McKenzie v Lucas

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
CITATION: McKenzie v Lucas [2010] NSWSC 1083
HEARING DATE(S): 15 September 2010
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

15 September 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Bryson AJ at 1
DECISION: 1.I grant leave to the plaintiff to file an amended summons joining Brian Dewing as executor of Estate Late Susan Dewing as 5th defendant.
2.Save as aforesaid, dismiss notice of motion
3.Order that applicants pay the respondents’ costs of the notice of motion.
CATCHWORDS: FAMILY PROVISION - agreement to settle claim - three defendants associated with will beneficiary claimed orders awarding provision to plaintiff and disposing of proceedings on basis of alleged agreement in correspondence between solicitors for these parties - executors (also defendants) were not parties to this correspondence and did not support the alleged agreement - consideration of lack of enforceability of agreements to settle Family Provision claims unless an order has been made under Family Provision Act section 7 - on the facts, an order should not be based on the alleged agreement because the facts underlying the offer changed when principal will beneficiary died after the plaintiff's offer was made and before acceptance - on the terms of the letters there was no formation of contract by offer and acceptance - enforcement of alleged agreement was refused.
LEGISLATION CITED: Family Provision Act 1982 section 7
CATEGORY: Consequential orders
CASES CITED: Bartlett v Coomber [2008] NSWCA 100
PARTIES: Katrina McKenzie (Plaintiff)
Paul Lucas (1st Defendant)
Roderick Cummings (2nd Defendant)
Susanjohn Pty Ltd (3rd Defendant)
Slackks Pty Ltd (4th Defendant)
Brian Dewing (5th Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2009/289129
COUNSEL: Plaintiff/respondent: Ms Harstein / Ms Pringle
1st and 2nd Def/respondents: Mr R O’Neill
3rd, 4th and 5th Def/applicants: Mr Ellison SC
SOLICITORS: Pl: Hansons Lawyers
1st, 2nd Def/respondents: Coleman & Greig
3rd, 4th, 5th Def/applicants: MCG Lawyers,


IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
PROBATE LIST

BRYSON AJ

Wednesday 15 September 2010

SC 2008/289129 Katrina McKENZIE v Paul LUCAS & Ors

1 HIS HONOUR: In these proceedings the plaintiff claims provision under the Family Provision Act 1982 out of the estate of her late father. There have been several other claims in that estate some of which have been settled, and the plaintiff's claim and the other remaining claim are to be heard by an associate judge later in this month.

2 The first and second defendants have obtained probate of the Will of her late father. Susanjohn Pty Limited the third defendant, described as trustee of the Slackks Superannuation Fund, the fourth defendants Slackks Pty Limited and the fifth defendant Susan Dewing appear to be entitled to all or most of the assets in the estate unless the dispositions made by the Will are disturbed.

3 The third, fourth and fifth defendants are in a general way associated in interest. They apply by notice of motion of 10 September 2010 for a number of orders. First they apply for orders which substitute Mr Brian Dewing as fifth defendant in place of Susan Dewing. Mr Brian Dewing obtained probate of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McKenzie v Lucas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 1083
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McKenzie v Lucas, the dispute involved a claim under the Family Provision Act 1969 (Vic) for provision out of the estate of a deceased individual. The plaintiff sought an order for provision from three defendants associated with a beneficiary of the deceased's will, arguing that an agreement to settle the claim existed based on correspondence between their solicitors. The executors of the estate, who were also defendants, were not parties to the correspondence and did not support the agreement. The court was required to determine whether the alleged agreement was enforceable and could form the basis of the order sought.

The court examined whether the agreement to settle was enforceable in light of the requirement for orders under the Family Provision Act to be made before agreements to settle could be enforced. The court also considered whether there was a valid contract between the parties, which would require an offer, acceptance, and consideration. The court found that the executors were not bound by the correspondence between the plaintiff's solicitors and the defendant's solicitors because they were not parties to the agreement. Additionally, the court found that the facts underlying the offer changed when the principal beneficiary of the will died after the plaintiff's offer was made and before acceptance. The court concluded that there was no formation of a contract by offer and acceptance on the terms of the letters, and therefore, the enforcement of the alleged agreement was refused.

The court held that the plaintiff's claim for an order based on the alleged agreement was not successful, and the application was dismissed. The court did not make any orders regarding provision for the plaintiff from the estate of the deceased. The court's decision highlights the importance of clear and binding agreements when settling Family Provision claims and the need for executors to be involved in any settlement discussions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of McKenzie v Lucas concerns a claim under the Family Provision Act 1969 (Qld). The plaintiff, McKenzie, sought provision from the estate of her deceased father, who had passed away leaving a will. The will left the majority of the estate to three defendants, who were associated with a beneficiary under the will. McKenzie's claim was based on her belief that the will did not adequately provide for her and other family members. During the proceedings, the three defendants associated with the will beneficiary claimed orders that would award McKenzie provision, and sought to dispose of the proceedings based on an alleged agreement in correspondence between the solicitors of these parties. However, the executors of the estate, who were also defendants in the case, were not parties to this correspondence and did not support the alleged agreement. The correspondence in question suggested a settlement agreement whereby McKenzie would receive a certain amount from the estate. However, the principal will beneficiary passed away after McKenzie's offer was made and before any acceptance was made, leading to a change in the underlying facts of the offer.

This case came before the court as a result of McKenzie's application for family provision from the estate of her deceased father. The three defendants associated with the will beneficiary filed a response to McKenzie's claim and sought to dispose of the proceedings based on the alleged agreement in correspondence between their solicitors. The executors of the estate, who were also defendants, opposed the enforcement of the alleged agreement. The matter proceeded to a hearing where the court considered the enforceability of the alleged settlement agreement. The court's decision focused on whether the alleged agreement could be enforced, given that the executors were not parties to the correspondence and did not support the agreement, and whether the agreement was legally binding under the Family Provision Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Can an agreement to settle a Family Provision claim be enforced if the executors of the estate were not parties to the correspondence and did not support the agreement?
2. Does the alleged agreement constitute a valid and enforceable contract under the Family Provision Act?
3. Was there a formation of contract by offer and acceptance on the terms of the letters exchanged between the solicitors?
4. Does the change in the underlying facts of the offer, due to the death of the principal will beneficiary, affect the enforceability of the alleged agreement?

Held
1. The court concluded that an agreement to settle a Family Provision claim cannot be enforced if the executors of the estate were not parties to the correspondence and did not support the agreement.
2. The court found that the alleged agreement did not constitute a valid and enforceable contract under the Family Provision Act.
3. The court determined that there was no formation of contract by offer and acceptance on the terms of the letters exchanged between the solicitors.
4. The court held that the change in the underlying facts of the offer, due to the death of the principal will beneficiary, affects the enforceability of the alleged agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the requirements for enforcing an agreement to settle a Family Provision claim. It noted that under the Family Provision Act, such agreements are generally not enforceable unless an order has been made under section 7 of the Act. The court held that, in this case, the executors of the estate were not parties to the correspondence between the solicitors, and they did not support the alleged agreement. As such, the court concluded that the agreement could not be enforced.

In considering whether the alleged agreement constituted a valid and enforceable contract, the court turned to the principles of contract law. It examined the terms of the letters exchanged between the solicitors to determine if there was a formation of contract by offer and acceptance. The court found that, on the facts, there was no such formation of contract. Additionally, the court noted that the underlying facts of the offer had changed when the principal will beneficiary died after the plaintiff's offer was made and before acceptance. Consequently, the court held that the change in facts affected the enforceability of the alleged agreement.

The court also considered relevant authorities and case law on the enforceability of agreements to settle Family Provision claims. It distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasising the importance of executors being parties to the correspondence and supporting the agreement. The court ultimately concluded that an order should not be based on the alleged agreement, as the necessary conditions for enforceability were not met. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an agreement to settle a Family Provision claim cannot be enforced if the executors of the estate were not parties to the correspondence and did not support the agreement, and that changes in the underlying facts of the offer can affect the enforceability of such an agreement.