Crown Prosecution Service (Appellant) v Aquila Advisory Ltd (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2021] UKSC 49

On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 588

Appellant

Andrew Sutcliffe QC Julian Christopher QC

Anne Jeavons

(Instructed by CPS National Proceeds of Crime Unit)

Respondent

Stuart Ritchie QC Martin Evans QC

Sam Neaman
(Instructed by Kingsley Napley LLP)

3. There were a number of parties to these civil proceedings but by the date of the

participating in the trial were Aquila and the CPS. The issue between them, as defined
by the judge (at para 1) was, in essence, whether the proprietary rights to which Aquila
would otherwise be entitled against Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin could be asserted “in
the face of” the confiscation orders obtained by the CPS against Mr Perrin and Mr

LORD STEPHENS: (with whom Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Sales, Lord Burrows and Lady

Rose agree)

Introduction and overview

1.          Mr Robert Faichney and Mr David Perrin exploited their position as directors of

Vantis Tax Ltd (“VTL”), in breach of fiduciary duty, to make a secret profit of £4.55m. Aquila Advisory Ltd (“Aquila”), which has acquired the proprietary rights (including choses in action) of VTL, relies, in particular, on the judgment of this court in FHR European Ventures LLP v Mankarious [2014] UKSC 45; [2015] AC 250 (“FHR”), to assert that Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin are to be treated as having acquired the benefit of that secret profit on behalf of their principal, VTL. The result, Aquila argues, is that the secret profit was beneficially owned by VTL under a constructive trust, the beneficial interest in which has now passed to Aquila.

2.          The amount of £4.55m was also the benefit obtained by Mr Faichney and Mr

Perrin from the crime of cheating the public revenue by dishonestly facilitating and inducing others to submit false claims for tax relief. Those crimes were committed by Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin in relation to four tax avoidance schemes. Following their criminal convictions, the Crown Prosecution Service (the “CPS”) sought confiscation orders under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (“POCA”) against Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin. The judge in the criminal trial found that Mr Perrin’s benefit from the offence was £4.55m but that the available amount was £809,692. An order was made requiring Mr Perrin to pay that amount. Subsequently, an order was made requiring Mr Faichney to pay £648,000, which was the available amount in his case. However, Aquila asserts that as it has a proprietary claim to the secret profit of £4.55m (from which secret profit all the property assets of Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin were obtained) it has priority over the confiscation orders, as those orders do not give the CPS any form of proprietary interest in the assets of either Mr Faichney or Mr Perrin. If that is correct, then Aquila will be entitled to all of Mr Faichney’s and Mr Perrin’s assets leaving nothing to satisfy the confiscation orders.

trial before Mann J and by virtue of two settlement agreements, the only…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crown Prosecution Service (Appellant) v Aquila Advisory Ltd... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] UKSC 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Crown Prosecution Service (Appellant) v Aquila Advisory Ltd (Respondent) involved a dispute between the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) and Aquila Advisory Ltd over the ownership of funds obtained through fraudulent tax avoidance schemes. The CPS sought to enforce confiscation orders against the former directors of Vantis Tax Ltd (VTL), Mr Robert Faichney and Mr David Perrin, who had been convicted of cheating the public revenue. Aquila, which had acquired VTL's proprietary rights, claimed that it was entitled to the £4.55 million secret profit made by Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin on behalf of VTL. The central issue was whether the proprietary rights of VTL, now held by Aquila, could be asserted against the confiscation orders obtained by the CPS. The Supreme Court dismissed the CPS's appeal, holding that the fraud of the former directors could not be attributed to VTL, and therefore, the illegality defence did not apply. The court found that the reasoning in Bilta (UK) Ltd v Nazir prevented the attribution of the former directors' dishonesty to the company, allowing VTL to pursue its claim against them for breach of fiduciary duty. The court also rejected the CPS's argument that the decision was inconsistent with the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, stating that the Act does not interfere with existing third-party property rights.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal by the Crown Prosecution Service was dismissed, and Aquila Advisory Ltd was entitled to assert its proprietary claim to the funds in dispute in priority to the claim of the CPS. The court granted a declaration that the moneys totaling £4.55 million were held by Mr Faichney and Mr Perrin and their wives on constructive trust for VTL, whose rights had been assigned to Aquila. The CPS was obliged to instruct the receiver to transfer to Aquila the net proceeds realized from all the assets listed in the confiscation orders.