Abley and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

Abley and Comcare (Compensation) [2023] AATA 989 (1 May 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/4381

Re:Lynette Abley

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:L M Gallagher, Member

Date:1 May 2023

Place:Perth

I refuse the Applicant’s request that I recuse myself from the hearing of this application.

.............[Sgd]...........................................................

L M Gallagher, Member

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – recusal application – apprehended bias – application by Applicant for recusal of Member constituted to hear substantive application – test for apprehended bias in Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337 – whether a fair-minded lay observer would reasonably apprehend that the Member might not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the issues to be decided – Applicant alleged bias due to alleged conduct by Member – recusal grounds alleged by Applicant included alleged interruptions by the Member – Applicant’s previous Counsel alleged inappropriate facial expressions were made by the Member – missing portion of the transcript – non-disclosure of the Member’s qualifications/experience – asserted relationship between Member and Respondent’s Counsel – Applicant’s claims of apprehended bias not firmly established – no logical connection between alleged conduct and ability to determine the issues on their merits – application for recusal refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 2A, 33(1)(a), 33(1)(b), 42A(1)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – ss 5B, 14

CASES

ALA15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 30

Charisteas v Charisteas (2021) 393 ALR 389

Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337

Gambaro v Mobycom Mobile Pty Ltd (2019) 271 FCR 530

Isbester v Knox City Council (2015) 255 CLR 135

Johnson v Johnson (2000) 201 CLR 488

Jones (as President of the Victorian Farmers Federation Chicken Meat Group) v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and Another (2002) 76 ALD 424

JRL; Ex Parte CJL (1986) 161 CLR 342

Michael Wilson & Partners v Nicholls (2011) 244 CLR 427

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507

R v Magistrates' Court at Lilydale; Ex parte Ciccone [1973] VR 122

Rana v Department of Defence [2018] FCA 1642

SZRUI v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 80

Taylor and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] AATA19

Vakauta v Kelly (1989) 167 CLR 568

Vietnam Veterans’ Association of Australia (New South Wales Branch Inc) v Gallagher (1994) 52 FCR 34

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Legal Services Directions 2017 - Appendix D, paras [3]-[4]

REASONS FOR DECISION

L M Gallagher, Member

1 May 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 5 May 2020, the Respondent issued a determination which denied liability to pay compensation to the Applicant pursuant to section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act) in respect of “chronic fatigue/fibromyalgia” that the Applicant claims to have sustained in January 2016.

  2. On 31 May 2020, the Applicant requested a reconsideration of the above determination.

  3. On 30 June 2020, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abley and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 989
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant for the recusal of Member Gallagher from hearing substantive applications before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The Applicant alleged apprehended bias due to the Member's conduct during the hearing, including alleged interruptions, inappropriate facial expressions, a missing portion of the transcript, non-disclosure of the Member's qualifications, and an asserted relationship between the Member and the Respondent's counsel. The Respondent opposed the application for recusal.

The legal issue before the Tribunal was whether a fair-minded lay observer would reasonably apprehend that the Member might not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the issues to be decided, applying the test established in *Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy*. This required the Tribunal to consider the Applicant's specific allegations of bias against the Member's conduct and the surrounding circumstances.

The Tribunal applied the objective test for apprehended bias, considering whether the Applicant's claims of bias were firmly established and whether there was a logical connection between the alleged conduct and the Member's ability to determine the issues on their merits. The Tribunal found that many of the Applicant's allegations were not supported by the transcript or audio recordings of the hearing, and that the alleged conduct did not demonstrate prejudgment or a lack of impartiality. The Tribunal noted that it is important for justice to be seen to be done, but also for judicial officers to discharge their duty to sit and not encourage parties to seek disqualification to obtain a more favourable outcome.

The application for recusal was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent opposes the Applicant’s application for the recusal.[3][3]R2. RELEVANT BACKGROUND The Applicant had two applications before the Tribunal, applications 2020/4381 and 2020/5242. The substantive hearing of the above two matters was heard over two days on 26 October 2021 and 27 October 2021.[4] [4]No assertions of bias were made at the hearing. On 26 October 2021, application 2020/5242 was dismissed by consent pursuant to s 42A(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act). A Direction made 16 November 2021, directed the following:(a)The parties are to exchange a copy of the transcript of the hearing held on 26 and 27 October 2021;(b)On or before 7 December 2021 the Applicant is to file with the Tribunal written closing submissions and serve a copy on the Respondent;(c)On or before 4 January 2022 the Respondent is to file with the Tribunal written closing submissions and serve a copy on the Applicant; and (d)On or before 18 January 2022 the Applicant has leave to file with the Tribunal and serve a copy on the Respondent any written submissions in reply, or written notice that she does not intend to do so. On 22 November 2021, the Applicant’s representative received a copy of the transcript of the hearing on 26 and 27 October 2021.[5][5]A2, document 1, para [33]. On 30 November 2021, by request of the Applicant, an extension of time to file submissions was granted, as there was a delay in receiving the transcript. On 7 January 2022, the Applicant’s representative filed the Applicant’s closing submissions. On 17 January 2022, the Applicant’s representative notified the Tribunal that a section of the transcript was noted to have been omitted in the parties’ copy.[6] [6]A2, document 1, para [36]. Enquiries were made with the relevant transcript provider about the omission from the transcript. On 25 January 2022, the parties were provided with a corrected transcript including the omitted eight minutes of the transcript. On 31 January 2022, the Respondent filed its closing submissions. On 8 February 2022, the Applicant made a Freedom of Information (FOI) application requesting all documents relating to the transcription of the hearing on 26 and 27 October 2021 and also requested the audio files by way of email.[7] [7]A2, document 1, para [45]. On 14 February 2022, the Applicant filed amended closing submissions, having requested an extension of time in order to address additional evidence referred to in the corrected transcript.[8] [8]A2, document 23. The application for recusal was made on 24 February 2022, as outlined at para [5] above.[9][9]The Applicant was self-represented from April 2022 to December 2022, including the periods during which the matters at paras [24] and [25] below occurred, namely the Applicant’s FOI applications, several requests for extensions of time and submissions in support of her application were made.The Applicant’s representatives, Soul Legal, made the application for recusal on the Applicant’s behalf. On 3 April 2022, Soul Legal confirmed that the Applicant was self-represented for her recusal application and that it continued to represent her in relation to her substantive application. The Applicant said Soul Legal continued to assist her “where required” (A6, document 1, para [3]) including filing Dr John Henstridge’s report (A3), the preparation of the FOI Chronology (A6, document 3 “B”) and her reply submissions dated 14 November 2022 (A4): A6, para [4].On 1 December 2022, the Applicant said she was informed that “Soul Legal managed to secure alternate Counsel (Mr Graham Droppert SC)” to help with her recusal application, and that Soul Legal were “prepared to get on the record to represent [her]” before the Tribunal (A6 [9]).On 2 December 2022, Soul Legal advised that it had been instructed 1) to act for the Applicant in relation to her application for recusal and that 2) Mr Graham Droppert had been instructed as Counsel for the hearing of the recusal application. On 30 January 2023, the Applicant, through her representatives, wrote to the Acting President of the Tribunal requesting that “an independent senior member of the Tribunal be administratively allocated to handle the [recusal application]” noting the “voluminous evidence in support of the appearance of bias” and the announcement of “the intended dissolution of the Tribunal, recognising the issue with the independence of members appointed to the Tribunal.” On 13 February 2023, the President of the AAT refused the Applicant’s request on the basis that it was not in the interests of justice or the expeditious and efficient conduct of the proceeding.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In JRL[28], Mason J observed:It seems that the acceptance by this Court of the test of reasonable apprehension of bias in such cases as Watson and Livesey has led to an increase in the frequency of applications by litigants that judicial officers should disqualify themselves from sitting in particular cases on account of their participation in other proceedings involving one of the litigants or on account of conduct during the litigation. It needs to be said loudly and clearly that the ground of disqualification is a reasonable apprehension that the judicial officer will not decide the case impartially or without prejudice, rather than that he will decide the case adversely to one party. There may be many situations in which previous decisions of a judicial officer on issues of fact and law may generate an expectation that he is likely to decide issues in a particular case adversely to one of the parties. But this does not mean either that he will approach the issues in that case otherwise than with an impartial and unprejudiced mind in the sense in which that expression is used in the authorities or that his previous decisions provide an acceptable basis for inferring that there is a reasonable apprehension that he will approach the issues in this way. In cases of this kind, disqualification is only made out by showing that there is a reasonable apprehension of bias by reason of prejudgment and this must be “firmly established”… Although it is important that justice must be seen to be done, it is equally important that judicial officers discharge their duty to sit and do not, by acceding too readily to suggestions of appearance of bias, encourage parties to believe that by seeking the disqualification of a judge, they will have their case tried by someone thought to be more likely to decide the case in their favour.(Emphasis added.)(Citations omitted.)[28](1986) 161 CLR 342 at 352. EVIDENCE The recusal application was heard by way of an interlocutory hearing on 22 February 2023 in person at the Perth Registry. Mr Graham Droppert, SC, represented the Applicant as Counsel, instructed by Mr Kevin Wong of Soul Legal. Mr Ashley Burgess represented the Respondent as Counsel, instructed by Ms Claire Tota of HBA Legal. The Applicant was present at the interlocutory hearing; however she was not called by Mr Droppert to give evidence nor was she required for cross-examination. Mr Nugawela was also present at the hearing and gave oral evidence in answer to questions from myself. The Applicant’s and Mr Nugawela’s evidence is addressed under the Tribunal’s consideration of the Applicant’s grounds of recusal, where relevant. The Tribunal admitted the following documents into evidence at the interlocutory hearing: (a)Applicant's request to make a recusal application, dated 24 February 2022 (Exhibit A1);(b)Affidavit of Lynette Rosalie Abley In Support of Application for Member Gallagher to Recuse Herself, sworn 24 March 2022 (Exhibit A2);(c)Report of Dr John Henstridge, Chief Consultant Statistician - Abley/1 - Analysis of Hearing Outcomes, dated 17 October 2022 (Exhibit A3); (d)Applicant's Further Submissions In Reply pursuant to Directions of 27 October 2022 by Member Gallagher, dated 14 November 2022 (Exhibit A4); (e)Statement of Brian Nugawela in relation to the Recusal Application scheduled for 22 February 2023 at 10AM, dated 30 January 2023 (Exhibit A5); (f)Supplementary Affidavit of Lynette Rosalie Abley In Support of Application for Member Gallagher to Recuse Herself, sworn 30 January 2023 (Exhibit A6); (g)The Applicant's Letter to the Hon Justice Susan Kenny AM, Acting President of the AAT, dated 30 January 2023 (Exhibit A7); (h)Respondent's Submissions in Response to Applicant's Recusal Application, undated, filed 3 October 2022 (Exhibit R1); and (i)Respondent's Amended Submissions in Response to Applicant's Recusal Application, dated 16 February 2023 (Exhibit R2).

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 30 June 2020, the Respondent issued a reviewable decision affirming the determination made on 5 May 2020 (the Reviewable Decision). On 21 July 2020, the Applicant filed an application for review of the Reviewable Decision with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). APPLICATION FOR RECUSAL On 24 February 2022, the Applicant’s representative made an application that I recuse myself from this matter on the ground of apprehended bias.[1][1]A1. In support of the Applicant’s recusal application, she has provided two affidavits which are further discussed below.[2] [2]Being A2 and A6. The Respondent opposes the Applicant’s application for the recusal.[3][3]R2. RELEVANT BACKGROUND The Applicant had two applications before the Tribunal, applications 2020/4381 and 2020/5242. The substantive hearing of the above two matters was heard over two days on 26 October 2021 and 27 October 2021.[4] [4]No assertions of bias were made at the hearing. On 26 October 2021, application 2020/5242 was dismissed by consent pursuant to s 42A(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act). A Direction made 16 November 2021, directed the following:(a)The parties are to exchange a copy of the transcript of the hearing held on 26 and 27 October 2021;(b)On or before 7 December 2021 the Applicant is to file with the Tribunal written closing submissions and serve a copy on the Respondent;(c)On or before 4 January 2022 the Respondent is to file with the Tribunal written closing submissions and serve a copy on the Applicant; and (d)On or before 18 January 2022 the Applicant has leave to file with the Tribunal and serve a copy on the Respondent any written submissions in reply, or written notice that she does not intend to do so. On 22 November 2021, the Applicant’s representative received a copy of the transcript of the hearing on 26 and 27 October 2021.[5][5]A2, document 1, para [33]. On 30 November 2021, by request of the Applicant, an extension of time to file submissions was granted, as there was a delay in receiving the transcript. On 7 January 2022, the Applicant’s representative filed the Applicant’s closing submissions. On 17 January 2022, the Applicant’s representative notified the Tribunal that a section of the transcript was noted to have been omitted in the parties’ copy.[6] [6]A2, document 1, para [36]. Enquiries were made with the relevant transcript provider about the omission from the transcript. On 25 January 2022, the parties were provided with a corrected transcript including the omitted eight minutes of the transcript. On 31 January 2022, the Respondent filed its closing submissions. On 8 February 2022, the Applicant made a Freedom of Information (FOI) application requesting all documents relating to the transcription of the hearing on 26 and 27 October 2021 and also requested the audio files by way of email.[7] [7]A2, document 1, para [45]. On 14 February 2022, the Applicant filed amended closing submissions, having requested an extension of time in order to address additional evidence referred to in the corrected transcript.[8] [8]A2, document 23.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal has also taken into account the transcripts for both days of the substantive hearing on 26 and 27 October 2021, and the audio files for these two days. CONSIDERATION As the test for apprehended bias set out in Ebner is whether a fair-minded lay observer might “reasonably apprehend”[29] that a decision-maker might not bring an impartial mind “to the resolution of the issue he or she is to decide”, the issue for review in the Reviewable Decision necessarily warrants mention to inform the context of the present application. [29]That is, the test for whether a decision-maker should be disqualified for apprehended bias is an objective test, which does not require any demonstration that he or she is in fact biased. The sole remaining issue for the Tribunal’s consideration in the Applicant’s substantive application is whether the Applicant’s fibromyalgia condition was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment by the Commonwealth.[30][30]In accordance with s 5B of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).Member behaviour and conduct at substantive hearing The Applicant’s first claim in support of her application for recusal[31] appears to be made on the basis that such conduct suggests prejudgment of the nature and scope of the issues for review in the substantive application and/or (or indeed, in turn) prejudgment of its outcome.[31]See alleged conduct outlined at paras [27(a)] and [29(a)] above. Mr Nugawela’s statement includes his address of these matters, as follows:[32][32]A5.6. I make the following statements purely from my recollection and without consulting the transcript, audio materials, or any other materials.[33]7. I recall that [on the first day of the hearing] early in the course of developing a legal submission…[Member Gallagher]…kept interrupting my oral submission before I could get to the compound conclusion I was trying to make. It got to the point where I recall I had to say words to the effect “If I can just finish…”[34] [Member Gallagher] then immediately reacted to this in an emphatic, punctuated and loud way, explaining “Oh. My. Goodness.”[35] She then made a motion with her hand as if zipping her mouth[36] and gestured for me to continue making my submissions. I wondered at the time whether I had offended [Member Gallagher] in such a way as to prejudice my client’s interests, but resolved to continue.8. Later on the first day, [Member Gallagher] spoke over me a few times as I was trying to complete sentences, which led me to say [sic] “you first.”[37]9. On another particular occasion, I think still on the first day, she asked (in what I felt was a sarcastic tone) if she was “permitted” to ask a question,[38] to which I responded with words to the effect that I very much value the decision-maker’s very important questioning,[39] to which she responded in the same emphatic [sic] punctuated and declaratory way “I. Would. Have Thought. So.”[40]10. At the end of the hearing on the first day, I discussed with the Applicant what I thought were worrying signs that I had upset [Member Gallagher] who seemed not to be able to get over the upset. It was decided, on balance, to carry on the next day with my continued representation.11. On the second day, I recall the pattern repeating with [Member Gallagher] talking over me and then repeating the motion of zipping her mouth, locking it, and throwing away the key.[41] My client did not attend the second day of the hearing.12. Altogether, I recall her doing this mouth zipping motion at least twice, if not three times.[42] On one of the occasions, I recall saying to [Member Gallagher] “Ma’am does not need to be like that.”[43]…..(Emphasis added.)[33]At hearing, Mr Nugawela confirmed that he did not consult the transcript of hearing in preparing his affidavit even though it was available to him at that time.[34]These words do not appear in the transcript.[35]These words do not appear in the transcript. My words “Goodness me” appear in the transcript (transcript, p 64 at [40]. As for the words being emphatic, punctuated and loud as claimed, these comments were made in reference to words that were not stated and in any event, the audio recording demonstrates that the words that were stated (“Goodness me”) follow the general course of the dialogue between myself and Mr Nugawela that precedes them (transcript audio at 2:48:00). The exchange between myself and Mr Nugawela following my having said “Goodness me” demonstrates Mr Nugawela then went on for a substantial period to explain the Applicant’s position without interruption and the questions that followed were directed to better understand the argument put. The Respondent was then given an opportunity to address the same issues.[36]This did not occur and is not recorded in the transcript as having had occurred. In any event, Mr Nugawela’s statement alleges this motion (which did not occur) was directed to myself and followed by my gesture for Mr Nugawela to continue (A5, para [7]).[37]Mr Nugawela’s words “No, you first, ma’am” appear at transcript, p 67 at [25]. [38]My words were “If I’m permitted to ask the question, how so?” (transcript, p 65 at [40]). These words follow the general course of the dialogue between myself and Mr Nugawela that precedes them (transcript audio at 2:52:00).[39]These words, or words to this effect, do not appear in the transcript at this point of the substantive hearing.[40]These words do not appear in the transcript. My words “I had thought it was” appear in an unrelated context at transcript, p 67 at [30]. As for the words being emphatic, punctuated and declaratory as claimed, these comments were made in reference to words that were not stated.[41]Again, this did not occur and is not recorded in the transcript as having had occurred.[42]Again, this did not occur and is not recorded in the transcript as having had occurred.[43]These words appear at transcript p 65 at [40]. However, these words were stated directly following my own words “If I’m permitted to ask the question, how so?” and not in response to any purported zipping of the mouth by me (which, in any event, did not occur).