Easter Term
[2017] UKSC 35
On appeal from: [2015] EWCA Civ 16
| JUDGMENT |
Gard Marine and Energy Limited (Appellant) v China National Chartering Company Limited and another (Respondents) China National Chartering Company Limited (Appellant) v Gard Marine and Energy Limited and another (Respondents) Daiichi Chuo Kisen Kaisha (Appellant) v Gard Marine and Energy Limited and another (Respondents)
before
Lord Mance
Lord Clarke
Lord Sumption
Lord Hodge
Lord Toulson
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
10 May 2017
Heard on 1, 2 and 3 November 2016
Appellant/Respondents Respondent/Appellant (China National (Gard Marine & Energy Chartering Co Ltd) Ltd) Michael Davey QC Mark Howard QC James M Turner QC
Simon Birt QC
(Instructed by Winter (Instructed by Ince & Co
Scott LLP) LLP)
Respondent (Daiichi Chuo
Kisen Kaisha)
Dominic Kendrick QC
David Goldstone QC
Gavin Geary
(Instructed by MFB
Solicitors)
LORD CLARKE: (with whom Lord Sumption agrees. Lord Mance, Lord
Hodge and Lord Toulson agree on the first and third issues only)
Introduction
1. This appeal arises out of the grounding of the OCEAN VICTORY (“the vessel”) in the port of Kashima in Japan on 24 October 2006. She was a Capesize
bulk carrier, built in China in 2005. By a demise charterparty dated 8 June 2005, the
vessel’s owners, Ocean Victory Maritime Inc (“OVM” or “the owners”), chartered the vessel to Ocean Line Holdings Ltd (“OLH”), which is or was a related company,
on the widely used Barecon 89 as amended. On 2 August 2006, OLH time chartered
the vessel to China National Chartering Co Ltd (“Sinochart”) and on 13 September 2006, Sinochart in turn sub-chartered her to Daiichi Chuo Kisen Kaisha (“Daiichi” or “the charterers”) for a time charter trip.
2. The demise charterparty and both time charterparties contained an undertaking (on materially identical terms) to trade the vessel between safe ports. On 12/13 September 2006, Daiichi (and thus Sinochart) gave the vessel instructions to load at Saldanha Bay in South Africa and to discharge at Kashima. Between 19 and 21 September she loaded 170,000 tonnes of iron ore. She arrived off Kashima on 20 October and discharge began that afternoon.
3. The port of Kashima is entered from the sea through the northern end of a specially constructed channel known as the Kashima Fairway, which runs almost due north south, and is the only route into and out of the port. The Kashima Fairway is bounded on one side (to the east) by the South Breakwater and on the other (to the west) by the land.
4. On 24 October the vessel sought to leave the port during a storm. However, she allided with the northern end of the South Breakwater and grounded. Shortly thereafter another Capesize vessel, the ELIDA ACE, also grounded in the Kashima Fairway while attempting to leave the port. Salvors were engaged but the OCEAN VICTORY eventually broke in two. Her wreck was subsequently removed in the course of a lengthy wreck removal operation.
5. Some two years later, on 15 October 2008, Gard Marine & Energy Ltd
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read THE “OCEAN VICTORY” and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKSC 35
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Supreme Court considered three main issues: whether there was a breach of the safe port undertaking, whether the provisions for joint insurance preclude rights of subrogation and recovery against the demise charterer for breach of the safe port undertaking, and whether the charterers are entitled to limit their liability. The Court found that the conditions at Kashima were indeed an abnormal occurrence, and thus there was no breach of the safe port undertaking. Regarding the insurance provisions, the Court held that the joint insurance clause did not preclude rights of subrogation and recovery against the demise charterer. Lastly, on the limitation of liability, the Court found that the charterers could limit their liability in accordance with the Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims 1976.
In conclusion, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal on the safe port issue, upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal on the joint insurance issue, and found that the charterers were entitled to limit their liability.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi