Bresco Electrical Services Ltd (in liquidation) (Appellant) v Michael J Lonsdale (Electrical) Ltd (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Trinity Term

[2020] UKSC 25

On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 27

Appellant/Cross- Respondent/Cross-
Respondent Appellant
Peter Arden QC Fiona Sinclair QC
Ben Shaw Thomas Crangle

Chantelle Staynings

(Instructed by Blaser Mills (Instructed by Fladgate
LLP (High Wycombe)) LLP)

LORD BRIGGS: (with whom Lord Reed, Lord Kitchin, Lord Hamblen and

Lord Leggatt agree)

Introduction

1. This appeal and cross-appeal raise important questions about the compatibility of two statutory regimes, namely the adjudication of construction disputes and the operation of insolvency set-off. In bare outline, section 108 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 (“the 1996 Act”) confers a right upon a party to a construction contract to refer a dispute arising under that contract to adjudication. Rules made under the Insolvency Act 1986 (now rule 14.25 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 (SI 2016/1024)) (“the IR”) make provision for automatic set-off of cross-claims between a company in liquidation and each of its creditors, giving rise to a single net balance between them, to be ascertained by the taking of an account. Rule 14.24 does the same for a company in distributing administration. The 1996 Act does not deny the right of a company to refer disputes to adjudication merely because it is in liquidation, but it is argued on this appeal that, if there are cross-claims between parties to a construction contract and one of them is in liquidation, then there can be no adjudication of any dispute between them about those cross-claims even if, but for the liquidation and the existence of cross-claims, one or more of those disputes would fall within the right to refer to adjudication conferred by section 108.

2. This objection to the use or availability of adjudication in the context of insolvency set-off is put on two grounds, which may be labelled jurisdiction and futility. First it is said that since insolvency set-off replaces the former cross-claims with a single claim for the net balance, there is no longer a claim, or therefore a dispute, under the construction contract, so that the adjudicator’s jurisdiction under section 108 (or under a bespoke or standard form contractual provision to similar effect) is not engaged. There is only a dispute about the net balance arising under the regime for insolvency set-off. Secondly it is submitted that, even if there is jurisdiction, the conduct of an adjudication in the context of insolvency set-off will, generally speaking, not lead to an enforceable award, and will therefore be an exercise in futility which the court can and ordinarily should restrain by injunction, before costs are thrown away upon a process which serves no useful purpose. In short, it is said that the two regimes are simply incompatible. Both these submissions were endorsed by the trial judge in the present proceedings, but only the futility argument prevailed in the Court of Appeal. This court is therefore faced with an appeal against the order made by the Court of Appeal by way of an injunction restraining the pursuit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bresco Electrical Services Ltd (in liquidation) (Appellant)... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] UKSC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the UK Supreme Court was an appeal and cross-appeal concerning the compatibility of the adjudication of construction disputes under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 with the operation of insolvency set-off as provided by the Insolvency Act 1986. The central dispute involved cross-claims between Bresco Electrical Services Ltd, which was in liquidation, and Michael J Lonsdale (Electrical) Ltd, where one party sought to refer a dispute to adjudication while the other argued that insolvency set-off rendered such adjudication futile and incompatible with the insolvency process.

The legal issues centered around whether there was jurisdiction for the adjudicator to hear the dispute, and if the adjudication, given the existence of cross-claims and insolvency set-off, would be an exercise in futility. The court had to determine whether the insolvency set-off regime, which replaces cross-claims with a single claim for the net balance, rendered the adjudication process futile or incompatible with the insolvency process.

The Supreme Court held that there was jurisdiction for the adjudicator to hear the dispute, rejecting the argument that insolvency set-off removed the dispute from the scope of the construction contract, thereby removing the adjudicator's jurisdiction. The court found that disputes under the contract could still be adjudicated upon, even if they were affected by insolvency set-off, and that the existence of cross-claims did not deprive the disputes of their separate identity for all purposes. Furthermore, the court dismissed the argument that the adjudication would be an exercise in futility. It was held that the insolvency company had a statutory and contractual right to pursue adjudication as a means of dispute resolution, and that the potential lack of enforceability of the adjudicator’s decision was a matter to be dealt with at the enforcement stage, rather than preventing the adjudication from proceeding.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal against the injunction restraining the adjudication and dismissed the cross-appeal on jurisdiction, concluding that construction adjudication was not incompatible with the insolvency process and was not an exercise in futility. The court emphasized the role of adjudication as a mainstream method of dispute resolution, which could lead to the speedy and cost-effective resolution of disputes even in the context of insolvency set-off.

The final orders of the court were to allow the appeal and set aside the injunction, thereby permitting the adjudication to proceed, and to dismiss the cross-appeal on jurisdiction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established