Re B (A Child) (Habitual Residence: Inherent Jurisdiction)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Hilary Term

[2016] UKSC 4

On appeal from: [2015] EWCA Civ 886

JUDGMENT

In the matter of B (A child)

before

Lady Hale, Deputy President


Lord Clarke
Lord Wilson
Lord Sumption
Lord Toulson

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

3 February 2016

Heard on 8 and 9 December 2015

Appellant Respondent
David Williams QC William Tyler QC
Alistair Perkins Hannah Markham
Michael Gration Miriam Carrion Benitez

Mehvish Chaudhry

(Instructed by Freemans (Instructed by Goodman
Solicitors) Ray Solicitors)

Intervener (Reunite)

Richard Harrison QC

Madeleine Reardon

Jennifer Perrins

(Instructed by Farrer & Co

LLP)

Intervener (The

International Centre for Family Law Policy and

Practice)

Henry Setright QC

Hassan Khan

Dorothea Gartland

Katy Chokowry

(Instructed by Dawson

Cornwell)

Intervener (The AIRE

Centre)

Deirdre Fottrell QC

Michael Edwards

(Instructed by Bindmans

LLP)

LORD WILSON (with whom Lady Hale and Lord Toulson agree):

INTRODUCTION

1. It has been hard-wired into the mind of many family lawyers in England and Wales that, were a parent to remove a child from a state in which they were habitually resident to another state with the settled intention that they would cease to reside in that first state and make their home in that second state, the child would be likely to lose habitual residence in the first state immediately upon the removal and, until later acquiring habitual residence in the second state, would be likely not to be habitually resident anywhere. The absence of habitual residence anywhere places a child in a legal limbo. The main question raised by this appeal, which arguably the lower courts were not free to answer, is whether the expectation of family lawyers about the point at which habitual residence is lost requires

adjustment in the light of this court’s recent adoption of the European concept of

habitual residence. The court’s answer to this question should enable it to determine

whether the lower courts were correct to conclude that, on the relevant date, the child
at the centre of this appeal was in the limbo to which I have referred.

2. The child is B, a girl, who was born in April 2008 and so is now aged seven. The women who are the two central parties to this appeal were living in England in a same-sex relationship from 2004 to 2011. Other than biologically, B is the product of their relationship. The respondent is the biological mother of B and her father is an unknown sperm donor of Asian ethnicity. The appellant has strong claims also to be described as a mother. Nevertheless, in order to avoid confusion, it is better to refer to the central parties as the appellant and the respondent respectively.

3. The appellant, who continues to live in England, is a British national, aged 35, of Indian ethnicity. The respondent is a British national, aged 45, of Pakistani ethnicity. B, likewise, is a British national. On 3 February 2014 the respondent took B to live in Pakistan, where they have remained ever since. On 13 February 2014, aware that the respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re B (A Child) (Habitual Residence: Inherent Jurisdiction) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] UKSC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a dispute over the habitual residence of a child, B, who was removed from England to Pakistan by her biological mother, the respondent. The appellant, who was a significant figure in B's life, sought orders for contact and shared residence, as well as for B to be made a ward of court and returned to England. The High Court and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant's applications. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal. The main issue before the Supreme Court was whether B had lost her habitual residence in England when she was removed to Pakistan and, if so, whether the court should exercise its inherent jurisdiction to order her return to England. The Supreme Court held that B had not lost her habitual residence in England on 13 February 2014, the date when the appellant's application was issued. The court found that the factors indicating B's continued habitual residence in England were stronger than those suggesting a loss of that residence. These factors included B's short time in Pakistan, lack of integration into Pakistani society, and ongoing emotional ties with the appellant and other family members in England. The Supreme Court also held that, even if B had lost her habitual residence in England, the court should exercise its inherent jurisdiction to order her return to England in order to protect her welfare. The court found that the restrictions on the use of the inherent jurisdiction did not preclude its use in such circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established