Philipp (Respondent) v Barclays Bank UK Plc (Appellant)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read
Trinity Term
[2023] UKSC 25
On appeal from: [2022] EWCA Civ 318

JUDGMENT

Philipp (Respondent) v Barclays Bank UK PLC (Appellant)

before

Lord Reed, President
Lord Hodge, Deputy President
Lord Sales
Lord Hamblen
Lord Leggatt

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
12 July 2023

Heard on 1 and 2 February 2023

Appellant
Patrick Goodall KC
David Murray
Ian Bergson
(Instructed by TLT LLP)

Respondent
Hugh Sims KC
Christopher Hare
Lucy Walker
Jay Jagasia
(Instructed by Squire Biggs Law)

Intervener – Consumers’ Association
David McIlroy
Tristan Jones
(Instructed by Penningtons Manches Cooper LLP)

Intervener – UK Finance Ltd
Sonia Tolaney KC
James Ruddell
(Instructed by White & Case LLP (London))

LORD LEGGATT (with whom Lord Reed, Lord Hodge, Lord Sales and Lord Hamblen agree):

A.INTRODUCTION

  1. In 2018 Mrs Fiona Philipp and her husband, Dr Robin Philipp, fell victim to a fraud. They were deceived by criminals into instructing Barclays Bank (“the Bank”) to transfer £700,000 in two payments from Mrs Philipp’s current account with the Bank to bank accounts in the United Arab Emirates (“UAE”). The payments were made and the money was lost. In these proceedings Mrs Philipp claims that the Bank is responsible for this loss. She contends that the Bank owed her a duty under its contract with her or at common law not to carry out her payment instructions if - as was allegedly the case here - the Bank had reasonable grounds for believing that she was being defrauded.

  1. The Bank applied to have the claim summarily dismissed on the ground that as a matter of law it did not owe Mrs Philipp the alleged duty. Judge Russen QC, sitting as a judge of the High Court, agreed with this submission and granted summary judgment in favour of the Bank: [2021] EWHC 10 (Comm), [2021] Bus LR 451. But an appeal by Mrs Philipp to the Court of Appeal was allowed: [2022] EWCA Civ 318, [2022] QB 578. Birss LJ, in a judgment with which Sir Julian Flaux C and Coulson LJ agreed, accepted the claimant’s argument that, in principle, a bank owes a contractual duty to its customer of the kind alleged: whether such a duty arose on the facts in this case is a question which can only be decided at a trial.

  1. For the reasons explained in this judgment, the Court of Appeal was, in my opinion, wrong to reach this conclusion, which is inconsistent with first principles of banking law. It is a basic duty of a bank under its contract with a customer who has a current account in credit to make payments from the account in compliance with the customer’s instructions. This duty is strict. Where the customer has authorised and instructed the bank to make a payment, the bank must carry out the instruction promptly. It is not for the bank to concern itself with the wisdom or risks of its customer’s payment decisions.

  1. It would be possible for a bank to agree as an express term of the contract…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Philipp (Respondent) v Barclays Bank UK Plc (Appellant) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] UKSC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Philipp v Barclays Bank UK PLC, the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom considered whether a bank owes its customer a duty under its contract or at common law not to carry out payment instructions if the bank has reasonable grounds for believing that the customer is being defrauded. The Court concluded that such a duty does not exist. The bank's fundamental contractual duty is to execute its customer's payment instructions promptly and in accordance with its mandate, unless doing so would result in the bank committing a crime. The bank has no obligation to investigate the wisdom or risks of its customer's payment decisions. While the bank has a duty to exercise reasonable skill and care in carrying out the customer's instructions, this does not create a duty to refuse to execute an instruction without making inquiries unless the bank has reasonable grounds for believing that the instruction is an attempt to defraud the customer. The Court rejected the argument that the bank owes a duty to its customer to refrain from executing payment instructions when the customer is a victim of "authorised push payment" fraud. The Court held that the bank's duty to execute valid payment instructions is not limited by the customer's actual or apparent authority to give the instruction, as the bank's authority to execute instructions derives directly from the customer's mandate and not from the agent's authority. The Court concluded that the bank cannot be faulted for executing the customer's instructions in such circumstances and that the bank has no obligation to attempt to recall funds transferred to fraudulent accounts before the customer has countermanded the payment instructions.