Oceanbulk Shipping and Trading SA v TMT Asia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2010] UKSC 44

On appeal from: 2010 EWCA Civ 79

JUDGMENT

Oceanbulk Shipping & Trading SA (Respondent) vTMT Asia Limited and others (Appellants)

before

Lord Phillips, President


Lord Rodger
Lord Walker
Lord Brown
Lord Mance
Lord Clarke

Sir John Dyson SCJ

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

27 October 2010

Heard on 14 and 15 July 2010

Appellant Respondent
Jonathan Crow QC Alistair Schaff QC
James Leabeater James Willan

(Instructed by Ince & Co)

(Instructed by Berwin Leighton Paisner LLP)

LORD CLARKE (with whom Lord Rodger, Lord Walker, Lord Brown, Lord

Mance and Sir John Dyson agree)

Introduction

1. This appeal raises a question as to the scope of the exceptions to the principle that statements made in the course of without prejudice negotiations are not admissible in evidence (“the without prejudice rule”). Specifically, the question is whether facts which (a) are communicated between the parties in the course of without prejudice negotiations and (b) would, but for the without prejudice rule, be admissible as part of the factual matrix or surrounding circumstances as an aid to construction of an agreement which results from the negotiations, should be admissible by way of exception to the without prejudice rule.

2. The dispute between the parties relates to a series of forward freight agreements (“FFAs”) and is set against the background of the extraordinary volatility of the freight markets in 2008. Capesize bulk carriers are large vessels, so called because they were historically too large to pass through the Suez Canal. The Baltic Exchange index of daily rates of time charter hire for such vessels fell from about US$200,000 per day in May 2008 to US$3,000 per day in December 2008. Each FFA was a swap agreement which consisted of a bet on whether the settlement rate (being the average of the published rates, as stated in the relevant index, for each index publication day in the relevant settlement month) would, on specified future settlement dates, be higher or lower than the contract rate as defined in the FFA.

3. Under each FFA the seller bet that the market rate on the settlement dates would be lower than the contract rate and the buyer bet that it would be higher. If it was higher on a given settlement day, the seller was obliged to pay the difference between the two rates multiplied by the contract period, which was usually the number of days in the month. If it was lower the buyer was obliged to pay the seller the appropriate amount. The relevant FFAs had settlement days at the end of one or more months within the period May to December 2008. At the end of each month all settlement sums due under all the FFAs were to be netted off and payment made by the indebted party under the net position to the other party. (I use the word “bet” because it was used by the parties in the agreed statement of facts and issues and because it appears to me to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oceanbulk Shipping and Trading SA v TMT Asia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] UKSC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Oceanbulk Shipping and Trading SA v TMT Asia Ltd, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether facts communicated between parties in the course of without prejudice negotiations should be admissible as an exception to the without prejudice rule. The dispute centered on the interpretation of a settlement agreement between the parties regarding a series of forward freight agreements (FFAs) affected by market volatility in 2008. The key issue was whether certain representations made during the without prejudice negotiations could be used to interpret the terms of the settlement agreement.

The court concluded that such facts should indeed be admissible as an exception to the without prejudice rule. The reasoning was that the principles governing the interpretation of contracts, which include considering the context and background knowledge available to the parties, should apply equally whether or not the negotiations were without prejudice. The court emphasized that admitting evidence of objective facts communicated during negotiations would respect the modern principles of contractual interpretation and would likely encourage settlements rather than discourage them. The court found that this approach would not undermine the underlying principle of the without prejudice rule, which is to encourage frank communication and promote settlement.

Consequently, the court held that evidence supporting the representations made during the without prejudice negotiations could be admitted to assist in the true construction of the settlement agreement. This decision aligns with the principles of rectification and construction of contracts as clarified in recent cases, ensuring that the agreement reflects the parties' true intentions. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, overruling the decision of the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.