Evergreen Marine (UK) Limited (Appellant) v Nautical Challenge Ltd (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

Hilary Term

[2021] UKSC 6

On appeal from: [2018] EWCA Civ 2173

Appellant Respondent

Simon Rainey QC Nigel Jacobs QC (Instructed by Ince

Vasanti Selvaratnam QC

James Shirley
(Instructed by Clyde &

Gordon Dadds LLP and Co)

Stann Law Limited)

LORD BRIGGS AND LORD HAMBLEN: (with whom Lord Lloyd-Jones,

Lady Arden and Lord Burrows agree)

I Introduction

1. This is the first appeal in a collision action to come before the Supreme Court.

Indeed, it is approaching 50 years since the last such appeal before the House of
Lords - The Savina [1976] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 123.

2. The appeal raises two important questions of construction of the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea 1972 as amended (“the Collision Regulations”). Both questions relate to the application of the “crossing rules”, as set out in rules 15-17 of the Collision Regulations. These rules apply where two power- driven vessels are crossing so as to involve a risk of collision. They require the vessel which has the other on her starboard side to keep out of the way (the “give-way vessel”) whilst the other vessel is required to keep her course and speed (the “stand- on vessel”). They are of cardinal importance to the safety of navigation.

3. The first question which the court has been asked is whether the crossing rules are inapplicable or are to be disapplied where an outbound vessel is navigating within a narrow channel and has a vessel on a crossing course approaching the narrow channel with the intention of and in preparation for entering it. This concerns the inter-relationship between the crossing rules and the “narrow channel rules” - rule 9. Rule 9(a) requires vessels proceeding along the course of a narrow channel to keep as near to its starboard outer limit as is safe and practicable.

4. The second question which arises is whether it is necessary for the putative give-way vessel to be on a steady course for the crossing rules to be engaged. The “putative give-way vessel” is the vessel which, if the crossing rules apply, would be required by rule 15 to keep out of the way of the other vessel. In practical terms it is the vessel which has the other vessel on her starboard side. We will call that other vessel the “putative stand-on vessel”.

5. The collision which gives rise to these questions was between the appellant’s large container vessel, Ever Smart (“EVER SMART”) and the respondent’s VLCC (very large crude carrier), Alexandra 1 (“ALEXANDRA 1”). The collision took place within the pilot boarding area, just outside the dredged entrance/exit channel to the port of Jebel Ali in the United Arab Emirates (“the channel”), at 2342:22 local time (GMT+4) on 11 February 2015. (The time of the collision is referred to hereafter as “C” and times leading up to the collision as “C-x”.) EVER SMART was outbound from Jebel Ali laden with 48,564 mt of containerised general cargo and, until shortly before the collision, was proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evergreen Marine (UK) Limited (Appellant) v Nautical Challen... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] UKSC 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Evergreen Marine (UK) Limited v Nautical Challenge Ltd was heard by the Supreme Court, with the key issues being the interpretation of the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea 1972 (the Collision Regulations), specifically the "crossing rules" in rules 15-17. The questions centered on whether these rules apply when an outbound vessel is navigating within a narrow channel and another vessel approaches with the intention of entering the channel, and whether the approaching vessel must be on a steady course for the crossing rules to apply. The collision in question occurred between the appellant's container vessel, Ever Smart, and the respondent's VLCC, Alexandra 1, in the Jebel Ali port channel. Both the Admiralty judge and the Court of Appeal had ruled that the crossing rules were inapplicable in this scenario, leading to the appeal. The Supreme Court, after considering the submissions and advice from nautical assessors, concluded that the crossing rules do apply in such situations, and that there is no requirement for the approaching vessel to be on a steady course for these rules to engage. This decision was based on the principle that the crossing rules are fundamental to preventing collisions at sea and should not be easily disapplied. The Court allowed the appeal, but deferred to the Admiralty Court to reconsider the apportionment of liability and fault in light of this decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established