURCES LTD, KALGOORLIE LAKE VIEW PTY LTD, MOUNT MARGARET NICKEL PTY LTD, NORTH KALGURLI MINES PTY LTD, ARCHAEAN GOLD NL, BARRICK GOLD OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED, CROESUS MINING NL, FORRESTANIA GOLD NL, LAKE JOHNSTON LTD, PLUTONIC OPERATIONS LTD, WESTONIA MINES LIMITED, MENANGINA PTY LTD, STAR OF ENNUIN PASTORAL COMPANY, AILSA ELIZABETH BAYLY, ROBERT THOMAS BAYLY, CALLION PASTORAL COMPANY PTY LTD, BRADLEY ROSS CULLEN, MALCOLM RAYMOND CULLEN, THOMAS EDWARD CULLEN, HORACE ANTHONY DELLA BOSCA, LAURENCE PAUL DELLA BOSCA, ROBERT LEO DELLA BOSCA, BERNARD GUERINI, BERNARD ANTHONY GUERINI, JOSEPH MICHAEL GUERINI, LINA GUERINI, RAYMOND ACHILLE GUERINI, JARAC PTY LTD, BARTON CECIL JONES, BURCHILL FRANCIS CECIL JONES, CHARLES BARTON CECIL JONES, JOHN LOAD CECIL JONES, KEITH MADER, MT JACKSON PASTORAL CO PTY LTD, MT KERSEY MINING NL, MT VETTERS PASTORAL CO (1966) PTY LTD, HORACE PANIZZA, ARTHUR ROBERTS, BERNARD MICHAEL SCANLON, HAYDEN CHRISTOPHER SCANLON, NANCY FAYE SCANLON, TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED, ACTIV FOUNDATION INC, BALLARDONG AND MADUWONGGA OVERLAPPING CLAIM GROUPS
File number: WAD 65 of 1998
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 26 August 2010
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE - Court’s discretionary power to dismiss an application on its own motion if the application has not been amended since earlier failure of registration test and no evidence that likely to be amended in a way that would lead to a different outcome - proposed substituted applicant for deceased applicant
Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 61(1), 190F(5), 190F(6), 190F(6)(b)

Federal Court Rules O 78 r 12

Cases cited: Sambo v State of Western Australia [2009] FCA 940
Date of hearing: 17 May 2010
Date of last submissions: 8 June 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 51
Counsel for the Applicant (Central West): S Dayley
Solicitor for the Applicant (Central West): Shayne Daley & Assoc
Counsel for the Ballardong Applicants: S Blackshield
Solicitor for the Ballardong Applicants: South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council
Counsel for the State of Western Australia: T Creewel
Solicitor for the State of Western Australia: State Solicitors Office
Counsel for the Commonwealth: A Gerrard
Solicitor for the Commonwealth: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Various Mining/Fishing Interests: M Watts
Solicitor for the Various Mining/Fishing Interests: Hunt & Humphry
Counsel for the Various Pastoral Interests: Mr Graham
Solicitor for the Various Pastoral Interests: Cornerstone Legal
Counsel for…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sambo v State of Western Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 927
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sambo v State of Western Australia (No 2), the applicant, the Central West Goldfields People, sought to challenge the dismissal of their native title claim. The matter was before the court on the application of the applicant for the dismissal of the application to be set aside. The application for native title had been considered on three occasions by the Registrar, but was ultimately not accepted for registration. The central issue before the court was whether the application should be dismissed under section 190F(6) of the Native Title Act 1993 (NTA), given that it had not been amended since its last consideration by the Registrar and it was not likely to be amended in a way that would lead to a different outcome.

The court considered the history of the claim, the ongoing disputes within the applicant group, and the lack of progress in resolving these issues. Despite the applicant's assurances and submissions that they were now in a position to hold a claim group meeting and had secured funding for that purpose, the court found that the claim was unlikely to be amended in a way that would result in its registration. The court noted that while the applicant had gathered anthropological and other evidence to support the claim, this evidence would not be destroyed by the dismissal of the application and could be used in any future application. The court concluded that there was no other reason why the application should not be dismissed and that dismissal would not prevent the bringing of a further application if that was the course advised by the members of the native title claim group or any other claim group that might be formed.

The court dismissed the application under section 190F(6) of the NTA, finding that the application had not been amended since it was considered by the Registrar and was not likely to be amended in a way that would lead to any different conclusion by the Registrar. The court emphasised that the dismissal of the application would not prevent the bringing of a further application if that was the course advised by the members of the native title claim group or any other claim group that might be formed. The decision highlights the importance of progress and resolution of internal disputes within a native title claim group in order to support the registration of a native title claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

By way of example, the Explanatory Memorandum suggests that the Court may consider that an application should not be dismissed if, despite being unregistered, the claim is close to reaching resolution (para 4.331). BACKGROUND In Sambo No 1, the applicant filed submissions, under the title of Central West Goldfields People, on behalf of all members of the applicant other than Ms Sue Wyatt and Mr Victor Cooper. Those submissions highlighted that the Registrar had considered the claim on three occasions: on 4 October 1999 when it was accepted for registration; on 18 September 2006 when it was not accepted for registration; and on 16 September 2008 when it was again not accepted for registration. In relation to the decisions of the Registrar on 18 September 2006 and 16 September 2008, the applicant conceded that it had not taken any steps to seek review or reconsideration of the Registrar’s decision. In particular, no steps of a kind contemplated in (1)(iv) of s 190F(5)(b) NTA were taken. The primary difficulty then, as it is now, was the state of deadlock which has persisted for some time between various members of the applicant, in particular Ms Sue Wyatt and Mr Victor Cooper, who are in disagreement with the remainder of the claim group. Those disputes, it is said, have centred on handling of ‘future act’ matters, monies paid in respect of ‘future acts’ and the strength of the connection of the Cooper members’ immediate families to the Central West claim group. In Sambo No 1, the applicant submitted that notwithstanding these difficulties, considerable resources had been put into the preparation of the Central West claim, with extensive research undertaken into the laws, customs and historical and cultural connections of the Central West people. Expert reports were filed by an anthropologist, a linguist and an ethno-botanical expert giving, it was submitted, weight to the notion that the claim is serious, proper and deserving of further attention by the Court and the respondents. More significantly, in Sambo No 1, the solicitors for the applicant indicated that while no active steps had been taken at that time in relation to the claim, including the holding of a claim group meeting, this was primarily because of the existence of the disputes between members of the applicant. The solicitors for the applicant believed that holding a claim group meeting would be the first step in reactivating the Central West claim. It was submitted that there was likely to be a change in the composition of the claim group if such a meeting were held and that if issues as to the membership of the claim group could be satisfactorily resolved, the claim was likely to be re-registered. The applicant acknowledged at that time that a further claim group meeting or meetings would need to occur in a timely manner. In Sambo No 1, I declined to dismiss the proceedings at that stage, in order to allow the applicant the opportunity to hold a claim group meeting. It was difficult to be satisfied that the outcome of such a meeting would result in the application being amended in a way that could give rise to its registration. However, the extensive submissions filed and the assurances given by the solicitors for the applicant, at least led to an inference that there was a reasonable and relatively imminent possibility of that event occurring. That has not occurred. CONSIDERATION

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is not a situation akin to the one outlined by way of example in the Explanatory Memorandum to the NTA, which suggests that an application should not be dismissed if, despite being unregistered, the claim is close to reaching resolution (para 4.331). CONCLUSION On the basis of the history, I am satisfied for the purposes of s 190F(6) NTA that the application has not been amended since it was considered by the Registrar and is not likely to be amended in a way that would lead to any different conclusion by the Registrar. There is no other reason why the application should not be dismissed. Such anthropological and other evidence as has been gathered to date to provide a factual basis for the application will not be destroyed by the dismissal of the application. It will be for the members of the native title claim group or of such other claim group as is formed to take such action as they may be advised in relation to the bringing of a fresh application. Dismissal under s 190F(6) NTA of this application will not prevent the bringing of a further application if that is the course advised. The application is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Sambo No 1, I declined to dismiss the proceedings at that stage, in order to allow the applicant the opportunity to hold a claim group meeting. It was difficult to be satisfied that the outcome of such a meeting would result in the application being amended in a way that could give rise to its registration. However, the extensive submissions filed and the assurances given by the solicitors for the applicant, at least led to an inference that there was a reasonable and relatively imminent possibility of that event occurring. That has not occurred. CONSIDERATION Given the ongoing lack of progress, the parties were advised at the directions hearing on 17 May 2010 that the Court would once again, of its own motion, consider the dismissal of the application pursuant to s 190F(6) NTA. I invited parties to make submissions. It is common ground that the Central West Goldfields people’s application still has not been amended since consideration by the Registrar on 16 September 2008. Against the background discussed above, it is desirable to consider whether the claim is ‘likely to be amended in a way that would lead to a different outcome once considered by the Registrar’ Section 61(1) NTA provides that an application can only be amended if the amendment is authorised by:…all of the persons (the native title claim group) who, according to their traditional laws and customs, hold the common or group rights and interests comprising the particular native title claimed, provided the person or persons are also included in the native title claim group.Applicant’s submissions Since judgment in Sambo No 1 (and although the applicant has not held a claim group meeting as previously indicated) the applicant now advises that it is in a position to hold a claim group meeting and that it has secured funding for that purpose. The applicant contends that there is a reasonable prospect of the claim being registered and that there is increasing support amongst members of the claim group for this to occur. This is said to be largely in consequence of the resolution of some litigation in the Supreme Court of Western Australia (the Supreme Court) relating to the establishment of a trust administered by ‘Plan B’ Trustees Limited (Plan B). Submissions for the applicant indicate that in those proceedings all the members of the claim group, except for Ms Wyatt and Mr Cooper, were able to participate in extensive mediations and conferrals with each other upon issues relating to the establishment of the trust, and were also afforded an opportunity to begin talking about a way of resolving contentious issues which had arisen between members of the claim group. All the members of the claim group, except for Ms Wyatt and Mr Cooper, reached a consensus about the terms of the trust deed to be adopted, the appointment of Plan B as trustee and the persons who should be appointed as initial advisory trustees of the trust. As a consequence, some of the members of the claim group who had previously been hostile towards the claim and who had been actively involved in its deregistration in 2006 are now prepared to support the claim with a view to its being re‑registered and progressing towards a determination of native title.