Affoo v Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Affoo & Anor v Public Trustee of Queensland [2011] QSC 309

PARTIES:

WILLIAM FREDERICK AFFOO AND RHONDA ANN AFFOO
(applicants)
v
PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND as the Legal Personal Representative of the Estate of Irene Joan Blair, deceased
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 11376 of 2003

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

24 October 2011

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 September 2011

JUDGE:

Dalton J

ORDER:

Application for Family Provision dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

Contracts – voidable for want of capacity – construction of condition precedent – contract immediately binding as to some obligations notwithstanding effect of s 59 Public Trustee Act 1978 – implied promise to make reasonable efforts to bring about fulfilment of condition precedent – implied term that condition precedent to be fulfilled within a reasonable time

Family provision application – does not abate on death – need for Court Order to finalise proceeding – significance of agreement between parties as to orders – effect of death of applicant after agreement as to orders – distinction between Court making final orders in family provision application and sanction pursuant to s 59 Public Trustee Act 1978

Sanction pursuant to s 59 Public Trustee Act 1978 – test to be applied on application – material relied upon by applicants

Public Trustee Act 1978 (Qld) s 59
Succession Act
1981 (Qld)

Bailey v Warren [2006] EWCA Civ 51
Bartlett v Coomber
[2008] NSWCA 100
Bourke v Bourke (No. 2) (1994) 18 Fam LR 1
Brennan v ECO Composting Ltd and Anor [2006] EWHC 3153 (QB)
Dietz v Lennig Chemicals Ltd
[1969] 1 AC 170
Drinkall v Whitwood
[2003] EWCA Civ 1547
Fisher v Marin
[2007] NSWSC 1411
Gibbons v Wright
(1954) 91 CLR 423
Groser v Equity Trustees Ltd (2008) 19 VR 598
King v Condon
[2009] 2 Qd R 143
Kirk v Kirk [2002] QSC 310
Lieberman v Morris (1944) 69 CLR 69
McKenzie v Lucas [2010] NSWSC 1083
Mitchell v Osborne
, unreported decision Supreme Court of New South Wales Equity Division, Young J, 20 May 1997, BC 9702446
Perri v Coolangatta Investments Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 537
Read v Nicholls
[2004] VSC 66
Reid v Moreland Timber Co Pty Ltd
(1946) 73 CLR 1
Re Hatte
[1943] St. R. Qd. 1
Re Shannon
(1935) 35 SR (NSW) 516
Re Wardle
(1979) 22 SASR 139
Smallman v Smallman
[1972] Fam. 25
Smith v Butler [1900] 1 QB 694
Smith v Smith
(1986) 161 CLR 217
Sprott v Harper
[2000] QCA 391
Total Gas Marketing Ltd v Arco British Ltd and Ors [1998] 2 Ll Rep 209
Underwood v Underwood
[2009] QSC 107

COUNSEL:

NJ Thompson for the applicants
RT Whiteford for the Public Trustee

SOLICITORS:

Parker Family Law for the applicants
Official Solicitor to the Public Trustee for the Public Trustee

  1. DALTON J:  Mr Edward Blair was born in 1915.  He married in 1937 and had five children before divorcing in 1954.  In 1971 he married again, his second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Affoo v Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QSC 309
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Affoo v Public Trustee of Queensland was heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland. The deceased, Affoo, had made a will leaving the bulk of his estate to the Public Trustee of Queensland. Affoo's daughter, the applicant, brought an application under the Family Provision Act 1908 (Qld) seeking a Court Order for the Public Trustee to provide for her from the estate. The applicant later brought a separate application under the Public Trustee Act 1978 (Qld) seeking a sanction to require the Public Trustee to dispose of a property in accordance with the deceased's will. The deceased passed away before the Court made a final order in the family provision application.

The Court was required to determine the effect of the deceased's death on the family provision application, whether an agreement between the parties as to orders could be enforced, and the test to be applied in making a sanction order under the Public Trustee Act. The Court also needed to consider the implied terms in the contract between the deceased and the Public Trustee and whether a condition precedent had been fulfilled within a reasonable time.

The Court found that the family provision application did not abate on the deceased's death and that the agreement between the parties as to orders could be enforced. However, the Court distinguished between making final orders in a family provision application and sanctioning a disposition under the Public Trustee Act. The Court held that a condition precedent in a contract could be binding notwithstanding the effect of s 59 of the Public Trustee Act, and that there was an implied term that the condition precedent be fulfilled within a reasonable time. The Court found that the Public Trustee had not breached the contract by failing to dispose of the property in accordance with the deceased's will, and dismissed the applicant's application for Family Provision.

The Court dismissed the application for Family Provision and made no order in relation to the sanction application. The Court held that the family provision application did not abate on the death of the applicant and that an agreement between the parties as to orders could be enforced. However, the Court distinguished between making final orders in a family provision application and sanctioning a disposition under the Public Trustee Act. The Court found that the Public Trustee had not breached the contract by failing to dispose of the property in accordance with the deceased's will, and dismissed the applicant's application for Family Provision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application for Family Provision dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a family provision application initiated by the plaintiffs, Affoo, against the Public Trustee of Queensland. The plaintiffs sought provisions from the estate of their deceased mother, who had executed a will leaving her estate to the Public Trustee of Queensland, subject to a condition precedent that she had to be alive on the date of the order of the Supreme Court approving the will. The plaintiffs argued that the will should be void due to their mother's lack of testamentary capacity. The Public Trustee applied for a sanction under section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978 to give effect to the terms of the will, which was opposed by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs' mother passed away during the pendency of the proceedings. The dispute centred on whether the family provision application should abate upon the death of the applicant and the implications of an agreement between the parties regarding the orders to be made.

The matter came before the court on an application for family provision and a counter-application by the Public Trustee seeking a sanction under section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978. The proceedings began with the plaintiffs filing a family provision application against the Public Trustee. The Public Trustee responded by applying for a sanction to give effect to the terms of the will. Both parties entered into an agreement regarding the orders to be made, but the plaintiffs' mother died before the orders were finalised. The court had to determine whether the family provision application should continue and what orders should be made regarding the estate in light of the mother's death and the agreement between the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the family provision application abate on the death of the applicant?
2. What is the need for a Court Order to finalise the proceeding?
3. What is the significance of the agreement between the parties as to the orders?
4. What is the effect of the death of the applicant after the agreement as to orders?
5. What is the distinction between the Court making final orders in a family provision application and the sanction pursuant to section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978?
6. What test should be applied on an application for a sanction under section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978?
7. What material did the applicants rely upon in their application?

Held
1. The family provision application does not abate on the death of the applicant.
2. A Court Order is needed to finalise the proceeding.
3. The agreement between the parties as to the orders is significant in finalising the proceeding.
4. The death of the applicant after the agreement as to orders does not affect the need for a Court Order.
5. There is a distinction between the Court making final orders in a family provision application and the sanction pursuant to section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978.
6. The test to be applied on an application for a sanction under section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978 involves considering the material relied upon by the applicants.
7. The applicants relied on specific material in their application for a sanction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the implications of a contract voidable for want of capacity, focusing on the construction of a condition precedent. It noted that such a contract could still be immediately binding as to some obligations, despite the effect of section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978. The court implied a promise to make reasonable efforts to bring about the fulfilment of the condition precedent, as well as an implied term that the condition precedent should be fulfilled within a reasonable time. Regarding the family provision application, the court held that it does not abate on the death of the applicant, emphasizing the necessity of a Court Order to finalise the proceeding. The court also underscored the significance of the agreement between the parties concerning the orders. The effect of the applicant's death after reaching an agreement on orders did not negate the requirement for a Court Order. The distinction between the Court making final orders in a family provision application and the sanction pursuant to section 59 of the Public Trustee Act 1978 was explored, highlighting different legal contexts and consequences. The test for a sanction under section 59 was applied by examining the material relied upon by the applicants, which included specific considerations and evidence presented. The court's decision to dismiss the Family Provision application and the reliance on the presented material were key outcomes of the case.