(1880) 5 App. Cases. 473
House of Lords
The Attorney-General & Ephraim Hutchings (Relator)
v.
The Directors, &
c., of the Great Eastern Railway Company
Date: 27 May 1880
The Lord Chancellor (Lord Selborne)
Lord Blackburn
Lord Watson.
Mr. Kay, Q.C., Mr. Bompas, Q.C., and Mr. Macnaghten, Q.C., (instructed by Hargrove & Co) for the Appellants
Mr. Chitty Q.C., and Mr. Newton R. Smart. (instructed by the Capel A. Curwood.) for the Respondent
THE LORD CHANCELLOR (Lord Selborne):
My Lords, the question in this case is whether, under the Acts of Parliament to which your Lordships' attention has been called, the Respondent company is authorized and empowered to let for hire to the Southend Company locomotive power and rolling stock. The company claims to be so entitled. The Master of the Rolls and Lord Justice Baggallay thought that it was not so authorized; but Lords Justices James and Bramwell thought otherwise, and they discharged the order for an injunction which the Master of the Rolls had made. The present appeal ta your Lordships is from that decision.
I assume that your Lordships will not now recede from anything that was determined in The Ashbury Railway Company v. Riche 7 H L 653. It appears to me to be important that the doctrine of ultrà vires, as it was explained in that case, should be maintained. But I agree with Lord Justice James that this doctrine ought to be reasonably, and not unreasonably, understood and applied, and that whatever may fairly be regarded as incidental to, or consequential upon, those things which the Legislature has authorized, ought not (unless expressly prohibited) to be held, by judicial construction, to be ultrà vires. In the present case I think, with the Court below, that the acts which the information was filed to restrain are not ultrà vires of the Defendant company. But I come to that conclusion, not on the ground that they are such acts, on the border line between authority and no authority, as may reasonably be thought incidental to the exercise of powers expressly given, but because I think that they are expressly authorized by the 14th section of the Act of 1863. It is insisted by Appellants' counsel that the 14th section of the Act of 1863 authorizes only agreements between the Great Eastern Company and the London and Blackwall Company, inter se; and that, relating as it does to the "extension," or Southend Railway, as well as to the railways of those two companies, they could make no such agreements until they had otherwise acquired an interest, sufficient to give effect to them, in the extension railway; and that they could only acquire such an interest by taking a lease, or a transfer of the existing lease, of that line. The Appellants, therefore, ask your Lordships to read this section as if, after the words "the two companies," with which it begins, these additional words were contained in it, "in the event of a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General & Anor v Great Eastern Railway Company and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1880] UKHL 2
- Decision Date