LHL Leasing Solutions Limited v Pinto Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2013-404-5240

[2018] NZHC 1387

BETWEEN

LHL LEASING SOLUTIONS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

PINTO LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 23, 24, 26 April 2018

Appearances:

G Denholm for Plaintiff R J M Sim for Defendant

Judgment:

12 June 2018


JUDGMENT OF JAGOSE J


This judgment is delivered by me on 12 June 2018 at 4.30pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

.....................................................

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Foy & Halse (G W Halse) Epsom, Auckland

Gallaway Cook Allan Lawyer (RJM Sim/DP Robinson), Dunedin Greg Denholm, Barrister, Auckland

LHL LEASING SOLUTIONS LTD v PINTO LTD [2018] NZHC 1387 [12 June 2018]

Introduction

[1]    The plaintiff (“Leasing Solutions”) seeks to recover $607,015.98 from the defendant (“Pinto”) in liquidated damages – calculated by reference to “the average monthly rent during the term of this Agreement” – for Pinto’s alleged failure to deliver up leased equipment to Leasing Solutions on the lease’s expiry on 20 December 2010.

[2]    Leasing Solutions’ claim also to recover alleged unpaid rent, and Pinto’s counterclaim/affirmative defence for the same amount in damages for Leasing Solutions’ alleged breach of ‘good repair’ obligations, were earlier struck out. Associate Judge Bell held delays in Leasing Solutions’ prosecution of the case meant a “fair hearing” on those issues was no longer possible.1 But the Judge held “there are better prospects of a fair hearing” on a claim for failure to return equipment, either as liquidated damages, or for “actual losses from the non-return of the equipment”.2 Only the former liquidated damages claim was pursued.

[3]    Pinto’s counsel, Diccon Sim, argued the effect of Associate Judge Bell’s judgment was also to render determination of the “average monthly rent” ‘unfair’, meaning Leasing Solutions could not succeed. He sought leave to make oral application to strike out the balance of Pinto’s case.3 I required such application to be made in writing, if it was to be pursued. The strike out issue was not advanced further.

[4]The issues for determination in this proceeding are thus:

(a)was Pinto in breach of an obligation to deliver up equipment to Leasing Solutions on expiry of the lease?

(b)if so, is the “average monthly rent during the term of the Agreement” capable of being determined, both in law and in fact? and

(c)if so, is the liquidated damages provision enforceable as a matter of law?


1      LHL Leasing Solutions Ltd v Pinto Ltd [2017] NZHC 1050 at [49], [50], and [54].

2 At [51].

3      Leave was necessary because this was as an application for “the same or a similar order” after the failure of the first application: HCR 7.52.

Background

[5]    Associate Judge Bell’s judgment outlines a complicated preface to the essential facts before me.

[6]    For present purposes, it is enough to say Leasing Solutions and Pinto were both party to a document titled Novation of Lease and Guarantee and dated 9 August 2006 (the “novation agreement

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LHL Leasing Solutions Limited v Pinto Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1387
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, LHL Leasing Solutions Limited, sought to recover liquidated damages from the defendant, Pinto Limited, for the alleged failure to deliver leased equipment on the expiry of the lease. The issues before the court were whether Pinto was in breach of its obligation to deliver up the equipment to Leasing Solutions, if so, whether the “average monthly rent during the term of the Agreement” could be determined, and if so, whether the liquidated damages provision was enforceable as a matter of law. The court found that Pinto had no obligation to deliver up the equipment to Leasing Solutions, as there was no triggering expiry or entitled Hirer obliging Pinto's return of the equipment to Leasing Solutions. Even if clause 10 could be regarded as imposing a freestanding obligation on Pinto to deliver up the Equipment on the lease's expiry or termination, there was another problem with any such failure giving rise to an obligation to pay liquidated damages. The court held that the parties had agreed to the terms of the lease, which was confirmed by the novation agreement, and the pleadings and evidence made it clear the parties intended to be bound by the terms and conditions contained in the lease. However, the court found that clause 1 of the lease did not provide for the lease as a whole to bind the Lessee, but identified specific obligations which were to apply. The court held that the parties had proceeded, in practice, on the basis that the lease was binding in all respects as between them, but sought now also to argue the lease had never come into effect as between Mr Leaupepe and the former lessee. The court held that the absence of signature by the Hirer meant the former lessee's obligations were only as a ‘tenant at will’. On the lease's novation, those became Pinto's obligations. The court found that clause 1's bracketed words were effective to exclude any obligation on Pinto to pay clause 10’s liquidated damages, which were defined as “a monthly rent equal to the average monthly rent during the Term of this Agreement”. The court held that if it was wrong in that, it would turn to consider whether liquidated damages were payable under clause 10 in the present circumstances. The court held that even if Pinto had any obligation to return the equipment to Leasing Solutions, the obligation was compromised and met by Pinto's arrangements with those in possession of the equipment. And without the obligation, the arrangements comprised the mutual ending of the tenancy, “without prejudice” to Leasing Solutions’ entitlement to proceed against Pinto for unpaid rent (if any), and outstanding costs and expenses. Thus, in terms of clause 10, Pinto had not ‘failed’ to deliver up the equipment. No liquidated damages were payable in any event. The court dismissed Leasing Solutions’ claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.