MacDonald and another (Respondents) v Carnbroe Estates Ltd (Appellant) (Scotland)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2019] UKSC 57

On appeal from: [2018] CSIH 7

JUDGMENT

MacDonald and another (Respondents) v Carnbroe Estates Ltd (Appellant) (Scotland)

before

Lord Reed, Deputy President


Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
Lord Briggs
Lord Sales

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

4 December 2019

Heard on 2 May 2019

Appellant Respondents
Lord Davidson of Glen Clova QC Kenneth McBrearty QC
Jonathan Brown Susan Ower
(Instructed by Levy & McRae (Instructed by Harper
Solicitors LLP (Glasgow)) Macleod LLP (Glasgow))

LORD HODGE: (with whom Lord Reed, Lord Wilson, Lord Briggs and Lord
Sales agree)

1. This appeal concerns the Scots law of gratuitous alienations on insolvency. It raises three principal questions. First, there is a question as to the interpretation of

the term “adequate consideration” in section 242(4)(b) of the Insolvency Act 1986

(“the 1986 Act”). Secondly, there is the question whether the Inner House was

entitled to interfere with the Lord Ordinary’s evaluation that the consideration given

by Carnbroe Estates Ltd (“Carnbroe”) amounted to adequate consideration under

that statutory provision. Thirdly, a question arose during the hearing as to the interpretation of the words in section 242(4) that empower the court to grant a remedy. The court invited and received written submissions from counsel for both parties. The question is whether the court has any discretion as to the remedy it may give.

Factual background

2.         Grampian MacLennan’s Distribution Services Ltd (“Grampian”) was, as its

name suggests, a distribution services company. It carried on business from a site at

9 Stroud Road, Kelvin Industrial Estate, East Kilbride (“the Property”). The Property, which was Grampian’s principal asset and centre of operations, consisted

of a warehouse, a vehicle workshop and a yard with a gatehouse. Grampian purchased the Property in August 2005 for £630,000. The buildings on the Property had been constructed in the 1970s and by 2014 were in need of further maintenance,

repair and upgrading. Grampian’s shareholders until June 2014 were Derek and

Hazel Hunter, and Derek Hunter (“Mr Hunter”) was the sole director.

3.         In March 2013 DM Hall, chartered surveyors, (“DM Hall”) valued the

Property at £1.2m on the open market with the valuation falling to £800,000 if one were to assume a restricted marketing period of 180 days. By early 2014 Grampian was in financial difficulty. In May 2014 Mr Hunter consulted an insolvency

practitioner to obtain advice as to whether he should put Grampian in members’

voluntary liquidation. At that time Mr Hunter believed that the sale of the Property would enable Grampian to pay all its creditors and make a distribution to the shareholders. His belief was supported by the DM Hall valuation of March 2013. Shortly before the consultation in May 2014, Carnbroe had intimated through its solicitors an interest in purchasing the property for £950,000. In mid-2014, another company, Bullet Express Ltd, also expressed an interest in acquiring the Property at a price of £900,000.

4. Mr and Mrs Hunter chose not to pursue those expressions of interest in the Property but instead sold their shares in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MacDonald and another (Respondents) v Carnbroe Estates Ltd (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] UKSC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an appeal by Carnbroe Estates Ltd against the decision of the Inner House of the Court of Session, which ordered that a disposition of property be reduced and ordered Carnbroe to execute a disposition in favour of the liquidators. The appeal raised questions about the interpretation of the term "adequate consideration" under the Insolvency Act 1986, the evaluation of the Lord Ordinary's assessment of the consideration, and the interpretation of the statutory remedies available to the court. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, but only to the extent of remitting the case to the First Division to consider an appropriate remedy under section 242(4) of the 1986 Act.

The Supreme Court found that the Inner House was entitled to interfere with the Lord Ordinary's assessment of the consideration, as there was no evidence that a sale by NatWest or a sale by the liquidator with NatWest's consent would have achieved a price net of expenses comparable to or less than the sale price which Grampian accepted. The Court also found that the statutory remedies provided in section 242(4) of the 1986 Act do not mandate restitutio in integrum in every case, and the court has the power to devise an appropriate remedy, taking into account the consideration which a bona fide purchaser has paid. The Court concluded that the previous cases of Short's Trustee v Chung and Cay's Trustee v Cay were wrongly decided and should not be followed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established