Zheng Li Trustee Limited v Henderson

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-193

CIV-2015-485-198 [2015] NZHC 1723

BETWEEN

ZHENG LI TRUSTEE LIMITED AND

MK TRUSTEE (2013) LIMITED Plaintiffs

AND

EWAN STUART HENDERSON Defendant

Hearing: 7 July 2015

Counsel:

D Consedine for the Plaintiffs
E S Henderson in Person

Judgment:

27 July 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

Introduction – the summary judgment application ....................................................................... [1] Mr Henderson’s opposition ............................................................................................................ [15] Summary judgment – legal principles ........................................................................................... [30]

Relevant provisions of the deeds of lease and guarantees ............................................................ [37] The Victoria Street lease ............................................................................................................... [37] Mr Henderson’s guarantee of the Victoria Street lease ................................................................ [42] The Courtenay Place lease ........................................................................................................... [45] The guarantee of the Courtenay Place lease ................................................................................ [49]

The issues to be determined............................................................................................................ [50] The Victoria Street lease ............................................................................................................... [50] The Courtenay Place lease ........................................................................................................... [50]

Discussion and conclusions on the issues ....................................................................................... [53] The Victoria Street lease ............................................................................................................... [53] The Courtenay Place lease ........................................................................................................... [93]

Result ...............................................................................................................................................[114]

ZHENG LI TRUSTEE LIMITED AND MK TRUSTEE (2013) LIMITED v EWAN STUART HENDERSON [2015] NZHC 1723 [27 July 2015]

Introduction – the summary judgment application

[1]      In  each  of  these  proceedings,  the  plaintiff  landlords  apply  for  summary judgment  against  Mr  Henderson,  who  guaranteed  the  lessees’ obligations  under separate leases of commercial properties in Wellington.   By consent, the summary judgment applications were heard together.

[2]      The first of the two relevant properties is a multi-storey building situated on the corner of Victoria Street and Chews Lane.  Until recently a company called 3C Bar Limited (3C) operated a restaurant and bar in premises on the ground floor of the building (the Victoria Street premises).

[3]      3C occupied the Victoria Street premises as lessee under a ten year lease which had commenced on 1 May 2008 (the Victoria Street lease).   Mr Henderson personally guaranteed 3C’s obligations under the Victoria Street lease.

[4]      The other property is a building situated at 134 Courtenay Place.   Until recently,  part  of  the  property  (the  Courtenay Place  premises)  was  leased  to  a company called Molly Malones (Wellington) Limited (Molly Malones), which operated a restaurant/bar in the building.  Molly Malones had a nine year lease of the Courtenay Place   premises   which   had   commenced   on   30   May   2007   (the Courtenay Place  lease).     Mr Henderson  personally  guaranteed  Molly Malones’ obligations under the Courtenay Place lease.

[5]      Mr  Henderson  was  a  director  of,  and  shareholder  in,  both  3C  and Molly Malones.  He says that the two companies were managed together, and that their businesses were interdependent in that there were times when each depended on the other for cash flow.

[6]      3C  failed  to  pay any of  the  rent  instalments  which  were  due  under  the Victoria Street lease on 1 November 2014, 1 December 2014, and 1 January 2015.  It was  placed  in  voluntary  liquidation  on  23 January  2015.    As  at  that  date,  the plaintiffs say the rent arrears totalled $70,504.38.

[7]      On 13 February 2015, 3C’s liquidators gave formal notice of disclaimer of

the Victoria Street lease. At that stage, the rent arrears had risen…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zheng Li Trustee Limited v Henderson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1723
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Zheng Li Trustee Limited and MK Trustee (2013) Limited (the plaintiffs) brought an application for summary judgment against Mr Ewan Henderson in relation to two commercial leases. The plaintiffs claimed the outstanding rent and interest under two leases of commercial properties in Wellington which were held by companies, 3C Bar Limited and Molly Malones (Wellington) Limited. Mr Henderson was a director of both companies and had personally guaranteed the respective liabilities of both companies under the two leases. The plaintiffs sought summary judgment on the basis of the affidavit evidence alone, without the need for the claims to proceed to a trial in the usual way. Mr Henderson opposed the summary judgment applications. Mr Henderson argued that neither company owed or owes anything to the plaintiffs because they have claims of their own which they are entitled to set off against the amounts claimed by the plaintiffs. Alternatively, the companies have counterclaims which provide a basis on which the Court should exercise its discretion to refuse to enter summary judgment. The court held that there was no basis on which Mr Henderson could argue that the plaintiffs were not entitled to summary judgment. The court found that there was no arguable defence to the claims brought against Mr Henderson, and that any counterclaims he might have should not influence the Court to exercise its discretion against the entry of summary judgment. The court held that it would not be inequitable or otherwise inappropriate to permit the plaintiffs to enforce the guarantee of the leases against Mr Henderson without determining at the same time any counterclaims he might have. The court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to summary judgment. The court made orders for summary judgment for the plaintiffs against Mr Henderson in relation to the outstanding rent and interest under the leases. The court also made orders that the claims for indemnity for losses incurred as a result of the disclaimer of the leases go forward to trial in the ordinary way.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.