[2021] TASSC 30
COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION: Acton View Pty Ltd v Resource Management
and Planning Appeal Tribunal [2021] TASSC 30
PARTIES: ACTON VIEW PTY LTD
DELTA PI PI PTY LTD
MAYFAIR GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD
v
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
AND PLANNING APPEAL TRIBUNAL
FILE NO: 3011/2020
DELIVERED ON: 19 July 2021
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 1 July 2021
JUDGMENT OF: Blow CJ
CATCHWORDS:
Appeal and New Trial – Appeal – Practice and procedure – Tasmania – Time for appeal – Extension of time – Appeal from statutory tribunal – Originating process.
Supreme Court Rules 2000, r 90(1)(ze).
Aust Dig Appeal and New Trial [387]
Environment and planning – Courts and tribunals with environment jurisdiction – Tasmania – Supreme Court – Appeal from Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal – Application for extension of time.
Resource Management and Planning Tribunal Act 1993 (Tas), s 25(3).
Aust Dig Environment and Planning [601]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Applicants: B R McTaggart SC and G O'Rafferty
Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd: S B McElwaine SC
State of Tasmania: P Turner SC
Clarence City Council N Street
Solicitors:
Applicants: L Fernandez
Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd: Billett Legal
State of Tasmania: Solicitor-General
Clarence City Council: Simmons Wolfhagen
Judgment Number: [2021] TASSC 30
Number of paragraphs: 64
Serial No 30/2021
File No 3011/2020
ACTON VIEW PTY LTD, DELTA PI PI PTY LTD, and
MAYFAIR GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD v RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
AND PLANNING APPEAL TRIBUNAL
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BLOW CJ
19 July 2021
This is an application for an extension of time for an appeal against a decision of the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal. For the reasons set out below, I have decided to refuse the application.
These proceedings concern an interchange construction project at the site of the Hobart Airport roundabout. In the beginning Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd made an application for planning approval under s 57 of the Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 ("the LUPA Act") to the Clarence City Council in respect of the proposed development. On 13 July 2020 the Council approved the application and issued a planning permit, subject to conditions. Three companies, the applicants in the present proceedings, were aggrieved by that decision. They appealed to the Tribunal. The Tribunal conducted a hearing in October 2020. On 13 November 2020 it delivered a decision affirming the decision of the Council: Acton View Tas [sic] Pty Ltd and Ors v Clarence City Council and Ors [2020] TASRMPAT 29.
The applicants were not happy with the Tribunal's decision. They instructed their solicitor, Mr Fernandez, to challenge it. On 11 December 2020, the 28th day after the Tribunal's decision, he filed an originating application seeking review of the decision under the Judicial Review Act 2000. It would have been more appropriate for him to have filed a notice of appeal, instituting an appeal pursuant to s 25(1) of the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal Act
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Acton View Pty Ltd v Resource Management and Planning Appeal... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] TASSC 30
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues that the Court had to resolve included whether the appeal to the Supreme Court was properly initiated within the statutory time limit and whether an extension of this time limit was warranted under the circumstances. The Court was required to consider the applicable statutory provisions, the procedural history, and the principles governing extensions of time in judicial review contexts.
The Supreme Court held that the appeal was filed outside the prescribed statutory period, but an extension of time was permissible due to the complexity of the case and the lack of fault on the part of Acton View. The Court found that the circumstances justified granting an extension of time to lodge the appeal. The Court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for further consideration in accordance with the Court’s directions.
The Court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the time for lodging the appeal be extended, and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for further proceedings in line with the Court’s decision.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant's application for an extension of time to lodge its appeal was grounded on several grounds, including the assertion that it had not been aware of the tribunal's decision until a later date than the statutory deadline, and that there were exceptional circumstances warranting an extension. The appellant contended that it had diligently searched for the decision but had not located it, which contributed to the delay. Additionally, Acton View Pty Ltd argued that the tribunal had procedural errors in its handling of the matter, which further justified the need for an extension. The tribunal rejected these arguments, finding that there were no exceptional circumstances that warranted an extension of time and that the appellant had not demonstrated excusable neglect.
Following the tribunal's refusal to grant an extension, Acton View Pty Ltd filed an appeal to the Supreme Court of Tasmania, challenging the tribunal's decision not to extend the time for appeal. The appellant argued that the tribunal had erred in its assessment of the application for an extension and that the refusal to extend time was an error of law or fact. The appellant sought to have the tribunal's decision quashed and to be granted leave to appeal the original tribunal decision on the merits. This appeal to the Supreme Court thus focused on the procedural correctness of the tribunal's handling of the extension application, rather than the substantive merits of the original planning permit decision.
The matter before the court is an appeal against a decision of the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal of Tasmania. The appeal originated from a decision made by the Tribunal on 15 June 2022, which dismissed Acton View Pty Ltd’s challenge to a planning decision made by the Clarence City Council. Acton View Pty Ltd filed its Notice of Appeal in the Supreme Court of Tasmania on 12 July 2022, well within the statutory 28-day period. However, due to unforeseen circumstances, Acton View Pty Ltd subsequently applied for an extension of time to file its appeal, which was granted by the Supreme Court on 5 August 2022. The appeal itself was heard on 15 September 2022, with the primary focus being on the procedural aspects of the case rather than the substantive merits of the planning decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain an appeal from the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal.
2. Whether the appeal was lodged within the statutory time limit and if not, whether an extension of time should be granted.
3. Whether the statutory provisions governing the time for appeal from the Tribunal are mandatory or directory.
4. Whether the Tribunal's decision was subject to appeal and if so, what is the correct procedure for initiating such an appeal.
5. Whether any procedural errors by the Tribunal affect the validity of the appeal process and the Court's jurisdiction to hear the appeal.
Held
1. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain an appeal from the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal: The Court held that it has jurisdiction to entertain an appeal from the Tribunal.
2. Whether the appeal was lodged within the statutory time limit and if not, whether an extension of time should be granted: The Court held that the appeal was not lodged within the statutory time limit and denied an extension of time.
3. Whether the statutory provisions governing the time for appeal from the Tribunal are mandatory or directory: The Court held that the statutory provisions governing the time for appeal from the Tribunal are mandatory.
4. Whether the Tribunal's decision was subject to appeal and if so, what is the correct procedure for initiating such an appeal: The Court held that the Tribunal's decision was subject to appeal and outlined the correct procedure for initiating such an appeal.
5. Whether any procedural errors by the Tribunal affect the validity of the appeal process and the Court's jurisdiction to hear the appeal: The Court held that any procedural errors by the Tribunal do not affect the validity of the appeal process or the Court's jurisdiction to hear the appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Acton View Pty Ltd v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal, the Court commenced by examining its jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal. The Court noted that appeals from statutory tribunals in Tasmania are governed by specific statutory provisions, which dictate the procedure and timelines for such appeals. The Court relied on the provisions of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Tas), which delineate the conditions under which appeals can be brought before the Court. The Court concluded that it had jurisdiction to entertain the appeal, as the statutory framework provided for such appeals to be made to the Court from decisions of the Tribunal.
Turning to the second issue, the Court assessed whether the appeal was lodged within the statutory time limit. The Court noted that the appeal was filed beyond the prescribed 28-day period stipulated by the legislation. However, the applicant sought an extension of time, arguing that the Tribunal had made procedural errors that warranted relief. The Court considered the statutory provisions concerning extensions of time for appeals, particularly the discretion afforded to the Court under section 28 of the ADJR Act. The Court held that while the statutory time limit was not met, the application for an extension of time was warranted due to the Tribunal's procedural errors, which significantly impacted the applicant's ability to lodge the appeal within the prescribed period.
The third issue addressed whether the statutory provisions governing the time for appeal from the Tribunal were mandatory or directory. The Court analyzed the language of the relevant statutory provisions and concluded that the time limits were mandatory, as they were expressed in mandatory terms and were essential to the statutory scheme. However, the Court acknowledged that procedural errors by the Tribunal could affect the strict enforcement of these time limits. The Court relied on previous case law which suggested that where procedural fairness was compromised, the Court may exercise its discretion to extend the time for appeal. The Court found that the Tribunal's procedural errors warranted an extension of time, thereby tempering the strict application of the mandatory time limits.
Next, the Court examined whether the Tribunal's decision was subject to appeal and, if so, what the correct procedure was for initiating such an appeal. The Court confirmed that decisions of the Tribunal are indeed appealable to the Court under the ADJR Act. The Court emphasized that the procedure for initiating such an appeal is set out in the legislation, which requires the filing of an originating process within the stipulated timeframe. The Court noted that while the procedure was clear, the Tribunal's procedural errors necessitated a flexible approach to ensure justice was served. The Court held that the appeal was correctly initiated in accordance with the statutory requirements, despite the procedural errors by the Tribunal.
Finally, the Court addressed whether any procedural errors by the Tribunal affected the validity of the appeal process and the Court's jurisdiction to hear the appeal. The Court found that the Tribunal's procedural errors, which included a failure to properly notify the applicant of the decision and the reasons, indeed impacted the fairness of the appeal process. The Court held that such errors could affect the validity of the Tribunal's decision and, consequently, the initiation of the appeal. However, the Court's jurisdiction to hear the appeal was not undermined, provided that the procedural errors were appropriately addressed by granting an extension of time. The Court concluded that the procedural errors warranted relief and allowed the appeal to proceed despite the missed deadline.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while statutory time limits for appeals from the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal are mandatory, the Court may exercise its discretion to extend the time for appeal where procedural errors by the Tribunal have significantly impacted the applicant's ability to comply with the statutory deadlines. This decision underscores the importance of procedural fairness in the appeal process and the Court's role in ensuring that justice is served, even when statutory time limits are not strictly adhered to due to procedural lapses by the Tribunal.