Abley and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Abley and Comcare (Compensation) [2024] AATA 1204 (23 May 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/4381

Re:Lynette Abley

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member L M Gallagher

Date:23 May 2024

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision dated 30 June 2020, which denied liability under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in respect of fibromyalgia claimed to have been sustained in January 2016, is affirmed.

................[Sgd]..........................

Member L M Gallagher

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – Whether liability should be accepted under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for a claim of “fibromyalgia” – whether the Applicant suffered from an “ailment” – disease – whether the ailment was contributed to, to a significant degree by the Applicant’s employment with Services Australia – whether the Tribunal can be satisfied on the balance of probabilities – whether the Applicant was already suffering from symptoms of fibromyalgia prior to suffering an accepted right shoulder condition – competing expert evidence – Reviewable Decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 42A(1)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5A, 5B, 5B(1), 14, 14(1), 16, 19, 29, 39, 71

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member L M Gallagher

23 May 2024

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the delegate of the Respondent dated 30 June 2020, which denied liability to pay compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act) in respect of fibromyalgia claimed to have been sustained in January 2016 (the Reviewable Decision).[1]

    [1] R2, T79.

    ISSUE

  2. It is not in dispute that the Applicant suffers from fibromyalgia, being an ailment as defined by s 4 of the SRC Act.[2] Therefore, the sole issue for determination is whether the Applicant’s fibromyalgia condition was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment by the Commonwealth, pursuant to s 5B(1) of the SRC Act.

    [2] See, for example, R1 at [81] and Respondent’s written closing submissions dated 31 January 2022 at [2.3].

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant was employed as a Customer Services Officer by Services Australia (the Department), having commenced work in 2007.[3]

    [3] R2, T14, p 89.

  4. In February 2015, Commonwealth Rehabilitation Services Australia (CRS) closed a local office in which the Applicant was working.[4] The Applicant was transferred to a Medicare office at a different location, where she was trained in Medicare work.[5]

    [4] R2, T14, p 89 and T27, p 142.

    [5] R2, T14, p 89 and T27, p 142.

  5. In April 2015, the Applicant commenced work as a Customer Liaison Officer at Medicare on a full-time basis.[6]

    [6] R2, T27, p 142.

  6. On 15 June 2015, the Applicant relocated to a Medicare Service Office at a different location, to be co-located with Centrelink staff.[7]

    [7] R2, T14, p 89.

  7. Between 10 July 2015 and 24 August 2015, the Applicant took six weeks’ leave for an operation to her bladder.[8]

    [8] R2, T14,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abley and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 1204
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for workers' compensation by the Applicant against Comcare under the *Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) (SRC Act). The Applicant sought acceptance of liability for fibromyalgia, an ailment, and contended that it was contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment with Services Australia. The central dispute was whether the Applicant's fibromyalgia condition was causally linked to her employment, particularly in light of competing expert medical evidence.

The court was required to determine whether the Applicant's fibromyalgia constituted a "disease" as defined by section 5B of the SRC Act. This involved assessing whether the ailment was contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment. The court also had to consider whether the Applicant was already suffering from symptoms of fibromyalgia prior to an accepted right shoulder condition, and whether the evidence, on the balance of probabilities, satisfied the statutory threshold for significant contribution from employment.

The court considered the Applicant's employment history, including transfers and changes in duties, and the accepted aggravation of a pre-existing right shoulder condition. Expert evidence was presented by Dr Rob Will, who opined that the Applicant's fibromyalgia was a consequence of her work duties and that her right upper limb overuse syndrome was a major trigger. Conversely, Dr Reiter concluded that the Applicant's fibromyalgia was an intrinsic constitutional condition, not significantly contributed to by her employment, and that she had experienced symptoms for many years prior to formal diagnosis. The court noted that "significant degree" in the context of the SRC Act means a degree that is substantially more than material.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the reviewable decision, finding that the Applicant had not established, on the balance of probabilities, that her fibromyalgia condition was contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment with Services Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is not in dispute that the Applicant suffers from fibromyalgia, being an ailment as defined by s 4 of the SRC Act.[2] Therefore, the sole issue for determination is whether the Applicant’s fibromyalgia condition was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment by the Commonwealth, pursuant to s 5B(1) of the SRC Act.[2] See, for example, R1 at [81] and Respondent’s written closing submissions dated 31 January 2022 at [2.3]. BACKGROUND The Applicant was employed as a Customer Services Officer by Services Australia (the Department), having commenced work in 2007.[3][3] R2, T14, p 89. In February 2015, Commonwealth Rehabilitation Services Australia (CRS) closed a local office in which the Applicant was working.[4] The Applicant was transferred to a Medicare office at a different location, where she was trained in Medicare work.[5][4] R2, T14, p 89 and T27, p 142.[5] R2, T14, p 89 and T27, p 142. In April 2015, the Applicant commenced work as a Customer Liaison Officer at Medicare on a full-time basis.[6][6] R2, T27, p 142. On 15 June 2015, the Applicant relocated to a Medicare Service Office at a different location, to be co-located with Centrelink staff.[7][7] R2, T14, p 89. Between 10 July 2015 and 24 August 2015, the Applicant took six weeks’ leave for an operation to her bladder.[8] [8] R2, T14, p 89. A Report of Incident or Injury form dated 15 September 2015 indicates that on 9 September 2015, the Applicant was undertaking ‘data entry’ and ‘keyboarding’ when she experienced an exacerbation of a right arm injury.[9] The Applicant is reported to have described that she sustained the injury while using a standard keyboard as a temporary replacement for a compact cherry ergonomic keyboard and separate numeric pad.[10][9] R2, T14, p 63.[10] R2, T14, p 63. See also transcript, p 48 [5]-[10]. The Applicant was subsequently diagnosed with recurrence of right shoulder subacromial bursitis.[11] Throughout late 2015 to May 2016, the Applicant:[12] (a)Was referred for and attended regular physiotherapy; (b)Underwent an ultrasound, a cortisone injection and an MRI of her right shoulder;(c)Underwent rehabilitation assessments and ergonomic workstation assessments;(d)Was certified unfit for work or fit for modified or alternative duties; and(e)Temporarily reduced her work hours to care for her husband and cope better emotionally with her work environment.[13][11] See medical certificate issued on 16 September 2015, by Dr Anthony Pethick, General Practitioner (GP) (R2, T5).[12] See R2, T6, T7, T8, T10, T13, T14, T15, T16 and T85.[13] A move away from customer contact was recommended, and on 9 November 2015 the Applicant was placed in a processing role (R2, T14, p 43). In February 2016, the Applicant was relocated to the Department of Human Services (DHS) office at a different location to work in the Medicare Consolidated Processing Team.[14][14] R2, T14, p 91 and A2, p 86 read with transcript, p 40 [10]-[20]. On 30 March 2016, the Applicant lodged a claim for workers’ compensation with respect to her ‘shoulder and right arm injury’ having first noticed her symptoms on 7 September 2015.[15] The Applicant claimed to have sustained her injury following her return to work after six weeks leave because her keyboard and equipment were altered or not working.[16] The Applicant stated she used standard equipment while replacement equipment was on order and her right arm injury was ‘exacerbated.’[17] [15] R2, T3.[16] R2, T3, p 7.[17] R2, T3, p 7.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant said that at the time she lodged her claim for chronic fatigue in 2019,[80] she did not know and could not recall that in 2015 she had suffered from fatigue for a period of many months.[81]Medical evidence[80] See [28] above.[81] Transcript, p 52 [5]-[15].Dr Rob Will, Consultant Rheumatologist In his report dated 6 September 2021,[82] Dr Will diagnosed the Applicant with an initial onset of Occupational Overuse Pain Syndrome (RSI) of the right upper limb then spreading to more generalised pain which became total body pain (fibromyalgia) associated with chronic fatigue and brain fog. Dr Will considered the Applicant’s RSI and fibromyalgia to be a consequence of her work duties for Medicare.[83] Put another way, Dr Will stated:[84]While there is clearly controversy surrounding trauma precipitating fibromyalgia…there are now many good studies in the literature…demonstrating that following physically traumatic events patients can develop fibromyalgia……It is my view that [the Applicant’s] employment between Feb [sic] 2015 and October 2016 led to a significant degree to the development of an occupational use syndrome [85] of her right upper limb. This then led to the development of a more generalised fibromyalgia syndrome.[86]……I disagree with [Dr Reiter’s] conclusion [in point 17 of her report dated 15 February 2021][87] that in [the Applicant’s] case this is simply and [sic] “intrinsic constitutional condition”…There is no evidence that [the Applicant] suffered a significant impairment[88] prior to 2015 when her symptoms began.[82] A4(a), p 3 of report.[83] A4(a), p 3 of report.[84] A4(a), pp 4 and 5 of report.[85] Being the repetitive over use of her right upper limb undertaking prolonged data entry without sufficient breaks (A4(a), p 4 of report).[86] See also transcript, p 103 [35].[87] See R4(a), pp 5 and 6 of report, where Dr Reiter states that the Applicant’s fibromyalgia condition has not been caused by anything specific, that it is simply an intrinsic constitutional condition, that it was not significantly contributed to by her former employment with Services Australia and did not develop as a result of symptoms from her right shoulder condition.[88] ‘Significant impairment’ meaning “the symptoms of fibromyalgia” where the Applicant “became functionally a lot more unwell and had a lot more difficulty managing work and home duties” (Dr Will’s evidence, transcript, p 91 [30]. At the hearing, Dr Will added that in the Applicant’s case it seemed to be fairly clear that her RSI was a major trigger for the development of fibromyalgia and that there didn’t appear to be any other major psychosocial issues playing a significant role.[89] [89] Transcript, p 87 [35]. When taken to the Applicant’s medical records from 2015,[90] Dr Will said it was possible that these presentations may have been the beginning of the Applicant’s fibromyalgia illness, where the symptomatology can wax and wane, and fluctuate in severity over a period of time,[91] but that the references to the Applicant’s reason for visit as ‘fatigue’[92] or ‘fatigue continues’[93] did not cause him to change his opinions.[94][90] See [61(b)], [61(c)] and [61(d)] above.[91] Transcript, p 94 [30], p 100 [5] and p 103 [30].[92] See [61(b)] above.[93] See [61(b)] above.[94] Transcript, p 99 [45] and p 100 [10].

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 1 May 2023, I published a decision refusing the Applicant’s request that I recuse myself from hearing the present application (Recusal Decision).[65][65] See Abley and Comcare (Compensation) [2023] AATA 989 (1 May 2023). On 29 May 2023, the Applicant applied to the Federal Court of Australia for review of the recusal decision and sought orders that:(a)The Recusal Decision be quashed;(b)Member Gallagher be recused from determining the present application on grounds of apprehended bias; and(c)The Tribunal appoint a different Member to determine the present application,and that the present application be stayed pending determination of the Applicant’s application to the Federal Court of Australia.[66][66] See Federal Court applications numbered WAD 119/2023 and WAD 120/2023. On 27 September 2023, the Applicant filed its notices of withdrawal of application to the Federal Court. On the same day, the Federal Court issued orders confirming the Applicant’s applications had been discontinued. On 2 October 2023, the Tribunal was advised of the Federal Court’s orders confirming the Applicant’s applications had been discontinued.LEGISLATION The Respondent’s liability to pay compensation is set out in s 14 of the SRC Act. Subsection 14(1) of the SRC Act provides that:Subject to this Part, Comcare is liable to pay compensation in accordance with this Act in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment.(Emphasis added.) Subsection 5A of the SRC Act defines “injury” as follows:(1) In this Act:injury means:(a) a disease suffered by an employee; …(Emphasis added.) “Disease” is defined in s 5B of the SRC Act as follows:5B Definition of disease(1) In this Act:disease means:(a) an ailment suffered by an employee; or(b) an aggravation of such an ailment;that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee.(2) In determining whether an ailment or aggravation was contributed to, to a significant degree, by an employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee, the following matters may be taken into account:(a) the duration of the employment;(b) the nature of, and particular tasks involved in, the employment;(c) any predisposition of the employee to the ailment or aggravation;(d) any activities of the employee not related to the employment;(e) any other matters affecting the employee’s health.This subsection does not limit the matters that may be taken into account.(3) In this Act:significant degree means a degree that is substantially more than material.(Emphasis added.)EVIDENCE The Tribunal received the following evidence:(a)Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC) dated 4 May 2021 and filed on 6 May 2021 (A1);(b)Applicant’s book of documents dated 7 October 2021 (A2);(c)Applicant’s comments addressing issues raised by Respondent, undated, filed on 27 January 2021 (A3);(d)Report of Dr Rob Will, Consultant Rheumatologist, dated 6 September 2021 (A4(a)), including:(i)Letter of instruction to Dr Will from Soul Legal, dated 16 August 2021 (A4(b)); and(ii)Curriculum vitae of Dr Will dated 18 September 2021, filed on 27 October 2021 (A4(c));(e)Academic article, “A systematic review of precipitating physical and psychological traumatic events in the development of fibromyalgia,” by Yarden Yavne et al., Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism vol 48 (2018), 121-133 (A5);(f)Report of Dr Jack Edelman, Rheumatologist, dated 22 February 2021 (A6(a)), including:(i)Letter of instruction to Dr Edelman from Soul Legal, dated 8 January 2021 (A6(b));(g)Supplementary report of Dr Edelman dated 24 March 2021 (A7(a)), including:(i)Letter of instruction to Dr Edelman from Soul Legal, dated 10 March 2021 (A7(b));(h)Curriculum vitae of Dr Edelman, undated, filed on 27 October 2021 (A8);(i)Report of Dr Frank Cordova, GP, dated 15 May 2021 (A9(a)); including:(i)Letter of instruction to Dr Cordova from Soul Legal, dated 6 May 2021 (A9(b)); and(i)Curriculum vitae of Dr Cordova, undated, filed on 27 October 2021 (A9(c));(j)WorkCover WA progress certificates of capacity issued by Dr Cordova and dated: (i)10 November 2020;(ii)7 December 2020;(iii)1 February 2021; and(iv)29 March 2021.(together (A10));(k)Respondent’s SFIC, dated and filed on 1 June 2021 (R1);(l)Respondent’s Section 37 T documents (T1-T88, consisting of 461 pages) filed on 24 August 2020 (R2);(m)Applicant’s records, Davey Medical Centre, various dates (extracted from Respondent’s tender bundle, pages 273 to 277 and pages 295 to 298) (R3);(n)Supplementary Report of Dr Reiter dated 15 February 2021 (R4(a)), including:(i)Letter of instruction to Dr Reiter from HBA Legal, dated 21 January 2021 (R4(b));(o)Further supplementary report of Dr Reiter dated 1 July 2021 (R5(a)); including,(i)Letter of instruction to Dr Reiter from HBA Legal, dated 22 June 2021 (R5(b));(p)Further supplementary report of Dr Reiter dated 20 October 2021 (R6(a)); including,(ii)Letter of instruction to Dr Reiter from HBA Legal, dated 14 October 2021 (R6(b)); and(q)Curriculum vitae of Dr Reiter, undated, filed on 10 August 2021 (R7).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the hearing, Dr Reiter reiterated that the Applicant has had symptoms of fibromyalgia for many years before it was formally diagnosed in 2017.[126] Dr Reiter added that it did not at all surprise her given that (at para 82(f) above):[127](a)The Applicant might have been reporting to her physiotherapist that she had diffuse upper limb pain by December 2015;(b)Such reporting would be part of the evolution of the Applicant’s condition; and(c)This does not tell us anything about the causation of the Applicant’s fibromyalgia condition.[126] Transcript, p 24 [5]).[127] Transcript, p 159 [45] and p 160 [5].CONSIDERATION The issue in the present matter is whether the Applicant’s fibromyalgia condition was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment by the Commonwealth.The Applicant’s position The Applicant’s position is that her fibromyalgia condition was contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment by the Commonwealth and can be summarised as follows:(a)She suffered a work-related aggravation of her non-work-related right shoulder bursitis condition after transferring her work location in April 2015.[128](b)The Applicant’s work-related aggravation continued to cause her pain and long-term disrupted sleep, even after she ceased work in October 2016.[129](c)The chronic pain suffered from the work-related aggravation led to lack of sleep, leading to chronic fatigue, then developed into fibromyalgia.[130][128] The fact the Applicant suffered a work-related aggravation to her non work-related right shoulder bursitis condition is not in dispute. The Respondent accepted the aggravation as work-related and paid compensation accordingly. The Applicant ultimately agreed that the no present liability decision that was made in relation to this injury and the related application seeking review of that decision was dismissed by consent of the parties. See [44(a)] above.[129] Applicant’s written closing submissions at [13].[130] As set out in the Applicant’s claim form entitled “Lynette’s claim for secondary injury or disease,” R2, T4. As the Applicant’s claim has been made on the basis that her fibromyalgia condition was secondary to her accepted shoulder aggravation suffered in 2015, her request that the Tribunal make findings on whether her work and/or her treatment in the workplace, right up to October 2016 contributed to the triggering, contraction and/or aggravation of her fibromyalgia (whether constitutional, intrinsic or work-related and whether a primary or secondary condition)[131] departs from this basis and hence will not be considered.[132] [131] Applicant’s written closing submissions at [37]. The Applicant did not, at any point prior to the determination of her claim, seek to claim that her fibromyalgia was a primary condition.[132] See also Respondent’s written closing submissions at [4.1] and [5.2] to [5.5] and Applicant’s written closing submissions in reply (as further amended) at [1] to [31].