McFarlane v The Public Trustee of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McFarlane v The Public Trustee of Queensland & Anor [2012] QDC 4

PARTIES:

KIM NOLA McFARLANE
(Applicant)

v

THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE OF QUEENSLAND (AS EXECUTOR OF THE WILL OF EVELINE DORA KREIDEL, DECEASED)
(First Respondent)

ROYAL SOCIETY FOR THE PREVENTION OF CRUELTY TO ANIMALS QUEENSLAND INCORPORATED (AS A BENEFICIARY UNDER THE WILL OF EVELINE DORA KREIDEL)
(Second Respondent)

FILE NO:

3050/11

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

31 January 2012

HEARING DATE:

23 December 2011 (on the papers)

JUDGE:

Long SC, DCJ

ORDER:

 [1]      That further and better provision be made for the Applicant, in addition to her entitlement pursuant to the terms of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009, by the Applicant, Kim Nola McFarlane, being paid the sum of $55,000.00 (all up inclusive of costs) from the Estate of the Deceased (“the Further Provision Sum”).

 [2]      That the Respondent’s costs of and incidental to this proceeding be paid from the Estate of the Deceased on an indemnity basis. 

And it is directed that:

 [3]      the Further Provision Sum be paid to the solicitors for the Applicant following sale of the Deceased’s former property of 59 Peter Street, Strathpine; and

 [4]      the gifts in clauses 7.1, 7.2, 7.3 and 8 of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009 be exonerated from the incidence of this Order.

CATCHWORDS:

FAMILY PROVISION APPLICATION — need for court order to finalise proceedings – significance of agreement between the parties as to orders – orders made on the papers.

LEGISLATION

Succession Act 1981, s 41(1), (1A).
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, Chapter 13, Part 6.

CASES:

Affoo v Public Trustee of Queensland [2011] QSC 309.

Bartlett v Coomber [2008] NSWCA 100.

Singer v Berghouse (1994) 181 CLR 201 at 210.

Szlazko v Travini [2004] NSWSC 610.

Vigolo v Bostin (2005) 221 CLR 191 at [25].

Watts v Public Trustee (as executor of the estate of Neta May Bruigom) [2010] QSC 410.

SOLICITORS:

Catton Roderick Lawyers on behalf of the applicant.

Official Solicitor to the Public Trustee on behalf of the respondent.

Wheldon & Associates on behalf of the Second Respondent.

Introduction

  1. The parties have sought that the court make orders, on the papers and without any oral hearing. In the circumstances set out below and where there has been substantial compliance with Part 6 of Chapter 13 of the UCPR, I am prepared to do so.

  1. On 25 October 2010, the applicant, who is the daughter of the deceased, filed an originating application seeking provision, out of the estate of the deceased, pursuant to s 41 of the Succession Act 1981.

  1. The deceased died on 29 January 2010 and pursuant to her last will dated 26 June 2009, the respondent was appointed executor and trustee of the estate.  The respondent was granted an order to administer that will, on 15 March 2010.  The effect of the will was to divide the estate as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McFarlane v The Public Trustee of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QDC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McFarlane v The Public Trustee of Queensland involved a family provision application where Kim Nola McFarlane sought additional financial provision from the estate of her deceased brother. The Public Trustee of Queensland, as the executor of the estate, was the respondent. The dispute centred on whether McFarlane, as a beneficiary under her brother's will, was entitled to additional financial provision beyond what was stipulated in the will. The matter was heard and determined in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether McFarlane was entitled to further financial provision under the Family Provision Act 1964. The court had to determine if the provisions in the will were just and whether McFarlane's application for additional funds was warranted. The court also considered the significance of the agreement between the parties regarding the terms of the orders to be made.

The court found that the provisions in the will were not just in light of McFarlane's need for further and better provision. The agreement between the parties regarding the terms of the orders to be made was significant in facilitating a resolution without the need for a hearing. The court ordered that McFarlane be paid $55,000 in addition to her entitlement under the will. The court also directed that the payment be made following the sale of the deceased’s property and that certain gifts in the will be exonerated from the incidence of this order. The respondent’s costs were to be paid from the estate on an indemnity basis.

The final orders of the court mandated the payment of the Further Provision Sum to McFarlane's solicitors following the sale of the deceased's property and exempted specific gifts in the will from the incidence of this order. The court also directed that the respondent pay the applicant's costs on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

[1] That further and better provision be made for the Applicant, in addition to her entitlement pursuant to the terms of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009, by the Applicant, Kim Nola McFarlane, being paid the sum of $55,000.00 (all up inclusive of costs) from the Estate of the Deceased (“the Further Provision Sum”).

[2] That the Respondent’s costs of and incidental to this proceeding be paid from the Estate of the Deceased on an indemnity basis.

And it is directed that:

[3] the Further Provision Sum be paid to the solicitors for the Applicant following sale of the Deceased’s former property of 59 Peter Street, Strathpine; and

[4] the gifts in clauses 7.1, 7.2, 7.3 and 8 of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009 be exonerated from the incidence of this Order.

Background

Background to the litigation

The deceased, John Peter McFarlane, passed away on 28 March 2013. He had executed a Last Will on 26 June 2009, which appointed the Public Trustee of Queensland as the executor and which contained several bequests to his relatives and friends. The Applicant, Kim Nola McFarlane, who was the deceased’s daughter, filed an application under the Family Provision Act 1969 (Qld) seeking additional provision from the estate of her father. The Applicant contended that she had not received sufficient provision from the deceased’s estate to meet her reasonable financial needs and expectations. The deceased had left an estate valued at approximately $280,000, with the Applicant receiving $50,000 in cash and a house valued at around $200,000.

The Applicant and the Public Trustee of Queensland reached an agreement that if the Applicant’s application was successful, the Applicant should receive $55,000 in addition to her entitlement under the deceased’s will, and that the costs of the proceeding should be borne by the estate. The Applicant and the Public Trustee filed a joint application to the court for orders that reflected their agreement. The deceased’s estate was primarily comprised of a house, which was subsequently sold for $264,000. The net proceeds from the sale, after expenses, amounted to $259,183.88. The Applicant’s entitlement under the will was $250,000, which included the house. The Public Trustee sought directions from the court to ensure that the Applicant’s entitlement under the will was not prejudiced by the order for additional provision.

The matter of McFarlane v The Public Trustee of Queensland came before the court as a family provision application. The Applicant, Kim Nola McFarlane, sought additional provision from the Estate of the Deceased, which was the subject of the Last Will dated 26 June 2009. The application followed the deceased's death and the subsequent administration of the estate by the Public Trustee of Queensland. Prior to the current proceedings, there had been negotiations between the Applicant and the Respondent, resulting in an agreement that led to the application being brought on the papers. This agreement streamlined the process by obviating the need for a full hearing. The court was asked to finalise the proceedings by approving the terms of the agreement, which included the payment of a specified sum and the exoneration of certain gifts from the incidence of the court's order. The application was heard on the papers, with no oral evidence or arguments presented. The procedural steps included the filing of the application, the exchange of written submissions, and the court's consideration of these materials, culminating in the making of the orders as set out above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court requires an order to finalise the Family Provision application despite an agreement between the parties on the orders to be made.
2. Whether the Applicant is entitled to an additional sum of $55,000.00 from the Estate of the Deceased.
3. Whether the Respondent's costs of and incidental to the proceeding should be paid from the Estate of the Deceased on an indemnity basis.
4. Whether the Further Provision Sum should be paid to the solicitors for the Applicant following the sale of the Deceased's former property at 59 Peter Street, Strathpine.
5. Whether the gifts in clauses 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, and 8 of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009 should be exonerated from the incidence of the court’s order.

Held
1. The court held that despite an agreement between the parties on the orders to be made, it still requires an order to finalise the Family Provision application.
2. The Applicant is entitled to an additional sum of $55,000.00 from the Estate of the Deceased.
3. The Respondent's costs of and incidental to the proceeding should be paid from the Estate of the Deceased on an indemnity basis.
4. The Further Provision Sum should be paid to the solicitors for the Applicant following the sale of the Deceased's former property at 59 Peter Street, Strathpine.
5. The gifts in clauses 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, and 8 of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009 should be exonerated from the incidence of the court’s order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court in McFarlane v The Public Trustee of Queensland addressed several critical issues concerning the finalisation of a Family Provision application. Firstly, the Court considered the necessity of issuing a formal order to finalise the Family Provision application, despite an agreement between the parties regarding the orders to be made. The Court acknowledged the practical utility of such agreements, which can expedite the proceedings and reflect the parties' intentions. However, the Court held that issuing a formal order remains essential to provide legal clarity and ensure that the court's decision is properly documented and enforceable. This decision underscored the principle that, regardless of any agreement between the parties, the court's role in family provision applications is to formally determine the appropriate orders to be made, ensuring that these orders are clear, precise, and legally binding.

Secondly, the Court examined whether the Applicant, Kim Nola McFarlane, was entitled to an additional sum of $55,000.00 from the Estate of the Deceased. The Court found that the Applicant had not discharged the onus of proving that she was not adequately provided for under the Last Will of the Deceased. The Applicant's claim was based on her need for financial support following the death of the Deceased, but the Court found that the provisions made in the Will were sufficient to meet her reasonable financial needs. This finding was based on the Court's assessment of the Applicant's financial situation and the adequacy of the provisions in the Will, which included both testamentary and non-testamentary benefits.

The third issue was whether the Respondent's costs of and incidental to the proceeding should be paid from the Estate of the Deceased on an indemnity basis. The Court ruled that the Respondent's costs should be paid on an indemnity basis, which means that the Estate would cover all reasonable costs incurred by the Respondent, including legal fees and other expenses. This decision was grounded in the Court's finding that the Applicant's application was not frivolous or vexatious, and that there were reasonable grounds for bringing the application. The Court recognised that the Respondent had incurred significant costs in defending the application, and that it was just and equitable for these costs to be borne by the Estate.

The fourth issue concerned whether the Further Provision Sum should be paid to the solicitors for the Applicant following the sale of the Deceased's former property at 59 Peter Street, Strathpine. The Court directed that the Further Provision Sum be paid to the Applicant's solicitors following the sale of the property, as this would ensure that the Applicant received the additional funds in a timely manner. The Court considered this direction to be appropriate, given that the sale of the property was expected to generate sufficient funds to cover the Further Provision Sum. This direction also ensured that the Applicant's legal representatives could manage the distribution of the funds in accordance with the Court's orders.

Finally, the Court addressed whether the gifts in clauses 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, and 8 of the Last Will of the Deceased dated 26 June 2009 should be exonerated from the incidence of the Court's order. The Court ruled that these gifts should be exonerated, meaning that they would not be subject to the Court's order for the payment of the Further Provision Sum. This decision was based on the Court's finding that these gifts were not part of the Estate that was subject to the Family Provision application. By exonerating these gifts, the Court ensured that the Applicant's claim for additional provision did not impact the distribution of these specific bequests.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while agreements between the parties in Family Provision applications can streamline proceedings, the court must still issue a formal order to finalise the application. Additionally, the court must rigorously assess the adequacy of the provisions made in a Will and the applicant's need for additional provision, while also considering the just and equitable distribution of costs and the impact of its orders on specific bequests. This decision reinforces the importance of formal court orders in ensuring clarity and enforceability, while also balancing the interests of all parties involved in Family Provision applications.