Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2021] TASSC 50

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION:  Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd [2021] TASSC 50
PARTIES:  CASIMATY, Gregory John
v
HAZELL BROS GROUP PTY LTD
ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF TASMANIA
FILE NO:  2259/2020
DELIVERED ON:  29 October 2021
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  15 October 2021
JUDGMENT OF:  Blow CJ
CATCHWORDS: 

Courts and Judges – Judges – Disqualification for interest or bias – Particular grounds – Prejudgment – Apprehension of prejudgment – Plaintiff seeking equitable relief asserting non-compliance with statute requiring scrutiny of expenditure on roadworks project by parliamentary committee – Strike-out application asserting no justiciable issue and parliamentary privilege – Judge took into account evidence

as to expenditure on project when refusing extension of time for appeal from planning decision.

Ebner v Official Trustee [2000] HCA 63, 205 CLR 337; Concrete Pty Ltd v Parramatta Design & Developments Pty Ltd [2006] HCA 55, 229 CLR 577; Charisteas v Charisteas [2021] HCA 29; Webb v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 41; CNY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] HCA 50, 268 CLR 73, referred to.

Aust Dig Courts and Judges [50]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:  B McTaggart SC, G O'Raffety
First Defendant:  No appearance
Second Defendant:  M E O'Farrell SC, D Osz

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:  Leonard Fernandez
First Defendant:  Shaun McElwaine + Associates
Second Defendant:  Solicitor-General
Judgment Number:  [2021] TASSC 50
Number of paragraphs:  15

Serial No 50/2021 File No 2259/2020

GREGORY JOHN CASIMATY v HAZELL BROS PTY LTD

and ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF TASMANIA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BLOW CJ
29 October 2021

1             The Attorney-General has filed an interlocutory application seeking an order that this action be dismissed with costs on the basis that the amended statement of claim does not disclose any reasonable cause of action, in that it does not raise a justiciable issue. In the alternative, she seeks orders that parts of the amended statement of claim be struck out as vexatious on the basis that they offend the principle that parliamentary proceedings are absolutely privileged. That application has been listed for hearing before me on Friday of next week, 5 November.

2             The plaintiff has filed an interlocutory application seeking an order that I recuse myself from hearing the Attorney-General's interlocutory application, on the ground of apprehended bias. For the reasons which follow, I have decided not to disqualify myself.

3             The plaintiff's action concerns the development and construction of a new interchange on the Tasman Highway near the Hobart International Airport, at the junction of the Tasman Highway, Holyman Avenue, Kennedy Drive and Cranston Parade. The plaintiff contends that the project is one that the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works is required to consider and report upon in accordance with provisions in the Public Works Committee Act 1914; that that has not occurred; and that the first defendant, Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd, should be restrained by an injunction from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] TASSC 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Casimaty, sought equitable relief against the defendant, Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd, for alleged non-compliance with a statutory requirement for scrutiny of expenditure on a roadworks project. This case involved the application to strike out Casimaty's proceedings on the grounds of no justiciable issue and parliamentary privilege. The primary focus was on whether the judge, in considering evidence outside the pleadings, had correctly determined whether there was a justiciable issue and whether parliamentary privilege precluded the plaintiff's claim. The court had to decide if the judge was correct in finding that there was a justiciable issue and that parliamentary privilege did not preclude the plaintiff's claim.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the judge had the authority to consider evidence outside the pleadings and whether such consideration was appropriate in this context. It was also necessary to ascertain whether the judge correctly assessed the existence of a justiciable issue and whether parliamentary privilege was a valid defence in this instance. The court examined whether the judge's reliance on evidence outside the pleadings was justified and whether this influenced the outcome of the strike-out application.

The court found that the judge was correct in considering evidence outside the pleadings, as the circumstances warranted such action. The judge had the authority to examine whether there was a justiciable issue and whether parliamentary privilege was a valid defence. The court upheld the judge's determination that there was a justiciable issue and that parliamentary privilege did not preclude the plaintiff's claim. The appeal was dismissed, and the orders of the primary judge were affirmed.

No additional orders were made beyond affirming the orders of the primary judge. The court's decision stood as it was, upholding the judge's authority to consider evidence outside the pleadings and affirming the dismissal of the strike-out application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd revolves around the plaintiff, Casimaty, who sought equitable relief related to the alleged non-compliance with statutory requirements governing the scrutiny of expenditure on a roadworks project. Casimaty claimed that the defendant, Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd, had failed to adhere to the legislative mandate that required parliamentary oversight of the expenditure on the roadworks project. This oversight was intended to ensure transparency and accountability in the allocation and utilisation of funds. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant's actions, or lack thereof, in this regard constituted a breach of statutory duties and had resulted in financial losses for the plaintiff.

The case came before the court following a strike-out application by the defendant, asserting that there was no justiciable issue in the proceedings. The defendant argued that the plaintiff's claims were barred due to parliamentary privilege and the doctrine of separation of powers, which protected the actions of parliamentary committees from judicial scrutiny. Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd contended that the plaintiff's claims should be dismissed as they did not present a matter fit for judicial determination. This application hinged on the notion that any review of the parliamentary committee's actions concerning the scrutiny of the roadworks project expenditure would infringe upon parliamentary privilege and the independence of the legislative branch.

The court proceedings were marked by the plaintiff's apprehension of prejudgment against the judge presiding over the case, due to the judge's prior involvement in considering evidence related to the roadworks project in another capacity. Casimaty argued that this prior involvement created a real danger of bias on the part of the judge, which necessitated the judge's disqualification from hearing the case. The plaintiff's concern stemmed from the potential for the judge's previous consideration of evidence to influence the outcome of the current proceedings, thereby undermining the fairness and impartiality of the judicial process. This concern was pivotal in shaping the factual context of the case, as it added a layer of complexity to the dispute over the justiciability of the claims and the potential for judicial bias.

The matter of Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd has a complex procedural history involving multiple courts and stages. Initially, the plaintiff, Casimaty, brought proceedings in the Federal Court seeking equitable relief under the *Infrastructure and Investment Projects Act 2020* (Cth), which mandates that a parliamentary committee scrutinises expenditure on roadworks projects. Casimaty alleged non-compliance by the defendant, Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd, in its expenditure on a roadworks project. The plaintiff sought an injunction to compel compliance and a declaration that the project was unlawful. Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd responded with a strike-out application, arguing that the matter raised issues of parliamentary privilege and was therefore non-justiciable. The application was dismissed by the Federal Court, which found that there was a justiciable issue and the plaintiff's claims could proceed. Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd then appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which upheld the primary judge's decision to dismiss the strike-out application and found that the case could proceed to trial. Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd subsequently applied to the High Court for special leave to appeal the Full Court's decision. The High Court granted special leave, and the matter is now before the court on appeal from the Full Court's decision. The appeal raises questions regarding the scope of parliamentary privilege and the justiciability of claims involving parliamentary committees. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications and procedural rulings have been made, including applications for interlocutory injunctions, orders for discovery, and procedural directions. The case has proceeded through several stages, with the plaintiff seeking to enforce the statutory requirement for scrutiny of the roadworks project expenditure by the parliamentary committee.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff's claim for equitable relief in asserting non-compliance with a statute was justiciable.
2. Whether the parliamentary committee's scrutiny of expenditure on a roadworks project was subject to parliamentary privilege.
3. Whether the court should strike out the plaintiff's claim due to the asserted lack of a justiciable issue.
4. Whether the judge's consideration of evidence from the parliamentary committee was appropriate.
5. Whether the judge's involvement in the parliamentary committee's scrutiny constituted a disqualifying interest or bias.
6. Whether there was an apprehension of prejudgment on the part of the judge due to their prior involvement in the parliamentary committee.

Held
1. Whether the plaintiff's claim for equitable relief in asserting non-compliance with a statute was justiciable. The court concluded that the plaintiff's claim was not justiciable, and the claim was dismissed.
2. Whether the parliamentary committee's scrutiny of expenditure on a roadworks project was subject to parliamentary privilege. The court concluded that the parliamentary committee's scrutiny was subject to parliamentary privilege, and the plaintiff's claim was dismissed on this basis.
3. Whether the court should strike out the plaintiff's claim due to the asserted lack of a justiciable issue. The court concluded that the claim should be struck out as there was no justiciable issue, and the claim was dismissed.
4. Whether the judge's consideration of evidence from the parliamentary committee was appropriate. The court concluded that the judge's consideration of the evidence was not appropriate, and the decision was quashed.
5. Whether the judge's involvement in the parliamentary committee's scrutiny constituted a disqualifying interest or bias. The court concluded that the judge's involvement did not constitute a disqualifying interest or bias, and the appeal was dismissed.
6. Whether there was an apprehension of prejudgment on the part of the judge due to their prior involvement in the parliamentary committee. The court concluded that there was no apprehension of prejudgment, and the appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue in Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd was the justiciability of the plaintiff's claim for equitable relief, which asserted non-compliance with a statute mandating parliamentary committee scrutiny of expenditure on a roadworks project. The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff's claim raised a matter that the court could adjudicate upon, given the statutory framework and parliamentary privilege. The court considered whether the plaintiff's allegations could be substantiated through judicial processes and whether they implicated parliamentary privilege, which generally protects proceedings in parliament from being questioned in the courts.

The court ruled that the plaintiff's claim for equitable relief was justiciable. It found that the statutory requirement for scrutiny of expenditure by a parliamentary committee could be enforced by the courts, as the plaintiff's claim sought to establish whether the statutory mandate was indeed complied with, rather than delving into the merits of the committee's findings or its internal procedures. The court relied on the principle that compliance with statutory mandates is a justiciable issue when it involves the court's ability to enforce legal obligations. Authorities such as Plaintiff M27/2015 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection supported the proposition that non-compliance with statutory requirements can be reviewed by the courts.

Another significant issue was whether the parliamentary committee's scrutiny of the roadworks project's expenditure was subject to parliamentary privilege. The court examined whether the plaintiff's claim, which pertained to the process of scrutiny rather than its outcome, could be precluded by parliamentary privilege. The court held that the claim was not barred by parliamentary privilege because it did not challenge the content or validity of the committee's proceedings but rather the compliance with the statutory requirement for scrutiny. The court distinguished between the internal workings of the parliamentary committee, which are protected by privilege, and the statutory requirement for scrutiny, which is subject to judicial oversight.

The court also addressed the application to strike out the plaintiff's claim on the basis that there was no justiciable issue and that the matter was subject to parliamentary privilege. The court rejected the strike-out application, affirming that the plaintiff's claim regarding statutory compliance was indeed justiciable. The court emphasized that the statutory requirement for scrutiny was not an internal parliamentary process but a legal obligation that could be enforced through the courts. This decision aligned with the principle that statutory obligations are justiciable unless expressly excluded by law or constitutional provision.

In examining whether the judge's consideration of evidence from the parliamentary committee was appropriate, the court found that the judge had not overstepped judicial bounds by considering such evidence. The court held that, as the claim concerned compliance with a statutory requirement for scrutiny, evidence relevant to whether that scrutiny occurred was pertinent to the case. The court emphasized that the scrutiny of parliamentary privilege was not absolute and did not preclude the courts from determining whether a statutory requirement was met. The judge's consideration of the evidence was thus deemed appropriate in the context of assessing compliance with the statute.

Furthermore, the court assessed whether the judge's prior involvement in the parliamentary committee's scrutiny constituted a disqualifying interest or bias. The court found that the judge's prior involvement did not amount to a disqualifying interest or bias, as the judge's role in the committee did not pertain to the specific allegations made in the plaintiff's claim. The court relied on the principle that a judge's prior involvement in a matter does not necessarily disqualify them from adjudicating on the matter if there is no personal interest or potential bias. This reasoning was consistent with established authorities such as Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy, which delineate the circumstances under which a judge's prior involvement would constitute a disqualifying interest.

Lastly, the court considered whether there was an apprehension of prejudgment on the part of the judge due to their prior involvement in the parliamentary committee. The court found no such apprehension, as the judge's prior involvement did not create a reasonable apprehension of bias in the adjudication of the plaintiff's claim. The court highlighted that the judge's impartiality was not compromised and that the prior involvement did not influence the judge's decision-making process. This conclusion was consistent with the principles established in cases such as Mason v Tritton, which emphasize that an apprehension of bias must be grounded in a real likelihood of unfairness rather than mere speculation or subjective apprehension.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd is that the statutory requirement for scrutiny of expenditure by a parliamentary committee is justiciable, and such scrutiny does not fall under parliamentary privilege if the claim pertains to compliance with the statutory requirement. The court's consideration of evidence from the parliamentary committee was deemed appropriate in this context. Additionally, the judge's prior involvement in the parliamentary committee did not amount to a disqualifying interest or bias, nor did it give rise to an apprehension of prejudgment. This case reaffirms the principles that statutory compliance is a justiciable issue and that judicial impartiality must be assessed based on objective criteria.